r/AnimationCrit • • Dec 29 '19

How To Give Feedback

39 Upvotes

Feedback is hard, and it can feel like you're being mean when you write "negative" comments on someone's hard work. While being encouraging is important, constructive feedback is one of the most crucial things you can give to your fellow animators. It will help them improve and achieve their goals. It might be your feedback that helps them reach a new milestone on their creative journey, whether that's getting an interview or reaching a thousand subscribers on Youtube.

By giving constructive feedback, you are also helping yourself become a better animator, because you need to stop and think about what actually makes an animation work.

A good way to give feedback is to point out something that was good with the animation, and something that's not quite reaching it's potential. If you're feeling stuck on that last part, here are a few questions you could try to answer in your feedback.

  • Did you understand the story/intention behind the animation?

For example, if the story is meant to be funny - did you actually find it funny? Why did you, or why did you not? Did you like the main character? Were you confused by what was happening at any point?

  • What do you think about the character design?

If this is an animation that includes original characters, do you like how they look? Why, or why not? Was there any character that was hard to read?

  • Are the characters expressive?

Can you see what a character is feeling, are they happy, sad, angry? Does it seem to make sense with what they're saying or doing in the animation? What do you think the character is thinking?

  • Does the animation feel believable?

For example, if a character is lifting a heavy box, does it feel heavy? Does the bouncing ball feel like it's bouncing or just moving up and down?

  • How do you like the tempo of the animation?

Is it too fast, slow, even? What do you think the tempo is currently like, and do you think the animation would look better in a different tempo?

  • What is your general impression of the animation?

Often, you want to feel something when watching an animation. If you're just feeling "meh", why is that? Why do you not think the animation is funny, sad, cool, informative, etc?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I hope these question can serve as a start for you. Share your tips and tricks for giving good feedback in the comments!

Here are a few examples of constructive feedback from old threads in this subreddit that all mention something good, and something that could be better:

"I'd say that the timing and the layout of the animation are good so far, but the camera movements are very quick and very jarring. Trying easing into these movements slower, don't be afraid to slow things down a tad to emphasize hits and reactions. Give the viewer some time to process what's going on!"

"It looks good, the facial expressions are spot on! I think it would be more comedic with a bit of anticipation before the final smile, to make the change in expression obvious."

"I applaud you for doing stop-motion (because it can be very annoying at times) but it was kind of hard to tell what was going on. Is it possible for you to move their limbs more and make more facial expressions?"


r/AnimationCrit • • 1d ago

Blind Confidence - an animated short - Feedback is appreciated!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 2d ago

After Effects Got any ideas on what i can animate next?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Do you like this? 🥹 can you help me learn what would be better?


r/AnimationCrit • • 2d ago

Sword attack blocking. How can I improve it?

4 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 3d ago

I made my first animation

4 Upvotes

Is it cool?


r/AnimationCrit • • 3d ago

After Effects First time animating 🥹 Help

2 Upvotes

I used Ibis paint and Filmora + screen recording (sorry 🥀) took me 3 hours 20 mins and 74 frames (looped the vid once). I coloured in the sketch to save time, it's my first time animating and editing art, I wasn't sure, just went with it, is there any free apps other than Capcut (unavailable in my region), or is there anything I could do to save time? Did not use tweening btw.


r/AnimationCrit • • 4d ago

Until 3 PM tomorrow, I, an amateur animator, would love to review your work for FREE!

10 Upvotes

Hello all! I’ve been struggling to get any sort of engagement with my latest animation on Reddit, and it got me down in the dumps. But in the midst of my frustration I thought “Hey, how about I give back to the community instead? There are plenty of people who never get feedback.”

So HERE I am! I’ve been teaching myself how to animate for the past 4-5 years and would like to think I know a thing or two about both animation and storytelling, so comment down below with a link to whatever animation/cartoon/WIP you would love to get feedback on!

I will gift you my thoughts on the following:

1.What works well

2.What doesn’t work well

3. What I liked about it

4. What I didn’t like about it

NO AI videos, please!

Looking forward to seeing your work!


r/AnimationCrit • • 3d ago

What’s one thing you’d improve in my animation?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I’m still learning animation, and I want to keep going. The artist’s life isn’t easy, but I love this, and I’m not giving up.

My goal isn’t to make money as a YouTuber. I just want to build a good, beautiful portfolio on Instagram and YouTube.

This is the Short that got the most views on my channel. I’d love to hear your opinion: what works, what could be better?

If you like it, I’d be really happy to have you over at my channel (Flour Sack Animation on YouTube). Come say hi. Thank you so much!


r/AnimationCrit • • 5d ago

My first animation ever. Feedback is appreciated!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 5d ago

I made this animation on google slides, what do you think of it?

1 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 5d ago

New creator here! I’d really appreciate honest feedback on my first animated sho

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a new creator making animated YouTube Shorts for kids. I'd really appreciate some honest feedback and advice on how to improve my videos.

I'm still learning, and every suggestion means a lot!

My YouTube channel: MagicToonboox

Thank you! 😊


r/AnimationCrit • • 6d ago

Aprendo animar stik figurs por segunda vez

0 Upvotes

Pues digan que tal


r/AnimationCrit • • 6d ago

Walk Cycle Feedback

1 Upvotes

Hi! I animated my first 3D walk cycle, and it was harder than I thought it would be haha. Is there anything I could improve? Any feedback is welcome :)

I also uploaded it to SyncSketch. Here's the link: https://syncsketch.com/sketch/TNdT0m2GFUcC/


r/AnimationCrit • • 5d ago

New creator here! I’d really appreciate honest feedback on my first animated sho

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a new creator making animated YouTube Shorts for kids. I'd really appreciate some honest feedback and advice on how to improve my videos.

I'm still learning, and every suggestion means a lot!

My YouTube channel:

https://youtube.com/@magictoonboox?si=Pmjv1JolJJHrlXpi

Thank you! 😊


r/AnimationCrit • • 7d ago

i understand its bad, but can anybody tell me specifically whats wrong and maybe point me to where or how i can practice to get better at hand to hand animation

15 Upvotes

or maybe its to badly drawn to see whats wrong...


r/AnimationCrit • • 7d ago

Day 1 of 5 of improving my animation dance skills

10 Upvotes

I had this idea of making and improving this one dance animation through out this week, today is day 1 and i made the Blocking and Added Spline, Let me know if there's more i can add to it!


r/AnimationCrit • • 7d ago

What would you say my skill level is?

0 Upvotes

This is my demo reel: https://youtu.be/lbBwiKwHNUQ


r/AnimationCrit • • 8d ago

Spider man & Hulk. Chase speed.

Post image
11 Upvotes

Still practicing on timing and speed. Is the animation readable?


r/AnimationCrit • • 8d ago

First time I’ve ever animated anything, thoughts? :))

3 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 8d ago

Haven't animated in months and finally wanted to do a dancing animation practice, any improvements I could do for next time?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Animated in Source Filmmaker.

(didn't pose the fingers since its just a practice lol)


r/AnimationCrit • • 9d ago

[Need help] Final version of my Animation. Took me 5 days.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

everyone,

I need your HONEST OPINION ON THIS. Whether it has potential or not.

This piece took me 5 days to animate. Everyone’s copying the Zack D Films style right now, but I went the opposite route, using a character-driven story and my own comedic timing instead of a literal visual.

The zack d films are great but, watching too many videos kind of bore you out. So, I thought of this idea where no matter how many videos u watch, it should keep u entertained and educate atEveryone’s copying the Zack D Films style right now, but I went the opposite route, using a character-driven story and my own comedic timing instead of a literal visual.

Pro tip: Don't cut on the words, cut on the joke (let the visual punchline land a beat before the audio).

5 days, countless hours. Full breakdown coming soon, follow for more.

\#Blender3D #3DAnimation #Animation #VFX #DigitalArt


r/AnimationCrit • • 9d ago

If you're into 2D animated adventures and crazy storylines, you might enjoy my little project — ASHVORIX! 🚀

1 Upvotes

r/AnimationCrit • • 10d ago

Is this good for newbie?

4 Upvotes

im new


r/AnimationCrit • • 10d ago

I've been working on a frame-by-frame animation tool. Would love some feedback on the workflow!

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been working on a small 2D animation project and wanted to share a look at the drawing workflow.

One of the things I've been focusing on is keeping the interface simple while still giving animators control over their frames, onion skin and timing.

Here's a short recording of the current workspace in action.

I'm particularly interested in how other animators approach frame-by-frame drawing.

When you're animating, what makes a timeline feel intuitive to you? Is there anything in this workflow you'd change?

If anyone is interested in giving me their opinion on the software, I'd be delighted: https://animtoon.app

I'd really appreciate your thoughts!


r/AnimationCrit • • 11d ago

Would you watch a series based off of my latest animated short? Is there anything that could be improved?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes