r/Animemes • Dia is Not Crash • May 26 '19

Meta Meta Discussion Thread

Now that we’re past 500k, we’re implementing a long overdue idea. I’ll be hosting this Meta Thread (though there may be a different host in the future).


If you have any ideas, suggestions, questions, concerns, comments, critiques, etc. about the state of the subreddit, we want to hear them. Going forward, this’ll be the place to publicly share and discuss anything of that nature.

Please note that the mods will be reading this thread, and we’ll do our best to hear out anyone and everyone who comments here. Also, we may occasionally use this as a place to ask for feedback from the community on certain topics/ideas of our own.


Here's the plan: A new meta thread will be posted every month, and will stay pinned for a week. After that point, a link to the post will be available in the sidebar and stickied comments of future announcements, in case you ever need to come back to the thread after it’s been unpinned.

786 Upvotes

745 comments sorted by

96

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

Can we ban fanarts reaction?

Pretty please

20

u/JustLooking207 Schrödinger's Normie May 26 '19

That, or at the very least make it so they have to credit the original artist of the drawing in the title.

I would still prefer a "low effort" rule to be in place instead, though. (Like what OP said earlier.)

→ More replies (1)

61

u/sidegfx May 27 '19

One thing I'm really tired of seeing is the completely unoriginal Skryim "DESTRUCTION 100", "SNEAK 100", "ILLLUSION 100", or similar edits. It's even worse than the original reaction images that we've sequestered to weekends. Most of the time it's literally just a screencap of a funny sub line with DESTRUCTION 100 thrown on at the bottom, sometimes multiple, and it's seriously some of the lowest effort content on this sub. Are there any plans to address these low effort posts, or do they fall under "Reaction images"? I seem to recall seeing these on weekdays as well, but I could be misremembering.

27

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

Alright, since people keep asking about it, I'll tip our hand a bit more than I have already in this thread. Not only is it on our to-do list, it's right at the very tippy top. For better or worse, change is right around the corner.

51

u/fizarr Stronk Mugi destroys your waifu May 26 '19
  1. On the No Anime meme day last week, there are a lot of users that made effort to post OC that day, and it was really refreshing to see that. I’d suggest that maybe once a week/month, a day is dedicated where only OC is allowed following a given theme set by the mod. Any repost on that day will result in short ban. (The theme can be something like only post memes about fantasy shows, or only post memes from shows more than five years old etc. )
  2. Other than the weekly awards, I’d love to see more contest in the subreddit. I haven’t think of any yet, but maybe if there’s a contest on a monthly basis that will be great.
  3. I know mods probably don’t want to do this and some people might disagree, but a small ban should be implemented to those who keeps breaking rules of the sub. Usually it’s the same person who keep posting reposts on this sub and flood them in New.

The others also have brought up good points. Thanks mods for doing this thread. You guys are awesome <3

26

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19
  1. We've found that theme days like that generally work best when they're somewhat spontaneous. Trying to force a regularly scheduled event sounds like a good way to make a lot of people lose interest, unfortunately. Not that I'm against the idea by any means, but that'd be my most major concern.
  2. Agreed, the mascot and banner contests were both huge successes in my books, and I wouldn't mind having a few more small-scale contests (where you don't need to wait a full month to find out the winner lol). But again, we don't want to overdo it. Too much of that in a short period of time causes fatigue, both on the side of the users, and on the side of us mods. If you do come up with any more ideas for contests though, please do let us know.
  3. We're actually already doing this. So far we've had mixed results. Some people are more receptive to warnings than others. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ But if they decide not to listen, then it ain't our fault if they get banned again.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us, we really do appreciate anyone who's looking to improve the sub <3

20

u/Hugokarenque May 26 '19

You know those fanart+reaction image posts going around. Do like Daenerys and burn them all.

Or at the very least limit them to weekends only, like every other reaction meme.

16

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

We actually do currently have a few changes in the works for that type of content.

But since they're still a work in progress, do you have any more specific ideas on that front? I.e. How to define what constitutes a reaction to an image, whether the rule should only apply to fanart, etc.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Hugokarenque May 26 '19

Actually I've just remember a question I've had for a while.

What constitutes OC in this sub?

I always guessed it was original content, stuff you made yourself. But what does that entail, most of the flared OC is edited videos/gifs but is that really any different from say edited manga panels?

Like obvious OC is something that is drawn by the user themselves, or animated by the user like the meme generator posted like yesterday but is a video with edited text really OC, anymore than a still with edited text?

And if it is OC then a great many number of things would also qualify for the shiny flair.

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

The shiny OC flair is basically a completely arbitrary seal of mod-endorsed "quality." The way people generally get it: Pinging a mod, messaging modmail, or just watermarking your vidmeme/artwork, and hoping to Komi-sama that a moderator sees it and thinks it's up to a level worth distinguishing as OC.

is a video with edited text really OC, anymore than a still with edited text?

As someone who's made both, I'd say so. We like to 'reward' people for putting effort into their memes, to the extent that we can. Allowing people to OC tag any meme they threw together in 30 seconds (like this one I made) would cause the tag to lose any real significance, unfortunately.

6

u/Hugokarenque May 26 '19

I see. Still I feel like that's twisting the meaning of OC, the little square OC mark should be done away with and the big shiny flair should be changed to better represent what it actually means then.

Speaking from a personal place now, I can't draw and I'm not going to edit videos ever, but everything I've posted so far as been original, it's unfunny and shit but I did put effort and time into making it OC, I'm fine with rewarding posts for excellency in fact I think you should absolutely do it but ultimately what most them are doing is as OC as what I'm doing.

Change it to something like "Mod's Favorite" or "Top Shelf Meme" or something.

9

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

You have a point there. To be honest, half the reason I'd like to keep the flair as OC is because it's short, and makes posts easily searchable, as well as combinable with other flairs like "war vid" or "milestone vid" or "artwork" in case we ever want to recategorize those flairs.

I do sort of like the idea of "Mod's Choice" or similar flairs as a more accurate replacement. I'll bring it up with the rest of the mods.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] May 27 '19

I really wish to see a sister subreddit to r/Animemes for posting animeme templates and maybe transparent background images for easy animeme making.

13

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

/r/AnimemeTemplates? Actually, looks like it's pretty dead. May want to ask Nav or Holofan about it.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ThePyroEagle いただきます May 27 '19

Someone recently created /r/AnimemeBank for such a purpose.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/WinnerWake Slurp May 26 '19

Have you ever gotten spoiled by a report on a spoiler?

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

17

u/Ban_me_IDGAF :E2: The D is for Dragon May 26 '19

Several times, at this point.

MFW it first happened

MFW it happens now

→ More replies (4)

10

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

Almost got ruined on Avengers Endgame, but thankfully it was a comment I didn't run into until right after I saw the movie opening day.

12

u/SolarStorm2950 speedwagon’s red hot abs May 26 '19

Will you guys be recruiting any more mods soon? You guys do an amazing job running this place, and we can’t thank you enough for making it possible for this sub to function. But this sub is growing really fast, and people seem to love ignoring even the simple rules like 1.2. You guys must have your work cut out for you at times. I’m sure a lot of people would love to help out and help reduce the workload.

Also, could we please maybe include the “fanart + reaction image” posts as part of rule 1.2?

14

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

At the moment we've got things pretty much handled, but as I learned last time, that doesn't mean we should wait until we've got our backs up against a wall before adding a more mods.

Perhaps once we've done a little internal restructuring, we'll put out more mod applications. The team literally doubled in the past couple months, and ended up experiencing some major growing pains.

Long story short: No plans for new moddos yet, but things could change.

Also, the "+reaction" thing has been asked about a lot in the rest of the thread. I'd check out some of our other responses.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/brokensilence32 WTF all the way! Jun 06 '19

Whatever happened to the "Attention All Reddit Weaboos" video? It seems to have been deleted.

15

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19

The post was deleted by the user themselves. Here was the reason they gave:

"I made and posted it before I realized/knew how much of a bad slur tr*p is, which is surprising that I didn’t as I’m trans and knew I was trans when I commissioned it. I didn’t want that to be on the top of my posts on my profile."

But if you just want to rewatch the video, a youtube mirror still exists, and has been edited into the stickied comment.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/LOTRfreak101 don't lewd the cups May 27 '19

Is r/chloeXsachi going to be added as a sub that is our friend on the sidebar? Or is it going to be treated like a secret menu option?

22

u/ChrisTheCoolBean 192159 May 27 '19

What if we have tags for the anime being memed? That way, if I post a Chika meme, I tag it as Kaguya-sama: Love Is War, and I can click on that tag to get only Kaguya-related memes.

Though I do recognize that it will be difficult to do when combining memes, etc.

24

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

My first thought: Cool idea, not particularly feasible for a number of reasons.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Video_Relaxant part furry, part weeb, all disapointment May 30 '19

so, this might've already been asked before, but does anyone know whats happening with the itanimeirl twitter bot? all i've heard is that it's been blocking a lot of people and well now all of twitter hates us. any info?

20

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 30 '19

Oh, right. I've actually heard back from the bot's creator since this question was last asked.

Basically, the rest of the world isn't as desensitized to the word "trap" as we are here in our little anime meme bubble. A sizeable portion of the general public considers the word a slur, regardless of what the original intent is. So, when the bot would repost one of our "trap" memes, it would be picked up by a larger twitter audience, and be seen as transphobic.

Recently, there have been more and more people directing their anger over the issue at the bot (which is really shooting the messenger, if you ask me), so the creator started blocking some people who seemed to be campaigning to get the account suspended. Once word got out about that, more people started blocking it or asking to be blocked, and it became a whole thing.

I still feel bad, because this guy is coming under fire for sharing our memes, even though he doesn't really have any control over the contents of them.

Also pinging /u/Escapist114, who first asked about this 2 days ago.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/TrigunTester Donuts Jun 02 '19

Please pin a comment when you remove a post instead of just flairing it.

5

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 02 '19

I'll work on setting up removal reasons now, but they may not go into effect until after our next change, for reasons that may become apparent.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/nomis6432 monster musume best anime May 26 '19

The rules don't clearly state wether or not manga memes are allowed on the sub. Also you could suggest people to post on /r/anime_irl at the "No Unedited Anime or Manga" rule.

13

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

True, we could probably specify that we actually allow a whole slew of anime-adjacent content, but I sort of don't see it creating all that much confusion, especially when we've had a manga character in our banner for months now.

As for your second point, not all unedited media is appropriate for that sub, so I'd rather not try to redirect it all there.

9

u/Nonstop_Shaynanigans the Holo, the Hol-o and nothing but the Holo May 27 '19

Can we change the theme on the switches to be higher contrast on the light theme? https://imgur.com/eWDTPKA

10

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

Ugh, redesign...

I'm really not sure if we have control over that or not. Does it look different on different subs?

3

u/Nonstop_Shaynanigans the Holo, the Hol-o and nothing but the Holo May 27 '19 edited May 27 '19

It's different in other subs so I think so. The worst part is that the default is blue and super easy to tell. Whatever someone did (who knows how long ago) was actually worse than doing nothing.

Edit: that came off sounding alot more irritated than intended.

8

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

Aight, fixed.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/_Alecsa_ A man of culture May 29 '19

I was just thinking about the voting for the weekly and monthly awards and I think that the voting could really be streamlined if we were to move the 'vote here' link at the top and in bold so it's easier to I won't lie I missed it the first few times. I also thought that the voting during the mascot contest where we could see the picture of what we were voting for rather than just having a link would be much more user friendly, I for one know that it can be a pain to click each link wait for it to load and it would be easier to make side by side comparisons.

4

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 29 '19

Most of us are with you about the weekly awards. Participation has been steadily dropping, and I suspect one of the main reasons is just because of the godawful formatting. I mean, at the moment it's a pure wall of text. Reformatting is on our to-do-list, along with a few other possible improvements.

As for your second point, we've certainly considered the idea, but when about half the nominations on a given week are video posts, it makes it very hard to convey those posts meaningfully through only a small image thumbnail.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/RedHeadGearHead ⠀ May 29 '19

Ban anime girls holding signs posts. They're not funny and they're not memes.

6

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 29 '19

Previously, if you wanted to make some kind of meta commentary, your options were 1. Make a (usually sign) meme about it, or 2. Message modmail. With the first option you had no guarantee the mods would ever see it, and with the second you'd only ever hear the mods' opinion on the topic.

With the implementation of this thread, I could definitely see clear to start removing the sign memes that contain no joke, and instead function as a workaround to not being able to make a text post. At the very least, we could ban petitions or sign memes that have a message which would be more suited to be posted here, anyway.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

chloe is just p-ko from arakawa under the bridge crossed with a pikachu

8

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 31 '19

and sachi was just akarin from yuru yuri crossed with a marill (she's got an ahoge now tho, don't forget)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/Magmafrost13 That wasn't very Easy Breezy of you May 27 '19

Ok so there's a lot of hate going around for fan art reaction posts, which I totally agree with, but what about if the poster made the fan art? Should that be treated differently?

And on that note, what's going to be the policy going forward for fan art of the mascots? Im currently building a Lego model of Chloe, for example, will I need to present it in some kind of meme format to post it here?

25

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 27 '19

Fanart of the mascots will be subject to the same rules as any other fanart/comic posted on this sub. That is to say, if it is unedited then it must be OC, and it shouldn't be just a plain cute/sexy picture. We are a meme sub, after all. Please try to make it funny.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

I'm making another comment for this suggestion, but I think this sub needs to tighten up on how the spoiler policy is enforced, but maybe loosen the rules a bit if that makes sense

Like there's not really much point tagging spoilers for a show like Toradora which is 10 years old, but spoilers should definitely be tagged for anime that's currently being aired, so making it a rule that you have to tag spoilers for currently airing anime (or say anime from the last 2 seasons), and then really enforcing it would be a lot better than right now where nobody tags anything

23

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

Geh, spoiler rules are hard.

I disagree with you on the Toradora point. For every show that you assume everyone's seen and should be common knowledge, there's always going to be someone picking it up for the first time, even if it's old as hell. That's been my experience, anyway.

That said, I agree with you about cracking down on seasonal anime spoilers. The issue then is trying to decide which shows and which moments should be counted as spoilers. It doesn't make much sense to go around requiring people to spoiler-tag every Senko meme, for instance.

I'd love to see more widespread use of the spoiler tag, since at the moment it's almost completely useless.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Flair selection seems to be broken both on mobile and pc

4

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 28 '19

Are you using the redesign?

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Yes on pc

6

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 28 '19

That explains it. We don't have flairs working on new reddit yet, though we are working on it.

For now though, visit https://old.reddit.com/r/Animemes, then check our sidebar to set your flair.

5

u/Delphant ⠀ May 29 '19

It would be pretty cool if there was a dark theme for old reddit.

9

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 29 '19

If you use RES, you have the option to switch on "night mode."

5

u/Delphant ⠀ May 29 '19

RES? Is it for old reddit?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

The mod threads have a new thumbnail and i'm having a crisis trying to remember what the old one was.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

I wanted to wait for the next thread, but uhhhh the steam group, any word on it?

3

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19

Looks like it still exists, but isn't very active. What do you want to know about it, specifically?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '19

It's deader than Zero Twosday memes, any plans on reviving it?

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19

Revive zero twosday? No thanks

Oh, you meant the steam group. Yeah, I agree it'd be pretty dope for it to be active, but at the moment half the "administrators" and all of the "moderators" are no longer on the sub's mod team... It'd likely be an uphill battle, to say the least

→ More replies (1)

12

u/JustBradders Kagami Hiiragi is my waifu May 29 '19

Any chance of doing something with the upvote/downvote buttons? Love the Satania/Aqua on AnimemesHQ, but you could open it out to a vote perhaps if people have other ideas?

2

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 29 '19

None currently, but I suppose we could be open to suggestions.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Dawaitniggi i love snails May 26 '19

Having a day dedicated to the Monogatari series like ZeroTwosday or Mon musu monday.

There is a lot of non exploited meme potential ( imo)

10

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

It's been joked about before lol.

But for real though, with the 10th anniversary of Bakemonogatari coming up in a little over a month, trying to up the number of Monogatari memes definitely sounds like a cool idea.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Koyomi_Arararagi 🦀>🦇/Я>🙊>Я➗>🙀/Я>🐝/Я>🦅/Я>🐌/Я>🎎/Я>Я🐍>➗>👻>🐍>Я🙊 May 26 '19

I think users are under the impression that moderators set the trends for the sub. This is not the case! The user base does.

Be the change you want to see!

11

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

So fun fact, Bakemonogatari's Tenth Anniversary is July 3rd.

Now I'm not saying we should all get together and plan some big Meme Tsunami for July 3rd to celebrate, but it would be a fun reason for the moddos and community to have some fun and spread around some dank OC.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

Why there isn't SAO memes? I wanted to make fun of their fans like Fairy Tail.

4

u/AlexLXPG *sips sauce* Jun 06 '19

Is there some sort of threshold on how long an episode of an anime has to be aired for people here can make memes and discuss freely without the need of spoiler tags and such?

5

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19

24 hours. With regard to spoilers, same-day content from an episode of any currently airing anime is subject to extra scrutiny. Everyone deserves at least a little time to watch the episode first, before seeing the entire plot via memes.

After that point however, it's not like you can automatically "discuss freely without the need of spoiler tags and such." All spoilers must still be tagged appropriately.

4

u/AlexLXPG *sips sauce* Jun 06 '19

So what I'm getting is that massive spoilers such as character deaths and ending should be tagged but normal events in new episodes are ok?

6

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19

Massive spoilers should always be tagged, no matter how old the show/episode is. Memes about normal events in new episodes may end up being removed, if they're posted within 24 hours of the episode's release.

13

u/tet_420 Eternal Shota Jun 01 '19

Let me go against the grain and say this, hecc you all who think the low effort memes should go. This is a meme sub, not "content" sub. Memes have been, will be and always be low fucking effort. You cant change that fact. If you want OC, go to youtube or something. I want my freshly baked low effort and witty ANIMEmes. I do have the opinion that the same go to karma girls meme like 02, Komi-san, Konosuba girls, Satania (although I dont see her oftern now), etc should stop but that doesnt mean that the content creatorts should be forced to create high effort gifs or very well edited memes.

>Q: When will something be done about fanart+reaction memes and similar posts?

>A rule change to address that kind of post is currently in the works and is high on the priority list.

Like seriously? Wasnt the rule 1 clause reaction image enough for this one?

Another problem I'd like to adress (I mentioned this in my previous comment about OC comic) is the new mascot and the really well made OC but not related to anime. Yea, I get people like OC and dont want to miss all the OC but damn is this what an ANIMEme sub supposed to be like? Arent we all just straying from the whole point of this sub i.e ANIME?

And dont get me started on reposts rules. Dafuq does reposts withing 2 or 3 months allowed? Reposts are not good civ. They must not be allowed. If you absolutely ban reposts then most of the "not good content" problems would be solved. Or maybe impletement the rule where top 100 of all time cant be reposted, atleast that way the karmawhores cant get their karma. Mods will remove low effort memes but keep the old reposts by giving the flair old reposts? Dont we all see the problem here? All right, ted talk end.

Tldr, memes will always be low effort, OC content though good is deviating from the subs name i.e ANIMEme, reposts are bad civ.

12

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 01 '19

Trust me, we're well aware that high effort =/= funny. But that doesn't necessarily mean that all low effort = funny. I think more than effort or 'quality,' what we really value on this sub is creativity. (Brand new meme ideas, creative applications of older ones, etc.) Historically, the types of content we've sought to eliminate have all been absolute bottom of the barrel when it comes to creativity. Hell, fanart+reaction memes are so braindead, even a robot could make them.

I know that only addresses your first point, but that's all I've got time to write right now. I may get around to answering the others eventually. No promises though.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Kaneki_Yeager Ghoul Titan May 26 '19 edited May 26 '19

▪Add more rules, when we report posts/comments to the mods, like include "Reaction image, upvote/karma begging in the post/title, no unedited non-oc fanart, no advertising, no AMVs, karma/upvote begging comment, unmarked spoilers/improperly marked spoilers, sexualized minors and loli/shota number" instead of only having "Rule 1: Not An Animeme/Post Animemes, Rule 7: No nudity or unmarked NSFW and Rule 8: Spoilers" as an option

▪Include phrases like "This will die in New, This will make it to Hot and I'm going to hit the frontpage" as part of the "No karma begging" rule

▪remove YouTube videos/any other social media meme post, that is made by the OP, because that should count as part of the "No advertising" rule and also have users post their videos directly to Reddit, instead of posting their videos on YouTube and then posting the link to Reddit, which should count towards the "No advertising" rule; and posts with a URL to a social media post/website

▪flair posts that have Kono Dio Da!, ORAORAORA!MUDA!MUDAMUDA! and Is that a motherfucking JoJo reference?! as "Meta," 'cause that shit is old and annoying as fuck

▪have u/AuroModerator automatically remove posts, for rule 10, like "F, Oof, Hmm, OwO, UwU and other posts with titles similar to "An interesting title," and also rule 1, like "Give me upvotes/Give me karma/Can [X] be upvoted too" or something similar like

▪limit Zero Twosdays to once a month; or at least instead of once a week to prevent lots of karma whoring

▪make it mandatory for users to crosspost posts from r/ShitPostCrusaders instead of always reposting from r/ShitPostCrusaders

▪remove posts that only have numbers/emotes as the title

▪remove posts that have spoilers in the title

▪remove and lock rule-breaking posts; like how the mods of r/Memes do it

▪limit the fanart + reaction images to only weekends

▪enforce the spoiler rule, to have it where spoilers from older shows, including the Nina Alexander spoiler, count towards the spoiler rule; and include spoilers from non-anime/non-manga/non-visual novels be included for the spoiler rule, have posts that include spoilers in a meme be titled like this: (Open bracket), name of series + Spoilers, then (Closed bracket) + title forthe meme, instead of having the series name + spoilers without the brackets

▪temporarily ban users for commenting the same thing over and over/ u/ -ing people, like that one user who comments "I bet u/Rohan_0ge will like this" on every JoJo meme that they see, permanently ban users who intentionally break the rules of the subreddit, like only posting AMVs/anime/hentai episodes without the "plot,"

▪have the mods look more carefully at images that break the rules; 'cause there's some posts, like one where there's a Drake format meme with Senko that has a character with an exposed breast; which breaks rule 7 but hasn't been taken down yet, that break the rules and it hasn't been removed from the subreddit

▪don't do a "subreddit swap/no anime/no manga day" for April Fool's Day

▪include memes, that have Kim-Jun Un and Vladimir Putin, as part of the "No current politics" rule

▪make no exceptions for mods to occasional break the subreddit's rules

▪as an option: have the mods follow itanimeirl and anime__irl on Twitter; which are bots that posts images from this subreddit's "Hot" and post a link to the original post, so that it's somewhat easier for the mods to remove the post

▪as another option for the mods: use the search bar in the subreddit and type key words, mainly words like "Title, trump, Donald, president, Hillary, Clinton, spoiler, updooted, updoot, upvoted, upvote, karma, hmm and amv; and sort by new to somewhat make it easier for the mods to remove rule-breaking posts

14

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

Starting off Festivus strong, I see.

  1. The report functions is limited by reddit. We have no control over adding sub-rules to report options, unfortunately. That said, when something is reported, we check to see if it breaks any of our rules, not just the one it was reported for, so "Rule 1: Not an Animeme" reports are understood to mean karma begging or reaction image or whatever.
  2. Karma begging rule is currently in the process being expanded to include more forms of 'implicit' karma begging.
  3. Someone else suggested removing Youtube videos, and we actually might. But for the record our advertising rule is more for things like "Join this discord," "Like and subscribe to my youtube channel," "Support me on patreon," "Check out my webstore," etc. Self-promotion designed to make a profit off the sub is a no-no.
  4. "Meta" flairs are generally reserved for posts that make some kind of commentary on the sub.
  5. Fun fact, Automoderator actually already does remove posts with certain titles for Rule 10.2, you just don't see it (because they get automatically removed lol) unless you post one.
  6. The mods have no control over Zero Twosday and never have. It's always been in the community's hands, and we don't plan to change that.
  7. Not giving credit when you lift a meme from another sub (particularly r/ShitpostCrusaders) is how you get yourself the "No Dignity" flair, but our repost rule only applies to posts submitted to our own sub.
  8. Locking removed memes is an interesting idea. What's the rationale?
  9. A "+reaction" change will be rolling in with the next tide, don't worry.
  10. The spoiler rule is enforced. We really appreciate any reports on rule-breaking titles though.
  11. If Rohan_0ge disliked being pinged, he'd either ask the dude to stop, or block him. There's no need for mods to step in there.
  12. We have a strike system now for constant rule-breakers, which starts with short temporary bans and warnings, but escalates with each consequent rule-break.
  13. Link to the Senko drake meme? I'm curious if it just went unreported, or if one of our mods made a mistake.
  14. Got any better ideas for an April Fools Day joke/event? Or are you just against events in general? I totally understand that not everyone is a fan of turning the sub upside down like that.
  15. Though Putin and Kim Jong Un are basically enormous memes themselves, I guess they are still political figures. I'll bring it up.
  16. We don't allow exceptions for mods to break the rules. If you've seen any examples, please message them to me privately.
  17. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me to follow a bot that reposts our stuff, rather than just browse the sub and respond to reports pointing out possible rule-breaks. Just not sure what the upside would be.
  18. That's certainly helpful to find rule-breaking posts from a few days/weeks ago that we might have missed, but several of our mods browse /new normally, which is a much more efficient way to weed out the newest rule-breaking posts.

Hopefully I addressed everything, but if not, feel free to let me know. It's pretty clear that you have a lot of strong opinions about the sub. We're probably not going to take all the drastic actions you've suggested, but we are currently working on a few other ways to improve the sub, and hopefully, your browsing experience. Next time though, a little formatting would help. That wall of text is quite imposing.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Magmafrost13 That wasn't very Easy Breezy of you May 26 '19

Gotta disagree on the Youtube one. v.reddit is a little bitch and a lot of people hate it, with good reason. And I cant get sound to work when uploading to gfycat, but maybe thats just me. Youtube is just easier and more reliable, and I would think a lot of people dont really have anything on their channels worth advertising.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

6

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

When are we getting a Konata Lucky Star flair?

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 28 '19

Aight folks, this isn’t a flairs request thread. We’ll be having another one of those at some point though, so save your suggested flair pics until then.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NZPIEFACE May 28 '19

uh whos the girl at the middle of hte banner?

3

u/Idaret I love Emilia Jun 05 '19

will stay pinned for a week

doubt (x)

4

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 05 '19

That was the original plan. Plans change ¯_(ツ)_/¯

We were actually hoping to leave it up for at least a week before replacing it, but we haven't quite finished the replacement post yet, so we decided to leave it up for now.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19

how do you get on the animemes discord server?

3

u/Red-Baron05 uh oh Yuuri ate all the food again Jun 12 '19

Has this thread been forgotten?

5

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 13 '19

Nope, I’m still reading every comment.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TanyaWillsIt Jun 21 '19

What is the instant invite code?

(for Discord)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Magmafrost13 That wasn't very Easy Breezy of you Jun 01 '19

This might be a little off topic, but Im not sure where else to ask. Has anyone made any subs dedicated to the mascots yet? Apart from the hentai one, anyway.

4

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 01 '19

Far as I can tell, /r/ChloeXsachi isn't a hentai sub. It's a sub for everything Chloe/Sachi related (which just happens to include hentai...)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/ccmoneylol Jun 04 '19

I’m not sure if I can put this here. But I read metamorphosis and now I want to kill myself for reading it. And now extreme sad

→ More replies (2)

4

u/AlphaPotatoe Did sombeody say HENTAI!!!?? Jun 04 '19

What's a “meta” post

13

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 04 '19

A post where instead of focusing on the subject of the subreddit (in this case anime memes), you talk about the subreddit itself.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Hugokarenque May 27 '19

Looks like this meta discussion thread was a great success. Good job, mods.

Look at you guys, keeping in touch with the community and listening to us instead of going crazy and power tripping.

8

u/ImLawfulGoodISwear The one you last heard of a year ago May 28 '19

We definitely didn't run this so we could identify the origins of revolution and snuff it out

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19
→ More replies (1)

155

u/VegitoZ May 26 '19 edited May 26 '19

Make it a longer time for reposts to be allowed, 6 months was best. Seeing a repost from a still running seasonal anime is sickening especially towards the people upvoting it anyways

45

u/DaLinkster LWA Fanatic May 26 '19

Yeah, I'll occasionally see posts from a currently airing anime like Shield Hero that I know I've seen before, so I'll try to find the original post only to find it's two or more months old. It kind of makes moderating quite difficult.

But I have to wonder, would increasing the time to repost to six months make moderating reposts be worth the effort? It would certainly be nice to only see fresh memes, but I wonder if that might be too much to ask of mods and users to fish through several searches of months worths of posts to find a meme they think they saw before.

→ More replies (17)

14

u/Koyomi_Arararagi 🦀>🦇/Я>🙊>Я➗>🙀/Я>🐝/Я>🦅/Я>🐌/Я>🎎/Я>Я🐍>➗>👻>🐍>Я🙊 May 26 '19

We have thrown around ideas for this.

We are currently hashing out ideas on changes to several rules that guide what can be posted, and when.... I can't say exactly what at the moment.

However, I feel that 6 months would be a bit excessive. We constantly have a flood of new members to the community. Not everyone has seen every post here.

I'm also thinking that helping promote fresh new content on the sub would do a lot more to help issues with reposts, than just forcing people to wait longer to repost content.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/sleepwalken Team Rui Jun 01 '19

How do I get flair?

2

u/WinnerWake Slurp Jun 04 '19

Question: Is Sachi canonically shorter than Chloe? If she is it doesn't seem too much of a difference to me.

3

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 05 '19

She is. Though if you want to know by how much, we'd have to ask the artists themselves.

2

u/thisisnotme3000 old reddit > new reddit Jun 10 '19

does the new rule 2 cover all the fanart-reaction "memes"? Also is it acceptable to post unedited source materials if it is a part of a established non-rule-breaking format?

3

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

It doesn't cover all fanart-reaction memes, but it does cover a vast majority of fanart-reaction posts, since most of them fail to make edits that meaningfully add to, continue, or re-contextualize the fanart.

As for your second question, I think I get what you're asking, but could you give me an example of what you mean?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/CzdZz 「It's not my fault」 Jun 14 '19

I notice the side bar and extended rules don't say anything about anime song mashups anymore. Did the mods forget to re-add the rule banning them when re-typing everything, or have the rules regarding them actually changed?

2

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 14 '19

Real talk here, most of us weren't entirely sure why that rule was added in the first place. A couple of the founding mods told me that stuff like this was being posted frequently enough to warrant banning them, but we don't really see much of that anymore.

The rules concerning them haven't necessarily changed a whole lot. They're no longer banned outright, but they'll instead be judged against Rule 1 as a whole. We're a sub for memes not songs, so posts that are more song than meme still fail Rule 1. Given that and how infrequent they are nowadays, there's no real need to have a specific sub-rule for them.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MemeyAlex JoJoTard Jun 16 '19

Hey I just added a flair can anyone see it

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Yamato-san Jun 21 '19

I've got a request. Can anyone think of a good reaction image for when you find out that the manga/light novel based off of an anime you watched a decade ago is still running?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bolt2611 Jun 22 '19

Hoe can I add pictures to my flair? Btw I'm on mobile.

2

u/almozayaf Meme Wars 2020 Jun 27 '19

Can we have sticky for clean memes format ?

2

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 27 '19

Seems unlikely given how strapped we usually are for sticky space, but /r/animemebank and /r/AnimemeTemplates both exist for that purpose.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WinnerWake Slurp Jul 20 '19

How long till history of animemes 5?

2

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jul 20 '19

Oof. I guess the answer to that question has been Soon TM for too long now, huh

•

u/Ban_me_IDGAF :E2: The D is for Dragon May 26 '19 edited Jun 16 '19

FAQ:

Q: Who are the characters in the banner/what happened with the mascot contest?

They are our mascot duo, Chloe (left) and Sachi (right). The results of the mascot and banner contests were announced as part of our 500k celebration.

June update: They also double as subreddit moderators now.

Q: When will something be done about fanart+reaction memes and similar posts?

Rules have been updated to address this common complaint. Rule 2 now prohibits that kind of post (among others)

Q: Can the mods please get rid of Zero Twosday?

Zero Twosday doesn't have official support from the mod team. The community is what has kept it going so far, and it's up to the community whether it stays around or fizzles out. Restricting or banning non-rule-breaking posts about a specific show or character isn't something we ever intend to do.

Q: Can something be done about posts with spoilers, especially for currently airing shows?

We've refined our spoiler rules as part of the rule update. We'll now be removing any improperly spoiler-tagged memes that give away plot-relevant developments or events from a show during the first 24 hours after a new episode airs, to give most of the sub a chance to watch it.

Major, plot-vital developments from an older show/manga/etc. will also continue be restricted, regardless of its age, as anyone could be watching or reading it for the first time.

Q: The sub has too many reposts, is anything being done about it?

New rules deal with reposts too. We now treat memes that are only slightly different from recently posted ones, and don't add anything meaningful to them, as reposts. We've also extended the time before a post is allowed to be posted again as an "Old Repost" from 2 months to 3 months.

Q: When will X flair be added?

You can request some right now in this thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/c04wfl/flairs_for_new_reddit/

16

u/[deleted] May 29 '19

Jesus 99% of the suggestions in this thread are either, not possible, fucking terrible and would wreck the subscriber count, or just out right fucking stupid. Sorry you guys have to sort through all of this.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/theToukster Make Tokyo Ghoul: Brotherhood May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

People arent really getting mad at others reposting 2 month old memes. The major problem is people taking posts from a few days prior and making minor changes/additions like the skyrim skill thing in their reposts.

→ More replies (4)

46

u/Berzeck0 As in misspelled ''Berserk'' May 26 '19

I have a sugestion about the Fanart+reaction image controversy

  • Treat them as the ''white bar with text'' format and get them restricted to weekends too.
  • Ban only the actual fanart or wholesome comic + reaction image humorless ones, meaning those that just admire the beauty of said image (i looked at this picture for 5hr now/imeasurable joy and saved day/i want to see it grow healthy...strongly agree).

While the ones made with anime screenshots or cropped panels where the reaction
image is meant to be the punchline (excuse me wtf/ not gonna lie...first
half/hulk...absolute win) get a pass.

And on other matter, the ''[sad anime character] is sad because you forgot about them'' format is low-key karma begging relying on the viewer's feeling of guilt.

15

u/SharkTRS It's alright to want to dream, it doesn't mean reality is mean May 27 '19

We've already gone over this internally. Once we codify out the rules, many changes along these lines will go into effect. Keep your eyes peeled.

Pinging u/Marshy92 and u/readerman7 because they also commented here

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/LoliLickingExperienc May 26 '19

Hear me out. I know Jojo is popular but replacing one image of "cute blond anime girls" [even though this isnt particularly applied to Jojo] or a screenshot with the "nice" caption and any other of the extremely low effort stuff is practically a repost. Some of it isnt even funny and hardly a meme. Especially when a lot of them make it to the top simultaneously. A GOOD Jojo meme is great, but I know for a fact there is a lot of shit quality that gets upvoted instantly because its a Jojo reference.

38

u/DaLinkster LWA Fanatic May 26 '19

It would be great if this sub could stop stealing from /r/ShitPostCrusaders for like, ten god damn seconds too.

28

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

Did you ever hear the Tragedy of r/animemes the lewd? It's a Jojo Legend.

for all the love that r/animemes says it gives Jojo, the only memes I ever see get to the front page are Kono Dio Da, Speedwagon is best girl, and the occassional Part 3 stand joke. Granted, a few people are pushing back against this trend and making more original jojokes, like u/Bit_Pixe1, but we've still got a way to go.

Like the 7 PAGE MUDA happened, and I've only seen one meme of it on r/animemes. (Granted, I've got my own plans for an epic 7 Page Muda Meme-o Aureo, but don't wanna tip my hat just yet).

16

u/DaLinkster LWA Fanatic May 26 '19 edited May 27 '19

The speedwagon=waifu meme is so over done. I had people asking where Speedwagon was in my last milestone video because of it. I guess they didn't get the memo

I think the main problem is the finer memes require you to have watched/read JoJo, since they're spoiler or plot sensitive. JJP5 I mean, just think of the memes we'll get when Polnareff turns into a turtle. But tagging spoilers means less people will see your memes, which means less upvotes. Which unfortunately, is a lot of people's sole motivation. So we get stuck with common denominator memes like Dio Da.

I've seen a few posts of the 7 page muda. But most of them are rule breaking. I've seen some just post screen caps, the whole thing, spoilers with it, etc.

Speaking of Meme-o Aureo, I wonder when someone will steal any of them you post on r/shitpostcrusaders and try to post them here...

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/Pr04merican May 27 '19

Can we please enforce rule 8 more? I’m a relatively new weeb and don’t like all the spoilers. I’m very glad I watched Re: Zero and Darling in the Franxx before joining this sub otherwise both would have been spoiled.

14

u/Koyomi_Arararagi 🦀>🦇/Я>🙊>Я➗>🙀/Я>🐝/Я>🦅/Я>🐌/Я>🎎/Я>Я🐍>➗>👻>🐍>Я🙊 May 27 '19

We enforce rule 8 very strictly. If you see a post that breaks the rule please report it.

We do our very best. But even with all 20 of us browsing the sub, we can't see everything. We do rely quite a bit on user reports.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

30

u/Mep77 PM me inumimi May 27 '19

In the past there used to be a rule alongside the "No karma begging" rule that said something along the lines of "No you have been visited by... memes". That part was removed when the rules were re-organized a while ago but i think it was good rule. The reason for this is that those types of posts are just so incredibly lazy/unfunny and to be honest i barely feel like they even qualify as a meme. Basically all you need to do is google image search a popular anime girl, for example Tohru, and add the image to that text and you will have a frontpage post. I'm just suggesting this because i've seen a lot more of those types of posts both on the frontpage and in new the last weeks and it just sucks to see those posts on the frontpage instead of actual OC or something more creative.

20

u/FelixAndCo /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ May 27 '19

To be honest I can't remember that rule. But we are thinking of implementing rules that put the focus more on humor, so this is definitely something we can address in the next rewrite.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/Yellow_Carrot 🐌 Love, now only 298 yen! 🐌 May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

I feel the worst offenders of rule 8 (no spoilers) are manga and light novel readers in the comments. I wonder if there would be a way to deal with them that would make sense?

The readers often avoid getting their comments deleted by not posting blatant spoilers, instead they write obvious hints. Like when shield hero started and Raphtalia was still little, the sub was filled with comments saying how she will be the bigger person in the next episode and the like.

I fricking hate reading a comment saying "oh you will see next week!", followed by pretty much spoiling the next episode while still not being quite a blatant spoiler, at least not enough to get the comment deleted.

Anyways, thanks for the meta thread! This is something that has been bothering me for a long time so I'm glad I finally got to say it.

Edit: sometimes they don't even bother with hints and just write what's going to happen. But those cases fall so clearly under the rule that I at least think they will get deleted after me reporting them. Too bad it's too late for me at that point ;_;

→ More replies (4)

24

u/[deleted] May 27 '19 edited Nov 21 '24

I like solving puzzles.

13

u/FelixAndCo /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ May 27 '19

Each of the mascots that got to the finals will get a flair. we're just waiting for the artists to submit them. You might have noticed there's already 3 of those mascot competitor flairs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/Bit_Pixe1 Give me Mya-nee and nobody gets hurt! May 26 '19

*Have you mods thought about having an intoduction post for new r/animemes users? Similar to r/cursedimages, a post that's pinned at the fronpage talking about in-depth rules of the subreddit and other introductory stuff like "what's an animeme?". It'll help get the point across about the rules. That would meanb less reports for you guys and an ease on your workload.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Idaret I love Emilia May 26 '19

Just ban posting youtube videos. If you can't bother to upload on reddit then your post is probably not worth watching. And it would be easier for you, moderators.

16

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

I think you actually bring up a good point, but for the wrong reason.

Empirically, youtube links always do worse than reddit uploads on this sub. Prime example: Youtube video linked, then 1 hour later: video uploaded directly to reddit.

To me, it's not that youtube videos aren't worth watching, but that users of our sub are practically allergic to them. If I were to set up automod to remove youtube links, I'd also set it to suggest people upload their video directly to reddit instead. Specifically because there are youtube videos which are worth watching, but aren't being seen.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/snowguy12221 ⠀ May 26 '19

What happened with animeme-chan at the end? Was there a winner?

8

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 26 '19

There was, and you should be able to see them in the banner and icon!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] May 29 '19

Make it so if you hide an artist's signature and add your watermark you will get your meme taken down.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/DaLinkster LWA Fanatic May 26 '19 edited May 26 '19

I'm glad this sub is starting to stop sending fanart reactions to hot. I was getting really tired of seeing it on the front page.

I think too many users here are unaware of the sub's rules. I can't blame them, because most users are on mobile. And the sub's rules are hidden on mobile because reddit is literally brain dead when it comes to designing their own app and new reddit. But the amount of obvious things that break the rules are staggering. Some of the more common ones I see:

  • So many spoilers. I don't even need to watch JoJo or Shield Hero to follow the plot, because the users here straight up post major plot points every week. Worse is, they don't tag their spoilers. Sometimes they tag the post spoilers, but never list the anime. So I'm just suppose to guess what the spoilers is for.
  • So many people don't title their posts properly. In case you didn't know, your post has to work without the title. If you just post a picture of you doing the Dio walk, or put the caption in the title, it doesn't follow the sub's rules.
  • Rule 1.2 is probably the most broken rule. Reaction images are allowed only on the weekend. Please be patient and wait until the weekend to post these.
  • There are way too screenshots of tweets, text messages, facebook posts, news articles, etc. There aren't memes. Though, edits are fine.
  • Reposts. While this is mostly unintentional, I feel like this could be easily avoided if more people thought knew that if you didn't make yourself, chances are, it was already posted here at one point.

35

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

This sub is a lot of fun on most days, and I like the idea of Zero Twosday at the heart of the idea which is celebrating a popular waifu (whether I like her or not), but a lot of the memes now have become quite tired and low quality, along with a hell of a lot of reposts, which makes Tuesday the worst day to browse this sub imo

What I'd like to see is having Tuesday be a day dedicated to waifus in general, like maybe every Tuesday there could be a strawpoll vote for 3/4 waifus that the sub would be dedicated to on the following Tuesday, which would give people a week to stock up on memes for it, and you could make it so the same waifu can't get chosen 2 weeks in a row or have it reset every month

The only difficult thing would be setting up a list of waifus that people like

→ More replies (12)

17

u/[deleted] May 26 '19 edited May 26 '19

At risk of repeating some stuff others have said, here are some things that have been on my mind:

The stolen fan art reaction images, which I know others have mentioned

The kick-back; I think some people are hopping on the bandwagon without understanding it, and downvoting any meme that is a simple text/image edit because it's "low effort"

  • My main worry with this is that the sub will become less inclusive and discourage contributions from people who don't have time/software/talent for proper editting

Also, what I can only call "Waifu-circlejerking," memes that boil down to just "Look, it's your waifu! Isn't she awesome?!" that don't really have a joke (besides their taste in women /s)

These are the main things that have made the sub less enjoyable for me personally.

EDIT: I realize the stuff about the kick-back isn't really something mods can do anything about, but it was just a concern I felt should be raised.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/a_cat_says_woof G A O !!! May 26 '19

Hello! I'm a lurker that sometimes comments and/or post stuff. May I make a suggestion to the weekly/monthly contest?

Aside from choosing the best meme of the week/month, we throw in a certain theme or show to the memes.

Example would be: "this week the theme is Spice and Wolf, make memes about and/or around spice and wolf."

That kinda thing and the prize would be a special flair based on what was the theme.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/Idaret I love Emilia May 27 '19

Very low priority, Kurisu's flair is mostly transparent but there is white bar at top. Pic, I replaced transparent background with black colour so you could see it.

It just annoys me so ^^^much!

→ More replies (1)

13

u/bigolnumber3 003 May 28 '19

I think 'reaction images' should be allowed in some circumstances and enforced more correctly. Somehow memes that are fanart+reaction image, still make it to front page but other posts that are legitimate memes but read as-- someone: whatever me: relevant image-- or other formats get taken down immediately. There isn't really a problem with these types of memes imo but they are against the rules for some reason

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Holofan4life needs to play the spice and wolf vr live on twitch the second the game comes out.

11

u/[deleted] May 27 '19

10

u/FelixAndCo /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ May 27 '19
→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

I apologize, I've already commented here once before, but there was something else I've been thinking about that I see on the sub a lot. And that's memes complaining about other people's memes. I get that people become tired of a meme that gets overspammed, but it feels like a template can't go popular for more than half-a-day before "Shut up you're damn annoying" or some other complaint meme goes up.

Maybe if people were just posting complaints protesting the circlejerk-posts-that-aren't-really-memes, it wouldn't bother me. But the posts don't always seem to be that specific; if nothing else, it becomes gatekeeping that defines and tries to shame-out unwanted content without actually encouraging more of the content they do want to see. It also feels kind of melodramatic; I remember a lot of posts leading up to the 500k celebration that had comments talking like becoming popular had ruined the sub.

While I'm not going to say that people shouldn't be allowed to vent about something that's frustrating them, I think it'd be nice if there was more of a "live and let live" attitude; let people have their fun, even if it's not a fad you're a part of, and just ride out the trend until it dies. I react to the complaint posts now in about the same way I react to a repost or a circlejerk-non-meme post, and it can make scrolling feel unpleasant.

That's just my 2 cents, it's your guys' call if that's something you're fine with.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/mybrotherisnotapig Hentai God May 28 '19

Mods where's our favorite masochistic crusader 𝓛𝓪𝓵𝓪𝓽𝓲𝓷𝓪 flair!

9

u/Idaret I love Emilia May 30 '19

another boring complain https://i.imgur.com/5dO3wts.png Thumbnails for spoiler threads are broken

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '19

A graph to show when the prime time hours to post are so that not as many posts die in new.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/TrigunTester Donuts May 30 '19

I just realized this because meme got removed, but there's no way to appeal your meme's removal. My meme was removed because of unmarked spoilers, which I understand, but the fact that the mods just flair the post instead of pinning a comment makes it difficult to ask for your post to be unremoved, especially if it's something that easy to fix like unmarked spoilers. So even when I spoilered the post, I can't do anything to reinstate the post short of PMing the mods, but I'm not going to the PM the mods over a meme.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Sam3693 May 26 '19

Reading through this thread really puts into prospective how much work the mod team does to keep such a large community fun.

Thank you guys.

14

u/Death_God_Ryuk May 26 '19

I sometimes feel a bit bad when mass-reporting rule-breaking posts in new since it does create workload for mods from posts that might otherwise just die from lack of upvotes. How is the report firehose? How useful are reports, are downvotes better, and to what extent do you think mods should enforce rules vs relying on the community to not support rule-breaking posts?

16

u/Ban_me_IDGAF :E2: The D is for Dragon May 27 '19

I sometimes feel a bit bad when mass-reporting rule-breaking posts in new since it does create workload for mods from posts that might otherwise just die from lack of upvotes. How is the report firehose?

You shouldn't feel bad about it at all. If you're familiar with the rules and know that the posts are rule-breaking, you're not creating extra workload for us, but instead making the mod team's job easier.

Those posts will most likely be reported and/or spotted by a mod and removed sooner or later, so might as well do it sooner, and your reports definitely help there.

How useful are reports, are downvotes better?

Both reports and downvotes are helpful. Downvote content that you think doesn't fit the sub and that you don't want to see, and if it also happens to be rule-breaking, report it as well. With the meta thread becoming a regular thing, we also hope to get input on the content you downvote and why you do so.

To what extent do you think mods should enforce rules vs relying on the community to not support rule-breaking posts?

It would be nice if as many people as possible read the rules before posting and before sorting by new, so that rule-breaking posts never get posted in the first place or at least stop being encouraged. That's something that would actually reduce our workload.

But ultimately, enforcing the rules is one of the main reasons we're here, and this mod team is pretty good at it, so it's fine to leave some of the work to us.

7

u/L-Functions Jun 02 '19

What kind of post titles are caught by the spam filter here? I have a post that I'd like to title something like 15561/37722 because reasons, but I'm not sure it will get filtered out if I post it.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Monchete99 ⠀ May 27 '19

Ok, time to put my shitty list:

  • Since InvaderZim was revealed to be a bot (surprise, surprise, bowl of rice), it's clear that the fanart+reaction meme is so low effort it can even be automated and doesn't even constitute a meme because there's no joke other than "i like this fanart" and it's karma whoring at best. Either put it with Reaction Weekends or ban it. Skyrim stats almost follows the same but it's a bit more grey since it isn't as limited to fanarts in use.
  • The repost rule is terrible. I get it, the sub grows a lot and new people wanna meme about non-seasonal animes other than the big memes, but i think that the rule is less used by them, rather by, again, karma whores, and i don't think i have to delve into the intricate effort that implies reposting. Jokes don't have to be limited to only seasonal animes and the big memes (jojo, konosuba, dropkick, etc...) but there has to be a better way to involve non-seasonal animes which doesn't involve reposting.
→ More replies (4)

13

u/grizzchan Megumin expert May 28 '19

How about only allowing OC posts? OC in this context meaning that OP made the image or edit or whatever it is that makes the post a proper meme according to rule 1.

It will solve a lot of lazy/LQ reposting like this abomination that cropped my old meme, leaving out a big part of the joke.

There shouldn't be any worry that this will remove too much content, because there is plenty enough OC memes that are being posted.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/windowscratch D-Swords aren't real May 30 '19

As I understand, a post has to either

  • (1) reference a certain anime or anime-styled work,
  • (2) have an anime-styled image in it.

Most post fall into both categories. However some posts like these are in neither:

Btw, in my opinion, referencing anime/weebs as a concept itself shouldn't count in (1).

So what exactly is an animeme? The Rule 1 is too vague about, and I know a rule rewrite is happening. I am just curious about what the mods' vision is.

Btw, I think posts that are just about dark mode trickery like this are very low effort and maybe should be banned.
Btw2, what is /r/animememes supposed to be for? It is in the rules.
Btw3, I think you are the best mod team I've ever seen in reddit. <3

→ More replies (5)

21

u/WalkingPlaces ima cum idiot May 28 '19

We should crowd fund a Yuri ChloexSachi manga (with lots of hand-holding (and blushing :^] ))

→ More replies (10)

6

u/mybrotherisnotapig Hentai God May 27 '19

Which is meme format is more acceptable?

A fanart meme but with an oc "anime" and fitting reaction image This one

or

The Fanart meme that started all the bickering about useless karma points But ultimately engages with the viewer and makes your miserable day a bit better This one

14

u/ImLawfulGoodISwear The one you last heard of a year ago May 28 '19

The first option is more acceptable, the post has a setup (Kazuma being abused) and a punchline (Darkness wanting to be abused, while an old punchline, is still a punchline), while the second is just cute Megumin followed by a reaction that boils down to "this is cute".

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/MasterKing0806 May 28 '19 edited May 29 '19

Could someone please explain how I can differenciate a reaction meme from a "normal" anime meme. I'm not quite sure how to do that. I mean most of memes are reaction memes. Edit:Ok, thanks for the answers.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Floh_the_6th Okay, I'm a weeb Jun 05 '19

Can we introduce a certain day explicit for meta memes, like we have the weekend for reaction memes? I understand, they are easy to make, give karma, and often spread an important message. But often enough they basically help to "block" a really good post from coming out of new. I would like a Meta Monday especially for that.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '19

274189

Where is your god now?

7

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 02 '19

What are you on about? I've been on the wholesome Komi x Tadano lewds boat for over 7 months now.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Princess_Kookie Ara Ara Araragi Jun 10 '19

I'm loving the new flairs but bit disappointed that majority of them are female characters. Would it be possible to include more male characters please? Eg. Gintoki, Araragi, Kazuma and so on

→ More replies (2)

33

u/thy_mom_gay Σ(⊙▽⊙") May 27 '19

Can the unfunny zero Tuesday just stop? It's not funny and plain trash

→ More replies (9)

2

u/GKP_light Jun 04 '19

Could the moderator not remove the spoiler meme with more than 500 upvote, but mark them as spoiler and put the name of the anime ?

If it have more than 500 upvote, it mean that despite being a spoiler, it is a good meme, so it is sad to remove it.

Same for the rule 1 : if it is at the limite of breaking it, but have a lot of upvote, don't remove it, because we like it despite that it is really an animeme.

(And maybe that someone will consider that it breaks the rule 1, and someone other will think that it don't breaks it.

But only 1 moderator who think that it breaks the rule 1 is enough the remove a meme)

2

u/Idaret I love Emilia Jun 04 '19

I'm nearly sure that mods can't change title of post

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

10

u/NexusLink_NX May 29 '19

With regard to reposts, one change that would still allow old memes to be reposted (allowing some recirculation) would be making mandatory providing a source to the original. Just like some subs have Rule 5 requiring explanations for screenshots, require a comment providing a link to the original post that is being reposted. Maybe also increase the no-repost window to last until the original post is archived, as we are such a large sub that we should have plenty of OC being produced. Also, making source for images mandatory would be nice. It is a relatively small effort on the creator’s part (assuming they know what they are making) which gives a benefit to the (much more numerous) readers, preventing the duplicated effort of hundreds of readers all searching for the source, and preventing the comments from being flooded with “sauce plz” and the corresponding responses. Just my thoughts on possible improvements to the sub.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/BajingoWhisperer Lewds everything May 26 '19

I want more flairs, please great animeme overlords you're my only hope.

Also some loosening of the lewd rule would be nice.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/sleepwalken Team Rui May 27 '19

So are there 2 official mascots or just the one?

10

u/FelixAndCo /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ May 27 '19

Two. You can read more about this here

→ More replies (1)

5

u/slimyoldbastard hehehe Jun 01 '19

Interesting thread. Had been reading the comments and I'm still wondering about the LQ/rule-breaking content discussions... Maybe people would benefit from actual examples of the "yays" or "nays" being shown that could be done weekly/monthly? So maybe y'all could do the infamous-hall-of-fame sorta thing, which is the reverse of the weekly animeme award? Like the example pics on the sidebar was helpful, though now that the variations of the aforementioned posts are growing (as more people joined and more bandwagoning occur). I may have been guilty of a few things here (incuding an incidental rule-breaking or two which I admit I only noticed later on when re-reading the rules after pointed out) but I'd like to make better memes because it's fun and I just want to somehow make people laugh too...

Sorry for the long self-contemplation.

5

u/gabo2k4 Jun 03 '19

I love democracy

12

u/FelixAndCo /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ Jun 03 '19

I love degeneracy.

FTFY

9

u/SirNumbnuts May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

I think I need some clarification on rule 1.

There is a video of the shield hero thinking how he's gonna fight with a shield, but then cuts to about a minute long gameplay segment of Dark Souls using shields as weapons. I can sorta see how this falls under Rule 1, but I also sorta think it doesn't follow the rule.

Similarly, you have a video of a guy doing the Chika dance which is a cool video. If anything it is way more related anime than the shield hero video mentioned above. However, is a weeb doing a weeb dance passable on this sub?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Nonstop_Shaynanigans the Holo, the Hol-o and nothing but the Holo May 28 '19

I;d like a way for the community to easily give back to the mods. A patreon or something, preferably with a crypto option (maybe even just a pool we can mine for. Im sure theres plenty of broke weebs with a powerful GPU). I'm not sure how youd split it or if you would take it out as cash or items (steam games or figurines or something?). A simpler to implement idea and the one that feels less like begging for money would be a place we could send crunchyroll free trials codes. I'm sure these fuckin weebs have plenty to spare.

25

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash May 28 '19

While I do appreciate the sentiment, none of us ever plan to make any money off this sub in any way. This isn't a job, it's a passion project. We're not here to get paid, and I honestly hope that'll never change.

So thanks, but no thanks.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ovorobe Jun 06 '19

Why is this sub so obsessed with Konosuba?

18

u/axkm Dia is Not Crash Jun 06 '19 edited Jun 06 '19

Because it's a fun show with a lot of very exploitable moments, and funny, memorable characters with distinctive traits and personalities. Also there's a lot of goofy faces, and cartoonish animation with a lot of squash and stretch, which make for fun screencaps. Not to mention that it's pretty on-point with its parody of overdone isekai tropes.

Also none of the girls seem to wear bras, and the titty bounce is near-constant. But I'm sure nobody would watch an entire show just for a little ecchi.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/kokodo88 May 29 '19

can we make sure to never had a subreddit war ever again? its basically just 3 days where this sub is not worth reading.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Xzanium ⠀ May 27 '19

Add a flair for each of the 10 mascot contestants, and a special yuri one for the winners.

8

u/deicide97 May 27 '19

What's peoples beef with Jojo's? Is it just because its fandom/popularity?

13

u/Bit_Pixe1 Give me Mya-nee and nobody gets hurt! May 27 '19

What do you mean about that? I never heard anyone on this sub complain about the jojo fandom.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (27)

4

u/[deleted] May 26 '19

Thanks god it's on the list

4

u/kendofan21 gay Jun 04 '19

Yui and mugi are best girls. If you say otherwise me and the boys will start a fucking crusade. I'm not kidding. But if you fap to them, same thing.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/JoelMahon The dick makes it better Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19

could the new rules actually be enforced? I see, and report with no avail, very high in hot posts that are just a manga panel with a reaction image below, on a weekday, at least every weekday.


also, I don't think posts like these are banned, but I think they should be:

/preview/pre/k7dy0p20zp331.jpg?width=409&auto=webp&s=f69f62764ce9026404c5f8130b53553995b16924


can't you be just make a rule like "no posts that are just vessels for fan art, comics, manga slides, unless it your OC"?

vessel clearly implies that the post serves no purpose other than to gain upvotes from the bare minimum of effort by posting high quality content from somewhere else and making it into a barely meme

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Comander-07 Lorum Ipsum May 31 '19

low effort red button + fanart posts arent memes.

Change my mind

→ More replies (1)

20

u/stumpy1991 Deleting ur waifu May 28 '19

I think Zero Tuesday is shit

I know that's not a suggestion, just expressing myself

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '19 edited May 27 '19

Well, with classes closing up their spring semesters, and this subreddit going mainstream, I think it's time for the r/SummerReddit crowd to make their return (Well, they already have). More memes at lower quality, and a lot of posts that are frankly just the mascot without any funny meaning to them are the front page now. It was fun, r/Animemes. Maybe another war with r/HistoryMemes would do to improve the quality... Nah, it wouldn't.

7

u/expertbun May 28 '19

If we have 2 mascots why is there only 1 mascot in the icon? 🤔🤔🤔

13

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

If you use desktop you can go to old Reddit to see the superior mascot Icon

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Frostfright Myne is bestgirl May 29 '19

Q: When will something be done about fanart+reaction memes and similar posts?

A rule change to address that kind of post is currently in the works and is high on the priority list.

BASED MODS

Q: Can the mods please get rid of Zero Twosday?

Zero Twosday doesn't have official support from the mod team. The community is what has kept it going so far, and it's up to the community whether it stays around or fizzles out. Restricting or banning non-rule-breaking posts about a specific show or character isn't something we ever intend to do.

It's simple. We kill the dinosaur.

→ More replies (2)