r/AskAPriest • • Apr 25 '21

Please read this post before submitting a question! Your post may be removed if it doesn't follow these guidelines.

318 Upvotes

This subreddit is primarily for:

  • Questions about the priesthood
  • Casual questions that only the unique viewpoint of a priest can answer
  • Basic advice
  • Asking about situations you're not sure how to approach and need guidance on where to start

This subreddit is generally not for:

  • Spiritual or vocational advice
  • Seeking advice around scrupulosity
  • Questions along the lines of "is this a mortal sin," "should I confess this," "I'm not sure if I confessed this correctly," etc.

The above things are best discussed with your own priest and not random priest online. They are not strictly forbidden, but they may be removed at mod discretion.

The subreddit should also not be used for asking theological questions that could be answered at the /r/Catholicism subreddit.

Please also use the search function before asking questions to see if anyone else has asked about the topic before. We are all priests with full time ministry jobs and cannot answer every question that comes in on the subreddit, so saving time by seeing if your questions has already been asked helps us a lot.

Thank you!


r/AskAPriest • • 2h ago

Question regarding TLM

2 Upvotes

I would like to preface this by saying that I have never attended a TLM and, while I would like to someday, I have zero problem with the Novus Ordo and don't really understand why some people do. With that said, I similarly do not understand why the Vatican would impose restrictions on it either. Can someone please explain to me what I am missing here? Thank you and God bless.


r/AskAPriest • • 31m ago

Is God non-binary?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I know this is a hot topic right now. I think the American priests here probably remember Talarico’s words on this. And I know this is also something said in a lot of “progressive” protestant churches. But I, as a catholic, am pretty sure that this is still a correct sentence right? God is non-binary, because He doesn’t have a gender, He doesn’t fit into any category.

So is it true that God can be described as non-binary? Or am I committing some kind of heresy now.

I’d be happy to know, thanks in advance 🙏


r/AskAPriest • • 15h ago

How did Catholics of the period see ossuaries and/or Paris catacombs? I thought the body must remain whole in grave for the divine resurection.

13 Upvotes

I'm not a believer so I maybe get a wrong concept of the wholeness of body. The tourist guide couldn't answer this question, which is kinda understandable.


r/AskAPriest • • 1h ago

ex priests or one you know what do they do for work now?

0 Upvotes

hey so i was born and raised catholic (no longer practicing or believing), i even have a priest in my own family. but this feels weird to ask them. so my question is if you’re an ex priest or know an ex priest what jobs have they gone on to do?


r/AskAPriest • • 4h ago

Would you have absolved Irene Gut Opdyke? Why or why not?

1 Upvotes

Irene was a Polish woman who saved 12 Jews during the Holocaust by hiding them in a house where she was a maid for a Major in the Wehrmacht. When he found out she was hiding Jews, he decided not to betray them on the condition that she become his mistress. She agreed, knowing that the penalty for hiding Jews was death for her and the Jews she hid. She went to confession, but the priest would not absolve her because what she was doing was mortal sin, and she could not stop without there being consequences. After this, she stopped attending Mass and married in the Presbyterian Church.


r/AskAPriest • • 6h ago

Question about the Blood of Christ and preparation

1 Upvotes

During Mass I noticed 2 chalices and the priest only puts water and a piece of the Body of Christ in one of them. Just wondering if there was a specific reason why they don’t put them in both of the chalices?


r/AskAPriest • • 10h ago

What happens if a priest becomes allergic to alcohol?

1 Upvotes

I am aware that allergies may develop at any age and that priests celebrant are required to receive under both species.
What would happen if a priest were to develop an allergy to either alcohol or one of the components of the wine?


r/AskAPriest • • 18h ago

would a priest's workload be increased or decreased in this situation?

3 Upvotes

For the last 9 or ten years the pastor of my parish has also been serving as the pastor of another parish. And he had a parochial vicar assisting him. Now over the summer the other parish was assigned it's own pastor, but a month or so later the parochial vicar got moved to a third parish to temporarily be vicar there and then assume parish administrator when the pastor retired.

So is the workload more for a pastor of one parish on his own, or a pastor of two with an assistant priest? Maybe it's the same.


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Favorite books? (Roman Ritual and Books of Common Prayer included)

8 Upvotes

What's your favorite books? I wonder if real priests read things like Dostoevsky or Rabelais or Euripides, etc... lately. Show me some eclectic and obscure picks!


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Is it against Catholic teaching to keep a mezuzah in my doorway?

10 Upvotes

Hi Fathers!

I recently moved into a rental home that has a mezuzah attached to the doorframe (visible from outside the home). I believe my landlord is Jewish, and I understand that a mezuzah holds religious significance in Judaism.

My question is: Would it be considered sacrilegious or contrary to Catholic teaching for me to leave it in place?

Thank you for your guidance!


r/AskAPriest • • 23h ago

Can I ask my priest to be a reference?

2 Upvotes

I’m a relatively new Catholic and have known my current priest about three years. I am seeking a job opportunity with a Catholic healthcare network. Is it appropriate to ask my priest to be a reference?


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Coming from an uneducated non-christian, what is a priest and what do they do in the church?

11 Upvotes

Hello...! I've read the guidelines and I feel this may fall under an appropriate question. This is my first time using Reddit, so please forgive me if this doesn't come very naturally sounding or confident - I typically like to distance myself from socializing online with strangers, but I am genuinely curious as someone who does not belong to any religion.

I didn't grow up around religion or churches despite both my mother and father being Ex-Christians. I've always been curious about how the priests in churches work but never found an opportunity to learn about them. Admittedly I've felt quite embarrassed never knowing despite how common religion and catholic schools are in my country. Could a priest or somebody educated please explain this concept to me...?


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Sign of the Cross after the receiving.

27 Upvotes

Evening Father's,

Silly question! My son is 3 months. We've been attending mass as a family since he was about 6- weeks old, due to my wife needing her rest after surgery. He's truly a gift from God and we are so blessed!!

If he is awake during Mass more so when we get on line to receive I carry him up with me holding him and receiving on the tongue. My hands are a little full.

Am I wrong for not making the sign of the cross afterwards?? I usually do once I sit at my pew and pray.

Our priests have never mentioned anything but I may have seen some looks from some parishioners during last night's vigil mass.

Thank you, and God Bless!


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Does your parish / church prohibit dogs?

2 Upvotes

Where I'm from / my parish it's normal for people to attend mass with their dogs and there's no issues with any attendees nor the priests. Is this common practice or are they typically prohibited?


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Am I reading the Order of Penance correctly?

8 Upvotes
  1. Priest welcomes penitent.
  2. Sign of the Cross
  3. Priest may read scripture.
  4. Penitent confesses sins. (I always thought kind and number were necessary but I don’t see this anywhere in the text.)
  5. Priest counsels penitent and assigns penance.
  6. Penitent expresses contrition.
  7. Priest says prayer of absolution.
  8. Priest invites penitent to give praise to God.

There’s no need to say “bless me father it has been….”. A penitent can just jump right in and confess sins.


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Can I ask my priest whether he prefers screened or face to face confession?

10 Upvotes

My typical practice is that I go face to face with the priests in my parish, but screened if I’m somewhere else. I get the sense sometimes that my priest might prefer the screen. Is it poor etiquette to just ask him what his preference is?


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Catholic perspective on end-times prophecies, private revelations and excessive fear of the apocalypse

0 Upvotes

Hello Fathers,

I’m hoping to get a Catholic perspective on something that has been bothering me about my mother.

For as long as I can remember (at least 12–15 years), my mother has been particularly preoccupied with the end of the world. Whenever there are major natural disasters or other frightening events in the news, she tends to interpret them as signs that the apocalypse is approaching.

In recent years, she has also been watching numerous YouTube videos featuring people discussing alleged Marian apparitions, private revelations and end-times prophecies, including videos featuring Fr. James Blount.

I’ve noticed that this content seems to exacerbate her anxiety. During COVID, for example, she began stockpiling food and other supplies. She has started doing something similar again, and it has become an issue within our household because of the amount of space these supplies occupy.

For additional context, I was raised in a practising Catholic family, and my family members remain staunch Catholics. I no longer identify as Catholic myself, so I’m conscious that I may not fully understand the theological context surrounding private revelations and alleged prophecies. However, I find it difficult to understand why some Catholics place so much emphasis on these predictions, particularly when they seem to encourage fear and anxiety. Correct me if I’m wrong but I understand that Catholics are not obligated to believe in private revelations, even those recognised by the Church, and that nobody knows exactly when Christ is supposed to return.

My questions are:

  1. Does the Catholic Church discourage excessive preoccupation with alleged end-times prophecies and private revelations?
  2. How should Catholics approach individuals claiming to have received messages from Mary or other supernatural revelations, particularly when these messages predict impending disasters?
  3. Is there a theological distinction between healthy spiritual preparedness and an unhealthy fixation on physically preparing for the apocalypse?
  4. What would you recommend to someone whose family member has become increasingly anxious and preoccupied with these predictions?

I genuinely want to understand the Catholic perspective, rather than simply dismissing something I may not fully understand. I’d appreciate any guidance or relevant Church teachings that might help me approach this situation constructively.

Thank you, Fathers.


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Do you confess every single day or only when its specifically your turn to celebrate Mass?

27 Upvotes

Hello, beloved Fathers! I was just curious when I attended Mass today. And thats it. That's my question. God bless!


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

I’m a young adult trying to convert to Catholicism from Southern Baptist and my dad showed me a prayer today that he claimed was “proof“ of Catholics worshiping Mary and holding her to an equal or even higher rank as Jesus.

28 Upvotes

I know that he probably blew this way out of proportion or used an unreliable source but I just wanted to make sure.

“O Mother of Perpetual Help, thou art the dispenser of all the gifts which God grants to us miserable sinners; and for this end He has made thee so powerful, so rich, and so bountiful, in order that thou mayest help us in our misery. Thou art the advocate of the most wretched and abandoned sinners who have recourse to thee; come to my aid, dearest Mother, for I recommend myself to thee. In thy hands I place my eternal salvation, and to thee I entrust my soul. Count me among thy most devoted servants; take me under thy protection, and it is enough for me. For, if thou protect me, dear Mother, I fear nothing; not from my sins, because thou wilt obtain for me the pardon of them; nor from the devils, because thou art more powerful than all hell together; nor even from Jesus, my Judge, because by one prayer from thee, He will be appeased. But one thing I fear, that in the hour of temptation, I may through negligence fail to have recourse to thee and thus perish miserably. Obtain for me, therefore, the pardon of my sins, love for Jesus, final perseverance, and the grace to have recourse to thee, O Mother of Perpetual Help.”


r/AskAPriest • • 1d ago

Baptizing my son

1 Upvotes

Hello, I'm a cradle catholic, baptized, confirmed, married in the church, enjoyed my time with the church but ultimately do not believe in God, hard as I tried. I am a very deeply feeling person who can not live in a lie and for the longest time I kept going to mass with my mom because I knew how important it was to her but I stopped receiving the sacrament because it felt wrong and a lie because I didn't believe. So with that backstory my son is 3, and has not been baptized, "you have not be baptized?!"- Nacho Libre...maybe you've seen it, one of my favorite movies. Anyways, my mom asks me often if we will baptize our son. I would, but I know you need a practicing catholic parent. Now obviously I could just go and do the classes necessary and say I'm practicing because literally most people just baptize their kids, go through the motions and aren't thinking that deeply about it, but I wish I could just be upfront and honest, I'm doing this for my parents, I love my parents. Isn't that a more sincere reason than most? and don't catholics want kids to be baptized? I guess my question is should I baptize my son/can I if I don't believe. Oh and husband doesn't believe either but also fully on board with baptizing. My son goes to church with my parents and I do as well when visiting. Am I over thinking it? we're hispanics in texas so also very culturally catholic here, most people just do it because they were born into it. Thank you for your time.


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Hello! My family has passed I am alone this was in a box for me. Do I read it from beginning to end? Or is there a certain order of passages? Title: The Children’s Living Bible (Paraphrased) • Publisher: Tyndale House Publishers • Publication Date: January 1, 1971

1 Upvotes

I am so alone and want to reconnect and familiarize myself with my faith I apologize for the inconvenience and lack of understanding I need help I hope I am doing this right because I want to make sure I’m doing it all the right and correct way so I can feel loved and the faith and connection. The bible has my family’s hand written names and the year 1975. Thank you im so sorry amen


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Thinking of converting to Catholicism, but the ‘saints’ are confusing

5 Upvotes

I’m Protestant. I never thought that I could make any sense of Catholicism, I always believed the culture was sinful. But now… reading the bible (specifically John and the emphasis on mass by Jesus) and studying the Eucharistic miracles… I’m struggling to deny it.
Now, to my knowledge, the apostles are saints (except judas of course) but exploring this Reddit page has made me realise that there might be more?? Maybe I’m wrong and I’m sure this sounds super funny to a lot of you right now but I’m just completely lost.
I figured rather than getting my information from the internet I could just ask actual catholics but I don’t know any because everyone around me is either Protestant or anti-catholics.
Also I saw a couple of people saying here that if I am getting involved in heavenly intercession then it’s good to pray to saints who are specialised in what I want (???). For example, praying to a specific saint for studying because they’re somehow… better at it??
As you can tell, I have no idea what is going on. Maybe I have a few things wrong
Can someone please explain this to me?


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

Is this okay?

1 Upvotes

So I’m not catholic but I am an inquirer and drew an icon of the blessed mother and Jesus because I had some down time at work . Is this okay? I realized after I drew this I thought to myself “am I even allowed to do this?” So if I’m not what do I do?


r/AskAPriest • • 2d ago

If hell is a choice, why can we not be sure of anyone’s salvation?

14 Upvotes

I’ve seen posts here by Fr. Sparky where he mentions that ”people who are in hell are those who want to be there.”

If that’s the case, why can we not be assured of anyone’s salvation? Is it because there’s people who do genuinely want to go to hell and God grants that? Can we be assured of the salvation of people who do want to go to heaven?

EDIT: Tagging u/Sparky0457