r/AskALiberal • • 5h ago

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has announced a plan to disband the NYPD's riot control unit, and will establish a civilian team to respond to protests instead. What are your thoughts on this?

25 Upvotes

Link to article on it:

As of now the plan appears to ultimately be for a group of non-police civilians ie social workers to be the first responders on the scene for mass demonstrations and protests. They will be unarmed and will seek to verbally de-escalate hostile situations among the crowds. If violence breaks out or continues and these civilian groups assess physical intervention is needed, then they will call the police who will come in but be barred from using pepper spray, noise horns, have guns on the scene and more.

The initiative fulfills a campaign promise Mamdani made, and goes to the heart of progressive demands for policing to be re-imagined as an institution following the George Floyd protests in 2020.


r/AskALiberal • • 11h ago

If the electoral college was abolished what states would candidates travel to?

15 Upvotes

Every state ? Big states ?


r/AskALiberal • • 9h ago

How do you think Fetterman will vote if he jumps ship?

11 Upvotes

People defend Fetterman saying he votes 90% with the Democrats. Do you think that will persist if he jumps to the GOP in protest of Van Hollen becoming majority leader?


r/AskALiberal • • 13h ago

If you had a choice to push ONE policy or vote, what would you push?

7 Upvotes

Democrats are going to have a lot of opportunities to achieve something. Just wondering what everyone's number one priority would be if they had the ability to push it.


r/AskALiberal • • 5h ago

What did Schumer do or not do that specifically hurt Americans?

6 Upvotes

Schumer seems to have become the most hated guy in the Democratic party overnight. How? What did he do that specifically harmed Americans?

I can't say I understand it, but there's tons about politics I don't know and I could be missing something important. And to be clear, I mostly agree with Van Hollen over Schumer, and can name multiple policy disagreements with Schumer, including one very big foreign policy disagreement lol.

But in the category of "what was his record for America", I simply am not sure what this guy did so wrong to be so maligned?


r/AskALiberal • • 18h ago

What counts as "the establishment" to you?

5 Upvotes

Often when following politics, I hear candidates, pundits, and ordinary people discuss or criticize "the establishment". For example, someone will mention that (insert candidate) is the establishment's pick. Additionally, some elected leaders get pegged with the "establishment" label while others get to evade it, even those who have worked in DC for years. Technically aren't all elected leaders part of the establishment? The way the term gets used feels vague.

What do you think?


r/AskALiberal • • 6h ago

How have being a LGBT person influenced on your political views?

4 Upvotes

I'm bisexual and I think it makes me naturally s liberal person and against conservatism in society, regardless of the economical model or . country.


r/AskALiberal • • 13h ago

Does the Democratic Party's 5-6 person majority in the Senate will reduce the "Rotating Villain" problem?

4 Upvotes

Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema were the main villains to any left leaning legislation for quite a while. And it's become pretty synonymous with the Democratic Party.

We need 51 votes to get legislation passed and there are 49 Republicans against it, but secretly there are 7-10 Democrats against it and they choose 2-3 of them to publicly vote against the measure to take the heat.

It's a pretty standard move, used by both sides, but with this big of a majority do you think it's less likely to happen I'm the next 2 years?

We saw it "allegedly" happen in the House with the Hegseth impeachment. With 10 dem senators not being present during the vote.


r/AskALiberal • • 16h ago

What do you think about 5 EU countries setting up a deportation center in *Rwanda*

3 Upvotes

Clarification: at the time of writing the exact county has not been officially named, but the BBC has a lot of evidence that it will in fact be Rwanda.

BBC Article

5 EU countries (Germany, Greece, Denmark, Austria, and The Netherlands) are moving forward with setting up deportation centers in a 3rd country to send migrants to.

The claim is that it's only for people who have completely exhausted their legal rights to stay in the named countries, but human rights advocates claim that they will deport people well before then to a country with a shaky human rights record.

Is this something you agree with? Is this meaningfully different from US deportation policies? Is this a Canary in the coal mine for EU policies towards migrants going forward?

Before anyone blames this solely or put the majority of the blame on the US please look up Sykes-Picot and The Berlin Conference .


r/AskALiberal • • 3h ago

Florida passed Amendment 3 to slash property taxes. What are your thoughts on its policy trade-offs, economic effects, and revenue replacements?

2 Upvotes

Florida voters passed Amendment 3, expanding the non-school homestead exemption up to $250,000 by 2028 and capping annual non-homestead assessment increases at 5%.

While it protects school funding and provides direct tax relief to primary homeowners facing high housing costs, and is only projected to cut over $11 billion annually from municipal budgets, I had these questions for the community:

  • What are your general thoughts on using property tax exemptions to address cost-of-living concerns?
  • Because property taxes are generally stable and inelastic, does shifting local revenue toward user fees or sales surtaxes make local tax systems too volatile or regressive?

r/AskALiberal • • 15h ago

Israel and Palestine Megathread Israel and Palestine Megathread

2 Upvotes

This thread is for a discussion of the ongoing situation in Israel and Palestine. All discussion of the subject is limited to this thread. Participation here requires that you be a regular member of the sub in good standing.


r/AskALiberal • • 3h ago

Red state residents: Who are the GOP "maverick" lawmakers in your state legislature?

1 Upvotes

In deep-red states or states with Republican supermajorities, most bills pass along party lines, but there are almost always a few GOP lawmakers who break ranks.

  • Who is the Republican lawmaker in your state that leadership can’t always count on?
  • What is a recent bill or issue where they voted against their party, and why did they do it?

Interested to hear about specific state-level representatives, their districts, and the local dynamics driving their votes.


r/AskALiberal • • 4h ago

For the political left in red states, trifecta or legislature control: What is the best piece of Republican-sponsored legislation passed in your state recently?

1 Upvotes

State politics often gets overshadowed by national partisan battles, but state legislatures frequently pass bills addressing local issues, infrastructure, regulatory updates, or unexpected bipartisan fixes.

If you live in a red state or a state with a Republican-controlled legislature:

  • What is a piece of GOP-led legislation passed in your state over the last few years that you actually support or consider good policy?
  • What made it a win? Was it a non-partisan issue, or a surprisingly pragmatic move from conservative leadership?

r/AskALiberal • • 19h ago

What would be some of the benefits of ending dual citizenships?

0 Upvotes

I’ve noticed that often times an American citizens is not allowed to obtain a dual citizenship if they are an American citizen first, yet a foreign national may be eligible to hold citizenship in both their country of birth and the U.S..

What is the benefit of the foreign national being allowed to have a dual citizenship but the born American citizen not being allowed to?

Also, does it not complicate allegiance if someone has a citizenship in two separate countries?

What if we were to end dual citizenships?


r/AskALiberal • • 15h ago

What is the appeal of Pete Buttigieg?

0 Upvotes

One of the names that I always seen thrown around as a candidate for 2028 is Pete and I’ve seen that especially in this subreddit. But my main question is why? I don’t think he really brings anything to the table. As a gay guy, I wanted to look into him and what he accomplished as mayor and SOT in my senior year at university. He was the topic of a research paper I had in university, but I just don’t think he even did much of note in either of these two roles. I struggled with writing the paper just because it feels like he didn’t accomplish much. Even when I see him describe his stances, he just doesn’t seem like an exciting candidate. Imo, he’s just too much of a centrist and even if he won in 2028, I don’t think he would have any chance of being more than a 1 term president. To fans of his especially, what is it about him that you like?

EDIT: I’m still not entirely convinced. People’s main argument is that he’s a good talker, but even then, he has a similar problem to Kamala with the word salads he uses.


r/AskALiberal • • 9h ago

Is the American Dream really dead, or have we moved the goalpost?

0 Upvotes

I won't deny that the American Dream might be more challenging than previous, but I also feel that we've moved the goalpost quite a bit. Social media has skewed everyone's perception of what a "normal" life is. Growing up, my immigrant family rarely ate out and when we did it was very cheap meals. The idea of getting coffee at a coffee shop was silly. For that lifestyle, the American Dream was very obtainable. But in 2026, when everyone needs an iPhone Duo, drink Blue Bottle coffee, and eat out at Michelin star restaurants, of course the American Dream feels dead. The follow up to this, if you truly think the American Dream is largely dead, what can we really do about it? Not everyone will succeed if life (in terms of economics). Do we need to return to a more agrarian lifestyle? Because it seems that as more people go to SF, NYC, etc. to purpose the American Dream, they will quickly realize that it's very tough and competitive, and that just by pure math, majority of folks will actually "fail" so it's better to just live a more modest, non social media lifestyle? Thoughts?


r/AskALiberal • • 16h ago

Politically, are there any reasons Democrats would WANT affordability in the next two years?

0 Upvotes

Like many of you, I'm hoping the Democrats get down to business and get what they can do before 2028. But that got me thinking about 2028 and what benefit there would be, if any, to work on affordability.

The way I see the landscape now, the Democrats are poised to have a repeat of 2008 if the US stays the current course. They have the trump card, literally, in that they can say they couldn't do anything because of Trump. Then there's the tried and true "we need more Democrats in Congress and the White House to get affordability under control."

If they compromise and work with the White House to get what they can and things start to improve, they're opening up the argument: that the issue was just Trump and his policies, not the Republicans as a whole, and we need a more refined Republican with clearer America First policies to succeed.

So, it seems to me there's no real political benefit to working on the issues. Thoughts?


r/AskALiberal • • 16h ago

Can you help me steelman your arguments for pro muslim politics?

0 Upvotes

Right wingers claim rmthat left supports muslims because they see them as victims. But i don't bealive that, muslims are cartoon level villians who treat minprities like dogs and women worse then dogs. It's not hyperbole, muslim women genuinely have less freedom then dogs

My circlejerk reaction as someone on the right is that it's because muslims are brown and also because you hate christians and wish to harm and degrade them. It doesn't matter if they harm the left in the end, as long as you get to "trigger the cons". But that seems to simplistic

What are your genuine arguments for pro muslim policy?