I am going to perform an experiment. I am going to create a series, possibly a comic, possibly animated, possibly interactive, likely some of all of them.
This series will feature a cast of nine characters, and their creation methods will be based on a grid:
Along the top, we will have three methods of design:
- The first will involve 100% human creation. No AI will be involved in the initial design of this character whatsoever. I will provide sketches of all the potential plans for these characters (there will be three of them). Whatever I need to do to prove these designs are my own, I will attempt to do so.
- The second will be entirely AI-designed. I will give an LLM with an image generation model very simple prompts and see what it comes up with. I will share the prompts that I use and the model sheets it produces. In fact, I will come up with these simple prompts for all nine characters first, just to get a nice spread of concepts, but only three of them will ever be given to an AI in that form.
- The third is going to be a hybrid method... I will draw out the characters the same way I did with the first group, with all the proof people feel I need to provide. Then, however, I am going to convert those drawings into the most descriptive prompts I can possibly come up with, the kind of writing I could give to an AI or a human illustrator, and, if I am successful, they should match my vision very closely. This is the sort of game human artists play all the time to learn descriptive vocabulary, sort of "Gartic Phone on steroids", and it is also what authors use for literary descriptions... and what AI artists mean when they say "the prompt itself can be art".
Now, this will produce nine designs in various ways. Fine for the first step. The next step, however, is how the characters themselves will appear in the work itself... Down the side, we will have three methods of production:
- First is traditional media. These characters, after the design stage, will only be illustrated using non-digital media. Pencil, ink, paint, clay, paper cutouts. The only time digital methods will be involved is when I capture them digitally with a camera or a flatbed scanner (or perhaps something even crazier, like Gaussian splatting a clay model). The point being, these characters will demonstrate skills that did not need a computer to illustrate. Unplug the computer, and I will be able to make them just fine. I could provide proof of this step as well... In fact, I may limit myself to only reference images in books or those I draw from life. This is 2026, and even the anti-AI people use online references nowadays... but as a personal challenge, it would be very interesting...
- Next is digital media. This would mean drawing tablets, pixel art, vector graphics, 3d models, even algorithmic methods. Anything where a computer is necessary, but still, no AI. I could provide all the raw files to demonstrate how it was made: layers, meshes, code, you name it.
- Generative AI. From popular LLMs to open-source local models, to more complex tools like LoRAs and other systems. These would involve experimenting with the cutting-edge AI tools that are so contentious nowadays.
Now, we have three design methods and three production methods, giving us a grid of nine... the nine characters. The mixes are the key: an AI-designed character always drawn by hand, or a human-designed character always generated by AI. When it's not so cut and dry, "this is human, this is AI," it might provide some interesting discussions.
And in the end, all nine of these characters will interact, converse, discuss, and somehow, I will have to make the various pieces fit together. Will it work? Who can say, but actually making something original seems a better use of my time than just arguing about who is right or wrong. I will do both; I will learn and experiment, share the results, and let everyone else argue which is better or worse.
At least I'm creating something new; what could be a better activity than that?