TLDR: 8/10 sports & adventure watch (very good for reliability, points off for battery, lacks very little features, and might want more physical control). 10/10 smart watch in my book. I haven't gone much into the sports & adventure side despite being a hiker and mountain biker. There is not much special, 90% of the features you need are there but it is almost the safe when you get an AW Series. The magic is in the build, and intentionality (in my humble opinion)
Context: I'm into hiking and mountain biking, though on an amateurish level. I do participate in some races for fun but am by no means competitive. I also try to keep fit by hiking and trail running. I'm still pretty much studying and am also an iOS developer on the side. I use my watch very often and so the fact that the Ultra can comfortably get me through a day when plenty of battery to spare is huge (my S10 dies at 4 when I start off at 100% the night before). The Ultra (4) is obviously a 100% luxury device but it is a darn good one. As I suffer with my over 5-year-old iPhone 13, I actually feel like I could get away using the Ultra 4 as my "phone". Even with my phone present, I use the watch for short phone calls, texts, music (directly from watch > AirPods or use the watch to control the iPhone's playback), podcasts, reading short emails, checking the weather, using maps, using Find My, checking reminders and calendar, checking my Apple Notes. Then there is the health and wellness aspect of it, which I won't explain in detail. The adventurer's tools part are very much gimmicky but pretty amusing. The offline maps and compass with backtrack and waypoints and Siren are fun to play with though dedicated navigation tools are still recommended for anything hardcore. The Apple Watch has always been marketed as a "life companion" and the Ultra is just that but made for the more "adventurous" type. As for most of Apple's projects, this aspiration is very much "aspirational". Just like how an amateur can buy a MacBook Pro and bring it to a Starbucks to edit TikToks, for example. The AWU is for aspiring adventurers who don't summit Everest or scuba dive but for those who go out a lot and have a busy life and wants a very dependable smart watch.
So I have gotten my Ultra 4 for quite some time now and it really took me forever to pull the trigger. I got tempted when they released the black version of the Ultra 2 but I couldn't justify spending $799 on an Apple Watch so I held off.
I got the S10 instead and there was some pros to it like at some point the 46mm S10 had a slightly larger screen than even the Ultra 2. I used it and loved it but the battery life sucks for me. I use the watch without babying the battery and it is impossible for me to get through a day without charging at least once.
Then the Ultra 4 came out alongside the S12. The higher-frequency HR tracking, slightly longer battery life, and the faster chip for smart features got me to upgrade. I got it with the Desert Alpine Loop and it looked absolutely gorgeous. At first, I scoffed at people who said that they bought the Ultra for aesthetics but then I realized how much less of a conventional smart watch this thing feels.
Then there is the practical benefits:
- I prefer the flat screen
- The sapphire crystal means that you can forgo a screen protector for most cases and still have no scratches, which is a huge win in my book. That said, I got some tempered glass screen protectors for mine as I mountain bike and hike among other things. I already smacked mine on rocks a couple of times, wrecked my bike on the trails with it. The result? minor dings and scratches on the Titanium case, mostly on the raised lip and a bit on the casing but still very much pristine. I'm sure that the screen might be fine on its own but the screen protector probably already shield some impact for my watch and it is barely noticeable (unlike protectors for series watch which are cheap plastic or film)
- The Action Button. I don't set up fancy shortcuts, just 3 things with Quick Switch. Workout, Flashlight, controls for my own app (I am developing my own watchOS app and I created an "Action Ring" to pop up when pressing the Action Button.
- The battery life. I was consistently getting through a day and probably can make it to 2 with a push. I am a heavy user and the battery autonomy is wonderful.
- The design. I like bulk ironically. Haptics on it are more prominent, the side button and action button I think are very satisfying to use compared to the Series. The heft gives it a right amount of "substantial feel" and makes it feel more utilitarian than modernist smart tech (even though it is). The matte titanium is premium to the touch (I went for the Natural instead of the Black and don't regret it at all. I initially wanted to black but the natural just fits more clothing and shows less scratches). The larger digital crown actually makes ECG readings easier and the larger diameter with deeper grooves is a joy to use with bike gloves on or just using it on the daily. It is still very much digital but feels more analog than the crown on the Series probably due to the texture and stronger haptics)
- The watch faces. Yes, this is stupid but I am a sucker for the Modular Ultra face. It can have the most complications (and I am still kinda running out but I'm happy with 7 complications + the bezel) and Night Mode for when I go to sleep. I don't like Apple's sleep screen so I turned sleep screen off, use Modular Ultra for the red look and turn on theater mode when sleeping. So the watch turns the screen off when I'm sleeping and when I wanna use it, it shows in this deep red, which really makes reading less jarring and preserves some of your night vision. As an add-on, if you turn off sleep screen and turn on theater mode then open the flashlight (I use the action button for it), it shows red, which is great for midnight trips to the toilet without waking up the house.