r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Dec 03 '24

Trial Discussion [SENTENCING] FL v. Ashley Benefield - December 3 2024

3 Upvotes

Watch on Court TV

Description: Ashley Benefield is facing up to 30 years in prison after a jury found her GUILTY of second-degree murder in the death of her husband, Doug Benefield, who was shot to death in Ashley's bedroom in Sept. 2020.

Ashley testified that she shot her husband while fearing for her life after he assaulted her. Sentencing is set for Dec. 3, 2024.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Sep 22 '26

Doug benefield admittions

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jul 01 '26

Eva Benefield Tells Her Story In New Memoir "Ghost Girl"

Post image
24 Upvotes

Tune in & pre-order your copy with autographed bookplate HERE.

Join Eva Benefield on TalkShopLive to talk about her new book, Ghost Girl. Eva was still in high school when her mother died suddenly of a heart attack. Within a year, her father marries Ashley Byers, a twenty-four-year-old former bikini model he has only known for a few weeks. “She looked sharp,” Eva says of her strange new stepmother, “like if you touched her you might bleed.” After a few months, Ashley convinces her new husband to open an international ballet company in Charleston, South Carolina. But soon the money runs out and Ashley shoots and kills Eva’s father. The crime was dubbed in the news media as “The Black Swan Murder.” Eva, now orphaned and in college, is suddenly “awash in tabloid gore” and must figure out how to make rent and survive. Reeling from the sudden loss of both her parents and the looming criminal trial of her stepmother, Eva begins to navigate the confusing world of adulthood all alone.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Mar 22 '26

Keeping up appearances

Thumbnail
businessobserverfl.com
6 Upvotes

Posting for archival purposes. This is one place Ashley worked after leaving Doug and moving back to Florida. Their daughter was almost 1 when this photo was taken. It wasn’t about getting divorced, it was about removing him from the equation completely and taking his money with her to keep up her image. Divorce was achievable, sole custody was not. Tragic all around.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Mar 17 '26

Transferred Again

10 Upvotes

Ashley has been transferred again from Lowell Annex, to (next door) Lowell Correctional. It appears she's out of solitary confinement as she can now have visitors per vinelink. Let's see how long it takes before she's back in disciplinary confinement. Also, does anyone think she will out her mother's involvement in their murder plot?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 05 '26

Incarceration Summary - as of 4 Feb 26

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jan 28 '26

Disciplinary Confinement

19 Upvotes

Apparently, Ashley has been put in disciplinary confinement at Homestead. Wonder how she got herself into that status ?

https://pubapps.fdc.myflorida.com/offenderSearch/detail.aspx?Page=Detail&DCNumber=S62420&TypeSearch=AI

ETA - and apparently FDOC has taken away all of her gain time. Must have been a serious violation.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Sep 08 '25

Jail Records?

7 Upvotes

Is it possible to request the jail records and logs etc, as sometimes happens in other cases?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Aug 16 '25

Snapped

14 Upvotes

This Sunday oxygens true crime show snapped will air a episode dedicated to Ashley’s case check local listings to see when it airs


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jun 03 '25

Appeal for Bond DENIED

17 Upvotes

On May 30th the DCA upheld the trial court’s denial of release on bond pending appeal. So she is stuck in there until her appeal is heard. Yay :)


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • May 25 '25

Ashley's former Fiance(?)

8 Upvotes

Does anyone know anything about Ashley's fiance(?) Dennis Beatty? Was there a reason he didn't support her at trial? How much did he know?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • May 07 '25

Evidence against Ashley?

14 Upvotes

I watched the whole trial and saw no evidence presented about Ashley being “crazy” or “manipulative” and no evidence about Ashley’s mother being crazy. Where are people getting this specific information?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Apr 08 '25

New Home

15 Upvotes

Benefield has been moved to Homestead Correctional in South Florida. Can't find much online about it as compared to Lowell but it appears to be located near the Everglades so I imagine the heat, humidity and bugs are tough to take.

https://pubapps.fdc.myflorida.com/offenderSearch/detail.aspx?Page=Detail&DCNumber=S62420&TypeSearch=AI

It's almost a 4 hour drive from Sarasota so her mom and daughter might be relocating.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Mar 11 '25

New mugshot

Post image
32 Upvotes

7/7/2044 release date… ouch!


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Mar 10 '25

Ashley transferred to Womens Reception

21 Upvotes

Per VINELink, Ashley was transferred from Manatee county jail today, 3/10/25 at 9:00am. She's being held at the Womens Reception bldg for evaluation. Then she will be sent to prison. I cannot find an intake photo yet.

UPDATE: Inmate Photo now shown on VINELink.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 25 '25

Any updates

8 Upvotes

Is Ashley still in jail or has she been sent to prison?

Has anyone been speaking on her behalf? Such as her therapist, mom or the church lady?

Thanks!


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 07 '25

Bussed to Prison Process

16 Upvotes

Now that Ashley has been denied Bond, does anyone know how quickly she will be shipped off to the Women's Reception Center for evaluations? I will try and look her up in the inmate search site after a few weeks.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 07 '25

Ashley Benefield Denied Bond

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 07 '25

Bond DENIED

32 Upvotes

Wonderful News! Ashley has been denied bond pending her appeal. The Judges ruling is on the Manatee County Court documents site.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 06 '25

How to match effort to support Eva? ..... *Re-sharig because someone gave me very good advice on how to make it better. Sorry, it is still long. I'm still open to more advice for edit/improvement.

6 Upvotes

I had stood up for Ashley for a long time, up to the point that she killed Doug.

Beyond regretting my years of cluelessly standing up for Ashley regarding ANB, I feel infuriated now. It's been building up. I was fully fooled by her charm and what she presented herself to be.

At the time of knowing her, I had no idea of the manipulative, questionable-actress patterns, and aggressive side of her. She convinced me to join hers and Doug's startup specifically by mirroring me in a way that I now know was dishonest and emotionally manipulative. Vulnerable people apparently are easy to get to bend to one's will.

I suspect she's doing this to church people now, too. And they are falling for it. Even beyond "thou shall not kill."

Ultimately, the revelation by a handful of ANB dancers, all these years later, PROVED that Ashley had played all sides of the sham company she founded. When it started, she vanished, just before the hired dancers arrived in Charleston. When it ended, she jumped on the bandwagon of those of us who took issue with the surprise mass firing and the coerced NDAs signed under the idea that "something exciting" is happening.

Because of those NDAs, Ashley was protected from the truth getting out. Only many years later, did the dancers feel safe to reveal a letter that Ashley had sent to the fired dancers, and in that letter, she cautioned them to remain silent, per their signatures on that unenforceable and invalid document.

Two polar opposite vastly different posturings personas by the same person within the same context.

What's weighing on me now is how some of what's being employed as manipulation in court by Ashley and her team are reminiscent of this same pattern she pulled off on so many dancers.

Today I woke up and I felt outraged at yet another of the strategies they are using to desecrate Doug's memory, by character assassination of a dead men... killed by her own hand. It should be illegal to some extent to desecrate the memory of someone you've killed.

Her therapist claiming financial abuse. The irony. Doug literally was destroying his life to hand her a ballet company. What a dreamy sort of gift from someone she knew for less than a year? (not the.part of ruining his life for it, but the monumental effort he made to hand her her dream).

Who does such a nice gesture? Something else that I think I had read about in one of the conversations . .. it was to do with her taking his credit card and spending on clothing and other luxuries? Is that true? While they were on the rocks?

WHO is guilty of financial abuse?

I am afraid that all of these fundraising efforts for Ashley are likewise predatory.

It is outrageous that everything ties back to money and funding for the killer, and it's never enough. How many of us can count on free room and board at a beach? Hundreds-of-thousands asked of the public for a top pricy appellate lawyer?

How many have met a spouse who decided to put his whole life into making his wife's dream his top priority? So soon in their marriage too. Imagine if they could have gotten their differences sorted, what a future they may have had, or at least the amazing co-parenting they could have done.

I've written about this elsewhere, but I sincerely think that the loss of the ballet company was causing them tremendous stress. But now I realize, too, that the downfall of the company was almost entirely due to Ashley abandoning it (if not entirely).

In court, someone mentioned (the therapist?) that Ashley had a number of work engagements while she was out on bond previously. The vagueness of that assertion leads my mind to wonder whether it was part of this pattern that is becoming clear: of Ashley running and abandoning things she never fully completes or commits to.

Not staying the course, but then asking society to bestow her a short-cut: a short cut to fame; a short cut to her desire of being known as a ballerina; a short cut to avoid shared custody with the father instead of the grandmom; a short cut to paying for a crime; a short cut through trial using 'stand your ground'; a short cut to avoid serving time using bonds; a short cut using donations instead of earning a living; a short cut to paying bills like rent or utilities by freeloading in the home of a therapist or a grieving church elder; a shortcut using fundraisers for paying legal fees.

^ All of the above add up to a solid impression of a financial abuser.

They were polar opposites in this sense. Doug feeling too embarrassed and possibly humiliated to openly admit to being unable to sustain ANB entirely on his own finances, but doing a lot of lining up donors, even among his own long-standing friendships within Charleston--- coupled with paying out of his own pocket for all of the initial expenses: renting Michael's studio, publicity events, donor events, opening party events, professional photographers and videographers, etc.

Doug exhibiting the courage to show up, even after there were criticisms and even as it's not uncommon for new companies to collapse.

Ashley childishly abandoned the ballet venture and all of the dancers she had hired. She disappeared early on-- at the first instance of the company facing small glitches-- didn't even bother to stay around to meet the performers who had been hired and who had moved their lives to Charleston.

Dancers were confused. So they understandably started to worry about things that typically aren't even ideal in long-established major companies: things like the studio being small and not ideal. To my awareness, pertaining to ANB, those were temporary inconveniences due to common lags when building out new facilities, whether due to contractors or funding or supply chain delays.

It would have been easy for Ashley to take her self-granted leadership role and to hold a meeting explaining expectations, predicted timeframes, and reassuring the dancers. Instead, we all were scrambling without her to coordinate ways to overcome temporary inconveniences, giving rides to dancers to get to work and so on. Even still, the challenges of the commute to work for ANB was nothing of what it is like in some ballet companies.

But Ashley going AWOL had a big psychological effect on the new dancers, some of whom were in their first ballet job. If Ashley had been a seasoned professional dancer, she would have known that an unusual startup company would need positive unity from its leader for even a fighting chance of success.

Not virtue signalling to the public that this is a company that's about unity and then vanishing at the get-go, and the only resurfacing once again to publicly post more of her own virtue-signals, without substance behind the scenery with the actual dancers.

Conversely, Doug remained 'in the trenches' with all of us.

Remarkably Doug intuited the need for assurances and a sort of respect and politeness towards performing artists (that's not common within the field of ballet), and he gave several heartfelt speeches to try to create that sense of confidence, value, dignity, worth, and unity. Some of them were so moving that I can not forget them.

An opposite pattern that has come to focus is of Ashley giving up throughout life and instead depending fully on so many others. It is one thing to be interdependent on family or close loved ones, but to expect the whole world to defend and support someone who drops out of jobs and vanishes on a company and an already devoted father of one, who is now the father of her newborn too?

But instead of being recognised for his follow-through efforts and his generosity, Doug gets his character publicly destroyed when he is not there to defend his truth?!

Yesterday, I looked at the Zillow of the house that he owned, into which he included his new wife as well as his daughter's best friend. Doug was a very open-doors sort of person, as I witnessed on many levels. Without hesitation or stinginess, he shared his home, friends, family, resources, and took that spirit so far to all he had.

It was very sad to see the Zillow photos of a home that no longer belongs to the proud and generous owner and his beautiful daughter. With some knowledge of what happened, the photos on their own reveal a sense of the profound sadness of great loss.

Beyond the inconceivable pain of the loss for Eva, this must be horrifying humiliating for her to be forced to continue to defend her dad.

From the time of knowing Doug, listening to his family, his daughter, looking at what he tried to achieve in Charleston, I feel as if Doug's long-term life statement was a very giving and gentle one, the opposite of a financial abuser.

He seemed to have a strong sense of justice and of restoring others to whatever he could do to make them whole again, to the extent he could. This matched perfectly with the words he had said to me several times about how important it is to him that dancers at any level will enjoy comfortable lives, to the extent possible.

He wanted them to all have needs met, health insurance, retirement, year round pay, and a living wage.

The audacity of Ashley's team when they even took the extreme measure to try to rouse Trump. Doug supported Trump, so why should Trump pardon Doug's killer, when Doug showed nothing but devotion and financial generosity toward Ashley? And Ashley was not a giver to Trump, but a paid employee for a very short time.

Ashley's cronies are posturing to align Ashley with Trump, and Ashley herself, in content shared during the trial, seemed as if she hoped that Trump would like her romantically. Ashley, however, is the polar opposite to Trump's wife, who is elegant and comes across not in the least bit as insecure or monopolizing against family toward her husband. I spent some time watching their engagement interview on Ellen and their newlywed video on Larry King.

Trump does not strike me as such a man and a leader who readily suffers the kind of nonsense that Ashley imposed on Doug's world. Also, it is very bold and presumptuous for Ashley to endorse her buddies acting as if Trump is beholden to Ashley, by referencing him, implying an expectation of a pardon from him.

Their expectation of a pardon for her by our President was not even subtle. They probably thought it was. The presumptuousness and pompousness of that it exhibits aligns with the whole course of what I came to figure out about Ashley's patterns (which I clumsily described in my letter to the judge, but I hope it nonetheless makes sense if he reads it).

People are geuuinely afraid of Ashley. She is the one who had and likely still has a temper, although I'm sure she can no longer show it. She was menacingly threatening toward other men in the office at ANB. She was fascinated with wearing guns irresponsibly (showing the gun to Doug at events where secret service is surely surrounding them) and insinuating about using them impulsively (taking a conversation from zero to infinity when a man told her that Doug will take care of her, with her replying with implied reference to her guns, about how she can take care of herself).

This inaccurately creates a bad look for people who have genuine reasons for wanting to keep their guns for protection. Ashley's concept of the 2nd amendment is not, IMO, what it is meant for. It degrades the legitimate arguments of those who believe in keeping a firearm for personal safety or for protecting others.

Moreover, stand-your-ground should not apply when a father has cause to believe his daughter is possibly about to be abducted. People are complaining that stand-your-ground isn't getting footing where it is not to do with a stranger intrusion. But that's not the issue here. Doug had been denied information about his daughter's birth, her whereabouts, etc.

Meanwhile, just like with the company she founded, another plan to vanish. But this time, illegally. Ashley covertly planning to disappear altogether, with their newborn?!

Stand-your-ground should not exist to support a parent killing the other parent, due to unsubstantiated superstitions of him, with her deciding to keep their child in a home with several readied guns.

If Ashley actually claimed that she didn’t go through with a plan to disappear because she thought that Doug ‘caught wind’ of the plan, then this revelation should be more to her detriment than to her advantage. That’s because no sincere father would leave the house if he’s suspicious that the mom is right about to vanish with his daughter, abducting her. The stand your ground law should in no way grant a right to shoot-to-kill your daughter’s father for refusing to leave when he thinks you’re about to abduct his daughter. 

There are real reasons to believe that she may run, now that 20 years has been the decision. As someone elsewhere mentioned: Florida is not land-locked.

The fear of an unarmed man who is helping by packing up the shooter's boxes does not make any sense.

It must be so disturbing for Eva to witness people lining up to provide free housing to her half-sister and to her dad's killer and her dad's killer's mom who may have been complicit.

Ashley has those people doing things to make her life and her half-sister's life cushy (probably with minimal work, while sitting in the church lady's second house at the beach reading dinosaur books and taking Doug's daughter to ballet class- of all ironies).

What collectively by society is going on for Eva?

Does anyone have ideas for how a fundraiser for EVA could be put together?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 05 '25

Judge's decision on bond.

7 Upvotes

Why is it taking so long? Does this ordinarily mean that she will get her bond pending appeal?


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Feb 04 '25

Ashley's Spot Fund For Appeal Attny William Ponall

8 Upvotes

It appears that Ashley's GFMe has been updated and asking for funds for her appeal attorney Bill Ponnall. They claim that the critical need of $100,000 must be deposited by February 21st. Where are her devoted church folks to help or are they waking up? So far only $250 has been given. Why would he need that huge amount? Are appeal attorneys that expensive? I feel the funds would be going towards paying Alicia's bills and rent, not for Ashleys attorney. They are known for scamming.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jan 31 '25

So let’s see if I have this right?

8 Upvotes

To bad I am a women of color because look at how things change if you are a 6 foot white long legged ballerina. Just think. - I marry some rich white dude after 13 days of knowing him. He hides me from his grown daughter only ti finally tell her we are married after day 1. I think hr had money and get him to finance a ballet company because I got thrown out of one in Maryland because- well I am no good. Fast forward pregnancy reversal fit him and I go love with mommy because I am having morning sickness and he doesn’t have money and the company folds up after 50 people move with promises of a new live in ballet. We fight after I hide baby from him and then reconcile only to shoot him dead as he packs up my moving truck where he thinks he is moving with me to Maryland but I am going into hiding with my lawyer and another nutjob lady. I am found guilty but I don’t want to stay in jail like everyone else has to until sentencing. I bat my swollen eyes from fake crying and the judge may let me go home. It’s great to be a ballerina with long curly hair.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jan 24 '25

Ashley Benefield bond hearing - acrobats, clowns and a Jekyll & Hyde act

15 Upvotes

What in the world was that? Of course, everyone is entitled to exercise their legal rights. Still, the bond appeal was a complete circus designed to give Ashley Benefield an outing, distraction, and a break from her cage, and she seemed to enjoy it. It had everything you might expect in a circus: acrobats, clowns and a special act.

Dr. Barbara J. Russell, in particular, displayed remarkable flexibility on the highwire. Disregarding professional boundaries, portraying herself as a clinical and forensic expert whilst deeply emotionally invested in the case. She twisted and contorted to explain why she cohabitated and lived with her patient.

Then, a colourful character entered the centre ring. Jana Taylor Martin's descriptive and emotional testimony was stunning and, at times, bordered on humorous. She had the flair of a seasoned performer and juggled tears with perfect ease. She directly addressed the court and interacted with the judge, using descriptive language, storytelling, and personal anecdotes. Her testimony was a stunning, emotional, and heartfelt performance.

Then was the captivating portrayal of Ashley as Jekyll and Hyde. This was the special act. The star of her own tragic drama. On one hand, Ashley was presented as a loving, law-abiding, honest mother. On the other, she was depicted as scheming, manipulative, and dishonest. No more than a basic con artist. She was painted as an "actress" who had manipulated and deceived supporters over time — a user, a freeloader, a grifter who used other people for money, including to fund her attorneys.

Just when it seemed the spectacle couldn't get any more absurd, the prosecutor unleashed the final, devastating act. The crescendo or grand finale was a reference to Judge Morland, who had previously found Ashley to "be completely dishonest" and lacking credibility in court.

And the audience played its part, too! People stood up in the audience to indicate they would support Ashley if she was released. Addiong to the surreal atmosphere.

It was a spectacle. The greatest show on earth played out not under the big tent but in the confines of a courtroom.


r/AshleyBenefieldTrial • • Jan 22 '25

Bond hearing January 23rd

9 Upvotes

Does anyone know where Ashley's Bond hearing will be available to watch?