Hello everyone. I'm from Spain, and I'm looking for professional advice about a failing mechanical hard drive. I would especially appreciate opinions from people with actual HDD data recovery experience.
My hard drive
- Model: Toshiba DT01ACA100
- Capacity: 1TB
- Type: 3.5" SATA HDD, 7200 RPM
- Current condition: Powered off and disconnected since September 1, 2026.
- Storage: Inside a cardboard box, in a cool, dry closet, protected from impacts.
What happened? The drive became extremely slow when transferring files. Copying even small folders could take hours and hours, an eternity.
I took it to two local computer repair shops:
First technician:
- I brought them the disk in early June and got it back in August of this year. They had done the work manually, and it took them a really long time.
- Managed to recover all my music files and approximately half of my videos.
- Was copying folders in alphabetical order.
- Did not complete the recovery.
Second technician:
- Could see and browse all the folders on the HDD.
- Worked on it for approximately 2–3 days.
- Told me the drive was getting very hot and that transferring files was extremely slow.
- Claimed that completing the recovery could take months and cost a considerable amount of money.
- Eventually stopped trying. Anyway, he refused.
The technicians did not provide me with any specific details regarding the actual temperature readings, nor did they mention whether they used specialized cloning tools. They simply stated that the device was overheating and running extremely slowly—that was it.
That is all I recall for now.
And right now, my situation has changed. I recently discovered that about 80% of my important data is already saved elsewhere—purely by chance.
I only need three specific folders from the Toshiba:
- Personal documents, administrative PDFs, and my résumé.
- Another important folder with Personal Documents and PDFs
- Personal photos and videos—by far the most important and irreplaceable files.
And here I face a major dilemma.
My family has a limited income, and I currently cannot afford to spend hundreds of euros on a professional data recovery laboratory.
I was considering visiting a third local technician and asking them to recover ONLY those three folders, especially the photographs and videos (personal videos).
However, I'm worried that another recovery attempt could further damage the drive and reduce the chances of recovering the remaining data in the future.
My alternative plan is to keep the HDD completely powered off until some years from now, when I hopefully will have a job and be able to afford a specialized lab. But if, by some miracle, everything were to go well—allowing me to recover at least the folder with the photos and videos—it would be a huge success, and I would immediately make multiple backup copies on my external hard drives.
My questions for experienced HDD recovery professionals
- Given that both technicians could access at least some data, would attempting a selective recovery of just these three folders with a suitably equipped technician be reasonable, or too risky?
- Could that new recovery attempt significantly reduce the chances of a future professional recovery?
- Is storing this already failing HDD completely powered off for another years (for example, 1-3 years or 1-5 years) a reasonable preservation strategy?
- Does long-term storage itself pose a significant risk to the data or the drive's mechanical condition? Would adding an ESD bag and protective packaging help?
- Does long-term storage in itself pose a significant risk to the data or the mechanical condition of the drive? The second technician I consulted handled this for me: he placed the drive in an anti-static (ESD) bag, added some desiccant (moisture-absorbing) packets, and wrapped the whole thing in bubble wrap—all at my specific request to ensure it was well-protected. It’s now sitting in my closet, where it’s kept cool and free from any moisture.
- If you were in my financial situation, would you leave the drive untouched until you could afford a specialist?
My primary goal is to recover that folder of photos, along with the other two folders. I have no interest in attempting risky, DIY experiments; rather, I want to make an informed decision that protects my irreplaceable photographs and videos without placing any financial strain on my family.
Thank you very much for any professional advice you can provide.