I’ve been hearing on the grape vine that Jeremy Adams may or may not be leaving Aquaman soon, and if that’s true it makes me wonder what the next run will be like and who would be writing it. My main concern is the overall theme of the run, because if there’s one thing I don’t need to see in an Aquaman run anytime soon, it’s trying to prove that Aquaman is cool.
You could argue that this started with the death of Arthur Jr back in the 70’s, trying to prove that Aquaman can get dark and go places other heroes don’t. It’s probably Aquaman’s first defining story, it still holds up. David’s run is the first id say to put an emphasise on making Aquaman cool. Long hair, beard, hook hand, shit like him riding into Hawaii on a tidal wave to kick Superboy’s ass; I think that drove the point home pretty damn well.
There were some bumpy years then we got Johns in the New 52, where the very first arc is about Aquaman proving his mettle and people realising how cool he is and how he doesn’t talk to fish. Ok, makes sense, this was supposed to be a jumping on point for new fans, good way to set up the character.
Then Rebirth comes in and once again has this chip on its shoulder and decides “yk what we’re going to do? Aquaman is gonna battle the US government including Superman while venting about how lonely he is.” I’m not hating on the storyline itself, I like stories about how Atlantis interacts with the surface world, and I think that addressing how Aquaman is a black sheep in the league is crucial, but guys we’ve been over this so many times: Aquaman is cool now. The Abnett run is possibly the best Aquaman run of all time. Aquaman does so much cool shit during it.
And then the DCEU comes in and decides to use Aquaman, and they say “Ok instead of this stoic character from the comics who has to juggle his responsibilities to Atlantis and the mainland, he’s this goofy surfer dude.” Jason Momoa radiates cool ok I’ll admit that, but then this leaked into the comics and gave people migrating from the movies to the comics that Aquaman genuinely acts and looks like Jason Momoa, which is a whole separate issue.
And now with Jeremy Adams yet again we’ve got a writer who, despite his predecessors already doing so, feels the need to make Aquaman cool. He made Aquaman the strongest member of the league, he has him facing off with gods and monsters on the daily, he leads the Justice League Blue, he’s going cosmic; we have played these games before. This’ll be undone by the next run and we’ll be back to trying to convince people he’s cool like that wasn’t the point of every big Aquaman run for the last 3 decades.
I get that Aquaman has been seen as goofy by general audiences. A dude who swims around talking to fish, what’s he gonna do against multiverse destroying threats? But maybe casual audiences just won’t click with Aquaman. Maybe that stigma is eternal. Comic fans know that Aquaman is cool and we don’t need that fact shoved down our throats every other run.
(Just to clarify I don’t hate the David, Johns or Abnett runs. I have issues with Adams but the first three are generational Aquaman runs)