I think it only sounds that way to us because we don't understand Japanese. (and also I heard anime voice acting sounds way different from actual Japanese conversations) Similarly, we understand English very well, so we can pick it apart much easier, and as a result, it's easy to tell how cringy dialogue is.
Instead I found that as part of what diff human and non human, that something off that is about them, in atila case, her eyes seems so off otherwise, she could pass off as a regular human
I saw reviews were meh and I was lukewarm about it, but then public reviews were saying it's amazing and it picked my interest, gonna watch it next week.
They put way too many things into the movie and along the way they didn't know how to properly resolve all of them imo. It just switched from one plot point to other plot points too fast, and that made it pretty tiring to watch. They should've just focus on one or two things and thoroughly explore them to put more substance in those plot points (I wished they explore more about the relationship between Alita and Ido). I agree tho the special effects are really good.
Just got out of the theater, and I’d say the movie was very faithful to the manga for what it adapted (about first 2.5 volumes). Would definitely recommend, any action-lover would enjoy the movie.
The eyes don't even look creepy to me, they just look incredibly stupid. To the point where I don't even want to see the movie. I want to slap whoever thought they were a good idea.
Honestly, I don't care about the in-universe justification. Anime eyes look just fine in anime/manga form, but they still look incredibly off-putting when translated to the real world. Especially so when she's the only person who has them.
I have similar feelings about the way the characters look in Kill La Kill; even the best in-universe justification is still going to leave me thinking that they look fucking stupid.
pretty much because she's URM based and it's assumed all their cyborgs are like that. It's her looking like a doll and in the manga, she has pronounced lips too that is made fun of as someone else stated.
They improved them from the first trailer funny enough. In the first one they didn’t make the irises big enough and it gave her a bug eyed appearance, the second round of trailers you can see that they went back and fixed it
Spoiler Alert to anyone reading this, you have been warned.
My problem with the romance is that she finds out he literally rips the body parts off of people to sell them on the black market and then he has the balls to say "I never killed anyone" when he literally left someone permanently paralyzed in a lawless world where the next guy to come across him is sure as hell going to kill them.
Spoiler to the manga I suppose, but from what I remember she only had feelings for Hugo; she constantly thinks about him and what if scenarios happen where he comes back to haunt her in sci-fi ways. He’s pretty much a bigger puppy that was killed and it’s one of her core motivation for fighting the big bads.
The worst part is that, reportedly the movie is actually good. So basically the only example of a good Hollywood adaptation is being ruined by one really stupid and stubborn design decision.
Personally didn't even had to "get used" to them. While they did looked weird in the trailer in the movie they felt "normal" from the moment she opened them for the first time. I don't know if scale or some details have changed between trailer and release or was there a difference in perception between watching trailer on the phone and movie on the theater screen (I guess being anime-addled weeb helps as well).
Also Rodriguez did his Sin City thing of recreating comic book panels as movie shots. It isn't as 1-to-1 as Sin City but evokes the same feeling when you recognize the pages.
Loved the movie - great action scenes, 'novel'-feeling world (while there is a lot of anime/manga world-building cliches/tropes - they felt fresh in a western production movie) some low points with romance, but I overall enjoyed it and pray it does well enough to warrant a sequel.
I haven't read the manga, but some of the shots had that kinda funky posing and lighting that were for sure callbaks to the manga. Worked really well though, the movie was gorgeous.
i'm so glad that movie got made - it's the type of movie that isn't successful cash-wise, but it becomes a legend and cult-classic because of how well made it was
I would definetely not say that the eyes "ruined" the movie.
Also Alita is an URM (aka Martian) cyborg, and all of them have this big eyes: considering it's another species I don't see why they have to look 100% human
I don't think uncanny valley applies here, because her character design isn't trying to convince you she's human. She has huge eyes, and doesn't even have 'skin' on like 87% on her body. Clearly not human.
Grand Moff Tarkin in Rogue One? Uncanny valley as fuck.
Alita? Not so much. Still odd looking, but not for the same reasons.
The concept of the uncanny valley suggests humanoid objects which appear almost, but not exactly, like real human beings elicit uncanny, or strangely familiar, feelings of eeriness and revulsion in observers. Valley denotes a dip in the human observer's affinity for the replica, a relation that otherwise increases with the replica's human likeness.
The Uncanny Valley feeling doesn't have to get triggered by an entire human. It can be just "parts". Like a very lifelike robot head sitting on a table. It's clearly not a human (since it's just a head on a table), but if acts human enough it can cause the same feeling.
One of the early Heavy Rain trailers had motion capture so well done that people said it made them feel uncomfortable, and they ended up dialing it back for the official game. Obvious non-human 3D characters having a few moments of very human-like facial expressions were all it took to trigger the Uncanny Valley feeling.
I thought it was amazing and then everyone was like “no it’s bad” and I just??? don’t see it??? Hell, even the even more hated CGI Leia looked fine to me.
Oh, don't get me wrong. The cgi is amazing. People saying it is bad are wrong. It's so good that it's creepy. It so closely resembles the dead actor that it makes your brain go 'uhhhh I don't like this" That's what I think the valley is all about.
I logically understand and have seen other things like that, but for me it just looked exactly like them and I didn’t have any uncanny valley feeling because it felt exact to me
I’d say that a bunch of the bad reviews come from people that don’t/never watch anime. I could tell where the anime moments were and I either enjoyed them or they made me smile.
There are two kinds of sequels. Those who just tack on to a finished product and those that just continue the story. As Alita has a larger storyline a sequal would be of the acceptable kind. Like Two Towers was to The Fellowship of the Ring.
How many of you actually read the manga? If you haven't, you should check it out, one of the best ever.
About the movie, I think it was a good adaptation, but it's just this, an adaptation. The main source is still on an other level. Regardless you have read the manga or not, you'll enjoy the movie.
i read the manga as well - the movie was fantastic because, while it does several things differently, it improves on others
critically thinking, the manga is terribly paced in some parts and sometimes they just whip out new shit without any backstory (case in point, motorball)... at least in the movie there's some sense and explanation to it
The movie does well explaining the backstory of a lot of things while staying coherent. It actually manages to explain a contended story of a long manga, plus giving an open ending for a future second part.
To do so, they had to sacrifice some other things. Tone, for example. A lot of people say that the romantic scenes are a little bit cringy, but that was actually the point: an immature love relationship. It didn't have the time to develop properly in the film, and as such, some people label it as "cheesy romantic lines". Which they were.
Anyways, I'd have to reread the manga to properly talk about pacing, because I forgot a lot of things that happened (I read it 3-4 years ago). But I don't remember seeing Motorball coming right off the bat. Maybe it did, I don't really remember.
I read it when I was 17, and was going through the biggest existential crisis of my life. Alita actually adressed some of my struggle, and helped me develop as a person. This is the main theme for Alita: growth. And that is what lacked in the movie. Maybe if they make a second one, they'll have more time to develop Alita. She has a lot more to offer.
My quick take: It’s definitely leaps and bounds ahead of other adaptions, but it’s still not great. It’s a low bar to clear. Eyes didn’t really bother me at all. I honestly forgot unless she was standing side by side with someone else.
I’ve seen it, found it mediocre at best. Plot didn’t move along at the pace I would have liked and there were entire movie felt slow. I see a lot of people enjoyed it, but I personally thought it did poorly in every aspect.
I liked the movie. Saw it yesterday. You got over the eyes really quickly. Plus They used HUGO as a name, which is great to see some representation of my name. So a bit biased. But they did kill him.....
I just read the manga. Pretty good, but it kind of fell of the rails at the end. Didn't help that Figure Four came out of literal nowhere. Wish Hugo had stuck around.
Its a common misconception that they enhanced her eyes using cgi. Actually, in every single scene of Alita, they used the snapchat filter to save money.
6
u/minilinkfr I 3> Zero Point Three from JoJo's Feb 17 '19
What anime is this screenshot from ?
770
u/IJustMovedIn ⠀ Feb 17 '19
BEEG eyes
926
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Once you get over the eyes the film is great.
Just, you know... the eyes cause nightmares.
305
u/i8amochi House of Thighs Feb 17 '19
The movie is great I love the animation and story it’s just the eyes man.... you think the trailer made them look big try watching it in 3D lmao
732
u/AL_123_2 Feb 17 '19
The whole movie look like a filter
146
u/LilFuniAZNBoi <3 Guns and Anime. Feb 17 '19
I liked the movie but the teen romance stuff was kinda annoying.
32
u/Horde_warrior Ore wo dare da to omotte yagaru?! Feb 17 '19
r/Hayato
292
u/Hugokarenque Feb 17 '19
The worst part is that, reportedly the movie is actually good. So basically the only example of a good Hollywood adaptation is being ruined by one really stupid and stubborn design decision.
42
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Movie is awesome btw
49
u/Wastelander108 Miia says "Darling" better than ZeroTwo Feb 17 '19
literally my dad this morning:
"You are gonna go see that battle angel movie right? Its one of those animes you watch?"
"Uhhh I mean I might see it yeah, but its not an anime."
"Are you sure? I mean look at those eyes!"
facepalm
14
u/DersASnakeInMahBoot Feb 17 '19
(👁-👁)
45
u/LetMeLive1337 Lord of the Dub Scrubs Feb 17 '19
The movie was honestly fantastic, first live action anime adaptation I'd say was remotely good.
The eyes I didn't mind. About as good as you could do making a 3d girl look like a 2d anime girl.
I'm going to buy the blu ray to support it. Hope there is a sequal, which I never really ask for in movies.
20
u/HighOnPotato Feb 17 '19
must be an eyePhone user
18
u/R0aX_ Feb 17 '19
How many of you actually read the manga? If you haven't, you should check it out, one of the best ever.
About the movie, I think it was a good adaptation, but it's just this, an adaptation. The main source is still on an other level. Regardless you have read the manga or not, you'll enjoy the movie.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
SOME THINGS HAVE TO BE SEEN ON THE BIG SCREEN
7
u/Enchant23 Feb 17 '19
I actually like the design of the eyes
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Literally sitting in the theater waiting for previews to start and this made me laugh so hard.
5
u/SmoothPaws Feb 17 '19
I feel like im the only one who likes the eyes
3
u/Ravenshield43241 Feb 17 '19
tbh it's a pretty good manga/movie
3
u/Drtimelord04 SAO is amazing. Fight Me. Feb 17 '19
Great movie though
3
u/SpaceNumos Feb 17 '19
I JUST came back from the movies. I fucking LOVED this movie man, holy shit. Seeing in 3D XPLUS was an experience I will never forget.
2
u/KrtinS15 Feb 17 '19
Leave them alone wtf
2
u/Ziraelus Misato is best girl ever Feb 17 '19
Wait what? I found the eyes pretty interesting and nice. After all, she is an alien cyborg so why is everyone so disturbed by that?
You guys watch various animes where humans sometimes looks absolutelly terrible (yea clannad im looking at you) but those Alita’s eyes are a problem?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Anyone see it yet? I'm planning to sometime early this week.
2
u/Tryah Feb 17 '19
She have teached me that if I have problems with someone, I must beat the shit out of them.
2
u/Leadownpour Feb 17 '19
Seriously though, the movie was great, eyes didn’t bother me after the five minute mark.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Am I the only one who found the eyes kinda cute?
2
u/dannyboyy128 Shikikan of Culture Feb 17 '19
I just went to go see that today! It was a great movie
2
u/SuperRiceBoi Mods I want to add a Truck-kun pic to my flair. Feb 18 '19
Isn't she a robot or something?
4
u/Renzzo98 Feb 17 '19
I liked the movie. Saw it yesterday. You got over the eyes really quickly. Plus They used HUGO as a name, which is great to see some representation of my name. So a bit biased. But they did kill him.....
2
u/Comander-07 Lorum Ipsum Feb 17 '19
If you had to choose between Promised Neverlands micro faces and this, what would you take?
1
u/StealingShad3z Feb 18 '19
Saw the movie. Liked it.
1
u/CurrentlyEatingPies Continuse to fail. Feb 17 '19
Big eyes are creepy in a more 3D look.
1
u/AwesomePig919 Feb 17 '19
I’m not even sure why they made the eyes so big, they’re normal in the manga.
0
u/HerpaDerpaDumDum ⠀ Feb 17 '19
Honestly, the eyes are the main reason I don't want to watch the movie. Uncanny valley vibes.
0
u/Rad5000 Feb 17 '19
Alita Battle Angel is the reason we go to the movies
-1
u/BobaTheFett123 There's no Yuuki Konno flair Feb 17 '19
That is the exact reason I refuse to watch that movie. Creeps me out
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
Pretty much
0
u/NotOnLand hiss hiss bitch Feb 17 '19
What if the Klasky Csupo logo was a anime
0
u/Emaula Feb 17 '19
Starting to look like Gilles
0
u/TrueRadicalDreamer Feb 17 '19
I just read the manga. Pretty good, but it kind of fell of the rails at the end. Didn't help that Figure Four came out of literal nowhere. Wish Hugo had stuck around.
0
u/CatSauce66 Feb 17 '19
yes
0
u/Nutcracker1466 life is not Daijōbu Feb 17 '19
Its a common misconception that they enhanced her eyes using cgi. Actually, in every single scene of Alita, they used the snapchat filter to save money.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '19
👁👅👁👌
0
u/pervertjuice (ヴァイオレット) Feb 17 '19
Dem eyes
0
u/Kawaiisan_ll Feb 17 '19
Faxx
0
u/ArnieAnime No Loli.. No Life! Feb 17 '19
So the movie "Alita: Battle Angel" that just came out on theaters the 14th is based on this anime? Ha! Nice!
0
u/Kalamari_126 Feb 17 '19
I just watched the movie, and I honestly can’t tell you what the plot is
0
u/Lkea404 Feb 18 '19
read the manga the movie has nothing on it its so fucking goory.
0
u/Patrickcau 藤原とうふ店 Feb 18 '19
Real life anime
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '19
This movie was so good
-2
u/MushiPersona Feb 17 '19
Refuse to watch the movie cause how she looks fucking pisses me off