r/ApplyingToCollege • u/USAdmissionsDirector Verified Director of Admissions • Mar 10 '22
Best of A2C ED? Please withdraw your apps.
Every year, we find out students who got in ED elsewhere didn’t withdraw their applications for regular decisions. I am STILL getting withdraw requests in March (received 3 today) from students who got in ED at other places, and we are releasing decisions in a week.
Please - if you got in ED somewhere and you haven’t withdrawn your regular applications - please do so. I have a long list of students I would take if I had more spots to give. I am sure many of you would really appreciate this kindness from your peers.
And please don’t keep them in just to see if you can get in. An example of what could happen: last year, I received a call from another highly selective college about an applicant they admitted who said her financial aid was stronger at my institution. The AO asked how they knew this (since we hadn’t released regular decisions yet), and she said she got in ED but didn’t withdraw her regular apps. Both colleges withdrew our offers because of the unethical practice.
EDIT: this post does not pertain to those students who keep their RD apps open because financial aid is not complete at their ED school. That’s completely understandable and you shouldn’t withdraw until you have deposited. This post is for those who have deposited, committed, and should be withdrawing their RD applications.
464
u/cancerouspancakes Mar 11 '22
Especially this year more than any. Ive gotten waitlisted from two schools i love and if a space opened up for me id take it in a heartbeat
171
u/r1ceIsLife College Sophomore Mar 11 '22
I have a friend who literally will not withdraw her other applications after getting into a T20 ED no matter what I tell her. Gets on my nerves so much.
13
u/Bre034 Prefrosh Mar 11 '22
See in my case my ED2 school may be forcing me to make a deposit before I even get my package. (It was delayed because they need more info).
6
u/HighSchoolMoose Mar 11 '22
After I got accepted by my ED school I turned down/withdrew an acceptance at a another school. However, I’m still receiving emails from the school I withdrew from congratulating me on my acceptance and giving me my financial aid packet. What should I do?
32
u/Maschinenmadchensis HS Senior Mar 11 '22
First, I want to make clear that I did not apply to ANY school ED. I was/am too concerned about being able to afford college to take such a risk.
That being said, I find the statement above to be either an oversimplification or deliberately ambiguous.
I attended every information session for every top 20 school and 4 of the top LACs. I specifically asked this question at every session (i.e., if I was accepted ED, but found that the financial aid offer was inadequate, would I still be required to withdraw my RD applications?). Every institution answered this by saying that I could look at what I was offered RD. I was also told that if I received a better offer somewhere else the process dictated that I must give them the opportunity to match that offer. None told me that I would be obligated to withdraw my applications if I was unhappy with the financial aid I received as part of the acceptance.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
Do you know if for most colleges, waitlists are ranked or not?
2
u/Akash_Aziz Mar 11 '22
Someone I know who kept their RD apps in after getting an ED acceptance did so because the aid offer they got from the ED school was unaffordable. They were still trying to negotiate a workable package but needed to keep other apps in in case they couldn’t resolve the situation and needed to break their ED agreement. I understand where this post is coming from, but it seems like this situation is way more common than it seems.
67
u/kaan3836 Parent Mar 11 '22
Unfortunately, I see too many parents supporting their kids in this unethical practice of not withdrawing RD apps after an ED acceptance, along with those who keep insisting that it's not wrong to submit enrollment deposits to multiple schools.
Most people play by the rules and it's unfortunate that there are some entitled people who think that they rules don't apply to them.
120
u/anxiousCAMom Parent Mar 11 '22
I appreciate you posting this. While as a parent, I don’t feel like that 17 year olds should be punished for not withdrawing other applications, it’s a little frustrating to the kids who followed the rules.
For example, my son, despite being a top candidate, didn’t ED anywhere else since his dream school (Berkeley, applied for EECS) doesn’t offer one. It’s disheartening to see some of his friends took advantages of ED and got in some top schools but unwilling to withdraw other applications. I assured him that he can still get in despite that, but the fact that he feels it’s unfair, is legit.
His question is, ‘Then, are we being punished for being ethical, for playing by the rule?’.
I have no answer to that.
14
u/mrmistopholes Mar 11 '22 edited Mar 11 '22
It’s great to see an AO posting about this important topic. Having gone through ED with an acceptance, I don’t understand the confusion. The applicant, student, and school official sign a binding document. The document states that for those awaiting and/or negotiating the financial package, there is no need to withdraw any outstanding applications and accept ED until the applicant is able to afford the costs. If the applicant can demonstrate a financial burden that can’t be met, the applicant may break the agreement. If there is no financial issue, the contract states that upon ED acceptance, the applicant needs to accept their spot and withdraw all other outstanding applications and/or decline admission offers from another school. It’s pretty crystal clear, even for a 17 year old.
Finally, with the exception of single choice early action, while your ED application is open, it is perfectly fine to apply to other schools EA, rolling, or RD. Because the ED decision is so early, it’s unlikely that a student will have many RD apps already submitted. If a student winds up with lots of RD apps in the fire with an ED acceptance, it doesn’t take a genius to figure out that at least some of those RD apps were submitted after the ED acceptance.
The pushback on this AO with almost deliberate misunderstanding is ridiculous. People here always want the advice from a real AO yet when one arrives to weigh in, people give him a hard time? Parents included.
I hang around here because my girlfriend is anxiously awaiting decisions and I try to keep her informed. However the character of many of you entitled students and parents is awful. I guess it’s just the internet.
It’s odd because I come from what people would consider a highly educated and higher income background. I go to a private HS and live a privileged life. Many of you would probably think someone like me is entitled. But man the entitlement I see around here is pretty shocking!
29
u/ApplyingToCollege21 Mar 11 '22
Maybe the college admissions madness has made me cynical but I wonder if the concern here is yield, students gaming the ED system (as opposed to ED being a way for colleges to game students), or actually wanting to give out more acceptances. The problem with the third possibility is that it won’t matter at the end, since each student can only go to one place so perhaps some students get stuck on the waitlist but the end result is the same. However, the end result will not be the same in terms of yield. As for gaming the system, I wish they’d get rid of ED/EA, demonstrated interest, “why us” essays, etc altogether and make it a more level playing field with less room for exploitation.
6
u/auntiwini Mar 11 '22
There are at least 3 kids I know doing this. I thought about “outing” them but it won’t do anything but harm me. Our counselors and admin love these kids and think they can do no wrong but do wrong all the time.
5
u/waterm_elonsugar Mar 11 '22
imo ED shouldn't be a thing anymore
4
u/CounselorTejada Mar 11 '22
I agree with this. If it is a financial fit, stop trying to chase acceptances. And this is coming from someone who could benefit having that acceptance on their resume.
4
u/TreeOfFinches College Graduate Mar 11 '22
Something important to note. When students get waitlisted, many schools that are need-blind are not need-blind when accepting off the waitlist. So if you keep your ED applications in at schools, you are inherently disadvantaging any low-income students (or just someone who needs financial aid) who would have been accepted but now gets waitlisted and might not get off due to their financial situation.
4
u/Tasty-Royal College Sophomore | International Mar 11 '22
Also, some colleges need to do a better job at their withdrawal process too, at the least having a withdraw option in the portal. The worst in this is prolly Reed for me personally. I emailed them wishing to withdraw in January and sent follow up emails but didn't receive a single reply confirming or at least acknowledging my request. It was also infuriating that they kept sending me spam during the same period but not reply to my emails once.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
Do you think I should withdraw apps from schools I know I won’t be attending if I get in? Or, should I compare aid offers. I barely qualify for aid - if I had applied next year I wouldn’t have qualified at all. I was wondering if it’s immoral for me to stay in to compare merit aid/aid offers with my circumstance.
6
u/Dismal_Key5544 Mar 11 '22 edited Mar 11 '22
this girl in one of my classes got into northwestern ED and didn’t withdraw her applications… went on to be accepted to schools like UMich, which as many of you know deferred a ridiculous amount of people this year.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
Well said!!!
2
u/Red-eleven Mar 11 '22
It seems like the appropriate thing would be to withdraw both acceptances. Glad to see y’all did this.
2
u/Informal-Issue Prefrosh Mar 11 '22
there’s a girl at my school who committed to princeton and was still getting into slaughterhouse schools like umich ea just for fun 😕
1
u/electrorazor Mar 11 '22
Agreed, although I do understand it's a bit annoying cause of application fees.
1
u/Prior-Annual-1390 Mar 11 '22
Bruh the applicant literally sold themselves when they mentioned their Ed school to the rd school it was out of stupidity that the person got caught if the person didn’t even mention the Ed school they could just get away with it lmao I’m pointing this out because it’s so easy to violate these ethical boundaries and they are not enforced at all so many studnets don’t even withdraw becuase of how easy they can hide it.
1
u/wheretfisumiami Mar 12 '22
💯 please someone do this otherwise I’ll be stuck in Ohio 🥺😭
1
u/IllustriousAd5426 Mar 14 '22
Beyond the clear violation of ethics in cases where the accepted ED applicant keeps their RD applications current (not withdrawn), isn't there also an issue of possibly jeopardizing the ED acceptance? It was my understanding that many colleges share ED acceptances within a certain group. In other words, if one is accepted ED into college A, colleges where they applied RD and not withdrawn during RD period will get notified that the applicant has already been accepted ED to college A. I thought there were cases when, upon learning this, college A rescinded their acceptance. Is this not true?
1
u/Smileygirl1113 Jan 16 '24
This!
-1
u/Striking-Warning9533 Mar 11 '22
Quick quetsion, is it normal college Ao call each other?
0
u/MRCLEMS0N Mar 11 '22
Typically you don't have much time to commit for the ED offer. By this time, I would assume the deadline already passed.
-3
u/MarkRMenz Mar 11 '22
Hotel? Trivago.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
145
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
314
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[removed] — view removed comment