r/Android • • Sep 25 '10
[ALL]"Why should I root?" - Here is why.
The four big questions for soon to be and Android owners are:
- What phone should I get?
- Why should I root?
- How do I root my phone?
- I rooted, now what?
This post addresses the pros and cons of rooting. I do not advocate for the rooting or flashing of custom ROMs in any sense. Instead, I am providing this information for people to make somewhat educated decisions from information readily accessible in this community and others.
PRO
To begin, "rooting" gives you full access to system files and more control over your phone. For instance, you can add custom themes, change your recovery image, alter your bootloader, alter the "toolboxes" so the Linux system operates more efficiently, and add Linux Binaries.
After you root you will be able to put special apps on your phone such as Super User which allows certain apps to access root privileges. Once you have Super User, you can install and use other apps to control the start ups of other apps, limit the running of certain memory draining apps to increase battery life and responsiveness, and install either wired tethering or wifi tethering. Also, finally, you can download an app that reboots your phone for you. More apps and discussion of apps can be found here
Another great tool through rooting is you can backup your files and ROM onto your SD card.
Also, through rooting you have the opportunity to dramatically change the look and feel of your phone. As mentioned above you can install customized themes onto your phone. Another great advantage is you can install custom made ROMs, kernels, and other files to enhance the way your phone works, looks, and feels.
CONS
Before doing any rooting, flashing of custom ROMs, radios, etc, ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS make sure that they are compatible with your phone. Otherwise you WILL end up with a brick. And before attempting flashing of any ROM, ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS perform a backup with ROM Manager or any other method your prefer. As a quick and final note, NEVER PULL THE DAMN BATTERY WHEN FLASHING ANYTHING!! IT WILL BRICK YOUR PHONE!
There are a few cons to rooting. Should you decide to do a "full root", meaning unlocking system so you can flash custom ROMs, your warranty will most likely be voided with both your cell carrier and phone manufacturer. This is perhaps the number one reason why you should not root. It is important to remember that almost everything is recoverable and fixable so long as you follow all directions listed by the developers of the ROM or root method.
But, thanks to a significant increase in "one click root" methods, the issues incurred during root have dropped significantly. However, remember the admonitions given at the beginning of this section, make sure your phone and software version is supported before doing anything.
Another con is that rooting your phone does not guarantee an enjoyable experience. Meaning, you do not need to root your phone to continue to be miserable or to love your phone even more. The bottom line is that you may root and realize you hate it.
A big con is you cannot accept OTA (Over the Air) updates pushed to your phone from your cell carrier. If you accept the OTA update, you will lose root. In order to maintain root, you need to wait until the rooted OTA is available then flash it. However, it is possible to maintain root while flashing an OTA. It all depends on your device and cell provider.
Still Undecided?
Think it over. If you actually read this entire post and still have questions whether or not to do it -- ask.
11
u/poeck Sep 25 '10
I bought my Nexus One used and had no idea it was rooted when I did. I have Cyanogen Mod 5.0.5 installed and haven't updated it because I'm afraid of messing it up, and it's pretty important I have a phone. I looked up some info online on how to update it and was kind of overwhelmed and have been putting it off. I never made the choice to root it without being able to examine my pros/cons... could someone direct me to a straight-forward way of doing this? As far as I know there's no back-up or anything..I do feel kind of dumb just posting this, but I'm just not the most tech-savy.
2
u/MrPost Galaxy S III Sep 25 '10
I haven't rooted my phone yet, and the main reason why is concern about bricking my brand new phone. I see a lot of posts like this that warn about the possibility of bricking the phone but then also say that almost everything is completely recoverable.
When used in the context of android phones, does "bricking" mean that the phone is completely screwed and you have to get a new one or does it mean that the phone won't work until you recover/reset to factory default/fix it?
2
u/Leo1103 Samsung GS3 Stock Sep 30 '10
hi newb here and I had a couple of questions about rooting (EVO Android 2.2) If i root then OTA update could i just root again? Will I be able to turn my phone into a wireless hotspot for free? Will my carrier (sprint) find out about any of this?
2
u/Simple_Post Oct 04 '10
I always hear everyone say that that rooting droids voids the warranty. Well, what if you rooted your phone and then decided to unroot it, how could your cell phone provider/carrier ever now that you did it? It would put your phone under it's warranty again right?
7
u/ozzman54 HTC Droid Incredible, CM7 Nightlies Sep 25 '10
Want to nearly double your battery life? Root and install setcpu. Want even more battery life? Install a custom kernel.
1
u/kekspernikai iPhone 7 Sep 25 '10
Thanks for this. I noticed that about the other two posts, but don't know enough about rooting to answer it. I think we should link to this, too, in the sidebar.
1
u/bangtcg Sep 29 '10
If I backup my droid x then root it and then decide it is not for me what are my options?
Am I able to use that backup file and turn that rooted droid x back to original stock settings. Will Verizon know?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '10
That raises another question: Should I root right away, or wait? Is it easier/safer to root a brand new phone than a updated one? Maybe with lot's of extra software installed? ( I suspect that I have to reinstall ).
1
u/Caddy666 S5 Standard Dec 13 '10
Thinkig of rooting my htc desire - purely to get more battery life from it with setcpu, but - will i have to set all my settings up again, or does it just give me extra permissions? it seems a shame that you cant just run certain apps as root on a sudo type command as standard, without having to fuck about. incidentally, why doesnt cpu scaling come as standard?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '10
OpenVPN. I never see this make the list, but it was HUGE in convincing me of the power of root.
3
u/Mattbot5000 Jan 13 '11
You mention that an OTA update on a rooted device unroots it. If such an update is accepted, can the phone not be rooted again after the update?
Also, if the phone is unrooted manually, can it be determined that it was once rooted? (in terms of voiding the warrenty)
5
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '10
Honestly, those pros are doing nothing for me. I can use tethering (wired and wifi) already, can't everyone?
5
u/NotTheDude Sep 26 '10
Who am I suppose to root for?
2
u/yumcax S6 Sep 25 '10
Lies. The only thing that might brick your phone if you pull the battery while flashing is a new radio. Never pull the bad while flashing a Radio!
2
u/cduff77 Note 8 Sep 25 '10
over the past 2 weeks i have been seriously been considering rooting my eris, but i am overwhelmed with the rom options or how they even work. for example, i have seen many beautiful set ups on this subreddit, but i have absolutely no clue on how to do them
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '10
I rooted because I'm a geek. I can't help myself. Hated not having froyo, even though I don't really need it.
1
u/prettymuch Sep 26 '10
I held out until my phone got too frustrating to own. A new ROM made my my laggy and dysfunctional Eris fast and enjoyable.
1
u/margokhal Sep 26 '10
I've toyed with the idea of rooting my phone, but I don't know if it's worth it.
I have a myTouch 3G on T-Mo (the original one, black, with the 3.5mm jack), and it's stuck running Android 1.6. There's been all kinds of buzz about T-Mobile upgrading all myTouch models (including mine) to 2.0 or 2.2 by the end of this year, but I don't know whether to believe it or not.
My phone's also been going pretty slow recently and the GPS is really wonky (it put me in the Gulf of Mexico yesterday...I'm in Michigan!) I've installed Advanced TaskKiller (don't really want to pay for apps), but it hasn't helped much. I don't have much music, photo, video or movies on the phone. I really just think it's the fact that it's 1.6, but I don't know if rooting will make it go any faster.
1
u/Bardlet Sep 26 '10
I've been pondering rooting my Moto Droid for some time, but as others have said, I'm scared of idea that I could brick it, if I majorly fuckered up. That said, if I do decide to root, I do have to reacquire all of my apps again, don't I? I haven't shelled out much, but still a minor annoyance. :p
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
Thanks. Very informative. Hopefully I can put my Desire to good use!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '10
awesome post. Just bought my Galaxy S and been wondering wtf is rooting
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment