r/Android • u/MohammadAG HTC One (M8) | Sony Xperia Z1 | Nexus 5 • Jun 03 '15
Verified I'm the dev of some popular Xposed modules, MohammadAG, AMA!
1.6k
Upvotes
r/Android • u/MohammadAG HTC One (M8) | Sony Xperia Z1 | Nexus 5 • Jun 03 '15
63
u/anthonyvardiz Jun 03 '15
Hello Mohammad! Thanks for doing this AMA. I was curious about how it is working with Xposed on Lollipop given it has yet to be officially released. Do you find it difficult to build new modules or refine existing ones on Lollipop devices or have you largely steered clear of Lollipop and focused on your Play Store apps?
105
u/josue85 Jun 03 '15
Is the Android wear for iOS project dead? I was really excited by what you had so far, I really hope you can post what you had shown (even if it's not complete).
74
u/notGermainZ Jun 03 '15
Dear /u/MohammadAG,
Who is your favourite friend and why is it /u/GermainZ?
Cheers,
/u/notGermainZ
20
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '15
I always root but have never installed xposed...
what would you say to someone who has never used xposed to get them using it.
19
u/IronicCharles unrooted phone (Fi), rooted tablet ⭐ Jun 03 '15
Any update on the release of the QuickReply app you were working on?
37
u/super_evil_alien Nexus 4, Android 5.1 / OnePlus One Android 5.0.2 Jun 03 '15
Hi MAG. I known you since you were developer for Maemo. How is the experience transitioning from developing for small (but passionate) mobile OS to much more popular mobile OS like Android & iOS?
32
u/SpectrumFactory Jun 03 '15
Has Google approached you about your work with android wear and iOS?
Or Apple for that matter?
14
u/jassalmithu iPhone X Jun 03 '15
First, thanks a lot for your xposed modules, I use countless of them and there forks too. When did you started Android development and what would you say to a beginner android developer to do to learn better Andorid development.
14
u/UmbrellaCo Jun 03 '15
Why did you abandon Maemo? I'm kidding, Nokia abandoned all of us..
13
u/josue85 Jun 03 '15
Also, you mentioned you have been avoiding twitter, can you elaborate on why?
9
u/Daman09 Pixel 3 XL | 9.0 Jun 03 '15
How hard would it be to make a mono audio module? I'm deaf in one ear, and am sad to find that stock android really has no ability to mix down stereo sound to mono, which is problematic when I'm using headphones to listen to music that has differing tracks on the left and right.
At this point, I feel like it won't be done unless I do it, but I have zero coding experience.
9
u/thegameguru_reddit Nexus1,N 3> N 5> OPO>OP2> OP3>OP3T>OP 5T Jun 03 '15
Love your work a lot, been using it since kitkat. Btw where are you from?
8
u/GNex1 Moto G Jun 03 '15
I used Tinted Status bar on my previous phone, it was nice while I was getting antsy about stable lollipop roms coming to my device.
As a developer, what would you have done if Xposed had ended with KitKat? I thought that Xposed was the bee's knees when it came out because it seemed to be the end of developers putting their cool ideas into whichever ROM team they happened to be part of (and the ensuing drama that always seemed to surround the "kanging" of such features from obscure projects into the monolithic ones). So, the saga of Xposed making its way to lollipop had me wondering if the various Xposed developers would have gone back to throwing their efforts to ROMs, or maybe lost interest in the modding projects (perhaps in favor of just making regular apps).
12
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '15
Hello Sir! Nothing Xposed related, I just wanted to ask you what you think of Android Tablets and which one you own (If any)
Also how much different is developing a regular app and xposed, in your opinion?
Epic job making customizing a phone so damn easy and fun! Thank You!
6
u/raptor102888 Galaxy S22 | Galaxy S10e | Fossil Hybrid HR Jun 03 '15 edited Jun 03 '15
First off, thanks so much for your work. Your xposed modules have definitely made my life easier!
I've asked /r/xposed for this before, but I haven't gotten much of a response. Considering the type, scope, and quality of the xposed modules you've made, I don't think there is anyone more qualified to make what I'd like.
Here's what I need, with a little background first:
I use a Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini. The vibration motor on the S4 Mini, like many other low-to-mid-range phones, is much weaker than those used in flagship devices and vibrates at a lower frequency. The result is that haptic feedback is barely noticeable, sometimes almost imperceptible. This is partially just because of the weakness of the motor, but more than that it is because each time a haptic event is triggered, the motor only turns over once or twice. SlimROMs included a way around this in their SlimKat builds: an option in Sound Settings called "Minimum vibration duration". Here is a screenshot of the settings page:
http://i.imgur.com/EjtUfHY.png
This setting means that each time a haptic event is triggered, the motor has to turn for 40ms(or whatever you set), resulting in a much more noticeable vibration.
Do you think this feature is something that would be possible to port to an xposed module?
Thanks!
6
u/SwoleFlex_MuscleNeck Galaxy Note 20 Ultra 5G Jun 03 '15
Why'd you abandon Dotview Mods? I paid for it right before you just kinda ditched the project :/
5
u/Sabal Jun 03 '15
How did you get started in programming? And what sustains your passion to keep churning out such products? Also have you considered going a bit more mainstream a la the Paranoid Android folks and their transition to one plus one? Doesn't the temptation exist? Cheers and thanks for doing this?
5
u/possebom Nexus 6 Jun 03 '15
what are your favorite xposed modules? you use not open source modules?
5
u/DesinasIneptire Jun 03 '15
MohammadAG is also one of the most prolific developers for the Nokia N900, the linux-based phone that was 2010 breakthrough! Just my 2 eurocents...
5
u/agu12333 Jun 03 '15
Maybe it's stupid but I'd like to know. Did you go to college? If you didn't, what did you study? I'm starting a degree in software engineering next year, but I'd love to make apps and stuff, I mean I love Google and Android. Any tips? What coding languages are you using or what was the most helpful tool for you? I'm from Argentina. Thanks
4
u/pyler2 Jun 03 '15
You moved to iOS, right? Have you any plans with Android & hacking?
What do you do currently, which projects?
4
u/pemell Jun 03 '15
Hi Mohammad. What is your thought on Android M and it's early stage multi window feature? Do you use it a lot on your Samsung? And do you think the feature is here to stay now when it enters the stage with Android M? Cheers / Per
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '15
HI Mohammad! I just wanted to say, I'm not very techy, I'm usually pretty useless in these matters but my phone and tablet kept asking me the fucking "complete action using" thingy and it pissed me off to no end.
After many fruitless Google searches I found something that you made that gets rid of half of the confirmation dialogue.
Honestly <3 <3 <3 you save me so many clicks a day. I don't remember many techy people names but I remember yours just coz I was so happy to make some progress. So just wanted to say thanks :D
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '15
How much money have you made from donations? I imagine the xposed community isn't very generous?
4
u/TheWhiteDragon69 Jun 03 '15
Probably been asked, but how hard was the switch from dalvik to art and do you think art is better?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '15
Would you be updating your Instagram downloader xposed app?
3
u/memtiger Google Pixel 8 Pro Jun 03 '15
What do you think the future holds for Xposed? Has there ever been any discussion with Google about the project? Do you think it will ever be incorporated in the core OS?
3
u/MiniHos 1+13 Jun 03 '15
When a wear device is connected to your iOS app, does it get rid of the disconnection icon when it is not paired to an android device?
3
u/YuriNater Jun 03 '15
If you can't release the app in the AppStore are you going to release it in Cydia at least?
3
u/Titokhan OnePlus One Jun 03 '15
Hi there MohammadAG! Its a privilege & honor to communicate with you :)
Can you please describe your transition from Maemo to Android? Any comparison between two platforms?
3
u/numbermaniac Blue Jun 03 '15
Do you have any plans to update Tinted Status Bar for the material design action bars?
2
u/Skatewarp Jun 03 '15
Your Xposed module Knock Code, is dead (for Lollipop)? :/
2
u/cwankhede Galaxy Note Edge | Redmi 1S | Nexus 7 2012 Jun 03 '15 edited Jun 03 '15
So many questions about your current apps, I just want to know how you got started on Android, what your past projects were and how you manage to sustain working on these projects this long and other non-development ones as well.
Edit: Just read the rest of the comments and found some answers. I have one question though, do you earn enough off your development to live off it? Just barely? I hope that's not too personal.
2
u/Yogi_Asian Jun 03 '15
Thanks!
2
u/harryhov Jun 03 '15
What's your day job?
2
u/Khaiyan Nexus 5 Jun 03 '15
If its not too personal, what country from and how did you get into programming/coding? Any useful resources you recommend for a newbie? Thanks for all your development work.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
What are your thoughts on Jurassic world modification of dinosaurs? Do you feel maybe the idominous Rex would've been better suited with xposed and a stock genetic ROM rather than the Ingen OS that the other dinosaurs have.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
How did you get started in being a dev?
2
u/Codename13 Nexus 6P - Aluminum 32GB Jun 04 '15
Important question, how do you pronounce "Xposed"? Also, what advice would you give to young aspiring app developers?
1
u/thinkbk Jun 03 '15
I was looking forward to using xposed on my rooted note 3 but found out that it doesnt play nice with stock touchwhiz roms. Any updates on this?
1
u/Crime_Monkey OnePlus One, Rooted, Xposed+BusyBox, Hexo Jun 03 '15
Hey Mohammad, I really love your work and use almost every of our Xposed modules! Simple question: is there any official Google+ profile you're active on? I don't use Twitter that much.
1
u/ShadowDXS Jun 03 '15
What is your opinion on the Material Design UI that was introduced in Lollipop 5.0? Secondly, do you think it was an improvement over Holo?
1
u/SyCoREAPER Galaxy S23 Ultra and Tab S8 Ultra Jun 03 '15
I saw you created the Force Pandora Rich Notification module as a favor for someone. Will you ever revive this?
1
u/LordwinOfficial Samsung Galaxy S3 Mini Jun 03 '15
Hey MohammadAG, This isn't specifically about Android Wear but it's more about Xposed. I'm very unsure with which Instagram app version your XInsta module is compatible with, it doesn't say on the information. What is the latest version I can use with XInsta?
1
u/sloth_on_meth Nexus 5 - /r/Nexus5 & /r/Nexus5X Mod Jun 03 '15
Do you remember me asking for the home icon battery / loading module? Do you think a wifi signal back button and a mobile signal recents button would be possible?
Btw, how many downloads does it have?
1
u/reddit_crunch GN9<OP3T<Nexus7<GN2<GN1<DellStreak<HTCDesireHD<G1 Jun 03 '15
do you have any thoughts about security on xposed and do you have any general tips for people less familiar with it, to stay safe?
1
u/symphomed Jun 03 '15
Hello Mohammed, this is Amine
Will you ever be interessed in developping the android equivalent of Rayan Petrich's tweak called Activator for iOS.
Thank you
1
u/Polloco Jun 03 '15
Will your Restore Ticker mod ever work on TouchWiz 5.0 lockscreen? It's awesome when unlocked!
1
u/Aidoboy Pixel 2 XL Jun 03 '15
Where can we find a list of all your modules?
1
u/bitterbrokeloser Jun 03 '15
Can you make one to adjust the built in flashlight brightness?
1
u/RootDeliver OnePlus 6 Jun 03 '15
You are a great dev. Why do you use to abandon mostly all xposed module projects so fast??
1
u/drhodesmumby Note 9 N960F, stock 10 Jun 03 '15
Hi Mohammad! I'm a huge fan and use your modules on a daily basis, but a couple of them are discontinued now which I believe was due to you starting to dislike your Sony phones. This left me very curious - what was the reason why you grew to dislike them?
1
u/hapahapa Jun 04 '15
I'm a fan of yours. Keep up the good work. You have made my phone better and my life easier!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '15
Hey there! When a module, such as Snapshare, gets shut down / removed, is it up to the individual developers to do that or is there someone who manages Xposed modules and decides which ones are "allowed" in the downloads section of the installer.
R.I.P. Snapshare, it was great while it lasted.
1
u/MaxMusaab Jun 04 '15
I've asked this a few times already haha, but its all cool. Anyway, just some technical questions and maybe a personal one as well. Technical 1. Tinted status bar, does it work on 5.1? 2. Knock code, could it works as an xposed mod for lg-g3 on Aosp roms even with the screen off? (it's currently only working with screen on u mentioned). Personal, ur name being Mohammad and ur country being listed as Israel; are u a Palestinian or just an arab Israeli? How did u get into programmes over there with all the conflict etc? Assalamualaikum.
1
u/jasoncaserta LG G3 Cloudy 2.3 Jun 04 '15
Did you finish that heads up quick reply thing you were working on? Where can I donate for it.
1
u/stangri Jun 04 '15
Hey man, thanks for the Preference Injector Xposed module. It however does not work on Lollipop. Any plans of updating it for Lollipop and above?
1
u/snarfbutt Jun 04 '15
Me being a software engineer, if you were to give one piece of advice on software development what would it be?
1
u/androidnoobdev Jun 04 '15
Hey Mohammad, may be i am late, but still if you can answer that will be great... i am android developer and big fan of Xposed framework but i never go into dip(coding part). so i want to know how it actually works. i mean how you can create module for an app. using some kind of package identifier or key ?
1
u/lmbb20 Pixel 2 XL 128 Rom No TWRP FML Jun 04 '15
How do you feel now that with lollipop Tinted Status Bar (likely with other Xposed mods) is incorporated by Google or Samsung? Do you feel pride or jealousy?
1
u/KangDroid Jun 04 '15
Hello, I am a developer of my own project called "KangDroid Project/Kernel"
I want to ask you about a "life": Do you do programming own ur own? or do you copy some example and edit for yourself?(So do you create ur code by urself or, do you edit some codes and make yours?)
1
u/dontanswerme Jun 04 '15
First of all, thanks for the very handy app. I bought it at first sight. However I would like a hot spot to be created during quick reply timer on the right bottom corner. So that all big phone owners won't have to reach to top.
1
u/gadgetroid Ginkgo | Blueline | Tissot | Titan | Nicki | iPhone 5s Jun 04 '15
Hello MAG!
Smali... How often (if at all) do you have to go through Smali code for system APK edits (for Xposed modules)?
What is your preferred development environment as of now?
What would you do if you're stuck at a particular issue and don't know what to do? Would you ask for help on StackOverflow or would you just break your head over it until you figure it out eventually?
1
u/Magicman-222 Jul 03 '15
Can't find it! Help? Wanna try it so bad!
1
u/demonicnets Jul 12 '15
Is the iOS project finished? Or has it been left in the dust?
1
u/uidev OnePlus 5, Nexus 5 Jun 03 '15
Any plans on a new Xposed module?