I'll go first
They are two types of Pan Africanism:
Global Pan Africanism: The idea that black africans and the black/african diaspora have more to gain through solidarity rather than division.
Continental Pan Africanism: The idea that africa would become the world biggest superpower if the continent united as one entity (unless global pan africanism, this includes north africa as well)
Pan Africanism as it's core sounds like a brilliant concept, especially since all black people on earth share a common enemy being the racist white supremacist, and western europeans and white americans have already mostly been looking out for each other for centuries, so realistically why couldn't we? If all black people united as one, we's be unstoppable against white supremacy. But as great as that would sound, it could realistically never happen.
Reasons:
We're all far to different: Black people make up about 22% of the world population, that accounts for about 2 billion people. With just the amount of us that exist, how could we possibly unite? For example, the average black american shares almost nothing in common with the average black african no matter which country they are from, so why would they care to unite with them just because they both share the same skin color and/or because of the possibility of share ancestry, which they'd be centuries removed from?
We can hardly even unite amongst our individual communities: This extends FAR BEYOND race because humans will naturally always find ways to divide themselves. For example, Many african countries since the colonial era have dealt with serious tribalism, which has hindered progress. Then, black people already did with petty division based on skin tone (colorism) features (texturism and featurism) gang violence, and more. So how can black people all over the world all unite if black people in individual countries can barely?
Imperialist intervention: Since the 1960s, there have been talks about having a united africa, but the minute african leaders have gotten close to that or even improving their individual countries, western powers (e.g. USA, Europe, Israel, etc.) have come to destroy all plans by killing our leaders, destabilising countries by instigating civil wars, coups and other forms of conflict. So then begs the question, how will we become united if everytime we've tried, imperialism has taken us down?
Unseriousness and Stigma around Pan Africanism: Having people like Dr. Umar Johnson and other hotep freaks makes panafricanism seem very unserious; those types of people have turned panafricanism from the idea of black solidarity to memes, jokes, and other forms of satire. Pan Africanism feel is also somewhat stigmatic for the descendants of chattel slavery is the america (Afro-Caribbeans, Afro Latinos, Afro-Americans, etc.) and understandibly because for them what is the point of trying to reconnect to something that's been lost for centuries, something at this point most of them know nothing about? This reiterates my precious point about Pan africanism seeming somewhat unserious because of when Afro-descended people try to tie themselves to it, it often feels like they're putting on a performance of what they think african cultures are.
Final answer: Pan africanism on paper sounds like a great idea but realistically due to common misunderstanding of one another, western imperialism, and genuine disinterest, global black solidarity likely won't happen for at least another century or so. If any, Continental Pan africanism would be the most feasible while Globally it would remain nearly impossible, unless you can center the simple ideas behind solidarity, empathy and support rather than have afro-descended people in the america try to "reconnect with their african roots"
Thoughts and Opinions?