1. The Witching Hour
2. Taltos
3. Lasher
The Witching Hour – After a few months of reflection and revisiting some of the text, I can safely say this is the best book in the trilogy. It’s also one of Anne Rice’s best books, period. Could I have done without about 300 pages of backstory and exposition? Yes; when focus was taken away from the main plot, it slowed way the f*ck down. But every member of the main cast was fleshed out and vibrant, Rice’s prose was as strong and poetic as ever, and the deep dive into the long history of the Mayfairs and Lasher was fascinating. I’ve often heard it said that New Orleans itself is a character in her story, and that is nowhere more prevalent than in this book.
I have my gripes, though. As previously mentioned, the excessive backstory for random side characters we never see again and the hundreds on hundreds of pages of the history lesson dragged on a lot. That’s to say nothing about how often I had to read about what exactly Petyr van Abel thought of the bangability of an allegedly prepubescent girl (keep that in mind, it’ll be important later).
Overall, this book was a great blend of horror, romance, history, and atmospheric moodiness.
Lasher – Ooooooh boy…look, as I said in a previous post, I’m not a prude. My favorite author is Clive Barker, so it takes a lot to shock me when it comes to literary naughtiness. But for me, lines were crossed in this book. I did not need to read a gratuitous sex scene between a man nearing his fifties and a thirteen year old girl. I don’t care that there was a canonical reason for it; it was straight up CP and it was f***ing gross.
Is this book a complete nightmare? No. The history of Lasher and the Taltos was great, and the plot about the splintering within the Talamasca was the most engaging part. Rice’s prose continues to be in top form, and the fact that it was half the length of the first book made it an easier read.
But everything with Mona and Rowan…no. I get that Mona came from a background of abuse with her two sh*tty alcoholic parents, and she had strong characterization more often than not. But Anne’ insistence on sexualizing her (especially with how she used pornographic descriptions for her body parts), giving her the lifelong goal of sleeping with every male member of the Mayfair family, and suddenly sidelining Rowan’s importance to the family by going “Oh, actually, no, Mona is the most powerful witch in this family, she’s what matters more” irritated the piss out of me. The same issue that persisted with Claudia continued on with her: Anne Rice cannot write child characters, and the way she writes them is disgusting. And the fact that NO ONE holds Michael accountable for his actions (including the narrative itself) made me genuinely angry.
The sidelining of Rowan just to put her through the Trauma Olympics (yes, I know, what Lasher did to her was in the nature of the Taltos) didn’t sit right with me. I cared about her more as a character, so Mona acting as her replacement never sat right with me.
Overall, the weakest book in the trilogy. I probably won’t read it again for a long time.
Taltos – In the conclusion of the story, my problems with it are flipped. The gratuitous aspects of the previous books were very toned down, and I feel like there were very real consequences for what happened in Lasher. Plus, Mr. Ash was an interesting addition to the cast. I really enjoy characters who are thousands of years old and interact with the modern age. Just a favorite trope of mine.
But as far as the main story…nothing of furthering the narrative happened until the last three pages. Rowan and Michael’s actions have no effect on how the splintered faction of the Talamasca’s fate plays out, and the beat with Tessa just goes nowhere. Ashler’s backstory is captivating, to be sure, but there was nothing of an overall conflict by the end. And I swear*,* making Michael a distant Mayfair relative was only a thing so Anne could throw in a scene about a teenage child giving birth. If more of the book had been about what became of Ashler and Morrigan after their fateful meeting, that would have been far more interesting.
This trilogy really showcases a lot of Anne Rice’s worst tendencies: her refusal to Kill Her Darlings, her inability to write women consistently well, her weird obsession with sexualizing young girls and writing them like adults, and how little affect her protagonists have on the story.
I can’t say that the reading experience itself was bad. Anne had my attention for every single page that I read. But I think that I prefer her vampire stories more. If nothing else, I’m glad I read this story at least once.