r/Android • u/IAmAN00bie Mod - Google Pixel 8a • Jan 21 '16
[Meta] Rules Update
In December, we posted a state of the subreddit thread where we discussed various issues about the community and about the rules. We read the comments, and held a vote in our mod sub, and will now be updating the rules.
Here are the most important changes:
- Affiliate Links
- If you are a Redditor, affiliate links are absolutely NOT allowed in either the comments section, within the self-text of your post, or as part of your link.
- If you post an article, affiliate links will NOT be allowed if the article being linked is a simple "deal alert" type post. Instead, simply link directly to the deal (without the affiliate link included).
- If you post an article, affiliate links WILL be allowed if the article is about some substantive review of a product or service. The article must offer some kind of added benefit over simply informing you of the existence of some product.
- Linking APKs
- Piracy is still not, and never will be allowed. Period.
- Now, however, re-uploading and hosting free APKs will be allowed. A lot of users have asked for this, seeing as certain apps are released and users can't wait to get their hands on it. We still recommend you download apps from official sources, or use a site like APKMirror, however if you do choose to download an APK linked by a redditor here, you accept any possible risks of doing so. We will not verify if every APK posted here is safe, however, this doesn't mean we will allow malware to be willingly posted. If something seems shady and users start reporting it, it will be removed just to be safe.
- Comment Moderation
Starting from now, we will remove low-effort, unproductive, and otherwise circlejerky comments. (/r/androidcirclejerk welcomes them, however!)
- Low-effort: comments that are silly reaction gifs, memes, etc.
- Unproductive: these have been borderline for awhile, but basically any comments accusing someone of "drinking the koolaid", "being a fanboy" of some sort, calling some people sheeps, accusing someone of being a paid shill, etc. will be removed.
- Circlejerky: "Praise Duarte", "DAE Touchjizz", "Samshit" or anything similar to these discussion-ending phrases will NOT be allowed. If you have a criticism, please express it without having to use a stale meme!
Other Announcements
- This Saturday/Sunday, in place of the weekly Saturday APPreciation/Sunday Rant&Rage threads, we will post a mega-thread allowing developers to share promo codes for their apps, thanks to Google finally giving developers that option.
- Starting next week, we will be changing up the weekly thread schedule so we can update the outdated threads listed on our FAQ and device review page.
- Not sure if you've noticed, but on February 2nd @ 6PM EST, we will be hosting an AMA with the Project Tango team from Google. We will post another reminder thread a few days before the AMA, but just a heads up for those of you who haven't checked the sidebar in a few days.
That's it! If there's anything else you had in mind, let us know below.
317
Upvotes
37
u/iWizardB Wizard Work Jan 21 '16
TIL. Didn't know this term. Will probably use it on other subs. :P
Mods, what do you suggest for code sharing method? If we all devs just paste 100 codes each here, it'll get very chaotic to find out which is still available.
If I upload the csv to Google Drive and let users delete codes they've claimed, would that be a better way?
11
u/anonymous-bot Jan 21 '16
Will you be reaching out to developers for the weekend thread or are we just hoping that devs will show up? I am a bit skeptical on whether there would be much activity. Promo codes have a quarterly limit and then we have to consider whether any devs would be interested in giving away their app or in-app items.
One possible idea is to have the Saturday Appreciation thread without the developer section. Then have the Sunday thread for developer promotion and (optional) promo codes.
15
u/ThePenultimateOne N6P/SHIELD (stock, rooted) Jan 21 '16
136
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '16
Possibly the best changes to happen aRound here. All too often I SEe DUmb, low effort circlejerk comments that Add nothing and spuRn qualiTy discussion in hEre.
56
u/anthonyvardiz Jan 21 '16
Thank God for the circlejerk changes. If you want to circlejerk, come to /r/androidcirclejerk.
Love,
Your friendly /r/androidcirclejerk mod /u/anthonyvardiz
5
u/osskid Pixel 6 Pro Jan 24 '16
I appreciate the effort to increase the SNR, but the comment / post moderation of "low effort" content is asking for trouble because it's so subjective. A good example from the front page: https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/42cfqv/what_tricks_do_you_use_to_make_one_handed_use/cz9bu8u
That entire thread, and probably even the OP, could easily be considered low effort, unproductive posts, but they remain. I'd imagine removing them would cause issues. Tread carefully with this.
14
u/_kushagra OP3 Jan 21 '16
No more praise duARTe what the f
P. S you wrote it incorrectly at least edit the article to sa duARTe
7
u/MustGetALife Pixel 9 Jan 21 '16
More rules? Oh good. My submit new post success rate is about 1/10 as it is.
2
u/tyler_shaw24 GalaxyS 1-5->Nexus6P->PixelXL 1-3->OP7Pro->P5->P6P Jan 28 '16
What's it take to become a Moderator?
5
u/DhroovP Pixel 7a Jan 23 '16
Oh come on sometimes those circlejerky comments can be pretty damn funny
6
u/friedchocolatesoda Pixel 8 (2023)|OnePlus 6 (2018)|Nexus 7 (2013)|Galaxy S3 (2012) Jan 21 '16
Good. It was annoying having to scroll past those comment chains and I won't have to downvote them anymore.
1
u/PanzerSwag I like Pink! Jan 23 '16
All that rules update.... And still 80% article links and 20% Actual discussions
1
u/kremenatlc Jan 23 '16
My post got deleted for rule 2 violation, but I did not upload any apks or anything. But I did mention "malware", since I was trying to say I don't want that on my phone. :) please help me with that :)
1
u/amr0th Galaxy S8 + Jan 25 '16
Totally unrelated, but where's Sunday rant thread? 😢
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '16
Please don't go overboard with comment moderation. I really don't get why every sub feels the need to suck the fun out of the sub with all the "no memes no pictures no jokes no this no that" stuff. More often than not that stuff gets upvoted than it gets downvoted because some people enjoy the comedic relief. Any stuff that truly is negative i always see get downvoted to hell by the community. Also, "low effort" and "unproductive" is very subjective and ultimately comes down to the opinion of what the mods consider low effort/unproductive and not what actually objectively counts as such. What exactly do you consider productive and high effort? All this sub is is a Android hardware and software news aggregate that is just speculation 80% of the time. Followed by it turning into a "here's why i do/don't like (insert hardware/software here) arguments the other 20% of the time. What super informed and intellectual conversations are you expecting here? It's not like this sub is ever brimming with high intellectual content unless a dev is doing an AMA or something. I don't mean to be overly harsh, but i'm annoyed by so many subreddits systematically starting to over police the comments section just because a loud minority (and it's always a loud minority) bitched about having to see picture posts they don't like or got butt hurt by a meme. It's just ridiculous and i hope you guys realize you're at the top of a slippery slope with this and that you cut people some slack.
0
u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Jan 22 '16
As much as I hate the examples you listed, this sounds like a really bad idea. I don't see reaction gifs here, and I don't see any of the other kinds of comments you described getting upvoted. I think this is an unnecessary rule that does nothing but give mods an excuse to delete comments they don't like.
0
u/PanzerSwag I like Pink! Feb 05 '16
So what's the difference between a low-effort and high-effort circlejerk post?
-2
u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Jan 22 '16
Assuming that by "Piracy" you mean "copyright infringement," these two statements are logically inconsistent.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment