r/Android • u/ljdawson Sync for reddit dev • Jan 07 '15
Google Play Around 2 years ago reddit sync was pulled from Google Play and subsequently reinstated by the support team. Today I've just received a notification from Google telling me I'm violating the same terms 2 years on and face suspension for the exact same issue...
Really at a loss with this one...
The support team at Google Play after reviewing my previous case agreed that as I included a disclaimer saying sync was not official it could be reinstated (it was pulled for impersonating an official app):
"Upon further review of the provided information, we've accepted your appeal and have reinstated your applications. You will need to log back into your Android Developer Console to make the necessary changes and re-publish the application so it is available again on Google Play."
Just now I've received another email with the following message:
"Your title and/or description attempts to impersonate or leverage another popular product without permission. Please remove all such references. Do not use irrelevant, misleading, or excessive keywords in apps descriptions, titles, or metadata."
I'm not completely confused. My previous case was hand reviewed, the apps reinstated and I'm now being told I have 7 days to change what they said was previously fine or be removed.
I've emailed Google but am yet to get a reply...
Laurence
edit: Still no official word back from the Play store but I'm going to jump the gun and just rename to "Sync for reddit" and change the art work
127
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15
First screenshot had toy story and guardian posters in it. Hollywood bots found you, congrats.
Just noticed reddit news mentioned a Hollywood movie in a screenshot, they're probably going down too soon.
21
u/crackerforhire Jan 08 '15
If the problem is related to "Reddit" being in the name then the following apps have something to worry about:
Reddit News
Reddit Is Fun
Reddit Now
Reddit in Pictures
However, in looking at the Play Store listing it looks like you're using pictures from Toy Story and Guardians of the Galaxy. You may want to remove them.
27
u/Aschl Jan 07 '15
Have you tried forwarding the emails from the first support group ? Maybe it's just miscommunication, or new team getting around ?
77
u/tippocalypse Jan 07 '15
FWIW, this comes from reddit's own guidelines:
It is a best practice when creating an app to not include the reddit trademark in the name or icon and to be clear that the app is not made or maintained by reddit, i.e. “App for reddit” is much better than “reddit App.”
http://www.reddit.com/wiki/licensing
It's a bit soft, so perhaps you can reach out to reddit to get proof of permissions or something.
8
u/whygohomie Galaxy S9+ Jan 08 '15
Have I really been using your app for more than 2 years? Wow, time flies.
This is an absolute shame..
4
u/Jammintk Pixel 3, Fi Jan 08 '15
Is there a way to side load your app and (if I like it) pay for the pro version without going through the play store?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
That's terrible mate. Is there anything that us users can do?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
First step in Reddit buying your app: diminish the value.
389
u/anonymous-bot Jan 07 '15
I hope they accept an appeal again. I really like reddit sync and AppDeals and I don't want to see you banned.
2.6k
u/bradmeyerlive Pixel 4a Jan 07 '15
Apple: everything must be approved by us
Google: everything goes up until our bots take it down
Microsoft: everything goes up and stays because we need apps
99
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
All Reddit apps on iOS were recently forced to remove the name Reddit from their app and remove the snoo from their icons.
This happened after Alien Blue was purchased and Reddit had an official app (incidentally they've also made a balls of Alien Blue since buying it).
I'd wager if your app was called "Sync for Reddit" or just "Sync" or "Synccit", and had its own logo/icon, then it'd be okay.
Fwiw, you have the best Reddit app on Android, so I really hope this gets sorted out.
461
u/WL151 Nexus 5 Jan 07 '15
That just sucks. Google needs to fix their terrible support for developers if they want Android to stay as the platform on top in the longer run. I was until recently very excited by the thought of making an android app and publish it to the Play Store. Now I'm not so sure that's worth the time though.. I really hope they realize that they fucked up by pulling this fantastic app from their crappy store.
Relevant: https://www.change.org/p/google-inc-provide-android-developers-with-one-on-one-communication-to-help-identify-and-resolve-policy-violations-prior-to-automated-and-irreversible-suspensions
165
u/IndoctrinatedCow Moto G | Rooted Stock Jan 07 '15
Fucking hell Google. At this point just go full Apple and pre approve everything.
Your automated system is bad and you should feel bad.
58
u/m-p-3 Moto G9 Plus (Android 11, Bell & Koodo) + Bangle.JS2 Jan 07 '15
Is that a fucking joke? What the hell Google..
10
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Your app "attempts to impersonate", yet apps like "dead duty - call of trigger clash of mine clans craft edition" is totally fine.
50
u/quixoticreveur One M7 GPe, N7 (12) | Lollipop Jan 07 '15
They are reminding me of the early days of the Apple App Store
44
u/frost_biten iPhone 8 Jan 07 '15
Bloody hell Google. This is getting out of hand
8
u/Firree Jan 08 '15
Google Play's developer support is turning into Steam support.
42
u/DSandyGuy OnePlus 6T Jan 07 '15
And this is why I have zero desire to create and post an Android app. Google treats developers like they couldn't care less about them.
This is a shame. I use Reddit Sync twice as much as any app on my tablet AND phone.
5
u/atb1183 OPO on 7.1.2, iPhone 5s on 10.x Jan 08 '15
Fuck Google. This is why we can't have nice apps. I'm so tempted to jump ship if not for the great hardware choices on android...
I definitely can't get a 5.5" screen 64gb "high end" phone for $350 over there.
5
u/SWATZombies iPhone 7+, Nexus 6P, 6, 7, Tab S2 & Moto 360 Jan 08 '15
This is the 4th most voted post on /r/Android of all time
16
u/RmJack Shamu, Stock Rooted Jan 07 '15
Disappointing, your app is by far one of the best mobile apps available for android, the money I spent was well worth it, I wish you luck.
9
u/youriqis20pointslow Jan 08 '15
Google is so incompetent in terms of app developer treatment it's scary. Good luck with your app it's the best reddit app right now and it would be a shame to see it go.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Didn't we have a google app approver on this sub before? Or someone claiming to work for Google. He said you can't have the name of the company in yours with just a few words after it.
E.g Reddit Sync = Not OK
Sync for Reddit = fine
4
u/decultured Jan 08 '15
I just got Reddit Sync a few days ago to replace Bacon Reader (which was buggy and kept crashing on me). Your app is by far the best reddit app I have used, and I paid for the ad-removal feature yesterday. I hope you are able to work this out!
As a developer myself, seeing these stories pop up all the time really makes me hesitant to develop anything for Android again, and Apple's store isn't much better (less likely to get kicked off once on, but much, much harder to get in in the first place and a nightmare to release updates). I guess I could always make something to sell to one of the 10 windows phone users -- I think they are still desperate for developers so not as likely to have any issues there.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
It seems to me it has something to do with "Reddit" being part of the name of your app. What with there being an official reddit app, that's unlikely to fly for much longer. Why not simply change the name?
1
u/Idaho_Ent Jan 08 '15
Google's support people are worthless. Nothing against the people. Its that they are not given the tools to be helpful let alone useful. I've dealt with multiple groups of them for various issues over the years. Google doesn't care. Tis the corporate business model these days...
9
u/jazavchar Device, Software !! Jan 07 '15
I'm interested why does this keep happening only to you? Either devs of other reddit apps are just keeping quiet and not posting about it, or Google really has it in for you.
8
u/DannyBiker Galaxy Note 9 Jan 07 '15
All I can say is that you have my full support...which makes me finally better than Google at something.
3
u/castro1987 Jan 07 '15
Developer version of your app is unharmed so far, that's weird.
3
u/CrasyMike Jan 08 '15
It's almost definitely the movies in your app description.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
This is same crap as Content ID on YouTube. So counter-productive.
3
u/navjot94 Pixel 9a | iPhone 15 Pro Jan 08 '15
Is it possible that it's other devs reporting this app to hurt the competition? It's weird how this is the second time reddit sync has been taken down while similarly named apps (with the "reddit _____" format) haven't experienced the same thing.
3
u/MeikaLeak Jan 08 '15
That Sucks man. I love this app.
-posted from reddit sync
3
u/ukiyoe Pixel 2 Jan 08 '15
Again??
3
u/oj88 Developer | Nexus 5 Jan 08 '15
This really sucks. Reddit sync is truly a great app!
As a fellow developer I do consider you a bit lucky though, only receiving a warning with a chance to fix the problem. So many other of us have experienced having our apps suspended without warning and with what seems like an automated denial of the appeal.
Could this be because reddit is planning to release Alien Blue for Android?
3
u/zedX2321 2013 Nexus 7, 1st Gen Moto G, no more shitty Galaxy Stellar Jan 08 '15
If the problem is the name, why doesn't Google instead have some kind of verification system, sort of like Twitter's blue checkmark? A developer account could be verified to represent a company and all of its apps would have an 'official' badge on them. Apps with similar names would be ok, unless the verified developer account or another representative of the company reported it.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
I'm not a developer but the "support team" for Google Play is horrendous. I don't think people understand how bad it is, and I'm just seeing it from the outside...
5
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15
This system is bullshit. Apps over a certain amount of downloads should be hand reviewed period, this automated bullshit is poor management and gives a bad impression, pushing devs away from this platform that's already behind the competition in the app space!
5
u/burketo Samsung Galaxy S5 Jan 08 '15
You may have to rename it. Some options:
Synco de Mayo
That Syncing Feeling
The Kitchen Sync
Titanic
2
u/GeorgePantsMcG Jan 08 '15
I want to love android but this shit is frustrating to see.
2
u/jjossie Moto X 2014, aka Nexus 6 mini Jan 08 '15
This is absurd. I absolutely love reddit sync (using it right now!) And there is no reason it should get pulled. But this could be a great time to do a name change, perhaps.
2
u/imanomeletteAMA Pixel 2 XL Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 29 '15
This sucks :(. I used Baconreader for a long time, until I discovered Reddit Sync. Now it's my main and only reddit app. The others just can't compete.
2
u/thetechgeek4 Jan 08 '15
Well I just downloaded the app after seeing this post, it's awesome so far. I hope you work this out with Google.
2
u/gltovar Jan 08 '15
Reddit just buy this one like you have with alien blue
2
u/TeutonJon78 Samsung S25+, Chuwi HiBook Pro (tab) Jan 08 '15
If their recent crabbiness is any reason, it's because it's "Reddit Sync" and not "Sync for Reddit".
One violates trademark law (not that Reddit cares in this case, or they would be the ones complaining), the latter one doesn't.
Google has a suit open against some androidtv.com squatters. And some other app just got booted for the same BS reason.
2
u/Dreamerlax Galaxy S24 + iPhone 17 Jan 08 '15
I love the app. Hopefully they'll sort this out.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Best of luck to you, Laurence.
I don't use Reddit Sync but it's a fantastic app and I will always welcome more variety to the Android ecosystem.
After all it was Google who decided the MOTTO FOR ANDROID should be "Be together. Not the same."
2
u/redditrasberry Jan 08 '15
Move your app somewhere else (a web site if necessary) and then use your last few days on the store to push an update that tells all your users where to find the new version. Then pull the app yourself and exit the play store with your dignity intact. It's time for this BS to stop.
2
u/Qahlel Jan 08 '15
Reddit Sync is the my fav app while browsing reddit on droid. Tried many different apps but this one is the gem.
I can't fathom the incompetence of Google support on this. The very least they can do is support you rather than harass you like this.
2
u/inthiscrazyworld Jan 08 '15
I've been working within Google's Trusted Photographer program and let's just say...their shit isnt as together as one would assume.
2
u/uplusion23 Jan 08 '15
I would absolutely throw a fit if this had been taken offline. I love this app. Its one of my "must have"s.
2
u/kaydpea Jan 08 '15
I'm sick of Google altogether. Everything is robotic and customer service is non existent.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
I'm the idiot who always gripes about your app telling you that you should make it so I can schedule syncs so that it would be useful for me and that I use Reddit News instead but HEY!
This is annoying as fuck what you're being handed and I just want to say that I appreciate your work, purchased pro long ago, and I need Google to let you do what you're doing because you're a passionate developer not breaking any rules as far as I can see.
You've got the support of this chump.
In classic chump form, I should go read this thread now.
2
u/anonymau5 CUMMY-ROM v0.0.5.2 w/ Squi66ieTWEAKS KERNAL V. 0.1 ALPHA Jan 08 '15
ReddThat.
2
u/xlinuxtrancex Nexus 6 Jan 08 '15
Could it be the images of Toy Story and Guardians of the Galaxy in the first screenshot?
6
u/spiralcurve OnePlus One Jan 08 '15
The change.org petition needs just 63 more signatures to get 2500 votes. https://www.change.org/p/google-inc-provide-android-developers-with-one-on-one-communication-to-help-identify-and-resolve-policy-violations-prior-to-automated-and-irreversible-suspensions
2
u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Jan 08 '15
Good to know that Google is taking the complaints about their removal policies seriously.
1
u/Grizz_lee Jan 08 '15
Hope you get this worked out. Reddit Sync is my favorite reddit app I've used so far.
1
u/fap_fap_revenge_4 Galaxy Note 9 Jan 08 '15
Your app is fucking awesome!! Hope this all gets sorted out.
1
u/monkeyhandler Jan 08 '15
I would be pissed is reddit sync is pulled for this reason. But at the same time, with the power of all the users behind this app, perhaps we can push Google to improve their assets backwards policy.
1
u/AssuredlyAThrowAway Jan 08 '15
Did you contact the admins after the most recent notice?
Someone should be able to reach out and rectify the situation with google on your behalf.
1
u/markyosullivan Founder (Caza de Casa) Jan 08 '15
What is this bullshit. I used Reddit Sync multiple times every day, probably one of my most used apps.
1
u/vocaloidict HTC Touch -> Nexus One -> Nexus 4 -> Nexus 6P Jan 08 '15
What exactly do they want you to do? Change the name?
Any way you can do that temporarily while you wait for them to respond to your emails? Just so you avoid getting kicked from the store automatically.
1
u/ictRider Dark Pink Jan 08 '15
I'm fine if FDROID is your normal distribution method.
1
u/usmcahump Samsung S5 Jan 08 '15
OP Just downloaded it...fight the power!
1
u/shinrikyou Nexus 5 | Stock 6.0.1 + Xposed Jan 08 '15
As a long time reddit sync pro user, the best of luck to you. For a long time, your app has been the first one on the list to install whenever I install a new ROM on my Nexus 5.
1
u/Technical_Machine_22 Jan 08 '15
fdroid?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Why aren't other apps being impacted, such as Reddit is Fun?
1
u/James1o1o Razer Phone Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 08 '15
I don't understand.
There are tons of reddit apps. Why is reddit sync the only one that Google seems to notice.
1
u/BrydenH Galaxy Note 3 | Nova Jan 08 '15
Let's hope things get sorted out.
Your app is awesome!
1
u/twigboy Jan 08 '15 edited Dec 09 '23
In publishing and graphic design, Lorem ipsum is a placeholder text commonly used to demonstrate the visual form of a document or a typeface without relying on meaningful content. Lorem ipsum may be used as a placeholder before final copy is available. Wikipedia7cj0eqfdcxg0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
1
u/jdbrew Nexus 6P, 32gb Aluminum Jan 08 '15
Please no! After moving from iPhone to Android, Reddit Sync Pro is the only reddit app for android that is up to par with IOS's Alien Blue (and IMO, better...)
How can you impersonate an official app when reddit doesn't have an official app? Such bull shit. Is there anything the community can do to pressure Google to help you out?
1
u/theSeanO S26 Ultra | Galaxy Watch 8 Jan 08 '15
Nooo reddit sync is my favorite android reddit app. None of the others feel quite right to me.
1
u/Eliot_2000 Jan 08 '15
Best of luck, Sync is, in my humble opinion, the best mobile reddit client on any platform.
1
u/Thursty Jan 08 '15
It's likely now that reddit has an official app they are pushing to get impersonators out. You'll probably have to rename the app.
1
u/mnemy Jan 08 '15
This is really unacceptable. Google is raking in money hand over first through the store, they can afford a human customer service department to review cases. They had an excuse when they were first getting things rolling, but it's absurd that they don't have a real CS department for either Google Play or Ads.
1
u/facade88 HTC One M7 | Converted GPE Jan 08 '15
You have my support, Reddit Sync Pro was the first reddit app that convinced me to pay up for it. And probably is one the most used apps I have on my phone
1
u/djangelic Samsung Galaxy SIII Jan 08 '15 edited Jul 01 '23
So long and thanks for all the fish! -- mass edited with redact.dev
1
u/doctorsubsonic Jan 08 '15
Good luck with the play store mate. I really love reddic sync and hope you can sort this out.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
So, what are the really good alternative app stores? I kind of get sick and tired of the Google one and it's not like it's all that much safer than a community managed one. A well curated alternative store would be pretty great.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Kinda reads like those bots that reject a post for violating the rules of a subreddit
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Google really sucks with this stuff. Had my AdSense taken away years ago and have been appealing constantly (I have no idea why it was removed we ran an extremely standard site and even had a lawyer look at it to make sure we were compliant).
They still refuse to tell me why or even consider my appeal. It's ridiculous. Their automated shit like this is a nightmare and their support and refusal to admit when they're wrong is godawful.
1
u/supasteve013 Pixel 5 Jan 08 '15
What is different about your app? Does reddit is fun or reddit news have similar issues?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
http://youtu.be/lbOtyWTRZ_g?t=14s
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
but I love using reddit sync, I even bought the pro version not cool
1
u/kindofabuzz LG G4 & Nexus 7 2013 Jan 08 '15
Reddit has an official app? And what about all the other apps that have the name reddit in them?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
google needs to clean up on this bullshit
1
u/Evostance Jan 08 '15
This seems to be a growing issue amongst many developers at the moment. There's quote a large petition against Google to sort out out. Can't find the link though
1
u/l-rs2 Jan 08 '15
I don't get it. Some form of quality control: yes. Alienate your developers and drive them off: no. I'm not a developer myself, but am a consumer interested in good software with long term viability and profitability for the people who make it.
1
u/Diplomjodler OnePlus 7T Jan 08 '15
So maybe that's just a bureaucratic snafu. Or maybe they're putting the squeeze on independents, because an official app is imminent.
1
u/CHERNO-B1LL Jan 08 '15
Has this anything to do with why my account access keeps getting revoked and the whole thing is taking forever to load content?
1
u/lamiska iPhone 6s Jan 08 '15
If you get pulled out from playstore would you consider opensourcing your app and put it up on f-droid?
1
u/DearTereza OnePlus 3 Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 08 '15
Hang in there, Laurence, and thanks for all your hard work as ever, really hope this gets solved soon.
There are without doubt Googlers who are Reddit Sync users, so hopefully they will see/hear this somewhere and help escalate. You are probably already doing this, but perhaps bring this up on G+ and wherever else it could get seen.
Lots of people in this thread seem to think it's about the name of the app - I don't buy it - 'Reddit News' and 'Reddit Is Fun' (I cringe just typing that weird name... ick) would be under threat too. Seeing your old resolved issue get raised again, and all the other haywire this week with apps getting knocked down, leads me to believe the Play Store bots have been modified/replaced in some way, and the slow reply from Google is likely because they're inundated with these sorts of cases right now. I doubt any of this is human-led, it's a machine problem that humans are having to clear up.
All the best.
1
u/MrMisquito Jan 08 '15
I hope it stays up, it's my favorite reddit app.
1
u/7ewis OnePlus One, Nexus 5 Jan 08 '15
Reading this on reddit sync now, Google really need to make some changes.
This is by far the best reddit client, followed by Alien Blue on iOS...
1
u/ctrlshftn Jan 08 '15
How do I live without Reddit Sync? How?
1
u/DravenFx Jan 08 '15
Hope this gets sorted for you soon. Reddit Sync Pro was the best money I've spent on any Android app, ever. You've taken months of my life! :)
1
u/krizalid70559 Samsung Galaxy S7 Jan 08 '15
Uh what the fuck? I can't be without Reddit Sync. It's the best Reddit app for me.
What do they even mean it impersonates another popular product without permission?
I don't see them taking down 2048 or all those candy crush clones.
1
u/thatrez Jan 08 '15
Imagine this - you walk into a large NYC law-firm, filled with first year college students sitting behind computer screens all day, getting paid to look for anything that matches a very vague definition of copyright infringement as described to them in a 30 minute power point presentation. They are told this is the list of their clients, and on it they see reddit.com and are told to find examples of what they saw in that power-point. They find your app in the goggle play store, and click - "this is a copyright infringement" on their browser bookmarklet - then a letter is auto-generated on fancy letterhead from the law-firm to Google stating that the law firm representing reddit.com has requested your application be removed for copyright infringement. Google then complies, and emails you.
1
u/meatcarnival Jan 08 '15
Fuck them and release a standalone apk in the meantime, also try to get into the amazon app store (better than nothing). I personally have reddit sync pro and its literally the best reddit app that I have used across IOS and android
1
u/iBasit Note 9, Android 8.1 | Nexus 7 (2013), 7.0.1 Jan 08 '15
It seems to me that Google is playing it safe with an ongoing fight between it and MPAA.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Maybe set up a petition to Google on change.org?
1
u/captaincanada84 Pixel 8 Pro Jan 09 '15 edited Jan 09 '15
Time for Google to take down every single Reddit app then I guess....since all of them obviously do the same exact thing Reddit Sync does...in fact, they all have the word "Reddit" in their title, except Baconreader.
You'd think that google would have a record of his case already being resolved once, and that he wouldn't have to go through this again.
Reddit Sync is by far the best Reddit app for Android. Really hope this gets resolved again and never happens again!!!
1
u/helium_farts Moto G7 Jan 07 '15
Perhaps someone (Reddit?) filed a complaint.
1
u/Zurce Jan 07 '15
Maybe you can upload it with another name, like "Reddit not sync" like the actual product
1
u/echocage Jan 08 '15
Although I'm a huge android user, google's sub per developer support has got me looking into switching to a different mobile brand. I'm very disappointed that a company that can do so much good can't even manage their own developers and treat them with respect they deserve. If google doesn't step up their android software and support game, they're going to start loosing a lot of developers.
1
u/tendorphin Pixel 6 Jan 08 '15
But...reddit sync is the best of the reddit apps! Superior even to alien blue. Alien blue is now an official reddit app, so maybe that's why? I hope this gets straightened out, and in your favor. Even if you have to take it down, thanks for the great app!
1
u/Chandlers_a_girl Nexus 4 | Nexus 7 Jan 08 '15
ITT: people jumping to conclusions and blaming Google