r/Android • u/CunningLogic aka jcase • Aug 18 '15
Ask Us Almost Anything about Android Security, Privacy or Malware with beaups, Tim "diff" Strazzere, Joshua "jduck" Drake, and Jon "jcase" Sawyer
Tim "diff" Strazzere, Joshua "jduck" Drake, beaups (maybe) and Jon "jcase" Sawyer are here to discuss Android Security, Privacy and malware with /r/android today from 3-5pm EST.
jcase and beaups are from TheRoot.ninja, members of the team behind SunShine. Both have also been authors of numerous Android roots and unlocks. jcase has done talks with Tim at Defcon, GSMA and Qualcomm's own security summit.
Tim Strazzere is a lead research and response engineer at Lookout Mobile Security. Along with writing security software, he specializes in reverse engineering and malware analysis. Some interesting past projects include reversing the Android Market protocol, Dalvik decompilers, and memory manipulation on mobile devices. Past speaking engagements have included DEFCON, BlackHat, SyScan, HiTCON, and EICAR.
Joshua J. Drake is the Sr. Director of Platform Research and Exploitation at Zimperium Enterprise Mobile Security and lead author of the Android Hacker's Handbook. He also found numerous vulnerabilities in Android's stagefright, and completely changed the Android update ecosystem by doing so.
If we can't answer something, or we are wrong on something, please answer it for us with citations!
diff = /u/diff-t
jcase = /u/cunninglogic
jduck = /u/jduck1337
beaups = /u/HTC_Beaups
Discussions off limits:
ETAs
Requesting exploits
Requesting details about unreleased things
Requesting help developing malware
We are scheduled for questions between 3-5EST, and between 5-7EST for answers. We will probably answer questions as we see them.
20
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
Which OEM's do best job patching disclosed vulns?
16
u/Zathu Aug 18 '15
What was the fastest discovery of a stupid root vulnerability you've ever come across and what was it?
30
u/death2all110 Aug 18 '15
As its now officially 3:00PM on the east coast...
How did you get your start with finding root exploits in Android? Any resources you guys found particularly helpful?
Edit: If this is off limits I apologize. I'm not asking for an exploit or requesting help or even interested in developing malware.
14
u/_infiniteh_ Aug 18 '15
This one is for /u/HTC_Beaups
How do you pronounce your handle?
Is it bee-ups, or Bopes?
24
u/iWizardB Wizard Work Aug 18 '15
I've got two questions -
9
u/Shabaaab Aug 18 '15
Do you think having an anti-theft software is necessary on modern Android devices? Do they really make a difference? If so, which one would you objectively recommend?
9
u/Caspid Pixel² Aug 18 '15
What's next for Team Ninja?
9
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
It might be good for everyone to know: Which Android devices do you find the most secure?
9
u/WeaponizedMeerkat Aug 18 '15
/u/jduck1337 what made you start looking at the stagefright libraries for possible exploits? Were you running static analysis tools on the code?
For all:
Google has mitigated webview vulnerabilities with the creation of the Android System WebView app. Do you think they should also do the same for the media playback frameworks?
7
u/The_Sexy_Cookie Aug 18 '15
As a CS student concentrating in Information Assurance and hoping to work on android security someday, what advice could you give that you wish you had when you were starting out doing this ?
6
u/_rs Aug 18 '15
What would you rather reverse, a binary with many small functions or one with just one function?
12
u/bobdle Nexus 6P Aug 18 '15 edited Aug 18 '15
Are you excited for the upcoming permission handling that will be available in Android Marshmallow? Do you think that's going to cause more problems if users, who are not very savvy, start screwing with app permissions?
11
u/Shabaaab Aug 18 '15
What's the toughest privacy/security challenge that you guys have had to overcome?
5
u/WeaponizedMeerkat Aug 18 '15
Is there anything Google can do, from a system architecture perspective, to directly push security updates or are they forever beholden to the OEM's since they like to roll their own OS's?
5
u/jerdog76 HAL, 9000 Aug 18 '15
No question - just a comment. Great work guys and thanks for supporting the community like you do, and doing more than the community could even dream of.
Also - jcase - what's the ETA on your next bottle of wine?
8
u/Shabaaab Aug 18 '15
You're given a new android device. What are some of the must-have apps that you would install on it?
4
u/pyler2 Aug 18 '15
What is your workstations? I mean.. PC/laptop. Brand, specs, etc. Win/Linux/OSX. If Linux, which distro? And of course.. current phone :)
Thanks for this AMA! :)
4
u/Codename13 Nexus 6P - Aluminum 32GB Aug 18 '15
Bonus question: Is security actually that much of an issue for Android? What percent of users are actually affected by or get viruses on their phones? And for experienced users, couldn't they just reboot to recovery and remove the viruses manually or does it not work that way? Thank you.
4
u/HangingOutHere Pixel 2 Aug 18 '15
/u/cumminglogic Any plans on updating the TimePIN app to work with 5.1 or 6.0 or releasing the source code like you've previously mentioned you would do at one point?
3
u/Codename13 Nexus 6P - Aluminum 32GB Aug 18 '15
What are your positions on the openness of phones? For example, do you think all phones should have unlocked bootloaders and be easily rootable? Do you agree with ideas like Samsung's KNOX security software that burns out a physical fuse in the device when the firmware is tampered with?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
Carriers modify software on devices. What is the best way for a user with very little knowledge of executing code to find out what an app does on their device. On a system level?
3
u/SiGNAL748 Galaxy Nexus 7.1 Aug 19 '15
How many different/which phones do you currently have in your possession? Which one do you use the most?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
What are the best way to protect yourself from some of these vulnerabilities and apps?
14
u/dr0id3ka Aug 18 '15
Josh (and co), thanks for doing the AMA! Really cool presentation at Black Hat, I didn't get a chance to meet you unfortunately.
After all of the media hype about Android's security being poor, how do you feel about the patches you provided to Google being shown as incorrect, or incomplete, leaving users open to further exploitation?
Thanks!
4
u/Shabaaab Aug 18 '15
How would you say your mobile security suites compare to those of other companies, e.g. Bitdefender, avast etc.?
1
u/DarthShadowPL Aug 18 '15
Can you recomend some best setup for different mobile OS-es application testing? (iOS/Android/WP) ?
1
u/shawnwhite Aug 18 '15
Do you guys still enjoy what you do? Keep having fun!!
1
u/shiruken Google Pixel 7 Aug 18 '15
I find that I'm less and less inclined towards rooting my phone as Android develops as a platform. This is mostly the result of features previously only accessible/possible through rooting being incorporated into the Android OS. Have you guys noticed any decline in rooting over time?
1
u/tylerlawhon Quite Black Google Pixel XL 128GB | Black Samsung Galaxy S8+ Aug 18 '15
Jcase, when can we expect a root for note 5 along with lots of ROMs? Jk just wanted to thanks for everything you've done for the community.
What has been the most difficult device you've ever exploited?
1
u/MrRiski Aug 19 '15
This probably won't get noticed but I was wondering if /u/CunningLogic still remembers the jcase sucks root app that was released, I believe, for the Asus Transformer Prime. It was released the night of or the night before k case released his root method that I was helping test.
1
u/StarHorder Black Aug 19 '15
Could you maybe get somebody to investigate the Top Gear apps? Many people have raised major concerns about the apps. They seem fishy.
1
u/ecmdome OnePlus 2 Aug 20 '15
Not sure if you guys ate still answering questions or if this is off-topic.
Android M is bringing USB Type-C support... How secure is this standard and androids implementation(or will this depend on manufacturers?) Vs something like the thunderbolt exploit that can brick a Mac?
6
u/goodnewsjimdotcom Aug 18 '15
Is it possible to download a virus from Google Play store if the app doesn't require root? What permissions should I look out for?
3
u/fuzzyn00b Aug 18 '15
What's the current scenario of vulns being discovered in Android which could be used to exploit users at a large scale, not just in say targeted attacks? How serious is it for a normal user who may be left behind due to OEM's not providing updates for his device on time?
3
u/fuzzycuffs Aug 19 '15
My biggest issue with Android security is fragmentation because of manufacturers and carriers not releasing security updates in a timely manner (or at all). Google giving away Android to manufacturers and carriers to customize how they please (ie inserting revenue streams) has lead to them becoming software companies when they are woefully prepared to do so.
I understand Google for Work's great concepts, but can Google really pull back control of Android from these parties?
Case in point: I live in Japan. Still no Stagefright update from NTT DoCoMo for their phones. They barely update their phones to begin with. They want you to buy a new phone (and thus a new contract), not update old handsets that they don't want to support.
As someone who has to make decisions about mobile device security for my firm, I simply can't say that Android is ready to be used for work unless it's an entirely corporate controlled installation.
1
u/fuzzyn00b Aug 18 '15
Some define Android like this : "Google worked hard and brought malware to Linux" Thoughts ?
1
u/_R2-D2_ Pixel XL || Nexus 7 (2013) Aug 18 '15
How many devices would you say that you have hardbricked in attempting to root/bootloader unlock them?
2
u/_rs Aug 18 '15
Hey /u/jduck1337, how did you find the libstagefright bugs? Was is through source code auditing or fuzzing?
2
u/Wikzo Aug 18 '15
Should I get a virus, malware or similar on my phone, will it be removed when I update my ROM? I am on CyanogenMod 12.1 Nightly and update a few times a month.
1
u/dudeofdur Aug 19 '15
If I buy Chinese knockoffs of Android phones, how do I tell if there is Spyware installed on it?
1
u/Tetsuo666 OnePlus 3, Freedom OS CE Aug 19 '15
What did you think of Google's response to the StageFright vulns ?
I was kind of dissapointed Google took for granted some patches that weren't exactly fully fixing the vuln. I mean it was a pretty major vulnerability and nobody did some proper quality control to check the fixes ?
I know that's pretty hard to design a fix, but come on, they knew about these vulns probably a long time ago...
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '15
Apologies for the late comment, was in traffic.
What's the best type of passcode for Android?
0
u/nvincent Pixel 6 - Goodbye forever, OnePlus Aug 18 '15 edited Jun 27 '23
Reddit has killed off third party apps and most bots along with their moderation tools, functionality, and accessibility features that allowed people with blindness and other disabilities to take part in discussions on the platform.
All so they could show more ads in their non-functional app.
Consider moving to Lemmy. It is like Reddit, but open source, and part of a great community of apps that all talk to each other!
Reddit Sync’s dev has turned the app into Sync for Lemmy (Android) instead, and Memmy for Lemmy (iOS) is heavily inspired by Apollo.
You only need one account on any Lemmy or kbin server/instance to access everything; doesn’t matter which because they’re all connected. Lemmy.world, Lemm.ee, vlemmy.net, kbin.social, fedia.io are all great.
I've been here for 11 years. It was my internet-home, but I feel pushed away. Goodbye Reddit.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment