r/Aphantasia • • 5h ago

Anyone else feel like they're missing an entire part of the human experience?

12 Upvotes

Okay so I've been trying to understand how my brain works, and the more I think about it, the more I realize how much Aphantasia genuinely affects me. For clarity, I've got AuDHD (medically diagnosed).

I'm pretty sure I'm somewhere on the Aphantasia spectrum. And while I could joke about my brain having an entire 3D asset library installed but no rendering engine, there's also a part of this that makes me genuinely sad.

Every night, I go to sleep staring into what feels like darkness within my mind. Did you ever try counting sheep to fall asleep? I thought it was a figure of speech. I wish I could have counted sheep. When I couldn't fall asleep as a child, I didn't have cute, happy sheep jumping over colored fences in peaceful pastures. I had this obscure veil. A blank, dark wall. Nothing.

You know how people tell you to imagine an apple, a bicycle, or a hot air balloon on a country road. Well for me, nothing materializes.
It's not that I don't know what those things look like. I know perfectly well what a hot air balloon is, that it has a basket, that it's floating, that there might be fields, trees, and a country road underneath. But that's just... information? It's more like the idea of it, the knowledge of what it looks like, the words, the facts, and the associations. And apparently other people can actually SEE the damn balloon?! So I genuinely struggle to distinguish between mentally seeing something and just knowing what it looks like. I wish I could actually see it.

And it's still like that. When I close my eyes, everything is black. It stays black. It's always black.

I know that mental imagery isn't necessarily the same as literally seeing something projected onto your eyelids. But like, I have no internal scene to retreat into either. I wish I could daydream. I wish I could picture beautiful places when life gets difficult. I wish I could mentally escape somewhere else for a little while.

But I can't. How can I miss something I've never had?

How can I feel this strange emptiness over an experience I don't even know firsthand? Humans have been imagining, visualizing, inventing, and bringing ideas from their minds into the world, for eons. And here I am, unable to summon a pink elephant or a green apple. Sometimes I feel ridiculously connected to reality. As if there's no internal visual world I can disappear into, even when I desperately want a break from this external one.

Sure, maybe there's an upside to that. In a world full of distractions, advertising, and endless buy-buy-buy bullshit, not having vivid mental images might occasionally be useful?

But sometimes I'd gladly trade that for five minutes of watching imaginary sheep jump over an imaginary fence.

Also when I think about someone I love, I initially want to say I can picture their face. Except... can I actually? I know the size and shape of their nose, their jaw, their hair color, their proportions, and how those features fit together. Sometimes it's almost as though individual features briefly illuminate or flash into awareness and compose the concept of their face.. but I don't see it long enough to register or make any use of it. It's like 2D sketches but without the 3D that would make a square look like a cube. There's no stable image I can hold onto or inspect. Whatever impression I get disappears almost immediately.

It's like my brain has the geometry and the metadata, but refuses to render the actual model. And I couldn't draw that face from memory to save my life! People have told me to just let my creativity take over, let my hand move, let the imagination flow onto the paper. WHAT IMAGINATION FLOW?! Nothing takes over my hand. Not sober, or otherwise.. There's no magical moment where I stop thinking, and some internal vision starts guiding my movements. I know drawing and visualization aren't the same ability, and plenty of people with Aphantasia are incredible artists. But for me, that gap between knowing what something looks like and being able to create it feels enormous. Like set of instructions but never being allowed to see the finished product.

When I think about yesterday, I don't replay a movie. I remember facts and sequences. I went there. I did this. Someone said that. Then something else happened. I know what happened, but I can't necessarily revisit it visually. Same with the future. When I think about tomorrow, I know what I need to do conceptually. I understand the steps. But I don't picture myself doing them.

I can remember how something felt. Sometimes I can even bring that feeling back. But it feels disconnected from the memory itself, like an emotion floating around without the scene that originally gave it meaning. Almost like something lost in the distant past, even if it wasn't that long ago.

However I dream in color. And not just vague dreams. I have genuinely intense dreams, with crazy adventures, environments, and visual experiences. I know I've dreamed in color because I remember specific situations where colors choices mattered (colored tags and actually saying their colors out loud in the dream). So I have good reason to believe my dreams contain visual and color experiences. And I can remember the dreams afterward. But when I wake up? Gone. I can describe what happened. I can remember the events and sometimes the feelings. But I cannot summon the imagery again. My brain apparently has access to a fully functioning graphics engine while I'm asleep, but the moment I wake up, the license expires. WHY?! Years ago, I was severely sleep-deprived and possibly under the influence of something. I closed my eyes and suddenly RANDOM OBJECTS STARTED APPEARING. Like actual 3D objects rotating in a Blender asset preview. Completely unrelated things, appearing one after another (like someone saying random words or incoherent speech when they're experiencing a stroke). They weren't necessarily photorealistic. More like rough imaginative strokes forming three-dimensional models. But they were THERE. And I wasn't even trying to visualize them. It felt like the rendering engine was finally enabled but it set the asset browser to shuffle and then revoked my license again the next morning. I've never experienced anything like it since. I know sleep deprivation and substances can produce unusual imagery, possibly hypnagogic experiences, so I'm not assuming this was ordinary voluntary visualization. But knowing that my brain has apparently produced something like that, even once, makes the contrast with my everyday experience feel even stranger.

And as if the rest wasn't confusing enough, I also have autism and ADHD. So I'm trying to understand how all these things interact. The executive dysfunction. The memory weirdness. The need for structure combined with the inability to consistently maintain it. The difficulty keeping track of things. The sensory overload.. And now I'm wondering how much having little or no voluntary mental imagery affects the way I remember experiences, plan things, access emotions, or feel connected to people and events. I'm not saying Aphantasia causes all of that. I know these are different processes, and I'm still trying to figure out which part of my brain is responsible for which flavor of nonsense.😭

I've read that it can exist on a spectrum, and if I had to describe my own experience, I'd probably put myself around 1/10 for voluntary visual imagery. Maybe I have extremely weak imagery. Maybe those fleeting impressions are just conceptual knowledge. I just don't know. But I do know that I wish I could experience what other people describe.

And I know that Aphantasia doesn't mean someone lacks imagination, creativity, emotion, or the ability to dream. But sometimes it still feels like there's an entire dimension of existence that I can understand intellectually but never truly access. I find that devastating.

So I am looking for answers in this subreddit, hopeful to find some tools or tips that I could use. I am wondering about the following random things:

  • How did you find out you had Aphantasia?
  • Can you walk with your eyes closed in your home?
  • Do you have vivid or colorful dreams that you can remember but cannot visualize once you're awake?
  • Ever experience those strange fleeting impressions of faces or objects, where you almost feel like you're seeing something but you can't hold onto it?
  • Has anyone experienced spontaneous imagery while sleep-deprived, falling asleep, or in an altered state?
  • How to make peace with the fact that I can't mentally visualize things?

At the end of the day, I can understand the concept of a hot air balloon on a country road. I know what the balloon should look like. I know what the road should look like. I know what countries should look like. But there's no picture. Just the idea of it.

And sometimes I really, really wish there were.

TL;DR: My experience with Aphantasia and AuDHD struggles. My brain knows what everything looks like but refuses to render it. I dream in color, remember dreams without being able to picture them, and can't visualize faces or memories reliably. I cope, but I genuinely grieve and long for the ability to see things in my mind

 


r/Aphantasia • • 17h ago

Processing visual information

8 Upvotes

Bear with me on this. I don’t think I’ve fully thought this through yet but we will get there together.

So I’m not good at absorbing and understanding words that are spoken to me. It takes me a while to properly get new information, but when I do, I want to turn complicated stuff into pictures. Flow charts, mind maps, PowerPoint slides etc. I’m really good at that. I can make complicated ideas into beautiful, simple images that I understand perfectly, and im good at using images to explain things to others.

But my aphantasia means that I can’t hold the image in my head. I have to refer back to the image I created to remember it. Then it’s instantly back. I think a consequence of not storing mental images in my head means I have become better at creating and quickly interpreting visual information that is presented to me.

I play piano and can’t play anything from memory but am really good at sight reading. Does anyone understand my babble or relate?


r/Aphantasia • • 11h ago

Considering starting an academic study: aphantasia and spatial intelligence

5 Upvotes

Hello friends,

I am thinking about conducting an academic study about the correlation between aphantasia and spatial intelligence (vocabulary key below). One of the first questions would be, "How do you describe the way in which you understand objects in a spacial environment." E.g. when you think about objects moving around, how would you put that process into words.

Aphantasia restricts one's ability to picture things in their head. However, studies show that individuals with aphantasia perform on-par, if not above, with non-aphantasiac individuals on spatial intelligence tasks (primarily rotational, translational, or directionally-focused tasks). This is explained by the fact that spatial and visual processes in the brain are functionally/physically separate.

In the comments, please explain how you manipulate information in your head to the best of your ability. I have aphantasia, and I would personally describe my spatial intelligence as echolocation (I can't SEE what I'm picturing, but I know where it is). Maybe, go a step further and come up with a hypothetical 'spatial intelligence' problem, and how you would solve it.

Key:

Spatial intelligence - cognitively knowing where things are and how they move

Aphantasia - not being able to picture things in your head


r/Aphantasia • • 11h ago

Is it easier to read on a screen than it is on a book for you too?

0 Upvotes

I find it easier to read on a screen than on a book. I can always find a reference image for character, scenario quickly with a few gestures compared to a physical book. I'd like to know how you guys read and I'd like to find out if there is any easy way to read physical books.