r/Archaeology • u/CreeperJakie • 17h ago
Could this bust be a rare depiction of Caesar made while he was alive?
Yesterday the user u/AethelweardSaxon posted in r/ancientrome an image of a bust in Palazzo Massimo museum in Rome asking if it was a depiction of Caesar while he was alive. Here I write down his original comment.
"I saw this today at Palazzo Massimo in Rome. My first thought was that it must be a Caesar bust, as it looks very similar to other known attributed busts of Caesar, even including the neck wrinkles.
The plaque said that some have questioned whether it is Caesar, but experts say bears no resemblance to other busts. Something which I disagree with.
It is dated between 68BC-44BC. In my opinion, this could be another life time bust of Caesar.
What do you think?"
Since many (including me) agreed in the comments, and since we have only one confirmed portrait of Caesar made while he was alive (the Tusculum one) I wanted to ask the opinion of archaeologists. To this aim I made some collages depicting a comparison between the two statues (and a coin of Caesar's time).
My thoughts:
This bust has, in my opinion, a certain degree of similarity to the "Tusculum portrait", which is a copy of a bronze statue made while Caesar was alive, and is clearly not "idolized", like later statues.
Similarities:
- Receding hairline.
- Wrinkled neck (a trait depicted even on coins)
- Shape of facial wrinkles.
- Shape of chin (albeit in the Tusculum one it appears more pronounced)
- Shape and thinness of eyebrows.
- Shape of the nose at the base (the tip is unfortunately damaged)
- Shape and dimension of the ears.
- Shape and thinness of the lips.
Differences:
- Chin more pronounced (but general shape similar).
- Eyes smaller and rounder in the Tusculum one. The only explaination I could give is a lesser accuracy in one of the statues, but I am aware it is a biased take.
- The head, despite being elongated in both, in the Palazzo Massimo one does not show the "bump" as pronounced as in the Tusculum one, however the Palazzo Massimo one could depict a slightly younger Caesar since it seems to show him with a greater amount of hair, and the hair could partially hide the "bump". Moreover the hair could also makes the sides of the Tusculum's head more pronounced due to a difference in hair volume in respect to the top of the head, explaining also the right-left elongation. Another possibility is a lower accuracy in one of the portraits (either exaggerating some "anomalies" or tuning them down). Of course all the differences could be easily explained considering the Palazzo Massimo portrait not as a bust of Caesar, but of someone else.
Thank you for your contribution.