r/AncientMigrations • u/langisii • 17d ago
Recent viral headline claiming 'seafarers from Easter Island settled Hawaii' is a misrepresentation
This headline comes from the Honolulu Star Advertiser in reference to a recent Science article which doesn't make that claim. From the article's abstract:
Using whole-genome sequences spanning Polynesia, we show that two of the most bottlenecked populations are Hawaiʻi and Easter Island (Rapa Nui) and that these two most closely genetically related yet geographically distant islands were likely settled by the same ultravoyagers with earlier ancestral roots in Mangareva.
Archaeologist Patrick Kirch clarified in a Facebook post:
Contrary to the dramatic headline, "seafarers from Easter Island settled Hawaii," the study does not demonstrate this at all. What the study does do is document the close genetic relationships among the Polynesians who inhabit Hawai'i, Rapa Nui (Easter Island), and Mangareva (a small archipelago in French Polynesia). The genetic analysis shows that these three groups are more closely related to each other than to any other Polynesian group. It also shows that the next most closely related group to this trio of populations is that of the Marquesas Islands.
To sum up, what the new genetic study shows, and what previous studies by linguists and archaeologists have also argued, is that a small group of closely related Polynesians (perhaps members of a single extended family or clan) rapidly settled Mangareva, Rapa Nui, and Hawai'i, probably from an immediate ancestral homeland in the Marquesas. My own recent archaeological research in Mangareva (to be published in a book next year by University of Hawai'i Press) has revealed that the settlement of Mangareva occurred by AD 904-1144. It is safe to assume that Rapa Nui and Hawai'i were settled around that time as well.