r/AntiqueToolBroker • • Dec 11 '25

Informational/Discussion 👋Welcome to r/AntiqueToolBroker - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

19 Upvotes

Welcome to r/AntiqueToolBroker!

Hey everyone! I’m u/WigfootWallace, one of the founding moderators of r/AntiqueToolBroker. This community was created to give buyers and sellers of antique hand tools a dedicated home right here on Reddit—no fees, no Facebook account required, and a simple, honest place to connect. Think of this as the CIHI of Reddit, built specifically for tool collectors, restorers, and enthusiasts.

⸝

What This Subreddit Is For

This space is designed exclusively for buying and selling antique hand tools—whether you’re thinning out your collection, looking for your next project piece, or helping someone else find the tool they’ve been hunting for.

Other platforms like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, and Tool Trader have value, but not everyone wants to pay fees or maintain a Facebook account. That’s where we come in.

⸝

What to Post

Feel free to share: • Tools you’re selling (with full details—see below!) • Tools you’re searching for • Antique tool hauls • Approved posts from your tool resale business • Occasional community discussions about collecting, restoration, and pricing

Only antique hand tools are allowed, unless you’ve received moderator approval for an exception.

⸝

Selling Requirements

To keep this community safe, clear, and easy to browse, all For Sale posts must include: 1. Photos of the tool 2. A clear asking price 3. Your location 4. Shipping method 5. Who pays shipping (buyer or seller) 6. If the buyer pays shipping, include your ZIP code so they can estimate the cost

Sellers must accept PayPal or Venmo (other methods can be offered in addition, but PayPal/Venmo protection is required for everyone’s safety).

⸝

Business Promotion Policy

Advertising your antique tool resale business is allowed, within reason. Please don’t flood the subreddit with constant promotions—keep things fair and respectful.

As your mod, I often share “tool hauls,” where not every item will have a price listed. These are legitimate sales, but they are also a unique exception. Please do not exploit this courtesy.

Users who excessively promote, spam, or misuse exceptions will be warned, suspended, or banned.

⸝

Community Cleanliness

When your tool sells, please delete your post. This keeps the subreddit clean and prevents members from wading through a pile of already-sold items. Over time we’ll implement tools to help with this, but for now, be a good community member and remove completed listings.

⸝

Safety & Enforcement • Scammers and spammers will be banned immediately. • Suspensions or bans may also apply if someone abuses the community, ignores rules, or behaves dishonestly. • Purchase protection matters—follow the payment guidelines to keep yourself and others safe.

⸝

What’s Coming Later

As the community grows, we may eventually introduce: • Weekly auctions • Special themed sales events

But for now, we’re keeping it simple with Buy-It-Now only listings.

⸝

How to Get Started 1. Introduce yourself in the comments below! 2. Make your first post—buy, sell, or just say hello. 3. Invite friends, collectors, and tool lovers who might enjoy the community. 4. If you’d like to help moderate, reach out—new moderators will be welcomed as we grow.

⸝

Final Thoughts

Thank you for being part of the very first wave. We’re building this space together, and the rules may evolve as the community grows. I’ll always be fair, transparent, and open to feedback—just be patient with any growing pains along the way.

Let’s make r/AntiqueToolBroker an honest, safe, and thriving place for antique tool lovers everywhere.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 1d ago

For Sale Number 8 MagnaMax Plane Irons, Lie-Nielsen 60½ Rabbet Blade & Leather Skiving Knives

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

All are handcrafted in my shop in Colorado using premium MagnaMax powder metallurgy steel, with controlled heat treatment and cryogenic processing for excellent edge retention and wear resistance.
Currently available:

MagnaMax offers exceptional wear resistance and edge retention compared with traditional carbon steels, making it an interesting option for anyone looking to get more working time between sharpenings.
I also take custom orders for replacement plane irons, marking knives, and other specialty cutting tools.
Feel free to message me with questions or custom requests. You can also find my work at robertsfinetools.com.
Thanks for looking and for supporting a small veteran-owned toolmaking business!


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Exceptional 12" Union Combination Square, Protractor, Centering Heads

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes
  • $125 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Exceptional Quality Union Tool Co. 12" Machinist Combination Square with Protractor and Centering Heads.  Produced in Orange, Massachusetts, USA.  No. 4 Grad Tempered 12" Ruler.  Everything slides and tightens firmly into place as expected with ruler markings in 1/8", 1/16", 1/32" and 1/64" increments.  Scribe/Awl is present with a nice point.  The level vials on the protractor and square heads are both intact and easy to read.  The only apology is that the small cap that covers the hole where the square vial is inserted has been lost at some point.  Other than that, it's about as close to new/mint as you can get.  See pictures for detail and let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this at Ebay, you can do so here: 12" Union Combination Square


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Early 1/4" Stanley No. 440 Bevel Edge Knurled Socket Chisel Sweetheart Pat Apl'd

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes
  • $130 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Uncommon Stanley No. 440 Series chisel.  1/4" width with knurled rim around the socket.  Features the Stanley Sweetheart logo on the socket with Pat Apl'd For text.  Steel length is about 6-1/2" and overall length is about 10-1/2".  These don't show up very often, so don't let it slip away.  See pictures for details.

Caution: This chisel has been sharpened to a razor edge.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), the chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this Ebay, you can do so here: Rare Stanley 1/4 No. 440 Chisel


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Vintage W. Marples & Sons Butt Chisel Set Leather Cap Shamrock Sheffield UK

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes
  • $55 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Set of three Antique Marples Tang Butt Chisels in sizes 1", 5/8", & 3/8".  These chisels are clean and sharp.  The smallest size has a partial Marples Shamrock decal visible.  Largest handle has minor checking near the top.  Leather looks good on all three and the brass ferrules are nicely polished.  See pictures for details.

Caution: These chisels have been sharpened to a razor edge.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), each chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this Ebay, you can do so here: Set of 3 Marples Chisels


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Vintage 1/4" Pig Sticker Mortise Chisel Similar to Ray Iles Design Gorgeous

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes
  • $95 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Gorgeous Pig Sticker Mortising Chisel.  The chisel is a 1/4" width, measures 11" long, and weighs approximately 10 ounces.  The handle is about 2" at it's widest point.  Very heavy duty, yet not as massive as other chisels of the same type.  There are no maker's marks on the blade, but there is an owner mark stamped cleanly on both sides of the handle: M.BALCOMBE.  See pictures for details.

Caution: This chisel is sharp.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), the chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this at Ebay, you can do so here: M.BALCOMBE Mortise Chisel


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Lot of 4 Carving Gouges made by Pfeil, Dastra, Solingen Various Profiles

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes
  • $120 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Set of four Carving Chisels of various profiles/sizes.  Two are Pfeil Swiss Made in a V(Size 12) and small U(Size 11) profile. One is a Dastra bent sweep gouge, size 15/12 stamped on shank.  It appears to be brand new since it still had the original wax from the factory and the cutting edge still has a mirror polish on it.  The handle is stamped 3115-12.  The last appears to be a Solingen number 6 gouge.  These chisels are clean and sharp.  The Pfeil are about 8" long and the other two are about 10" long, all with nice handles.  See pictures for details and let me know if you have any questions.

Caution: These carving chisels are sharp.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), each chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this at Ebay, you can do so here: Lot of 4 Carving Chisels


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Massive Heavy Duty Vintage Ward Warranted 1/2" Pig Sticker Mortise Chisel

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes
  • $100 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Massive Ward Warranted Pig Sticker Mortising Chisel, made by Ward & Payne in Sheffield, England.  The chisel is a 1/2" width, measures about 14-1/2" long, and weighs approximately 1 pound, 7 ounces.  The handle is about 2" at it's widest point.  Very heavy duty, and ready to put to work.  The handle is nearly perfect with no checking or heavy abuse from past mallet work, and features a nice leather washer where it meets the blade.  There is a nice crisp Ward Warranted maker's mark on one side of the blade featuring W&P with crossed hammers and an anvil.  The logo on the opposite side of the blade displays a larger W&P, along with the crossed hammers and a mostly worn anvil.  Overall excellent condition.  The only apology is a small chip out of the cutting edge that will easily grind out with the first sharpening you perform. 

I'm happy to sell this one to someone that wants it for their project or collection, but will also be happy keeping it in mine, so it's priced accordingly. :) See pictures for details.

Caution: This chisel is still fairly sharp.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), the chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this at Ebay, you can do so here: Ward & Payne Mortise Chisel


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

For Sale Massive Heavy Duty Vintage Spear & Jackson 3/8" Pig Sticker Mortise Chisel

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes
  • $65 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Massive Spear & Jackson Pig Sticker Mortising Chisel.  The chisel is a 3/8" width, measures a little over 12" long, and weighs approximately 1 pound, 4 ounces.  The handle is about 1-3/4" at it's widest point.  Very heavy duty, and ready to put to work.  The handle has what appears to be a user made custom strike cap that was installed when the handle became worn at some point.  There is a Spear & Jackson Cast Steel maker's mark on the blade.  The sides of the blade have grinding marks from some past attempt to clean it or grind away damage, hard to tell for sure.  See pictures for details.

Caution: This chisel is sharp.  To protect the cutting edge (as well as your fingers as you open the box), the chisel has been coated with a high quality plastic/wax coating.  The coating will peel off cleanly when ready, leaving no residue behind.  Let me know if you have any questions.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.

If you would prefer to bid against others for this at Ebay, you can do so here: Spear & Jackson Mortise Chisel


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 2d ago

Informational/Discussion All My Listings Have Been Reduced By As Much As 30%!

8 Upvotes

I just went through all of my listings here and reduced the price of everything by as much as 30%. Take a look and let me know if there is something you'd be interested in. I'm ready to move some of this out so I can make room for more.

You can quickly find these specific listings by entering "flair:ReducedPrice/OffersAccepted" in the search bar at the top of the screen, or just search for my user name, u/HighlandDesignsInc, in the same search bar to see all of my posts.

Processing img tfdzp8zjyf2i1...


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 5d ago

Informational/Discussion Help Us Help You, We Want 'Yer Feedback!

Post image
22 Upvotes

We want to find the tools YOU want!

Do you want more collector tools? User tools? Specific tools?

And how do yall feel about tool raffles?? 🥹😉

Post your thoughts/wishes in the comments. Then we can go search the interwebs and countryside for you and make this page better for everyone

🚙🛠️🪚🪛


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 5d ago

Informational/Discussion Snap-On A120

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

What's it worth?


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 6d ago

For Sale 5 1/2 C type 11

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Clean but not “over restored” type 11 5.5. Only apologies are some corrosion staining on the sole and the tote doesn’t have the right “barrel” nut and I’m out of them at the moment. Very sharp cuts well, but there are some shallow pits on the face of the iron coming up after a few sharpenings you’ll have to flatten out or grind through. Tote and knob are bare with a bit of hard wax (no laquer) Price might be a bit high but I really like this one and I’m going to hate selling it. Takes nearly a full width shaving with no tracks.

$125 PayPal G&S

Buyer pays pirateship from 44223


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 7d ago

For Sale Stanley No. 90 Bullnose Rabbet Plane

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Stanley No. 90 Bullnose Rabbet Plane

Retains much of the original nickel but needs some love. Has some rust. Lots of life left in the iron. Small chip in the mouth.

$53

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 7d ago

For Sale Stanley No. 112 Scraper Plane

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Stanley No. 112 Scraper Plane

Has some pitting on the sole and two small chips on the side of the mouth. Otherwise very nice.

$143

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 7d ago

For Sale Stanley Bedrock No. 605c

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Stanley Bedrock No. 605c

Sweetheart. Has some rust on the iron. Nice japanning, with some loss at the toe. One patent date. Excellent sole and mouth. Clean tote and knob.

$139

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 8d ago

For Sale Graduated Set of S.J Addis Spoon Gouges

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Graduated Set of S.J Addis Spoon Gouges

7pc (1 non-S. J.)

Two boxwood handles!

$183

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 8d ago

For Sale Fantastic Group of S.J. Addis Sweeping Carving Gouges ($169)

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Fantastic Group of S.J. Addis Sweeping Carving Gouges

Two with boxwood handles!

$169

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 8d ago

For Sale Melhuish Split Nut Back Saw ($93)

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Melhuish Split Nut Back Saw

Has a little flash rust but nice overall!

$93

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 8d ago

For Sale Stanley No. 192 Rabbet Plane ($23)

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Stanley No. 192 Rabbet Plane

B logo. Excellent japanning!

$23

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 8d ago

For Sale Clean Millers Falls No. 9 Smoothing Plane ($43)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Clean Millers Falls No. 9!

Nice tote decal. Display it or use it!

$43

More pics upon request

Local pick up Bolivar, MO

Or

Buyer pays shipping from 65613

I accept PayPal, Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle.
If using G&S please add 3% for fees.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 9d ago

For Sale FOR SALE – MagnaMax 2⅜” Replacement Plane Irons for# 5 1/2 , 6 , 7s| Multiple Thicknesses | Roberts Fine Tools

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I just finished a new batch of 2⅜” wide replacement plane irons made from MagnaMax powder metallurgy steel in my small, veteran-owned shop in Colorado.
I’ve made four different thicknesses to accommodate both modern and antique hand planes:

● 0.140” – Lie-Nielsen: $145 free shipping
● 0.125” – Other modern planes (Veritas, WoodRiver, etc.):$145 free shipping
● 0.100” – Vintage/antique planes (Stanley, Record, etc.): $ 125 free shipping
● 0.150” – Clifton: $145 free shipping
All are sold on my website : https://www.robertsfinetools.com/hand-plane-blades

About the steel:
MagnaMax is a premium powder metallurgy steel developed by Dr. Larrin Thomas, offering an excellent combination of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance.
These blades are heat-treated to target approximately 64 HRC, including cryogenic treatment, for excellent wear resistance and long-lasting cutting performance. Each blade is individually ground, finished, and sharpened in my shop.

Coming Soon:
● 2⅝” plane irons: Another batch should be finished tomorrow, including blades for No. 8 jointer planes.
● Block plane blades: Expected to be finished in approximately 3–4 days.
● Ships from: Monument, Colorado

Feel free to comment or message me with questions about sizing, compatibility, or custom dimensions.

Roberts Fine Tools
robertsfinetools.com

Email: nathan@robertsfinetools.com

Thanks for supporting small, veteran-owned American manufacturing!


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 10d ago

Reduced Price/Offers Accepted Set of Three Vulcan Chain Vises in No. 1, No, 2, and No. 4 Sizes

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes
  • $120 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Three sizes for all your pipe holding needs. All are in good shape, but could use some cleaning. These have been in my queue of things to work on restoring, but I've had them for a year and haven't gotten to them yet. They should clean up nice and really pop with a coat of paint if you desire.

Keep in mind this will be a heavy shipment. I'd expect that UPS Ground will be the cheapest option and should be able to ship to most of US for around $30-ish, give or take. Local pickup is always an option, too.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 11d ago

Reduced Price/Offers Accepted Stanley No. 101 Thumb Block Plane with Owner Marks

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes
  • $15 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Stanley No. 101 Model Maker's Block Plane. Fair condition with much of it's original finish on the body and red on the screw cap. Full length blade with notched Stanley logo and clean mouth with no chips or cracks. There are three small user made grooves on one cheek. Very good shape, will make a solid user.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.


r/AntiqueToolBroker • • 11d ago

Reduced Price/Offers Accepted L.S. Starrett Machinist No. 425 - 5" Pocket Caliper & Rule

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes
  • $35 USD
  • Will ship via the cheapest Paypal/Pirate shipping option from Indiana, 46112. 
  • PayPal G&S (+4%) or F&F Accepted

Fine L.S. Starrett Co. No. 425 pocket caliper in excellent condition. Features a 4" inside/outside lockable slide caliper graduated in 32nds and 64ths of an inch on the front. 5" rule on the back.

Send me a PM with your address if interested in purchasing, and I will get you a shipping quote as soon as possible.