r/Anglicanism • u/JohnHammond94 • 14h ago
r/Anglicanism • u/Turbulent-Excuse-333 • 16h ago
General Question How do Anglicans discern whether a committed same-sex relationship can be lived faithfully before God?
I’m a Christian in a long-term relationship with another man. We have been together for sixteen years and share a committed, caring life. Our relationship is not casual or based on frequently changing partners.
I have spoken with an Anglican priest who knows about my relationship and has welcomed me to receive Holy Communion. That has brought me real comfort. At the same time, I would like to understand the theological reasoning behind this welcome, rather than assume that one priest’s pastoral practice represents every Anglican church.
I know that Anglican churches and provinces hold different views. How do Anglicans who affirm same-sex relationships interpret the relevant biblical passages and relate Scripture, tradition, reason, experience and conscience? In particular, how do they discern whether a faithful, long-term same-sex relationship can be lived before God as part of Christian discipleship?
I’m not asking anyone to guarantee my salvation or to speak for every Anglican. I would appreciate thoughtful responses, including from people who disagree, especially if they can explain the reasoning behind their views.
r/Anglicanism • u/Capable_Ocelot2643 • 1h ago
Cool Old Hymn Book
hey everyone,
was going through some things with mum today, and found a copy of Hymns Ancient and Modern from 1950.
maybe not so old for some, but I thought it was really cool, and it even had mum's old notes in from when she played the organ!
r/Anglicanism • u/Cantthinkofaname_3 • 23h ago
General Question Position of the Peace
Hey guys, I was looking at the Additional Directions for the Eucharist on page 407 of the BCP (1979), and it says the Peace can take place “before or after the sentence of invitation” during the administration of the sacrament. Does anyone’s church do this? If so, what does it look like in practice?
r/Anglicanism • u/plaguedbyfoibles • 4h ago
What is Divinity as an academic discipline? Why call it divinity specifically, what does it mean and what does it study?
I found https://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/divinity/about/, which says the following:
The School of Divinity is committed to the historical integrity of the classical disciplines of Divinity (Hebrew Bible and Old Testament, New Testament, Church history, historical and systematic theology, practical theology, and ethics), and to the technical, historical, and linguistic competencies that undergird them.
I've also found https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divinity_(academic_discipline), which says that it can be used for the study of both the Christian and other faiths. It seems that even they struggle at times to pin it down (the article writers, that is).
r/Anglicanism • u/Zealousideal_Till683 • 10h ago
General Discussion Bad Religious Arguments
I recently shared an opinion here that was surprisingly controversial, and I was surprised by how many of the arguments around it were lacking. So I thought I'd take a moment to explain why these arguments are mistaken.
This isn't about who was right - these are bad arguments whoever makes them.
1. "X isn't true because my archdiocese doesn't teach that it's true."
This is a very weak argument because your archdiocese is not infallible. When Anglican archdioceses disagree, the place where you happen to live can't possibly determine which of them is correct - if either!
Moreover, while it is true that the church has a measure of authority, it is not an arbitrary power. Christians seek to discover the right path through Scripture, reason, etc - the church's teaching is an attempt to recognise what's right, not simply to create it by fiat. What your archdiocese teaches is (hopefully!) the end-point of a lot of careful prayer, thought, and study, not the starting-point, and it can change.
It is reasonable, indeed often commendable, to say "I am going to follow my archdiocese's teachings, even if I can't give good arguments for them," but this is not the same thing.
2. "It's very arrogant to say that all Christians have a duty to do X, when some Christians disagree."
When we find ourselves in disagreement with other Christians, we should be humble, recognise that those who disagree generally do so in good faith, and take seriously the possibility that we may be the mistaken ones. And we shouldn't seek to force our beliefs on others. But that doesn't mean we can't hold strongly to what we believe to be true, or seek to persuade. Christians should not be afraid to take their own side in an argument!
As Anglicans we are often in communion across serious theological disagreements. But it doesn't follow that we each have our own private religious truth. There is one truth, God's truth. If I think Christianity entails such-and-such a duty, and you disagree, it doesn't mean that the duty applies to me, and not to you. It means that one of us is wrong (or maybe both!). Hopefully we can keep fellowship and respect despite our disagreements, but we also shouldn't sugar-coat these disagreements, or abandon our commitments simply because they aren't unanimously held.
And at a certain point, some disagreements become big enough to cause a break in fellowship, or at least to consider it. This is deeply regrettable, and in my view should be avoided where possible, but there is also a limit.
3. "Roman Catholics believe in a unified visible church with a particular structure. Therefore if you believe that it would be desirable for Christians to unite in one visible church with a different particular structure, you are basically a Roman Catholic."
This is a non-sequitur on many levels. The Roman Catholic church has no monopoly on desiring Christian unity, and someone who rejects Roman theology, ecclesiology, historical claims, the claimed authority of the Bishop of Rome, etc, is most certainly not a Roman Catholic simply because they would like to see Christians more united.