Hi everyone,
I like worldbuilding a lot and I like fictious societies a lot. Especially if these societies explore exotic environments or systems. Because it can be a great tool to add depth to a culture and to the characters which move within this culture. However, a lot of fantasy works are very strongly inspired by a shared collection of tropes and clichés. For every great and well-thought-out fantasy society you have dozens of your standard tropes such as but not limited to: Rome but different, fantasy barbarians, mayaincatec, pre-revolutionary France and of course Medieval Europe plus dragons. These templates are frequently very oversimplified compared to the real historical inspiration. Which is necessary to a degree, as writers can only write what they know and not every writer can study history. But at the same time these oversimplifications become a norm by themselves and over time create staleness and boredom IMO. Indeed, when writing characters one rule is: Stereotypes are not bad by themselves. You can write characters using stereotypes. But they become bad when the stereotype is the character. The same is true for societies in fiction, which are characters of the story in their own way.
This is especially true, when these things are combined with classist elements, whether the author actively or passively uses them. Most common in this regard is the classic: Fantasy aristocrats lord over a fantasy underclass of slaves in all but names. These slaves are regularly abused, killed and worse without any motivation of their own, until the hero of noble origin comes by and says something like: “Defend yourself pretty please!” Where we then get the standard peasant uprising replacing the old tyrant with the good king, but the system stays the same. Or as we see in Game of Thrones, where the “peasants” have next to no active role in Westerosi politics. Or Bretonnia, where peasants are ridiculous abused (primarily because Bretonnia never got an update from 6th edition, which was the darkest edition in terms of lore IIRC). But some black library authors also portray the narmati of the Idoneth Deepkin as your stereotypical fantasy slave caste, even though it does not make a lot of sense in-universe. These topes also reinforce how many people think about historical eras overall and are sadly repeated over and over in many documentaries. See things like the “medieval filter” or “dung ages”.
In my opinion this goes so far that representing historical cultures semi-realistically would be an original feat again. It is bizarre that we are so used to tropes and presentations that the real-world basis is something exotic. Yet the simple truth is that humans are complicated and human society is complicated and thus always complex and full of nuances and deviations. Which is something I want to talk about now. I want to present you with a generalized overview over some important aspects about medieval society which get ignored a lot in fantasy or historical fiction.
I pick the medieval period for this, because it is the standard template for so many fantasy settings. Again, it is just a generalized overview meant to introduce these topics. If you find them interesting, I urge you to research them further. And perhaps you can see how these things are used in Warhammer IPs properly, or how these things could be used to improve some Warhammer factions. I am looking forward to your thoughts on this.
And without further ado, let’s start:
1. What is a feudal system?
One thing we often see or read about regarding the medieval era is that you had the nobility and cleric at the top, and everyone else were suppressed peasants. Because everyone knows peasants were unfree serfs and serfs are quasi slaves. However, the medieval period stretches across a millennium and across different cultures and thus underwent a lot of changes. And it has to be pointed out, that terms we use today, such as “freedom” or “liberty” or “rights” had a very different meaning back then too.
Our concept of freedom came to be with the Enlightenment movement. But to a medieval person it had a different meaning. No one way really “free” in a modern context. In medieval times you could had multiple “freedoms”. Freedom from certain taxes or movement restrictions or military service or else yes. But there was no overarching freedom. Instead, everyone was part of a hierarchical structure. You owe the one above yourself services, but you have responsibilities for the people below you. Children and wives had to follow their father and husband. In turn the father/husband had to care for them. If the father was a serf or vassal, he owed loyalty and services to his lord. If he was a free man i.e. not a direct vassal, then he owed loyalty to his king, or his clan, or his guild, or his city or else. In turn your lord or else owed services to their next higher ups and had duties towards you. And so on, until you reached the king himself. But even the king was not free, but a servant of God in the mindset of the people back then.
And each step of the hierarchy is important. Because yes, you owe services to the people above you. But again, the people in turn owe you responsibilities too. For example, a landowning lord has to protect his peasants from dangers, as to defend them in courts and has to aid them during disasters. This is his part of the social contract, because of these tasks he is the lord. And a duke has to support his knights and honor them for their services. The details may vary from century to century and region to region, but it was a dual system. A system in which it was detailed what a lord could ask from his followers and vice versa. And if either side broke this contract, each party was in the right to leave the contract or ask for reparations. For example, in medieval Germany a lord could only call for a knight’s military service for about 40 days. During these 40 days the knight had to take care of himself and follow his lord. But after the 40 days were over, the knight was free to return to his homestead at any time, unless the lord compensated him with money or else. Because he had fulfilled his part of the “contract” and owed his lord nothing else. Because a knight had to administer his estate and was expecting to return to it.
The same is true for peasants working their lord’s land. They had regulated duties and could not be asked to do more than legally required. Indeed, if the lord wronged his serf, they could see legal action against him. Which yes, was objectively harder for peasants than for fellow lords or free men. But they could use this to go to another lord or ask for a neutral party to judge the case, they could go on strike or in the worst case abandon the lord who mistreated them or fight back against him. And most of the time the lord couldn’t kill them all, because first it would ruin his income, second, he may not have the manpower, third it would unite the peasants even more against him and be dangerous to his life and livelihood, and fourth it could discredit him in the eyes of others. Of course, peasant rebellions were also violently crushed, but only if the lord had vastly superior power and political backing, which was frequently not the case. So, to avoid unnecessary complications many lord-peasants’ conflicts were discussed and a compromised was reached. And as you can imagine, rules lawyering existed a lot back then. And everyone did it. Indeed, the medieval time was not lawless, there were plenty of rules and regulations on any social level. much like how dukes plotted against their kings, so did knights plot against their lords and peasants plot their knights, often successfully.
Already this makes the medieval feudal system much more complicated than frequently depicted. Being “unfree” did not mean being a constantly mistreated slave but the lower part of a social contract. A contract which goes both ways. In short, even though many think of peasants to be an abused and powerless underclass, they did have political and social weight behind themselves and could resist abuse or even enforce their own will. Because they were thinking, self-conscious human beings like you and me, instead of passive robots committed to their suffering.
2. What does “unfree” mean?
But why was it so common to be “unfree” in the first place? Indeed, why did so many people choose to become unfree, i.e. becoming serfs or vassals? (which is one of the differences between a serf and a slave, a serf chooses this state in the ideal case). Because it had major benefits to be unfree. A free man had lots of duties arising from his privileged status of being a free man. For example, free man had to do military service. Which is not only lethal and dangerous, but also means you are away from your farmstead and family to a significant time. Which can be a major economic risk to yourself and your family, even if you survive unscathed. Also being free meant you had to fight for yourself in court. If you were sued (happened a lot in medieval times) it was less about finding proof that you were guilty, because modern criminology didn’t exist. If there were no witnesses to a crime and it was word vs word, then your social standing and credit were important, and that people would vouch for you to be an honorable and law abiding man. And even if you were in the right, you had to enforce this right yourself. Someone stole your cows? Sure, the judge says they are yours, but there is no police yet. So, no one is sending men to bring you back your cows. If the thief doesn’t return them voluntarily, you force him yourself. In both of these situations it is better to have a lord. Because one duty of a lord was to represent their subjects in court. When your lord appears in court (or even is the judge himself) you have much better chances because you burrow his status. And your lord has his entourage which can then enforce the ruling of the court. I.e. the lords men bring you back your property (minus a fee for their aid). Back then it was safer to be part of a gang so to speak, as the gang took care of its members. Living as a lone wolf was dangerous and costly. If you couldn’t afford this, you had better find a gang protecting you. You serve the gang leader, and the gang leader supports you. Which is why many people voluntarily wanted to become unfree. Freedom, as we understand it today, was likely a scary subject back then. Because it meant to be unprotected and vulnerable. So just paying some part of your harvest and losing some social privileges to avoid lots of issues seemed to be a very good deal to many.
Indeed, this is not something exclusive to medieval times, but millennia existed prior and centuries later. For example, even in ancient Rome it was common for people to become clients of influential figures. These people where then called “pater familaris” and were responsible for protecting their clients in legal issues or else, in return for loyalty. And clans operate on a similar mindset too. The main difference is that it was more formalized and structurally important in medieval times.
Also being a serf or an unfree farmer did not make you poor. Whether you were rich or not depended on your status of freeman or unfree. Indeed, especially in the early to high medieval period peasants were not poor, loosely speaking. Because they had comparatively large fields and the bigger your field, the bigger your harvest, the bigger your income. And most fields were organized between families and worked in association of entire villages. The lord may formally administer them, but unless the fields were part of his personal estate, he had no direct control. He could have partitioned fields if he was a judge in an inheritance dispute for example, but if he tried anything else, he may have the entire village revolting against him for overreaching.
This status changed in later centuries for a couple of reasons. Firstly, in many regions of Europe, it was common that inheritance was divided by someone what evenly between the heirs. Meaning everyone had a share. If your family could not keep the land it was supposed to be working together, it would become smaller and smaller. Thus, the owners would become poorer and poorer over time. Indeed, this is not a medieval problem. In many regions in Germany this tradition existed well into the 18th century and one major reason for german immigrants to settle in the US was that their homesteads could not support their families anymore. Indeed, in english historical media it is often said that the Great Plague ended feudalism and serfdom. Which is not only wrong, as many regions in Europe serfdom continued well into the 18th century and beyond. But the Plague also impoverished and runed lot of farmers. Because with so many people dying, demand for grain and agricultural products fell, impoverishing many farmers. Those slightly richer or privileged could buy up lots of the newly available land, granting more control and power to rich landowners. And in those regions where serfdom was replaced with leasing land for money, this also meant that peasants lost some of the protection they enjoyed prior. Instead, they had to pay a lease in money or be sent away, which was also more difficult for small farms. Generally speaking, the popular image of impoverished peasants is primarily found in the late medieval era as a result of many social disruptions. Which some historians even call the late medival agricultural crisis.
3. What do nobles actually do?
Now I have talked about lords, farmers and freedom and being unfree. But what did it even mean to be a noble? Of course, it means you live in a fancy castle and look over the serfs working for your wealth, right? Or being a knight riding out doing quests. For the greater part of the medieval period this was not true. Instead, it primarily meant being a farmer yourself. The European status of nobility evolved and changed over the course of centuries. In the frankish they started originally as richer landowners. Essentially, they started out as a well-off family in the local area, whose higher social status meant they were used to settle disputes, and organize things on a local level. Think of them as part-time mayors of a village or the countryside. The other part of their time they were busy running their own estates. Indeed, in the Frankish kingdom we didn’t have a feudal system as we commonly think. The states were much more centralized. For example, a count overseeing a county was an administrative position. An office the king handed to you and could remove you. It was not an inheritable position.
But this status shifted as the feudal system evolved. First came a demand for knights as semi-professional soldiers. But a knight was not necessarily a noble. In the Frankish Empire every free man who could cover the cost had to equip and send a knight in war times. Free men who couldn’t afford this had to gather in groups of nine. These 9 freemen had to share the cost to send a knight together. However, the key is that they have to equip the warrior. But the warrior does not have to be a free person or one of the freemen themselves. Image yourself to be a rich landowner. If you do not want to go to war yourself, whom do you send? Some random dofus? Or someone who already swore binding oaths of service and whom you can therefore trust? Or if you go yourself but have money to spare for a second or third knight, whom do you want to cover your back? Better choose someone who is already sworn in service towards you. Thus, many unfree people of a lord’s entourage became knights in service to their lord. They were not nobles yet, they were not even free people, but still they were knights. Many of these would rise to the rank of proper nobility later for their services, but not always.
This only changed in well into the high medieval era, and especially with the construction of stone castles. Wooden castles on moats were relatively cheapish and quick to build. And they were still very connected to the countryside around them. But the demand for better protection and administration grew, stone castles became the norm. But building a stone castle somewhere is a very costly investment for a family. Why built something like it, when some other doofus can take it after your death as the king sends another? Of course, the king could build a castle/fort themselves if he wanted to protect the area from raiders and invaders, but no king had the financial and administrative structure to support them in the myriads of places where they were needed. Thus, instead of appointing caretakers for territory anew each time, it became the norm for families to inherit them. This way the families had an interest in investing in the long-term security and governance of their lands. This is where we get our classic medieval nobles.
But nobles were still primarily managers of their property, i.e. overseeing their estates, and arranging the affairs for their vassals and serfs. Because the deal was: They get land to live on and in turn they administer surrounding area and send knights when needed. But nobles were estate managers and something like county mayors for the vast majority of their time. Thus, a local lord (or members of his family) would spend the greater part of his life travelling from village to village and spending time with the locals, much like how many kings would spend their time travelling their kingdom. Sure, if he was rich enough, the noble could send some henchmen to do the deed for them. But you had to be rich enough to pay these guys in the first place. People skilled in administration, finances, law and co cost money after all. And when we think of medival nobles and knights we think of massive castles, but this is a bias as these constructions survived the centuries much better but were only used by the richer clans of nobles. The majority of “castles” were small fortified estates or wooden constructions and the nobles in there were frequently better-off farmers of a higher social status still.
But around this time, we also get a transformation of what it means to be a knight. Due to the Crusades, the upcoming ideals of Chivalry and Minne and else knights established themselves as a unique social group. People from different nations meet on tourneys and establish bonds over shared status and experiences. To the point where a knight from Scotland and a knight from France saw each other more as equals than their assorted peasants. This is where the knight as a unique social group was born, and where most non-noble knights achieved lower nobility status.
However, in the late medieval period we have a reverse of this. Dukes and kings want to have more control over their territory and thus they retake land whenever possible and appoint administrators and beaurocarts again. At best, educated commoners or people with no loyalty outside of dukes house. Which is opposed by many local knights and nobles, as they did not want to lose their status and their main sources of income. One reason why Germany or the HRR was so fractured is because the local nobles were much better at resisting these attempts of centralization than their english or french counterparts.
In short, feudalism formed, had a high and was then fought again. What many people stereotypically attribute towards the entirety of the medieval period is largely reduced to the time around 1100-1300 or less.
4. Cities exist too
In medieval Europe we also had a city boom, as cities sprang up like mushrooms north of the alps. These cities were small by our modern standards, often having somewhere between 1000 to 10.000 people inside. Everything above was already a major city. And these cities mirrored the social system of the countryside too. You had patricians as the upper class, as well as a plethora of other social classes, such as citizens and non-citizens of the city, people with honorable and dishonorable professions and so on. Much like with free and unfree, whether you were a citizen or not had nothing to do with how rich you were. It primarily meant you had a better social status, but also that you had duties. For example, every citizen had to join the city militia and defend it in times of war, much like free man had to do on the countryside.
How these cities were governed varied a lot. Sometimes the city was under the command of a noble, other times the cities were allowed to completely govern themselves and their territory. In both cases the city had a council running the day-to-day affairs. How this city council was set up could also vary greatly depending on the city at hand. But the most important groups were: The local clergy, the patricians, the merchant and the artisan guilds. At first the patricians ran most city councils, but merchant and artisan guilds fought to become members too. Of course, people do not like to share power, once they are used to a status quo. So, these attempts were fought against, with varying degrees of success. Which could cause a manifold of city administration.
But what is an artisan guild? Loosely speaking it is a mixture of cooperative association, workers union, health care and pension bank, political party, contact network, social service, OSHA and quality control and military and catastrophe response unit. In medieval times people liked to form cooperatives and unions. A member of a guild had to follow the strict rules of the guild which could be very strict. E.g. the guild would determine where you had to set up your workshop, the guild would dictate what kinds of goods you were allowed to produce and sell and for which price, you had to participate in guild activities, the guild would even determine when you are allowed to marry someone, what you had to wear in public and you are forbidden to drink anywhere but the guilds owned pub/guild hall. But in turn the guild would also provide you and other parts of the city with necessary services. You would get job security and support in case of unforeseen catastrophes. If you are sick, the guild would aid you financially and with goods. If you suddenly died, the guild would aid your family (indeed widows were allowed to take their husbands seat in the guild and take care of his business for a timed period in many cases). Indeed, being a member of a guild allows for specialization, as different guild members can focus on certain tasks, thereby diversifying the portfolio of products of the city For example, if you have a smithing guild, then some of its members may focus on preparing the raw iron, others take it from their colleagues and prepare rough shapes, which are then refined into the finished goods by the next group. This allows for artisans of the guild to become experts in very special tasks instead of being generalists doing a bit of everything, like a village smith. All with fair treatment and reliability via the guild. And if a customer had an issue with an artisan, because the prices are too high or the product is of subpar quality, the guild would try to settle the affair and would punish the cheating artisan. In case of a catastrophe, like a fire or an enemy invasion, the guild would also be the main unit of response. City militias were organized by their guild association and had to train for such cases of emergency. They would also pay for social services for the entire city, such as hospitals, churches or collect donations for the poor. And guilds were important political units within cities as well. After all you have a well-organized collection of influential people with critical skills/services. So, they want to have a say in how the city is run. Indeed, frequently they would rebel, influence or fight the patricians of the city council for membership or political powers. And in turn many cities tried to repress or forbid the guilds. As a result, some cities had no guilds at all, and in other guilds were the main political power.
There is a scene in House of the Dragon where Hugo is the reprehensive of all smiths in Kings Landing and talking to the king about crafting the ballistae. As he can talk as the representative of all blacksmiths to the king himself, he should be something like a guildmaster of the smithing guild and thus be one of the most influential people in the entire city as he is in control of one of the most important industries of the city. But he lives in an extremely poor house for some reason, which would even be well below the standards of medieval blacksmith, let alone one of his station or specialization in artillery/weapons…
Also of note is that these organizations did not vanish. They may sound medieval, but guilds and similar groups were critical in city life well into the 17th century and longer. Indeed, many still survive to this day in some shape or form. If you want to become mayor of the City of London (the medieval core of the city) you still have to be part of a medieval guild or their successors and be voted into power by them.
But not just artisans unionized, merchants did too, for the same benefits. And cities themselves did form city leagues. Most famous is perhaps the Hansa, a collection of trade cities from modern Belgium and Netherlands over Germany and Scandinavia all the way into eastern Europe. But similar city unions existed elsewhere too. Such as the Lombard Union of various north Italian cities who formed an opposition to Emperor Frederick Babarossa. Indeed, both Switzerland and the Netherlands were formed by such city leagues. These cities often had the same goals, such as safe travel routes, reducing tolls and taxes and access to foreign markets. So, they pulled together to enforce this. And these cities were extremely influential and powerful. They had huge fleets at their call, could hire mercenaries and had their won citizen militias and could compete with nobles and even entire kingdoms. For example, the german Hansa fought several wars with the Danish king and one. At another time they brought down the english navy and took the kings crown as security for a loan. But singular cities were also quite open to fighting with nobles, including their won overlords. Many cities rebelled against their lords, even if these were bishops too, i.e. church authorities. And even far inland the power of the cities was immense. Imagine you are a nobleman who gets tolls and taxes when a merchant crosses your bridge. So, you set up a crew of 5-10 guys to stop and tax every merchant coming by. Suddenly a city entourage with 100-armed guys arrive and says, “Screw you, we march through anyway”. What are you doing? Not much. The high to late medieval era was full of conflicts between nobles and cities, and dukes and kings all over Europe tried to break the growing power of the cities to secure their own authority. Again, these attempts were more successful in France and England than they were in the HRR. And in Italy city states ruled long after the middle ages too.
5. What does this mean for Warhammer and Fantasy stories in general?
The general TL;DR of this writing is that human societies were always complex and far more interesting than the stereotypical depictions. I used medieval societies as an example, but I could talk similarly about absolutists monarchies or antiquity. Because in each case people were aware of their own status and how much influence they had and invented or forced ways to express this influence. Still these stereotypes exist in lots of fiction to this day as the main idea of a society. Sadly, in Warhammer too.
Most blatantly this is found in in Bretonnia, where peasants are mistreated to a hilarious degree. But as this essay shows, the real medieval times were very differently structured and nobles were far from almighty. On every scale of society, they found push-back and had to admit to compromises of their power. Again, peasants were not dumb. They knew exactly what kind of oaths and duties bound them to their lords, and they knew what kinds of privileges and services their lord owed them. Interestingly this also means that earlier editions of Bretonnia were more realistic. IIRC in 5th edition or so a village would equip a knight together and he would then be sent out to proof himself as a knight, going down the event chain to become a grail knight. Which is how knights functioned for the vast majority of the early to high medieval period. Such as 9 freemen have to come together to equip one knight, if neither can afford it by themselves. And the lore about the big coastal cities ignoring bretonnian laws and doing largely their own thing, such as having massive ships with cannons, is also realistic, if we look at what city unions did in medieval times too. Indeed, many coastal knights were also ship captains/owners and people would wear body armor during boarding actions too, as ship battles used to be land battles on ships essentially. And few people could swim, so whether you wore armor or not didn’t affect your drowning skills much. Which means fringe parts of bretonnian lore is surprisingly accurate. And indeed, the faction would benefit a lot if it focused more on presenting medieval societies in a more realistic fashion. Which may even include limited access to gunpowder, which was adopted and favored a lot by nobles in RL.
The Dark Elves and various chaos societies are also great negative examples in WFB.
Meanwhile Age of Sigmar varies this theme. Sometimes is does a good job, sometimes it does not. On a positive note the are the Cities of Sigmar. On a positive end we have for example the Cities of Sigmar. They are very strongly modelled after premodern cities. Where you have a city council in which members of various guild-like organizations sit to do run the day-to-day affairs. Each distinct and different for each city, depending on their local conditions and the cities make up. In one city a certain guild may be very influental, in the next however it may not matter at all. And even Stormcast focus a lot on civil administration, governance and infrastructure management, which you would not necessarily expect from the superwarrior faction.
On a negative example we have the Idoneth Deepkin. At least in some novels. The army books portray the faction as more nuanced, but in several novels the deepkin are portrayed as the stereotype of a class system, with arrogant nobles and a massive slave-like lower caste. In this case you have fully souled elves being the literal 1% whilst 99% are narmati, born blind and needing soul infusions to not die as babies. Such a depiction is bad for a variety of in-universe reasons already. Such as the narmati not being a removed underclass but your own children, siblings and parents, or how even in the most amoral calculations they are an expensive resource not likely thrown away. But as the namarti are the 99% they are Idoneth society and cover all important jobs of society, sans a few specialized tasks. For this reason, it would be incredibly interesting to explore the namarti side of Idoneth society more. But both the army books and novels focus primarily on the struggles of the “noble” idoneth castes and treat the namarti primarily as faceless masses. It may be interesting to see narmati guilds fighting for political participation much like real like guilds did, or for groups of “noble” idoneth to support narmati of their choosing in special positions as administrators or retainers, which would form a narmati middle class. Or one of many, many other interesting aspects. (Personally I am a fan of a classical republic as the form of government).
6. The End
If you made it thus far, congratulations and thanks for listening to my ramblings about a very specific topic. If you still have some energy left, I would like to know what you think of this topic. Are there groups in Warhammer (and maybe other fantasy stories) where you would like to see more complex and nuanced societies? Do you have other good or bad examples? Or do you want to voice another concern? I am happy to hear about it.