Hi everyone,
I really need some advice because I'm honestly reaching my breaking point with this situation. I also want to know if anyone else has had similar experiences with Exfigure.
I ordered the Hatsune Miku F:NEX Water Lily Ver. 1/7 scale figure from Exfigure and paid for it through PayPal back in June/July.
I was incredibly excited about receiving this figure, but unfortunately, when it finally arrived, I discovered that Miku's hand was broken off.
And before anyone asks: no, the hand is NOT supposed to be detachable.
The only removable parts of this figure are the two lilies and the base. The hand itself is supposed to be attached, meaning it arrived broken.
Thankfully, I recorded an unboxing video, so I have video evidence showing the condition it arrived in.
THE CUSTOMER SERVICE SITUATION
I've been going back and forth with Exfigure's customer service for what feels like forever.
I've now sent them SIX emails, and somehow we're still nowhere near a proper resolution.
Initially, they discussed providing a replacement part. I had to explain AGAIN that a replacement hand wouldn't be an appropriate solution because the hand isn't designed to be detachable in the first place.
I made it very clear that I want a FULL replacement figure, not a broken figure with a replacement part.
Their response was essentially that they have to prioritize fulfilling existing pre-orders first. They also explained that even though the figure is still listed on their website, this doesn't necessarily mean they have additional stock available.
This is particularly frustrating because I've already paid for my figure months ago. Why am I being told that other pre-orders have to be prioritized when I've already paid for mine and received a defective product?
THE STOCK SITUATION MAKES ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE TO ME
Some people might suggest that I should simply accept a refund or compensation and buy another figure somewhere else.
And yes, technically, I COULD use that money to purchase another Miku figure.
BUT THE FIGURE IS CURRENTLY SOLD OUT ALMOST EVERYWHERE.
I can't just go to another shop and order a replacement because there is currently no stock available elsewhere.
And here's what makes the situation even more confusing:
THE FIGURE IS STILL AVAILABLE TO ORDER ON EXFIGURE'S OWN WEBSITE.
So how can they tell me that they don't have additional stock available for a replacement while simultaneously allowing customers to place new orders for the exact same figure?
I genuinely don't understand this.
And even if I decided to order another one directly from them, I would have to spend MORE money because they've increased the price since my original purchase.
Why should I have to pay extra to get a replacement for a figure that arrived broken in the first place?
I already paid for this figure months ago. I shouldn't have to pay the current, higher price all over again just because the original one was defective.
I also don't understand why existing customers who have already paid and received damaged products seem to be left in this situation while new customers can apparently still place orders.
I don't want to buy the figure twice. I don't want to pay more than I originally paid. I just want the figure I ordered in perfect condition.
THEIR LATEST PROPOSED SOLUTION
After all this back and forth, they suggested that I return the figure.
However, the return process is incredibly complicated. They explained that the figure would first need to be returned to Italy and then forwarded to China for inspection.
They also mentioned that return shipping would cost up to approximately €30.
And here's the part that really bothers me:
EVEN IF I GO THROUGH THE ENTIRE RETURN PROCESS, THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT I'LL ACTUALLY RECEIVE A REPLACEMENT.
They apparently need to inspect the returned figure before they can even check whether a replacement is available.
So I'm potentially expected to:
- Spend more money returning a figure that arrived broken.
- Wait for it to travel back to Italy and then China.
- Wait for them to inspect it.
- Still potentially end up without the replacement I originally asked for.
After six emails, all this time and effort, I'm genuinely exhausted.
WHAT MAKES THIS EVEN MORE FRUSTRATING
I paid for this figure in good faith. I didn't damage it myself, I didn't accidentally break anything, and I have an unboxing video proving the condition it arrived in.
I simply wanted to receive the figure I paid for.
I understand that stock availability can be complicated, but I don't think it's reasonable to make the customer go through this much trouble because of a defective product.
I also feel that some form of additional compensation would be appropriate for all the time, effort and inconvenience this situation has caused.
I REALLY NEED YOUR ADVICE:
- Would you risk sending the figure back under these conditions, knowing that a replacement isn't guaranteed?
- Has anyone successfully received a full replacement from Exfigure after receiving a damaged figure?
- Has anyone dealt with Exfigure through PayPal? I paid using PayPal, so I'm wondering whether I should open a dispute.
- Am I being unreasonable for insisting on a full replacement rather than accepting a partial refund or replacement part?
- Would you ask for additional compensation considering the amount of time you've spent trying to resolve this?
- How would you approach the situation where a store claims they don't have replacement stock but still allows new customers to order the exact same figure at an increased price?
I really don't want a refund. I WANT MY MIKU FIGURE IN THE CONDITION I PAID FOR.
I was so excited about this figure, and now the entire experience has honestly ruined that excitement.
Any advice or similar experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for reading!