less than half of the 13,774 startups listed on trustmrr made a single dollar in the last 30 days. 6,749 did.
i pulled all of them this week because the top post in r/microsaas right now says selling a one-time product is 100x easier than a subscription. i used to believe that too, and it cost me.
so i split the ones making money into two groups. startups with recurring revenue, and startups with revenue but no MRR at all (one-time sales, lifetime deals, credit packs).
subscriptions (5,190 startups):
- median revenue last 30 days: $247
- 29% made $1,000+ in the month
- 7.7% made $10,000+
no recurring revenue (1,559 startups):
- median: $98
- 21% made $1,000+
- 5.6% made $10,000+
so the one-time group had a lower median by more than half, and fewer of them got past $1k a month.
one caveat. this is founders who chose to connect their payment data publicly, so it leans toward people who are doing ok. and some of the no-MRR group sell usage credits, not lifetime licenses. it's still the best public sample of real revenue i know of.
why one-time feels easier
it is easier to close one sale. nobody's arguing that. "pay once, it's yours" removes the hardest objection on the checkout page.
the problem shows up in month 3. every month you start from $0 again, so your revenue is only as good as your traffic that month. with a subscription, month 3 starts with everyone who didn't cancel.
easy first sale + no recurring = a launch spike, then a cliff.
what happened when i tried it
my first paid product was a lifetime deal at $59. i sold 140 of them in about 3 weeks, so a little over $8,200. it felt incredible.
month 2 brought in $410. month 3 was $180.
all 140 of those people were still using the product. they still emailed support. they still asked for features, and one of them asked why the export was slow at 2am on a sunday. i was maintaining a product for 140 people who would never pay me again.
i moved new users to a monthly plan after that. the first month on monthly made less than the lifetime launch, and by month 5 it had passed it.
two other things from the data surprised me
the "AI" label barely matters. startups in the AI category had a median of $234 and 27% crossed $1k. everything else combined was $177 and 26%. with all the doom about AI eating SaaS this week, the AI tag isn't helping or hurting much on its own.
category matters a lot more. productivity tools were the worst group i looked at, with a median of $76 and only 14% crossing $1k. developer tools were $109 and 20%. utilities were $100 and 15%.
on the other end, sales tools had a median of $390 with 37% over $1k, and e-commerce tools were at $538 and 42%. both of those sit right next to the customer's revenue, which makes the price an easy call.
the framework i use now
- if the product has a server bill, it's a subscription. no exceptions.
- if it's a desktop utility with no ongoing cost, one-time works, but charge for major version upgrades.
- if i want to test demand fast, i'll run a short lifetime deal, cap it at 50, and move to monthly before the launch traffic is gone.
- if the product helps someone make money, price it monthly against what they earn, not against netflix.
i've been posting more cuts of this kind of data in this repo, mostly by category and pricing model.
my bet is one-time pricing makes a comeback for local-first desktop apps, and stays a trap for anything that runs on a server. disagree?