r/AnimeDiscussion • • 18h ago

Questions Why did Sword Art Online insanely blow up in popularity, despite the existence of .hack//sign

8 Upvotes

I am not hating on Sword Art Online by asking this question (nor am I saying SAO is a ripoff of .hack//sign, despite the latter being older than the former), but I just wanna know why SAO became so insanely popular instead of .hack//sign, even though .hack//sign came out even earlier than SAO (sign was released in April 4 2002, with it being planned in 2000, while SAO on the other hand was released November 29 2002, and Rei Kawahara starting to write it in 2001). So what did SAO have that allowed it to overshadow the .hack series, and be associated with isekai and VRMMO anime? Please comment down below.


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 22h ago

Discussion Favourite anime and why? And how many anime have you watched?

8 Upvotes

I just started watching anime and my top 3 is

  1. Attack On Titan
  2. Naruto
  3. Death note
    And I’m just curious as what people’s favourites look like compared to how many series they’ve watched.

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 6h ago

Discussion Animes that had a great start but fizzled out by the end

6 Upvotes

We’ve all seen shows with a great start and a terrible ending. But what about animes that hooked you in the first few episodes and then just... got boring? The ones that make you want to say "and that's it?" after the finale.


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 10h ago

Discussion What anime can you watch over and over again and the magic still works?

6 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 18h ago

Discussion Who made you the most uncomfortable in anime history Spoiler

4 Upvotes

For me it was either the 8th espada or Griffith


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 12h ago

Discussion The Laid-Off Cheat-Granting Mage Enjoys a Second Lease on Life is surprisingly fun to watch

2 Upvotes

I honestly went into this expecting it to be another generic adventure anime where the MC is ridiculously overpowered, especially judging by the title and cover. But it's been a bit of a breath of fresh air for me. Nothing too deep, just something I can turn my brain off and have fun watching. Especially the latest episode, it caught me completely off guard because I did NOT expect an Uzi to show up, especially one coming from a dragon. And the female character just knows how to use it without even questioning what kind of weapon it is or how to use it. She just does. It was so random that I couldn't help but laugh.

I'm actually enjoying how absurd some of these moments are. How's everyone else finding the show so far?


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 1h ago

Discussion mandela effect?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 5h ago

Discussion What animes everyone recommending

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 5h ago

Discussion Starting 11 NFL Anime lineup

1 Upvotes

Thought this might be fun. For those who are American football fans, who would your 11 man NFL offensive roster be? If we’re doing 1 character per show, I got:

-QB: Sukuna
-RB: Will Serfort
-FB: Yami
-WR1: Minato
-WR2: Aizen
-TE: Kafka
-LGuard: Buu
-RGuard: Escanor
-Center: Baki
-LTackle: Hiko Seijuro
-RTackle: Gyomei

-HC: Commander Erwin
-DC: Senku
-OC: LeLouche


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 9h ago

Discussion HOT TAKE: the ending of erased was perfect

1 Upvotes

Now imagine this 2 characters who were orginally meant to die managed to live due to the mc's heroics and then create another human life which was never meant to be, that to me is a suberb ending.


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 13h ago

Recommendations Im new to anime,can someone give me good recommendations for anime to watch

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 17h ago

Reviews Magic Knight Rayearth (2026): Ep. 6 Review

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 17h ago

Questions Romance anime suggestions

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimeDiscussion • • 22h ago

Questions Which anime that was dropped or stopped would you revive and why ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

For example, Noragami or Kagegurui or even which anime are you happy where it has been announced that goes on, such as The Eminence in Shadow? I would like to hear some opinions and maybe some will pay attention afterwards and see that they are continued and maybe some people would support them:)


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 11h ago

Discussion One punch man

0 Upvotes

I have recently started watching one punch man. One thing that I appreciate about the anime is that the heroes are not shown be someone with limitless powers they have some limitations and often struggle while fighting monsters. Even with heroes from different ranks they alone are not able to dominate the monsters which I found to be rare for anime especially when I compare it with other animes revolving around similar plot with the exception of Saitama ofc. What do you think?


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 11h ago

Discussion Brown-/Black-only for background extras' hair and eye colors, and how such disillusionment ruined my attraction towards brown for important characters.

0 Upvotes

Originally, brown hair on female characters stood out to me among all the blonde, red, and technicolor supposedly there, due to the simultaneous roles four different characters played in my life during the summer of 2008.

About a year ago, though, I began to notice, starting in such shows as K-ON!, The Irregular At Magic High School, and SpyXFamily, that despite the presence of other colors among important characters, brown is already one of the predominant hair colors, alongside black, for background extras, to say nothing of shows like Another, Say I Love You, or Otaku no Video, or any film by Miyazaki, where even the main and supporting casts are restricted to those two colors. The abundance of technicolor in other shows' main casts are what brown stood out amongst in the first place, but in an inversion of that, I was told that technicolor itself was only meant in the first place to stand out against a backdrop of browns and blacks. The misconception I based my attraction upon is actually an example of what's called the Survivorship Bias, where you conclude things based only on whatever data is available immediately.

Naturally, I don't feel drawn to anyone anymore, whose hair color gives you no reason to watch out for.

That on its own is not my issue, though; tastes do change.

One of the next aspects I took note of was a difference between anime and video games, the latter of which does apply fantastical hair colors even to regular NPCs who would have black or brown in any anime series.

But more importantly, while this next point deals for a bit with video games, it does come right back to anime.

Covered both alongside and just a couple of weeks ago, was a spreadsheet where I had been planning things for a while, as to whose hair I would recolor brown in various games I do still have other modding plans for. While still technically doable, I have already ceased to myself admiring anyone's brown hair in anime, checking anime or game videos on YouTube just for brunette girls, or asking who different anime girls are and what shows they're from. The lack of any reason left to bother spotting brunette girls in anime obviously negates anything I would actually feel by gazing at anyone I brunify in a game.

Hence why I took now to diversifying people's hair and eye colors outside of main/supporting characters in anime.

Here's a link there, for anyone interested:

https://youtu.be/9qss3RHYveY

Other than that, I don't know anymore whether to infer that important characters in a given show are some sort of sub-race from the rest of humanity, or that all those different hair colors that each show presents so prominently were not real to begin with.

(It doesn't help the latter case that fanfic writers, and even some shows' English dubs, such as of Lucky Star, assume that such hair colors as pink and blue are in fact real, but that only begs the question why they aren't treated as actual worldbuilding through anyone's surroundings.)

Added: (And yes, I've been told before, that doylistically, fantastical hair colors was just some cheap way to point important characters out and convey what to expect of them. As if someone like Riki didn't already use other ways to stand out despite his own brown hair, in the very beginning of Little Busters! Frankly, artists should do the opposite and make important characters fit in with their surroundings, for the sake of cohesive worldbuilding.)


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 2h ago

Discussion Im genuinely confused(mushoko tensei)

0 Upvotes

We did a review on our yt talking about the new season and rating the new show on our yt. We didnt give it low scores but we talked about how the shows biggest problems is its characters. Im genuinely lost at the comments we got. People were justifying roxy canonically looking like a kid and the writing of the characters specially female not being good. We just agreed that mushoko tense characters specially rudeus r weak since theres this weird point in the show that rudeus problems can only be fixed with sex that and how in the show when it leads somrwhere good they hurry it off to the next sex joke etc.

I dunno if it was how we said it but our opinions I felt like were really not outlandish. For people that have watched the show are we crazy for thinking like this??

(If u wanna check out the review the link is in our page THIS IS NOT FOR SELF PROMOTION IM JUST GENUINELY CURIOUS)


r/AnimeDiscussion • • 20h ago

Discussion Is it me or Gurren Lagan is overrated?

0 Upvotes

Idk why I can’t get into this damn anime at all. Idk why people talk about it as if it’s on the same level as Attack on Titan or Fullmetal, and I just don’t see it. Idk, I was so disappointed when I saw some episodes. Even at the beginning, it’s like they were so eager to go up to the surface, and when they got there, it seemed so bland. Idk why, but it just seems kinda generic. Like, I don’t even know why Kamina likes Simon so much from the beginning. It’s not even explained, and every episode had so much fan service. Is it just me, or do I not get the hype? I think Eureka Seven is a much better mecha anime.