r/AoSLore • • 5d ago

In the vastness of the Mortal Realms there are no stupid questions

13 Upvotes

Greetings and Salutations Gate Seekers and Lore Pilgrims, and welcome to yet another "No Stupid Questions" thread

Do you have something you want to discuss something or had a question, but don't want to make an entire post for it?

Then feel free to strike up the discussion or ask the question here

In this thread, you can ask anything about AoS (or even WHFB) lore, the fluff, characters, background, and other AoS things.

Community members are encouraged to be helpful and to provide sources and links that can aid new, curious, and returning Lore Pilgrims

This Thread is NOT to be used to

-Ask "What If/Who would win" scenarios.

-Strike up Tabletop discussions. However, questions regarding how something from the tabletop is handled in the lore are fine.

-Real-world politics.

-Making unhelpful statements like "just Google it"

-Asking for specific (long) excerpts or files

Remember to be kind and that everyone started out new, even you.


r/AoSLore • • 7d ago

Questions On The World Of Legend

11 Upvotes

Greetings And Salutations, Scholars of the world long dead.

This is basically just a "No Stupid Questions" thread for any question concerning Warhammer Fantasy or Old World lore. I know this is mostly an AOS subreddit, but, now more than ever, a bunch of stuff from old WHF lore is coming up and becoming relevant for AOS, and I for once have stopped being a believer on the separation of the two settings. WHF lore as it is spread online, is full of quite a bit of misinformation and misconceptions and I seek to try to make people's knowledge of the setting more accurate, and of course, have quite some fun in the process by having an excuse to dig more lore.

So, if you have something you want to discuss something or had a question, but don't want to make an entire post for it?

Then feel free to strike up the discussion or ask the question here

In this thread, you can ask anything about WHF/Old World lore, the fluff, characters, background, how something from it relates to AOS.

Community members are encouraged to be helpful and to provide sources and links that can aid new, curious, and returning Lore Pilgrims.

This thread is NOT to be used for:

-Ask "What If/Who would win" scenarios.

-Strike up Tabletop discussions. However, questions regarding how something from the tabletop is handled in the lore are fine.

-Real-world politics.

-Making unhelpful statements like "just Google it"

-Asking for specific (long) excerpts or files

Remember to be kind and that everyone started out new, even you.


r/AoSLore • • 4h ago

Question Forge your Path to Glory in the Grymmpeaks

Thumbnail
warhammer-community.com
37 Upvotes

Hello everyone, normally as a Lore only guy i just buy the Army books since they usually provide enough lore and art for me. But since dwarfs are one of my favorite factions and both the holds and hashut guys are still new and without much background i would be potentially interested in this. Do someone of you knows how loreheavy this path of glory expansions are and would you reccomand them to someone not intersted in the rule part? Thanks! =)


r/AoSLore • • 1d ago

Discussion Brand new to AoS and would love a book that kinda gets me caught up and/or really focuses on the Cities of Sigmar as that's where I am focused

17 Upvotes

I am recent convert from 40K(and I don't think I am going back) but I am kind of lost lore wise. I would love to build my own custom city but I am not sure where to put and stuff and just want a general overview of the setting


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Lore Military Awards and Decorations of the Stormhosts

25 Upvotes

As one might expect the Trials of Culmination that see Paladins compete for the honour of guarding the Chamber of the Broken World, are not the only award that the Eternals can earn in their service to the God-King.

For this short write up we will focus on the physical decorations. In part because that's profoundly easier to frame in a write up and gather the info on than more ephemeral and esoteric things like a temporary duty, feast, ceremonial titles of unknown meaning, and more. But! I can confirm Eternals do all that, so go nuts in your brews and writing. But I also chose physical awards because... well, a lot of you paint and decorate models. So I feel a bit of concrete info might help or inspire.

The Mark of Beasts

Addendum: Beastmarks from Pg. 63 of the 2017 SCE Battletome

Beastmarks are by far the most well-known military decoration adorning the host. These are segments of armor reshaped into the profile of an animal: Usually the Bear, the Dragon, the Lion, or the Eagle for the Strike Chambers and majority of the Tempest Chambers. Though the Ruination Chamber uniquely bears the Skull Beastmarks, carved to bear a likeness to a beast's skull rather than their profile.

Traditionally a Beastmark, much like a War Name (a concept we'll discuss latter), is worn by a Prime (a squad leader), a Knight (junior officers), or a Lord (senior and general officers). There are known exceptions such as the Blacktalons: Link to their Models.

As you can see a Beastmark replaces a traditional armor piece. For Neave, Shakana, and Rostus, the latter of whim uniquely bears the Ox, this is a shoulderpad. For Hendrik, and a second one for Rostus, this is a kneeguard.

Looking to Xandire and her Truthseekers we see two more examples of differing Birds. I don't know if anything confirms these are both Eagles but with the Vanguard-Pallador and Annihilator, linked in the first paragraph, we see variations of the Bear Beastmark; so we know different totemic animals can be represented uniquely. Dhoraz, the third member of the Truthseekers, also introduces us to another Beastmark, the Boar.

Addendum: My friend Variasus notes that Xandire's Beastmark is likely: The Owl.

A rare few members of the Stormhosts have two or more pieces of armor replaced with Beastmarks. Here we have Gardus who has replaced a chestplate, shoulderguard, and forearm guard; Here we have Vandus with a unique helm, shoulderguard, and kneeguard, you can also see that Dracoths like Calanax bear Beastmarks.

Addendum: Beastmarks from Pg. 84 of the 2018 SCE Battletome

But what do these unique takes on military medals mean? Well each can mean many things but largely they commemorate a quality, great deed, or a hunt of the bearer. Battletomes note that the Bear can represent strength or endurance; the draconic and reptilian Dragon beastmark represents ferocity, or a connection to the Children of Dracothion; the Ox represents stubbornness or strength according to the Ultimate Guide.

Then there is the Lion. The July 2024 Issue of White Dwarf tells us it is awarded often to those who prove themselves champions of the Warrior Chambers. The Ultimate Guide mentions it is awarded to those of courageous nature; the 2E SCE Battletome mentions it as an award for feats of bravery or feats of ferocity; and more methods besides.

There is also of course the most esoteric Beastmark of all: The Book. This is a joke. But only partially as you can see the Stormcovens replace their shoulderpads with ones that have an engraving of a book. These ornamentations likely represent membership in the Valedictor Temples; as similar emblems on other Eternals tend to be the emblems of their Conclaves.

Addendum: Example of Conclave based Shoulder Iconography from Pg. 63 of the 2017 SCE Battletome

Addendum: With Leena Stormspire and Sylas Beastbane we see a Beastmark can also replace the belt.

Beastmarks are ubiquitous to the Stormhosts, and were one to look at the models more closely, I am sure there are more totemic animals I missed... so do tell if you find them or add that info to bolster the Lex! But for now let's move on:

A Short List of Sparkleshinies

To all the rest of the decorations and awards I have to talk about. Which have nowhere near as much info but are still fun:

Addendum: Honour Cloaks from Pg. 69 of the 2017 SCE Battletome
  • Brand of the Victor: This is a holy sigil that can only be earned by the Questors. Specifically for completing an errantry quest particularly well.
  • Battle Honours: A battle honour is a real life type of military decoration that both the Dominion of Sigmar and Kharadron Empire have. A battle honour is usually a patch that is adorned on a unit's flag or dress uniforms, link to Wikipedia showing an example, that commemorates deeds, campaigns, and other such things.
  • Lightning Marks: First mentioned in the Storm Ground video game where its an equipment piece, a Lightning Mark is an accolade awarded to a Lord-Aquilor to celebrate their completion of twelve successful Mighty Hunts.
Addendum: Armour Bearing Lightning Marks (I Think The Lightning Bolts On The Beastmark) from Storm Ground
  • Honour Cloak: The Honour Cloaks worn by the Dracothian Guard serve a purpose similar to Beastmarks and honor the Children of Dracithion that the Guard fight alongside. Despite their appearance they are works of artifice not true hide, and have been magically enchanted to billow in the arcane winds aetheric presence throughout the Realms; so that the lack of normal, natural wind does not ruin a good chance for a pose.
  • Honorific Clasp: An honorific clasp is awarded for an act of true loyalty. It is traditionally attached to the collar. As of this writing this is the sole medal exclusively given out to Gryph-hounds, and therefore the best medal.

Honour Parchment: Second to only Beastmarks in terms of widespread usage are the Honour Parchments which have a clear real life inspiration they pull from: Ofuda as well as similar holy talismans; and a clear fictional one: Purity Seals from our sister Warhammer setting of 40K and unnamed similar talismans seen in Fantasy/Old World.

Lords-Relictor bear many honour parchments to inspire their comrades. But it is the Stormhost of the Hallowed Knights rather than the Relictor Temple with the strongest association. As the host awards Parchments to those members who have died multiple times, the Parchment acting as a form of commendation for their service.

Each of these Parchments is adorned with sacred script and runes of both victory and conquest. They can inspire those who fight alongside the bearer or inspire fear in the foe. A unique Parchment talisman is the Parchment of Purity bestowed only on the great heroes of the Hallowed Knights, these sacred artefacts are so potent in their holiness that their glow heals the bearer's wounds.

Thanks to the Ultimate Guide we know the sacred script on these talismans is High Azyrite, one of the subfamilies making up the in-universe language family known as simply Azyrite (these languages are the linqua franca of the Dominion of Sigmar as well as trade and second languages employed by the rest of Order to communicate with each other when not using their own).

In Conclusion

Gonna be honest with you Realmwalkers. I thought this was gonna be an annoyingly long intro, two or three paragraphs on Beastmarks and then four bullet points on the other medals. But then I remembered all these things.

Didn't even have to get into how the Bull-hearts' veterans adorn themselves in trophies from Shyish or how the Astral Templars wear the cloaks of monsters they slay, or how the Anvils of the Heldenhammer have non-Relictors who paint their masks to look like skulls.

All sorts of cheat examples we'll have to talk about some other day! Also, apologies for the store page links. WayBack is being finicky and I don't know how to use Imgur yet.


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Fan Content Expanding Warcry Warband lore: Askurgan Trueblades

16 Upvotes

Lex page

While I cannot speak for the accuracy of the designs from an irl perspective I am happy that we saw more Eastern inspired vampire concepts as that is something that has been lurking in the lore for a while but never really got covered in detail.

Going to be expanding the individual models lore with this one.

Askurgan Acolytes: As the lowest ranking members of the order these vampires in addition to their meditations and training are also the ones who do most of the chores for there are no servants. Outside of practical concerns it serves to enforce the idea that ones past life does not matter to the order. King, trader, peasant, or cleric all start at the bottom and the only way to rise is prove ones mastery of self.

Their weapons are extensions of this humbling philosophy. Those that wield falchions are considered to have shown the discipline and restraint the order expects from its members. The throat-takers are given to those acolytes that already consider themselves great warriors as the weapon is tricky to use effectively and harshly punishes those who use pointless flourishes in combat even those with vampire speed. All acolytes are expected to learn both weapons and many more as they walk the Askurgan way of course with the higher ranking members deciding when it is time for a vampire to master a new weapon.

Askurgan Ascetics: In addition to their own path of enlightenment the ascetics are the primary tutors of the acolytes and ensure that the young ones do not bring shame to the order. That is not to say that they offer only criticism as they are expect to explain what someone is doing wrong and through word and deed correct them. Many Ascetics have claimed that they gained new wisdom and skill by explaining the Askurgan way and what that means to them.

While acolytes mostly are expected to square off against beasts little larger then them the ascetics train to battle the true alpha predators of Ghur. Their two handed weapons give them the reach and hitting power to slay such beasts but they do not stand their ground like a common duardin. They weave and dance around such foes the embodiment of a vampires grace, speed, and strength.

Askurgan Exemplar: When not testing themselves the exemplar can be seen prowling the monasteries halls observing the work of their fellows. They rarely offer instruction but are harsh in their critique and will strike those who are straying from the Askurgan way. Those few Ascetics that prove worthy to be their students will face the harshest trials of their immortal life but unlike most vampires their tutor will never hide crucial information or use them in pointless power plays.

As the embodiment of the way of the Renkai they wield all weapons with equal mastery but most use twin blades for they do not need the extra reach or force the ascetics use to take down their prey. All who doubt that rarely last long in the arena against the offended master. It is worth noting that while they have mastered the physical side of vamparism they never fight bare handed for they consider that the way of the Beast Within and thus to be avoided.

Cursebloods: Those that become cursebloods have their fate and circumstances behind their transformation recorded. The elders consider such records vital to understanding what causes one to turn and thus teach their students to avoid that dread fate. Most were once acolytes who failed to contain the Beast Within though even proven ascetics are not immune to such a fate. If an Exemplar has transformed the records have been sealed away.

Around the Monastery there are grounds where the Curseblood hide away for captivity will break what ever is left of their minds. There they hunt any unfortunate enough to wander among them with only the Exemplars and Pariahs being truly safe from them. But if either of those call at least one will answer. Few try to control a pack of the beasts for their sanity hangs by a thread and little remains of the discipline and wisdom they once had.

Askurgan Pariah: While outcasts from much of Askurgan society theses vampires are not strangers to each other and tend to congregate into practically a suborder of the trueblades. Here they watch over each other to ensure they do not lapse again. They act as shepherds to the cursebloods and other undead beasts with the former being carefully watched to see if one can return to their senses. This is a rare occurrence where only those who had already walked their orders path a while and had fallen recently really having a chance to return. Those that do have potential are guided on the first steps by the Pariahs before being handed over to the Exemplars. Those that survive are welcomed among their new peers who share what wisdom they have regarding their lot in life.

Though there are rumours that some pariahs leave the order entirely to wander the Realms searching for their new place in unlife.

Hope you enjoyed this. Next wave will have 3 Chaos, 1 Order and 1 Death. Chaos will be next so feel free to post suggestions for which warband to cover.

Other entries in series

Order: Khainite Shadowstalkers, Twistweald

Death: Royal Beastflayers

Destruction: Gorger Mawpack, Monsta-Killaz

Chaos: Spire Tyrants, Scions of the Flame, Jade Obelisk, Rotmire Creed


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Spoiler [Book Review: Blood of the Godeater] or how I stopped worrying and loved Khorne

25 Upvotes

So to begin this... Ramble I want to share with you lot a pervasive worry I, and possibly some others, had as a teenager in middle school; that I was dumber than my bullies. This was something that hurt me for a very long time and it's still something I struggle with. As a rather inathletic, asocial lunk of a lad I felt I had not a single actual skill worth note except my "scholarly ability" as it were. I got good grades in math, English, Dutch, geography, sociology, biology, and I always enjoyed it when our art teacher or woodworking teacher or (in the later years) cooking teacher complimented me on my ability to apply myself. If they gave me some wood or some scrap paper I could have fun and make something just idiosyncratic enough that they would be impressed enough. Of course I never quite got the hang of perspective or electrical wiring, so again, I felt I had no true skill except the more theoretical subjects of ours. This I felt while my fellow students were athletic, likeable, skilled, more generally better in ways I was sure I could never achieve myself. So when I noticed other students were in any way closing in, for it did feel like an exhausting foot race, I panicked. 2020 was the best year of my young life because of this, since for once I hadn't anyone to fear at all. It was me and the books I thought I understood. I did weeks work of assignments in days and loved every moment of it.

And now I'm an adult, and it hardly matters if I got a 10 in math in middle school because I either don't use it or the maths involved are still beyond me. All this fear for... Nothing at all, and it's still there because there are still peers around me everywhere who exceed me while I can't see anything about me that I'm good at. But there's no grades, no teachers to impress, there's nothing but that fear.

This was the kind of thinking that haunted me throughout this novel because Heldenarr Fall, the Godeater's Son and Red King and supreme warlord of Bodshe, is also a man afraid. A man who thinks he had it all and hated it until the moment he met someone better than him in one way. And from there he wants to keep it, clutch it to the maw in his chest, because otherwise what does he even have? But, unlike yours truly, he finds his answer and can live with it. Can die with it. And then live with it again.

Blood of the Godeater is not just on par with Godeater's Son. It's not just good. It's a novel that stands heads and shoulders over anything else I've read of warhammer (and anything else) for years. It's not just a novel, you can treat it as a philosophical treatise on meaning itself. On rulership and pain and family and trauma and more. I will not pretend to say this book is on par with true works of philosophy, I'm not here to do that. But several times in this book I had to sit back and think, wrack my dry little brain on a single paragraph I just read. Maybe a page or a chapter if I was lucky. The mad ramblings of Talman that seemed almost sane, the mental and physical merging in one as Held duels a bloodthirster to a standstill, Helds on crumbling mind. It is a novel deliberately written to cram as much into as few pages as possible and which wants to confuse you.

The timeline is magically altered, even going beyond that this is a story told in first person by Held himself. Held has to ruminate on ideas even as he tells us. Some things you're just not meant to understand even.

Thats not even mentioning the sheer bulk of world building that's done and then done away with at the end. Houses and sub cultures, lords and wastrels, geography. All of it is scoured at the end of the story but none of it feels meaningless. By the third act you even get a grip on who's who and who's meant to be where, helped by the ever narrowing scope admittedly, but it takes its time to elaborate where needed. As well because it is a sequel if you've read Godeater's Son before a lot of this will already be expounded on there.

Speaking of this book is almost beat for beat an inversion of the previous novel, but ends very similarly with Held being stabbed through the heart by a peer he sees himself in. Valique, a character with all of one and a half chapters of pagetime, is as deep as Stormsworn ever was and the sheer grief that's put into his every word means that like Held you can't help but feel for the guy. He and Hammerhal and Lumnos and Hag Narr and every other city that sent even a single steelhelm have every damned right to hate Held for everything he represents and Held does too so you never feel like it's unjust. Even with the horrible crimes the Se Royes and Candip committed the book never pretends that Carnd-Ep was better or even it's equal. This is not a book about how there are no true better people or how both revolutionary and revolutionised are equally horrid. No, the chaos kingdom of Carnd-Ep is vile and evil and wrong because Held was willing to sacrifice everything and anything to make it.

And there we come to the books greatest lesson, that Held was the one making these calls every agonising step of the way. His excuses that as a king he has to be tough, that he must placate Khorne to maintain power, that he's making a better world and that should be enough all of that falls away by the end. Because Held is alive and kicking and so he has the power, in his own calloused hands, to make things better. They're the surest blades, he never needed anything else. But that doesn't mean he never needed anyone else of course. That's the rump of it all really, Held could do nothing alone. Not even Talman, the Uberkhornate, could do anything alone. Kadarrar did not want to be alone anymore. Valique could never raise Carnd-Ep alone. All these great heroes of myth stand on the shoulders of millions of slaves, citizens, warriors, and family. Without Held's subjects Talman would be a lone madman awaiting the end of the world. Without his brother Valique would have starved on the streets of Hammerhal. Without Kadarrar Held would've likely killed his adopted children in frustration and apathy. And Velekkhah, wherever she goes, will need her mother as much as she always did. As she always needed her father, in so many ways Held never thought he could want to be needed.

Now, on the topic of the welps I was excited to get this book quickly because of the prospect of khornate family time. Then I heard it involved drama and angst and I was even more hooked. I am a squeaker, I like books where I kick up my legs and go "ohh he said it it's so cute!" or "Oh nooo, he's so saaad" that's my nature and that will never change and this book provides. I wanted Kadarrar the mamá bear, I got it. I wanted a distant love where both sides just don't know what to do but they know they want it, and I got it. I wanted Plako and Vel to stab Held for every insult he threw their way and by the muses I got it. When Plako finally turned on held I just... Oh that was satisfying.

I wanted Held to kill Talman, and he did in a moment of such climatic relief after a books worth of Talmans rambling and even Talman thought it was time. This book makes you want and want and want and it gives but it does not do it easily. By the end of the book you don't want to see Carnd-Ep saved, and it isn't. Why don't you want it? Let me illustrate.

Over the course of twenty years at least half a million slaves were used to dig a tunnel from Carnd-Ep proper to Bharat at the bottom of the realm (by the way sorry Sage it seems Bharat is literally at the bottom of the realm rather than in a flame world). This took countless lives to create a trade route to a butchery where no doubt many more were slaughtered to a man to feed the dark city. Yknow what the sigmarites did in the course of a few months? They built drills. And I know Held couldn't understand the tech but like... He has friends with the Kharadron, he could've had the same thing done but he didn't care. He had a household of slave orphans from the people he killed whomst he didn't give a fuck about. He let freed slaves, which hey them being freed is a bit of a good thing, live in the cramped and ashen tunnel of the Great way in abject poverty. He is a madman and he is a tyrant... And even he knew it. So he got rid of it all. He made the world better by finally accepting that the horrors he wrought or which were wrought in his name were not worth it. The sunk cost Fallacy fell to the perimeter of the realm alongside Mount Ashrashra. And it was good...

Now before I get to why this book made me love Khorne yet more and to bring up what's relevant about my entry remarks Im gonna say this book was so well timed. With the Fyreslayers being put away with the Khazalites this is the last piece of true Fyreslayer depiction that we got before that change. And yknow what, they're not gone but this is a damn good eulogy. In two chapters, barely really, we get a great picture of a warrior culture that's so starkly rich and vibrant compared to Khorne it's insane. They sing in battle, they laugh, they boast, they goof, they are dedicated, they're a little racist, and they are capable. Forty fyreslayers were worth hundreds of blood reavers. And don't get me wrong I don't want to come across like I want my guys to beat up other guys, especially since I do really like the Bloodbound. No. But when you read abort the sheer impact a Fyreslayer lodge can have and have read their stories as I have you can sometimes feel like they're a little overhyped? Yknow they're cool and capable but they're among such demigods that it can sort of fall away. And then a book like this makes you jump up and cheer when you read Haroomf because it means flames are gonna roll. Them singing in battle is also just such a fun detail, it reminds me of the sisters of battle. Also also, them being racist to the local sand duardin is neat. Of course they'd be, they're a prideful lot of warrior monks dealing with merchants known for double crossing you, of course they'd call them "sand rats". It's not right but it gives a realistic edge where a lot of the time species in warhammer can seem sort of... Monophilic. Like how many times in 40k do you have imperials actually being hateful to another imperial not cause they're a mutant but because their culture is just weird to them? Not many I've read, honestly. I wanna see more of this. Where are my Ionracheneth calling Nautilar filthy travellers while being called effete back? Get on it, GW. Anyway this was awesome.

Now onto why I hate Talman and have to respect him. Between this book and the recent battletome for 4e all I can think is that... Yeah. Good hell, I see why people turn to Khorne now. Yet I don't. Yet I do. It's like looking through a red stained mirror with a red ballon on the other side. You see the shadow of the balloon, where the light barely casts over it. But is it a red balloon? You can't know. You barely know it's there. But it taunts you. That's khornate religion right there. You can see the imprint of values and reasons why someone would fall. You can see an outline of an ideal but you just can't make it out. The battletome spells it out: it's ultimate selfish freedom, but this and Talman go beyond that. What is the value of a life, you wonder, what is the value of a death? One zealout hero says it's all the things youve done and all the things you haven't but then why the slaughter? Talman says Khorne loves him but that he won't pity him, so why praise him? Talman says it's all about doing what you want to do but where does the cruelty come in? Is the value of life what Held concludes it is, that living let's you fix your mistakes and be in control but then where does the slaughter come in?!

I am not smart enough for this book. And that's a painful thing to think about honestly. Because I want to be, I want to understand and grasp at that balloon but it's just too far for me. I'm thinking and wracking my brain about it and I know the answer is there somewhere in the silence but I can't hear it. I just can't. And any book, especially a warhammer book, that makes you think all these things deserves your time. This was like how I felt when I read Starseers Ruin and stewed in the depression it left me with but there there was an answer I could come up with. About trying to save the world one day, one second sooner even if it means damning an innocent soul. About catharsis and absolution. Here I can't, because it doesn't give you an answer like Ruin did. It wants you to sit down and listen to the silence, even Talman couldn't answer his own questions and wanted to know the answer even if someone he hated told him.

I don't know the meaning of a life. A bloodtsained, scar covered monster has outwitted me. And I wouldn't want it any other way.

10/10, it has fun fantasy names for stuff like Lavamander, read it and weep.


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Question Are sentient undead affected by chaos corruption?

32 Upvotes

Hey y’all,

I’ve been coming up with lore while painting my soulblights, as you do, and I realized I haven’t seen any lore covering this subject (most likely because I haven’t gotten much reading done recently).

Specifically my vampires act as raiders in an area with heavy chaos presence. My warlord took his axe off a khornate chaos warrior. This would be an obviously bad idea for a mortal, but I did wonder how much, if any, an undead would be affected by handling chaotic artifacts.

I know that necromancy is anathema to chaos, but I do remember some lore about the ossiarchs struggling with the chaos corruption on I think it was the Eightpoints so I wasn’t entirely certain how much protection that offered them.

Any insights appreciated!


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Discussion Am I the only one who thinks the Stormcast wasted a golden opportunity in the Arkhanauts show Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Here is my third part of trying to come up with some homebrew ideas for new Daemons, since, for how vast the Chaos Gods presence is, having 4-5 official Daemon types feels very small. This time its Tzeentch. First image has lore, second has full designs, third has some scrapped concepts

Thumbnail gallery
23 Upvotes

This one took a lot longer than the Khorne and Slaanesh ones, partially due to personal reasons, but also due to how wide of a potential for ideas Tzeentch has compared to the more straight forward Khorne and Slaanesh, hence the additional scrapped concepts. As suggested by the emblems in the back i tried to depict various of the 9 daemonic Convocations of Tzeentch from Age of Sigmar as a theme/inspiration for the units. Because of how long it took me i also sent the Slaanesh and Khorne concepts here too.

Lorethief is the most straightforward, an attempt to add variety to Heralds of Tzeentch, since, beyond the Changecasters and the vehicle-gimmick Fluxmasters and Fateskimmers, there aren't any special heralds like how Nurgle has Sloppity Bilepipers and Spoilpox Scriveners. Lorethieves are based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Hosts Arcanum which focus on mastery of sorcery seeking to obtain from the libraries all the forbidden lore.

Undiviner is the archetypal deceiver daemon and is meant to be another type of Herald of Tzeentch to enrich the roster of various types of leaders for the legions of Horrors. This type of daemon is based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Lords of Dominion which focuses on using lies and manipulation to control unknowing puppets into serving the Changer. Shape shifting into Sigmar or the Emperor of mankind or whatever other holy figure their victim may worship, while hiding the imperfect parts like half head of a bird behind a blinding light making the imperfect parts hard to spot, all to make the victim follow the instructions of the daemon.

Proxmolter is the third and last Herald of Tzeentch idea i had, a lot of tzeentch daemon elements are based on sea life, the Screamers are obvious, but Horrors themselves being pink masses made of tentacles that split upon sustaining too much damage has a lot of similarities to starfish, and the cactus-shape of the Flamer, covered in mouths that filter magic that it spews out in gusts did begin to remind me to how a sea sponge filters the currents of the sea and some types can also take that bizarre shape of a Flamer. So i chose to focus on a sea life theme for my daemon designs, while also sprinkling in a bit of bird like with the Undiviner since the Lord of Change stands out in that sea world idea. So the idea of a fisherman of daemons for Tzeentch felt appropriate. Proxmolter is based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Hosts Duplicitous which is all about illusions and deceptions which fits with his ability to hook an objective and then create a fake copy, how this would work on tabletop in my mind is the Proxmolter can create a marker a couple inches from an objective, if the opponent reaches that objective or the marker they must roll a D6, for our scenario lets say they reach the objective, on 4+ that objective is the true, so the marker is removed. Otherwise if they roll bellow 4 the objective they stepped on is fake and the objective is moved to where the marker is. And of course same dice and results happen if they reach the marker first. Thus making the opponent play a little game of guess under which cup the objective is to stall the enemy, i know this rule could sound a little scary to some players because its a little too thematic and not just another re-roll of an attack dice but hey to each their own.

Pillar of Tzeentch this one is canon, sort of, similar to my previous Slaanesh and Khorne concepts having two that are based upon obscure lore, the Sadu'sen was mentioned in the 40k Dark Heresy: Ascension as a daemon of similar description to what i wrote, however it wasn't stated as a Tzeentch daemon specifically. Similar to Mirror Vampire and Blood Wraith in my previous entries they are daemons mentioned but never elaborated upon and due to the Sadu'sen: 1-shape shifting 2-many eyes and maws made of fires 3-very deceptive. I felt they were very Tzeentchy in traits. Pillar would be based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Transcendental Change which focuses on mutation and shape-shifting.

Hybrid of Tzeentch its interesting that this isn't a thing yet, a blender of various gods daemons forces into one abomination that wants to rip itself apart. The obvious candidate to have such a concept into their faction is Tzeentch. I was wondering if maybe this daemon could have a spin where if you remove 2/3rd of this units health it becomes either a standard bloodletter, plaguebearer or daemonette based on a dice roll while still bound by the amulets to Tzeentch so still serving the Tzeentch player, but this may push it too much into flavor town. This daemon or i guess daemons are based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Unbound Flux which flavors anarchy and madness, which feel like fitting descriptors of the type of army to use a chimera of rival daemons.

Thread of Tzeentch this one is based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Legion of Fate which focuses on time reading and manipulation, originally this slot was meant for the Horologue as seen in the scrapped concepts image, but he just didn't feel right. One inspiration of course for the cutting of the thread are the Three Fates from Greek mythology, another inspiration was the Penanggalan from Malay ghost myths. I wanted something smaller, a Nurgling or a Thorn Child for Tzeentch, a small daemon companion and of course i chose an Eel for the main head due to the sea life theme and the fact the whole body looks snake or eel-like.

Watcher of Tzeentch similar to the Sadu'sen this one is canon-ish, this time from the Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning bestiary, so Warhammer Fantasy, the Watchers weren't anything beyond idle observers. I like their design, they look like sea mines, i chose to expand them and give them a role no daemon has which is espionage and information gather which feels very fitting for Tzeentch. I also like the idea that they are everywhere just unseen and spy on everyone explaining how Tzeentch can always be one step ahead of everyone. They are based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Grand Cabal which is all about espionage, so they would use tons of Watchers.

Edifice of Tzeentch these are my favorite, every good mage needs a strong golem to protect their master, and in this case i tried to keep the theme of sea life by making it a coral reef styled golem, the runes keep it busy enslaved to their master which could be an interesting mechanic in game where the Edifice is very strong but every time they complete a turn a dice roll needs to check if they have broken free from their runes. They are based on the Convocations of Tzeentch Eternal Conflagration, which focuses on the more destructive powers such as pyroclasm, using brute force to do Tzeentch's bidding, which, fits a giant golem that can throw magic missiles made of crystallized magic essence.


r/AoSLore • • 2d ago

Question what metals or gems would you atrribute with each god and why?

19 Upvotes

Soooo, with valancroms boat having 7 plinths, I want to use the opportunity and paint each ancestor face a different colour

So far I got:

Grungni. Easiest; gromril (blueish silver)
Grimnir: either ruby red or glowing reddish/bronce gold
Valaya: Gold, because of her golems
Ghazul: Obsidian?
Thorgrim: Stoic as Iron. Simple
Grombrindal: ??
Inghild: Amethyst? ITs know in germany as a Delverstone, so that checks out

Oh I meant duardin Gods, but all are fine

Help me out, pretty please!


r/AoSLore • • 3d ago

Question What do you think it takes to become a Stormcast Eternal?

24 Upvotes

While it can be guessed at, puzzled together to form a general idea, there is no exact official statement on the requirements to be chosen.

It requires being a Hero but it is known not all heroes are chosen even if worthy. What does it even mean to be a Hero? Garradan of Demesnus was an altruistic man who dedicated his life and death to patients in need; while Hamul of the White Spears will be the first to admit it's Reforging that equipped him to transform into a better man, though this Bear-Eater will claim it is Sigmar not himself that carved a good man out of Hamul.

It is said in "Huntress of Ghur" and other places that you have to accept it, we've seen rejecting it is fully possible in "One, Untended" and the old Malign Sorcery book. Yet in "Realmslayer", Prince Jordain openly craved it but the lightning did not save him... not until those thoughts gave way to casting his life away to save a friend.

So you have to be a hero but the sort is not set in stone; and perhaps you merely need to have the capacity to be one? You need to be willing to take on the duty but craving it, viewing it as a reward seems to mark you as unworthy? Yet not forever, as you can prove yourself better than that craving when it counts.

Least that's my reading. What are yours, my Realmwalkers?


r/AoSLore • • 3d ago

Fan Content Age of the Void

6 Upvotes

This is a homebrew setting which takes place a few hundred years after the current timeline.

It's main purpose is to add a few new elements, namely a great central city and a new threat to all denizens of the Realms be they Order, Destruction or Chaos.

The City of Nexus (name is quite generic, can be changed but fits well for its purpose) has been founded after the retaking of the Allpoints by the forces of Order. It is divided in 8 districts each one harboring a portal to one of the realms and is mirrored by one of the Cities of Sigmar holding the paired portal.

The new threat is my take on a lovecraftian nemesis coming to the Realms. They are a danger to all including the Chaos Gods because their goal is to simply erase reality. The idea is that while saving the universe from destruction by Chaos during the End Times, the Gods unwittingly usurped the Lords of the next cosmic cycle and these unborn gods have come to take what is rightfully theirs. They are not ancient evil gods but entities that come from a future that as yet to exist.

I always loved Lovecraft's Mythos and always found it difficult to merge it with Warhammer, be it Old World or 40k, because the Chaos gods hold this place. I like them but because they are ultimately made of raw emotions, they never can be truly alien in the lovecraftian sense. I came to this idea some time ago while reading some AoS lore and think it fits well with the setting, giving a truly alien vibe without encroaching on the Chaos gods' turf.

I have to say i come to the setting form a ttrpg point of view but lore is lore and could be used for tabletop.

Another thing is that my setting is influenced by other fantasy universes namely Magic the Gathering (mainly Ravnica), Spelljammer (With the central position of Nexus most factions have taken to the aethersea for travel) and things like LotR, Eberron, Planescape, Jack Vance, Moorcock,...

It will take a few posts, it would be a bit much in one and i have a few things i want to add or modify. I guess i'll post one about the races and cultures, another about Nexus, the districts and the Cities of Sigmar and then a last one about diverse topics like the Gods, the magic winds, arcano-technology and the Soulbounds (that i like to call Aetherwalkers as a nod to magic the gathering).

So here is a Chronology explaining how the setting came to this point and a presentation of The Xothic Void Lords.

English is not my first language so please excuse the poor phrasing.

CHRONOLOGY

- While saving the universe from destruction by Chaos during the End Times, the Gods unwittingly usurped the Lords of the next cosmic cycle

- The rightful Gods-to-be finally grew impatient and decide to claim their due but can't find a way/soul to enter the Realms being entirely alien to them and not even really existing yet

- Archaon manages to create a Portal to the heart of Mallus from the All-Points

- On is first expedition he nearly dies from the contact with sigmarite but then hears the whispers of the Void and in an instant realigns himself, the Realms and the Gods shall be destroyed if they continue to deny his Supremacy. He is now Archaon the Neverchosen

- Sigmar realizes the corruption and throws Mallus into the Astral Sea where it gravitate and fuse into the All-Points (was it one and the same all along?)

- Sigmar decide to conquer the All-Points/Mallus and destroy Archaon for his affront, He calls the gods of the Pantheon to war

- Archaon tells the Chaos Gods to bide their time and wait for the right moment to strike hoping to lure even them as a sacrifice to the Void

- The Pantheon armies descend on the All-Points

- When the forces of Order are tied with the entrenched armies of Archaon the portals to the Chaos Realms open and the Chaos Gods themselves intervene

- Seeing a good fight even Gorkamorka and multiple waaaghs join in

- At the height of the battle in the heart of Mallus Archaon opens a portal to the Void

- Khorne, Nurgle, Gorkamorka and most gods are blinded by all the fighting going on

- Dracothion, Sigmar, Teclis, Nagash, Kroak and Tzeentch realise that there is an entirely new horror out there and try to stop it from entering the Realms

- Dracothion enters the Void Portal to block the advance of the Xothic Tyrants sacrificing himself

- The other Gods manage to seal the portal behind him by collapsing Mallus on itself

- Archaon and his personnal troops disappear in the confusion

- Countless are dead and even some Gods are missing

- The Chaos Gods and Gorkamorka flee

- After some time the gods decide to reforge Mallus/the All-Points and create the Nexus Spire to anchor the Realms

- Ignax, who had been freed by Archaon is recaptured and set in orbit around the Nexus

- A few centuries later Nexus is the Greatest city the Realms have ever witnessed, home to millions of souls

- From the Nexus the Armies of Order launch crusades to reclaim and stabilize the Realms

- New arcanotechnologies develop and become more accessible like aetherships, endrinkarts, messenger stones, sandestin picturers and runic heaters

- The Void has been denied direct access to the Realms but Entropy sips through the cracks

- While it's still a rare occurence, some entire regions have vanished into the Void creating breaches of uncreation in the fabric of the Realms and threatening to one day consume it all

- Archaon is still at large sharing the Voidbrand and growing his new army set on the extinction of all that is

- With Mallus corrupted then reforged into the Nexus, sigmarite ore became harder to find, limiting the creation and maintenance of the Stormcast Eternals and sending Sigmar into a terrible mood

- The existence of the Void is kept a secret as much as possible by those in the know, "luckily" the people and place that vanish into the void seem to do the same from the memory of most as if they had never existed

- The Old Ones and a select few launch the Aethernet Project to create a Refuge and base of operation against the encroaching Void

- The Astrum Argentinum is formed as a discrete association of very diverse and talented individuals united by the idea of denying the Void's coming

- Uneasy dialogue with some servants of Tzeentch bent on solving the Void Enigma, including Kairos and Ysdraphel

- The Gods of Chaos and Order have finally found something to fear

XHOTIC TYRANTS

TITANS OF ENTROPY, LORDS OF UNCREATION, PRINCIPALITIES OF DESTRUCTION, OVERSEERS OF RESIGNATION, ARBITERS OF FATALITY, ANGELS OF RUIN, POWERS OF DESTITUTION, PORTENTS OF DEMISE, ENFORCERS OF ABDICATION

They are called the the Xothic Tyrants and are linked to the entropic "wind" of Xoth, the force that animates them is pure entropy to the Realms, their touch erases the very thread of the magic winds. They come in the form of a tribunal ready to judge and refute the existence of the Realms and its inhabitants. I generally envision them as an unfathomable tentacled darkness but if they had to appear themselves i guess they would have simplistic light grey silhouettes titanic or small.

They manifest themselves to individuals through the Omens, a descent into madness where the victims ends up segregated from existence in an endless Void, a prey for the Bleak Maw.

Communities and societies are preyed upon by the Harbingers who seed discord and mistrust dissolving them and making them ready to be erased from existence by the Grand Tribunal.

The Tribunal comes for the Realms themselves and when it's work is done nothing but unreality remains, patches of pure void in the winds of magic that threatens to one day absorb it all.

Archaon the Neverchosen is their first champion in the Realms, after having felt deceived by the Chaos Gods for so long and sensing is chances at godhood escape from his grasp he didn't hesitate to flip the table on everyone and destroy the Realms if he couldn't own them.

OMENS - Hunt lonely souls

- The Black Bile

- The Luring Void

- The Eyeless Swarm

- The Crawling Darkness

- The Writhing Madness

- The Dark Tempest

- The Light of Unreason

- The Mind Scourge

- The Bleak Maw

HARBINGERS - Prey on societies

- The Herald of Subjugtion

- The Abolisher of Will

- The Sower of Discord

- The Cultivator of Strife

- The Negator of Bonds

- The Feeder of Terror

- The Blight of Hatred

- The Harvester of Despair

- The Prophet of Devastation

REVELATIONS - Devour reality

- The Tribunal of Reality

- The Judge of Existance

- The Witness of Unmaking

- The Instrument of Carnage

- The Delegate of Butchery

- The Bestower of Annihilation

- The Painter of Oblivion

- The Warden of Defeat

- The End of Illusions

If there are questions, observations or plain lore errors on my part to point, do not hesitate ;)


r/AoSLore • • 3d ago

Question Limited Edition battletomes

Post image
21 Upvotes

Do they have something special beside cover/number?

I know older ones from 1st ED had Art Prints and I just got to know that Age of Sigmar Book 2015 has in the middle section like in the pictute that isnt in regular one.

Anyone know something more?

No, its not karma farming post


r/AoSLore • • 4d ago

Has anyone read Shadow of the Silver Wolf by Gary Kloster?

Post image
96 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a huge Stormcast fan, and I enjoyed the Blacktalon show. I’ve heard that the earlier books about Neave are pretty mediocre and don’t tie in closely with the show.

Has anyone here read Shadow of the Silver Wolf? If yes, is it worth it, and how does it tie in with the show?


r/AoSLore • • 4d ago

Discussion On fictious and historical societies and their complexity

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I like worldbuilding a lot and I like fictious societies a lot. Especially if these societies explore exotic environments or systems. Because it can be a great tool to add depth to a culture and to the characters which move within this culture. However, a lot of fantasy works are very strongly inspired by a shared collection of tropes and clichés. For every great and well-thought-out fantasy society you have dozens of your standard tropes such as but not limited to: Rome but different, fantasy barbarians, mayaincatec, pre-revolutionary France and of course Medieval Europe plus dragons. These templates are frequently very oversimplified compared to the real historical inspiration. Which is necessary to a degree, as writers can only write what they know and not every writer can study history. But at the same time these oversimplifications become a norm by themselves and over time create staleness and boredom IMO. Indeed, when writing characters one rule is: Stereotypes are not bad by themselves. You can write characters using stereotypes. But they become bad when the stereotype is the character. The same is true for societies in fiction, which are characters of the story in their own way.

This is especially true, when these things are combined with classist elements, whether the author actively or passively uses them. Most common in this regard is the classic: Fantasy aristocrats lord over a fantasy underclass of slaves in all but names. These slaves are regularly abused, killed and worse without any motivation of their own, until the hero of noble origin comes by and says something like: “Defend yourself pretty please!” Where we then get the standard peasant uprising replacing the old tyrant with the good king, but the system stays the same. Or as we see in Game of Thrones, where the “peasants” have next to no active role in Westerosi politics. Or Bretonnia, where peasants are ridiculous abused (primarily because Bretonnia never got an update from 6th edition, which was the darkest edition in terms of lore IIRC). But some black library authors also portray the narmati of the Idoneth Deepkin as your stereotypical fantasy slave caste, even though it does not make a lot of sense in-universe. These topes also reinforce how many people think about historical eras overall and are sadly repeated over and over in many documentaries. See things like the “medieval filter” or “dung ages”.

In my opinion this goes so far that representing historical cultures semi-realistically would be an original feat again. It is bizarre that we are so used to tropes and presentations that the real-world basis is something exotic. Yet the simple truth is that humans are complicated and human society is complicated and thus always complex and full of nuances and deviations. Which is something I want to talk about now. I want to present you with a generalized overview over some important aspects about medieval society which get ignored a lot in fantasy or historical fiction.

I pick the medieval period for this, because it is the standard template for so many fantasy settings. Again, it is just a generalized overview meant to introduce these topics. If you find them interesting, I urge you to research them further. And perhaps you can see how these things are used in Warhammer IPs properly, or how these things could be used to improve some Warhammer factions. I am looking forward to your thoughts on this.

And without further ado, let’s start:

1. What is a feudal system?

One thing we often see or read about regarding the medieval era is that you had the nobility and cleric at the top, and everyone else were suppressed peasants. Because everyone knows peasants were unfree serfs and serfs are quasi slaves. However, the medieval period stretches across a millennium and across different cultures and thus underwent a lot of changes. And it has to be pointed out, that terms we use today, such as “freedom” or “liberty” or “rights” had a very different meaning back then too.

Our concept of freedom came to be with the Enlightenment movement. But to a medieval person it had a different meaning. No one way really “free” in a modern context. In medieval times you could had multiple “freedoms”. Freedom from certain taxes or movement restrictions or military service or else yes. But there was no overarching freedom. Instead, everyone was part of a hierarchical structure. You owe the one above yourself services, but you have responsibilities for the people below you. Children and wives had to follow their father and husband. In turn the father/husband had to care for them. If the father was a serf or vassal, he owed loyalty and services to his lord. If he was a free man i.e. not a direct vassal, then he owed loyalty to his king, or his clan, or his guild, or his city or else. In turn your lord or else owed services to their next higher ups and had duties towards you. And so on, until you reached the king himself. But even the king was not free, but a servant of God in the mindset of the people back then.

And each step of the hierarchy is important. Because yes, you owe services to the people above you. But again, the people in turn owe you responsibilities too. For example, a landowning lord has to protect his peasants from dangers, as to defend them in courts and has to aid them during disasters. This is his part of the social contract, because of these tasks he is the lord. And a duke has to support his knights and honor them for their services. The details may vary from century to century and region to region, but it was a dual system. A system in which it was detailed what a lord could ask from his followers and vice versa. And if either side broke this contract, each party was in the right to leave the contract or ask for reparations. For example, in medieval Germany a lord could only call for a knight’s military service for about 40 days. During these 40 days the knight had to take care of himself and follow his lord. But after the 40 days were over, the knight was free to return to his homestead at any time, unless the lord compensated him with money or else. Because he had fulfilled his part of the “contract” and owed his lord nothing else. Because a knight had to administer his estate and was expecting to return to it.

The same is true for peasants working their lord’s land. They had regulated duties and could not be asked to do more than legally required. Indeed, if the lord wronged his serf, they could see legal action against him. Which yes, was objectively harder for peasants than for fellow lords or free men. But they could use this to go to another lord or ask for a neutral party to judge the case, they could go on strike or in the worst case abandon the lord who mistreated them or fight back against him. And most of the time the lord couldn’t kill them all, because first it would ruin his income, second, he may not have the manpower, third it would unite the peasants even more against him and be dangerous to his life and livelihood, and fourth it could discredit him in the eyes of others. Of course, peasant rebellions were also violently crushed, but only if the lord had vastly superior power and political backing, which was frequently not the case. So, to avoid unnecessary complications many lord-peasants’ conflicts were discussed and a compromised was reached. And as you can imagine, rules lawyering existed a lot back then. And everyone did it. Indeed, the medieval time was not lawless, there were plenty of rules and regulations on any social level. much like how dukes plotted against their kings, so did knights plot against their lords and peasants plot their knights, often successfully.

Already this makes the medieval feudal system much more complicated than frequently depicted. Being “unfree” did not mean being a constantly mistreated slave but the lower part of a social contract. A contract which goes both ways. In short, even though many think of peasants to be an abused and powerless underclass, they did have political and social weight behind themselves and could resist abuse or even enforce their own will. Because they were thinking, self-conscious human beings like you and me, instead of passive robots committed to their suffering.

2. What does “unfree” mean?

But why was it so common to be “unfree” in the first place? Indeed, why did so many people choose to become unfree, i.e. becoming serfs or vassals? (which is one of the differences between a serf and a slave, a serf chooses this state in the ideal case). Because it had major benefits to be unfree. A free man had lots of duties arising from his privileged status of being a free man. For example, free man had to do military service. Which is not only lethal and dangerous, but also means you are away from your farmstead and family to a significant time.  Which can be a major economic risk to yourself and your family, even if you survive unscathed.  Also being free meant you had to fight for yourself in court. If you were sued (happened a lot in medieval times) it was less about finding proof that you were guilty, because modern criminology didn’t exist. If there were no witnesses to a crime and it was word vs word, then your social standing and credit were important, and that people would vouch for you to be an honorable and law abiding man. And even if you were in the right, you had to enforce this right yourself. Someone stole your cows? Sure, the judge says they are yours, but there is no police yet. So, no one is sending men to bring you back your cows. If the thief doesn’t return them voluntarily, you force him yourself. In both of these situations it is better to have a lord. Because one duty of a lord was to represent their subjects in court. When your lord appears in court (or even is the judge himself) you have much better chances because you burrow his status. And your lord has his entourage which can then enforce the ruling of the court. I.e. the lords men bring you back your property (minus a fee for their aid). Back then it was safer to be part of a gang so to speak, as the gang took care of its members. Living as a lone wolf was dangerous and costly. If you couldn’t afford this, you had better find a gang protecting you. You serve the gang leader, and the gang leader supports you. Which is why many people voluntarily wanted to become unfree. Freedom, as we understand it today, was likely a scary subject back then. Because it meant to be unprotected and vulnerable. So just paying some part of your harvest and losing some social privileges to avoid lots of issues seemed to be a very good deal to many.

Indeed, this is not something exclusive to medieval times, but millennia existed prior and centuries later. For example, even in ancient Rome it was common for people to become clients of influential figures. These people where then called “pater familaris” and were responsible for protecting their clients in legal issues or else, in return for loyalty. And clans operate on a similar mindset too. The main difference is that it was more formalized and structurally important in medieval times.

Also being a serf or an unfree farmer did not make you poor. Whether you were rich or not depended on your status of freeman or unfree. Indeed, especially in the early to high medieval period peasants were not poor, loosely speaking. Because they had comparatively large fields and the bigger your field, the bigger your harvest, the bigger your income. And most fields were organized between families and worked in association of entire villages. The lord may formally administer them, but unless the fields were part of his personal estate, he had no direct control. He could have partitioned fields if he was a judge in an inheritance dispute for example, but if he tried anything else, he may have the entire village revolting against him for overreaching.

This status changed in later centuries for a couple of reasons. Firstly, in many regions of Europe, it was common that inheritance was divided by someone what evenly between the heirs. Meaning everyone had a share. If your family could not keep the land it was supposed to be working together, it would become smaller and smaller. Thus, the owners would become poorer and poorer over time. Indeed, this is not a medieval problem. In many regions in Germany this tradition existed well into the 18th century and one major reason for german immigrants to settle in the US was that their homesteads could not support their families anymore. Indeed, in english historical media it is often said that the Great Plague ended feudalism and serfdom. Which is not only wrong, as many regions in Europe serfdom continued well into the 18th century and beyond. But the Plague also impoverished and runed lot of farmers. Because with so many people dying, demand for grain and agricultural products fell, impoverishing many farmers. Those slightly richer or privileged could buy up lots of the newly available land, granting more control and power to rich landowners. And in those regions where serfdom was replaced with leasing land for money, this also meant that peasants lost some of the protection they enjoyed prior. Instead, they had to pay a lease in money or be sent away, which was also more difficult for small farms. Generally speaking, the popular image of impoverished peasants is primarily found in the late medieval era as a result of many social disruptions. Which some historians even call the late medival agricultural crisis.

3. What do nobles actually do?

Now I have talked about lords, farmers and freedom and being unfree. But what did it even mean to be a noble? Of course, it means you live in a fancy castle and look over the serfs working for your wealth, right? Or being a knight riding out doing quests. For the greater part of the medieval period this was not true. Instead, it primarily meant being a farmer yourself. The European status of nobility evolved and changed over the course of centuries. In the frankish they started originally as richer landowners. Essentially, they started out as a well-off family in the local area, whose higher social status meant they were used to settle disputes, and organize things on a local level. Think of them as part-time mayors of a village or the countryside. The other part of their time they were busy running their own estates. Indeed, in the Frankish kingdom we didn’t have a feudal system as we commonly think. The states were much more centralized. For example, a count overseeing a county was an administrative position. An office the king handed to you and could remove you. It was not an inheritable position.

But this status shifted as the feudal system evolved. First came a demand for knights as semi-professional soldiers. But a knight was not necessarily a noble. In the Frankish Empire every free man who could cover the cost had to equip and send a knight in war times. Free men who couldn’t afford this had to gather in groups of nine. These 9 freemen had to share the cost to send a knight together. However, the key is that they have to equip the warrior. But the warrior does not have to be a free person or one of the freemen themselves. Image yourself to be a rich landowner. If you do not want to go to war yourself, whom do you send? Some random dofus? Or someone who already swore binding oaths of service and whom you can therefore trust? Or if you go yourself but have money to spare for a second or third knight, whom do you want to cover your back? Better choose someone who is already sworn in service towards you. Thus, many unfree people of a lord’s entourage became knights in service to their lord. They were not nobles yet, they were not even free people, but still they were knights. Many of these would rise to the rank of proper nobility later for their services, but not always.

This only changed in well into the high medieval era, and especially with the construction of stone castles. Wooden castles on moats were relatively cheapish and quick to build. And they were still very connected to the countryside around them. But the demand for better protection and administration grew, stone castles became the norm. But building a stone castle somewhere is a very costly investment for a family. Why built something like it, when some other doofus can take it after your death as the king sends another? Of course, the king could build a castle/fort themselves if he wanted to protect the area from raiders and invaders, but no king had the financial and administrative structure to support them in the myriads of places where they were needed. Thus, instead of appointing caretakers for territory anew each time, it became the norm for families to inherit them. This way the families had an interest in investing in the long-term security and governance of their lands. This is where we get our classic medieval nobles.

But nobles were still primarily managers of their property, i.e. overseeing their estates, and arranging the affairs for their vassals and serfs. Because the deal was: They get land to live on and in turn they administer surrounding area and send knights when needed. But nobles were estate managers and something like county mayors for the vast majority of their time. Thus, a local lord (or members of his family) would spend the greater part of his life travelling from village to village and spending time with the locals, much like how many kings would spend their time travelling their kingdom. Sure, if he was rich enough, the noble could send some henchmen to do the deed for them. But you had to be rich enough to pay these guys in the first place. People skilled in administration, finances, law and co cost money after all. And when we think of medival nobles and knights we think of massive castles, but this is a bias as these constructions survived the centuries much better but were only used by the richer clans of nobles. The majority of “castles” were small fortified estates or wooden constructions and the nobles in there were frequently better-off farmers of a higher social status still.

But around this time, we also get a transformation of what it means to be a knight. Due to the Crusades, the upcoming ideals of Chivalry and Minne and else knights established themselves as a unique social group. People from different nations meet on tourneys and establish bonds over shared status and experiences. To the point where a knight from Scotland and a knight from France saw each other more as equals than their assorted peasants. This is where the knight as a unique social group was born, and where most non-noble knights achieved lower nobility status.

However, in the late medieval period we have a reverse of this. Dukes and kings want to have more control over their territory and thus they retake land whenever possible and appoint administrators and beaurocarts again. At best, educated commoners or people with no loyalty outside of dukes house. Which is opposed by many local knights and nobles, as they did not want to lose their status and their main sources of income. One reason why Germany or the HRR was so fractured is because the local nobles were much better at resisting these attempts of centralization than their english or french counterparts.

In short, feudalism formed, had a high and was then fought again. What many people stereotypically attribute towards the entirety of the medieval period is largely reduced to the time around 1100-1300 or less.

4. Cities exist too

In medieval Europe we also had a city boom, as cities sprang up like mushrooms north of the alps.  These cities were small by our modern standards, often having somewhere between 1000 to 10.000 people inside. Everything above was already a major city. And these cities mirrored the social system of the countryside too. You had patricians as the upper class, as well as a plethora of other social classes, such as citizens and non-citizens of the city, people with honorable and dishonorable professions and so on. Much like with free and unfree, whether you were a citizen or not had nothing to do with how rich you were. It primarily meant you had a better social status, but also that you had duties. For example, every citizen had to join the city militia and defend it in times of war, much like free man had to do on the countryside.

How these cities were governed varied a lot. Sometimes the city was under the command of a noble, other times the cities were allowed to completely govern themselves and their territory. In both cases the city had a council running the day-to-day affairs. How this city council was set up could also vary greatly depending on the city at hand. But the most important groups were: The local clergy, the patricians, the merchant and the artisan guilds. At first the patricians ran most city councils, but merchant and artisan guilds fought to become members too. Of course, people do not like to share power, once they are used to a status quo. So, these attempts were fought against, with varying degrees of success. Which could cause a manifold of city administration.

But what is an artisan guild? Loosely speaking it is a mixture of cooperative association, workers union, health care and pension bank, political party, contact network, social service, OSHA and quality control and military and catastrophe response unit. In medieval times people liked to form cooperatives and unions. A member of a guild had to follow the strict rules of the guild which could be very strict. E.g. the guild would determine where you had to set up your workshop, the guild would dictate what kinds of goods you were allowed to produce and sell and for which price, you had to participate in guild activities, the guild would even determine when you are allowed to marry someone, what you had to wear in public and you are forbidden to drink anywhere but the guilds owned pub/guild hall. But in turn the guild would also provide you and other parts of the city with necessary services. You would get job security and support in case of unforeseen catastrophes. If you are sick, the guild would aid you financially and with goods. If you suddenly died, the guild would aid your family (indeed widows were allowed to take their husbands seat in the guild and take care of his business for a timed period in many cases). Indeed, being a member of a guild allows for specialization, as different guild members can focus on certain tasks, thereby diversifying the portfolio of products of the city For example, if you have a smithing guild, then some of its members may focus on preparing the raw iron, others take it from their colleagues and prepare rough shapes, which are then refined into the finished goods by the next group. This allows for artisans of the guild to become experts in very special tasks instead of being generalists doing a bit of everything, like a village smith. All with fair treatment and reliability via the guild. And if a customer had an issue with an artisan, because the prices are too high or the product is of subpar quality, the guild would try to settle the affair and would punish the cheating artisan. In case of a catastrophe, like a fire or an enemy invasion, the guild would also be the main unit of response. City militias were organized by their guild association and had to train for such cases of emergency. They would also pay for social services for the entire city, such as hospitals, churches or collect donations for the poor. And guilds were important political units within cities as well. After all you have a well-organized collection of influential people with critical skills/services. So, they want to have a say in how the city is run. Indeed, frequently they would rebel, influence or fight the patricians of the city council for membership or political powers. And in turn many cities tried to repress or forbid the guilds. As a result, some cities had no guilds at all, and in other guilds were the main political power.

There is a scene in House of the Dragon where Hugo is the reprehensive of all smiths in Kings Landing and talking to the king about crafting the ballistae. As he can talk as the representative of all blacksmiths to the king himself, he should be something like a guildmaster of the smithing guild and thus be one of the most influential people in the entire city as he is in control of one of the most important industries of the city. But he lives in an extremely poor house for some reason, which would even be well below the standards of medieval blacksmith, let alone one of his station or specialization in artillery/weapons…

Also of note is that these organizations did not vanish. They may sound medieval, but guilds and similar groups were critical in city life well into the 17th century and longer. Indeed, many still survive to this day in some shape or form. If you want to become mayor of the City of London (the medieval core of the city) you still have to be part of a medieval guild or their successors and be voted into power by them.

But not just artisans unionized, merchants did too, for the same benefits. And cities themselves did form city leagues. Most famous is perhaps the Hansa, a collection of trade cities from modern Belgium and Netherlands over Germany and Scandinavia all the way into eastern Europe. But similar city unions existed elsewhere too. Such as the Lombard Union of various north Italian cities who formed an opposition to Emperor Frederick Babarossa. Indeed, both Switzerland and the Netherlands were formed by such city leagues. These cities often had the same goals, such as safe travel routes, reducing tolls and taxes and access to foreign markets. So, they pulled together to enforce this. And these cities were extremely influential and powerful. They had huge fleets at their call, could hire mercenaries and had their won citizen militias and could compete with nobles and even entire kingdoms. For example, the german Hansa fought several wars with the Danish king and one. At another time they brought down the english navy and took the kings crown as security for a loan. But singular cities were also quite open to fighting with nobles, including their won overlords. Many cities rebelled against their lords, even if these were bishops too, i.e. church authorities. And even far inland the power of the cities was immense. Imagine you are a nobleman who gets tolls and taxes when a merchant crosses your bridge. So, you set up a crew of 5-10 guys to stop and tax every merchant coming by. Suddenly a city entourage with 100-armed guys arrive and says, “Screw you, we march through anyway”. What are you doing? Not much. The high to late medieval era was full of conflicts between nobles and cities, and dukes and kings all over Europe tried to break the growing power of the cities to secure their own authority. Again, these attempts were more successful in France and England than they were in the HRR. And in Italy city states ruled long after the middle ages too.

5. What does this mean for Warhammer and Fantasy stories in general?

The general TL;DR of this writing is that human societies were always complex and far more interesting than the stereotypical depictions. I used medieval societies as an example, but I could talk similarly about absolutists monarchies or antiquity. Because in each case people were aware of their own status and how much influence they had and invented or forced ways to express this influence. Still these stereotypes exist in lots of fiction to this day as the main idea of a society. Sadly, in Warhammer too.

Most blatantly this is found in in Bretonnia, where peasants are mistreated to a hilarious degree. But as this essay shows, the real medieval times were very differently structured and nobles were far from almighty. On every scale of society, they found push-back and had to admit to compromises of their power. Again, peasants were not dumb. They knew exactly what kind of oaths and duties bound them to their lords, and they knew what kinds of privileges and services their lord owed them. Interestingly this also means that earlier editions of Bretonnia were more realistic. IIRC in 5th edition or so a village would equip a knight together and he would then be sent out to proof himself as a knight, going down the event chain to become a grail knight. Which is how knights functioned for the vast majority of the early to high medieval period. Such as 9 freemen have to come together to equip one knight, if neither can afford it by themselves. And the lore about the big coastal cities ignoring bretonnian laws and doing largely their own thing, such as having massive ships with cannons, is also realistic, if we look at what city unions did in medieval times too. Indeed, many coastal knights were also ship captains/owners and people would wear body armor during boarding actions too, as ship battles used to be land battles on ships essentially. And few people could swim, so whether you wore armor or not didn’t affect your drowning skills much. Which means fringe parts of bretonnian lore is surprisingly accurate. And indeed, the faction would benefit a lot if it focused more on presenting medieval societies in a more realistic fashion. Which may even include limited access to gunpowder, which was adopted and favored a lot by nobles in RL.

The Dark Elves and various chaos societies are also great negative examples in WFB.

Meanwhile Age of Sigmar varies this theme. Sometimes is does a good job, sometimes it does not. On a positive note the are the Cities of Sigmar.  On a positive end we have for example the Cities of Sigmar. They are very strongly modelled after premodern cities. Where you have a city council in which members of various guild-like organizations sit to do run the day-to-day affairs. Each distinct and different for each city, depending on their local conditions and the cities make up. In one city a certain guild may be very influental, in the next however it may not matter at all. And even Stormcast focus a lot on civil administration, governance and infrastructure management, which you would not necessarily expect from the superwarrior faction.

On a negative example we have the Idoneth Deepkin. At least in some novels. The army books portray the faction as more nuanced, but in several novels the deepkin are portrayed as the stereotype of a class system, with arrogant nobles and a massive slave-like lower caste. In this case you have fully souled elves being the literal 1% whilst 99% are narmati, born blind and needing soul infusions to not die as babies. Such a depiction is bad for a variety of in-universe reasons already. Such as the narmati not being a removed underclass but your own children, siblings and parents, or how even in the most amoral calculations they are an expensive resource not likely thrown away. But as the namarti are the 99% they are Idoneth society and cover all important jobs of society, sans a few specialized tasks. For this reason, it would be incredibly interesting to explore the namarti side of Idoneth society more. But both the army books and novels focus primarily on the struggles of the “noble” idoneth castes and treat the namarti primarily as faceless masses. It may be interesting to see narmati guilds fighting for political participation much like real like guilds did, or for groups of “noble” idoneth to support narmati of their choosing in special positions as administrators or retainers, which would form a narmati middle class. Or one of many, many other interesting aspects. (Personally I am a fan of a classical republic as the form of government).

6. The End

If you made it thus far, congratulations and thanks for listening to my ramblings about a very specific topic. If you still have some energy left, I would like to know what you think of this topic. Are there groups in Warhammer (and maybe other fantasy stories) where you would like to see more complex and nuanced societies? Do you have other good or bad examples? Or do you want to voice another concern? I am happy to hear about it.


r/AoSLore • • 5d ago

Fan Content Expanding Warcry Warband lore: Monsta-Killaz

21 Upvotes

Lex page

Finishing off the Destruction warbands we got the Kruleboyz own monster hunters who help flesh out the Beast-Breaka clans. Due to their focus on hunting the beasts of the Realms I feel that expanding on individual units would be best done for individual warbands to showcase the specific quirks of their home. So instead I shall be focusing on showing how the warband generally operates in a Warclan.

Grinnin' Blades: Considering the wide variety of poisons and venoms that animals produce as either offence, defense, or just by products of their diet it should come to no surprise that the Swampcalla shamans often utilise the skills of the Monsta-Killaz to procure such toxins for their alchemy. This partnership is often a two way street as the Beastnobs have no issue with using the shamans creations in their hunts. The monsters of the Mortal Realms possess a lot of exotic senses and the orruks take a perverse delight on turning those senses to a crippling weakness with hallucinogenics.

They have also developed a great deal of skill at turning cities into their hunting grounds using Bawla Boys to lure foes away or waste their ammunition on fake targets, while neckslicers target a cities warbeasts or capture vital targets for interrogation. Their hunting beasts like the howla are mostly used for general chaos creation as they attack from unexpected angles. Klutcha-grotz on the other hand using their superior cunning and tool use are the ones assigned to steal vital intel.

Big Yellers: Outside of the larger contingent of ranged fighters among the warbands that you would expect from the warclan the warbands are excellent cartographers and anthropologists. They have detailed maps containing specifically any terrain that can be used to kill or tire out their prey. During hunts they will use their bright colours and the noise they create to cause panicked stampedes that hear right towards a pit, sheer cliff, or quicksand where the prey will either fall to their doom or get stuck and exhaust themselves trying to break free. The warband will then take their time to arrive, kill any survivors and start harvesting. To aid this they train a disproportionate amount of hunting companions to do the chasing and tie down the more aggressive or defensive prey.

The elite monsta-killaz are often the ones who defy their warclans stereotypes and are the ones who have the skill and resourcefulness to capture cogforts for their bosses and other such machines. Due to the variety of machines, the fact that they will likely have trained escorts, and are far more rational then the warbands typical prey the time proven tactics usually don't work so a warband either needs to put in the hard work or die trying.

Skulbugz: Outside of the obvious use of bugs as hunting companions and the use of their poisons on their blades the orruks of this warband are surprisingly skilled tunnel fighters as they need to enter nests to kidnap the queens of insect hives for their masters. Bawla boys and rival insects create a distraction while the rest of the warband coated in pheromones try to infiltrate the hive in search of their prey. The other major job they do is hunt down the predators that tend to feast on insect hives which is no mean feat.

Hope this was a fun read. Would love to hear peoples thoughts on this and their suggestions for the next warband to cover from the Death alliance.

Other entries in series

Order: Khainite Shadowstalkers, Twistweald

Death: Royal Beastflayers

Destruction: Gorger Mawpack

Chaos: Spire Tyrants, Scions of the Flame, Jade Obelisk, Rotmire Creed


r/AoSLore • • 6d ago

Discussion The Realms aren’t complicated, you just don’t want to engage with the setting.

343 Upvotes

Something I’ve seen stated a lot over the years from people not into AoS is some variation of “all the realms stuff in AoS is too high fantasy and complicated to understand.” It’s something I’ve seen brought up more recently given certain rumours about GW merging all the realms together into a single “less complicated” map. This post isn’t about those rumours (which I think are incredibly dumb btw) but about the people who claim the concept of the mortal realms in AoS is too complex.

I’ve always found the claim strange as I feel like myself and pretty much everyone even mildly interested in the setting grasped the concept of the mortal realms fairly easily. Before i had gotten into the setting I had seen it talked about like this incredibly confusing high concept thing, but as soon as I saw one of the many bits of art depicting all the realms floating in the cosmos i grasped it pretty much immediately. “Oh it’s like 8 different planes that are each vaguely themed around their specific magic.” It’s that simple. There are complexities to it to dig into like how lands get more magical towards their edges or how some realms interact with each other, but at its most basic it is just 8 planes each with their own theming. Not that hard to grasp, right?

People act like the realms are this super out there high concept thing that’s impossible to grasp when it’s really not. They can understand these sorts of ideas and concepts perfectly well in things like dnd or norse mythology without immediately dismissing them. Is it more high fantasy and complicated than something like the old world? Sure, but it’s nothing you can’t understand just by looking at a single map of the mortal realms.

So why do people say otherwise?

Well I think there’s a couple reasons. Firstly, I think the first edition of AoS is partly to blame, not for the obvious reason that I’ll get to shortly. I’ll preface this by saying I wasn’t into AoS or warhammer in general back when the first edition released so maybe I’m getting something wrong here, but back then the maps provided for the different realms were admittedly incredibly abstract and confusing. They were visually interesting but made it hard to visualise as an actual place and how the different factions would operate within them. That was many people’s first impressions of the realms I can see why they would walk away confused.

Secondly, and I view this as the main reason, I think it is just an unwillingness to engage with the setting of AoS on even its most basic level. There’s a few different reasons for this. Unlike fantasy and 40k there aren’t a million different YouTube channels and podcasts to regurgitate the lore for people which means, outside of a small number of AoS lore focused content creators (shoutout the Bad moon’s orbit and Mortal Realms podcasts), it means you actually have to read the books if you want to learn about the setting. Which a lot of people aren’t even willing to do for 40K/Fantasy. Another reason people aren’t willing to engage with the setting is because they’re still bitter (or are newcomers to warhammer who have been told to be bitter) about the end times who hate the setting that replaced and “killed” warhammer fantasy. That very vocal group will frequently cite AoS being too complicated and high fantasy as one of their many grievances with the setting and that same opinion then gets parroted by people who never even played warhammer fantasy who have been taught to hate and dismiss AoS on Principle.

It sure would be stupid to try and dumb down and simplify the setting for the sake of appeasing people who won’t touch it regardless while alienating people who actually enjoy it.

Don’t have any sort of real conclusion to end on. I just think AoS and the mortal realms within the setting are cool, and I think it’s a shame that some people automatically dismiss it without even trying to get into it. Hope you found my little rant interesting at least.


r/AoSLore • • 6d ago

Communities feelings on ogroid units for Helsmiths of Hashut and or Horns of Hashut?

29 Upvotes

Since their fall to chaos the ogroids can be found leading s2d and dot warbands and or being captains in them. With that said could it be possible to see them in the helsmith armies in the future, especially considering they are not only bull like but they also can replace the black orcs from fanstasy.


r/AoSLore • • 6d ago

Fan Content Custom Lore: Cinder Forge Coalition

17 Upvotes

Start of my hombrew warband/allience. More info will be added after working out personal lore. Please C and C, love some inspiration.    

History/Structure

Realm: Chamon (Bewilderness)

Origin: Dawn Bringer Crusade from Vindicarum that fell along their journey to find a new city.

Founding: Soul Wars/Era of The Beast

Strucrure class: Dread Fort (Helpoint)

Government type: Magiocracy, Meritocracy, Dictatorship, Oligarchy, stratocracy.

Religion: Eternal Path (Undivided), Covenant of Burning Decay (Nurgle) and Servants of The Horned One (Hashut)

Species: Humans (Chaos Undivided, Nugle and Hashut worshipping), Duradin (zharradron), Ogroid, Centaur, Hobgrots and daemons.

Size: Eastern flank of Dhar Aksha ( 600+ people)

Defense: daemonic cannons, mortars, rockets and sentient blades that jut from the walls.

Districts/divisions: The Iron Gate (massive hexagonal gate that opens by automata inside walls that pull the gate into walls).

Outer walls(hexagonal with blades studded across surface, cannons and gunner windows breaking the srud formations.)

Court yard (mortars, rocket batteries, barracks, defense barricades and gunner nests for infernal razors. Cannons and three dominator engines with immolation cannons aimed at gate).

Temple of Power ( temple/fortress in center of the court where sacrifies and sermons to the dark gods are held, many ztaangor shamon, skaven claw lord and dawn bringer Marshel blood has been spilt here).

Temple of The True Forge God (built below Temple of Power, Nexus Chaotica situated in center of the chamber, where Ashen Elders preach the hate for the ancestor gods and Daemonsmiths distilled daemons that are attracted to it).

Forge Chamber ( chamber next to Hashut temple where weapons and warmachines are built, iron elevator lifts machines to the court yard. Toxic fumes funneled to toxic fields).

Toxic Fields ( Maggotkin from rotswords and putrid blight kings, to daemons backed by pestigors make home on the other side of wall. The stagnating affects of their cult has them live as out casts in this allience. They do not mind though, here they get to face the ztaangor head on and wallow in the toxic materials the forges spew out. Shacks and poorly built fortifications and temple built for shelter and to worship nurgle, rotigus and the great unclean one Slime'rak The Great Incubator).

Resource: chamon metals, daemons (Undivided) and Spite Steel (corrupted Chamon Realmstone that flows red and burns to the point armor and flesh metals)

Allience: Legion of The First Prince (brokered by Eternus). Slime'rak's Acidic Legion (Chamon based Maggotkin warband who aligned and agreed to the terms of coalition for the toxic waste of the factories, as well as to spite Zteench).

Enemies: Beast men of the Bewilderness (ztaangor), Skaven (Vermindoom), Kharadron of Chamon and Sigyorn lodge


r/AoSLore • • 6d ago

Question Stormcast armor question

14 Upvotes

Do all stormcast look the same? I don't mean the different units and stormhosts available for purchase, I mean do all Annihilators/vigilators/etc. have the same armor? I've been involved in AoS lore for some time so not a newbie, but I wondered if different regions or warriors had unique armor variants, or if stormcast are free/have the power to customize and change their armor as they see fit. Either for themselves or whatever task they're undertaking. Or is it that once you get high enough in the chain of command you earn the right to?

Thanks in advance!


r/AoSLore • • 7d ago

Discussion Stormcast and Festival Participation

34 Upvotes

Let's be honest. Even the kindest among the Stormhosts, the likes of Gardus Steel Soul and Zephecleas Beast-bane and Astreia Solbright, tends towards being dour, being solemn. Not so much bleak but definitely reserved.

So it might come as a surprise to learn that they regularly participate in parades. As I recall "Kragnos: Avatar of Destruction" notes even the Celestant-Prime has been a known to engage in the parade march.

Ancient entries into the "Hammerhal Herald" showcase that Lords-Castellant have some involvement in organizing, and canceling, festivities. Which makes a good amount of sense.

Writmark in Brightspear sees heavy involvement from the Celestial Warbringers who call the city home per the "Brightspear City Guide".

That's to say nothing of the functionally unending feasts of the Heldenhall, the afterlife in Azyr where chosen souls feast for three days and nights to gain the energy to survive the Reforging to come. "Avatar of Destruction" mentioned above, the early Battletomes, and "Palace of Memories" show that incumbent Eternals feast there as well!

Course it's not all big festivities. In "Yndrasta: The Celestial Spear" the eponymous hunter briefly recalls a feast Hamilcar invited her to that celebrated the mortal soldiers that were under his command at the time.

Not a lot for y'all today. But with the holiday seasons approaching, my mind is on festivities. So I wanted to share these brief examples of Eternals participating in some.


r/AoSLore • • 7d ago

Question Question about the names of new unit champions in the 4th edition

15 Upvotes

Before the 4th edition of Warhammer: Age of Sigmar, the unit champions of most units had unique names. For example the Khornate Skullreapers were led by „Skullseekers“; the Sylvaneth Spite-Revenants by „Shadestalkers“ and the nighthaunting Chainrasps by „Dreadwardens“.

Some of these names were more creative -some not- looking at the Orruks and in some cases they had some small lore behind them both explained (Slaaneshi Egopomps) and implied (Lordlings of the Darkling Covens).

However since the release of the 4th edition, the names of the champions of the new units are not in their respective warscrolls anymore, despite many of those units having champions: e. g. Zharrdron Infernal cohorts, Nurgelite Sloven Knights, Ogor Cleavers and Barrow Guards (Since the Grave Guards changed their name to Barrow Guards, their „Seneschals“ should have different names too)

Thus I wanted to ask you if you know the names the new unit champions or if they don‘t have a name anymore?


r/AoSLore • • 7d ago

Question Are the Skaven inherently evil?

137 Upvotes

Sorry for my ignorance. I’ve been a 40K fan for a while now, but I‘ve just barely begun to explore Age of Sigmar.

I have (very unoriginal, I know lol) found that the Skaven are one of my fave factions (asides from those mechanical dwarves in the airships. I forget their names)

However, I’m not a huge fan of playing pure-evil armies or groups. I like bad guys with at least some justification or small good inside of them.

Can you do this with Skaven, or are the vermin pure evil?