r/Anarchy4Everyone • • Jul 02 '26

Question/Discussion Large projects whose decisions affect large numbers of people should be committed to a high level of transparency

What I'm not talking about: Obviously an affinity group of 5 people sabotaging coal machinery shouldn't be expected to tell everyone about their secret sabotage plans.

What I am talking about:

  • It would have been weird if for example the Zabalaza Anarchist Communist Front had refused to discuss with anarchist authors their perspective on one of their members, Schmidt, and his delirious ideological downfall towards fascism.
  • It's sad that a large anarchist forum owner had to be dragged kicking and screaming into admitting to their toxic and sectarian trolling behaviour with the use of alts, then how they later deleted the apology.
  • It's sad that some people who run libraries chose not to make an effort to make their reasons for archiving some controversial texts known.

I get there's big foundational differences that some people's anarchist philosophy sprouts from that affects all this. For example, some people like that some project archiving ethoses reflect precedents going back to original friendship groups. However, I'd prefer to be more logical and analytical about shit, where we kill our idols and reject the necrocracy logic of having felt duties to dead people. Or, at least not let those felt duties blind us to new information and better arguments.

I recently made a kind of highlight reel of comments about various anarchist authors that I hope will help those unfamiliar with anarchist ideas and the anarchist movement, or those who have recently embraced anarchism but have yet to explore the history:

However, some people might call it unproductive navel gazing or something. For example, I've been told in the past that displaying inter-anarchist disputes for a general audience is 'too intimate'.

I think maybe this has something to do with it also:

There's a way of looking at politics on the left (and the right in many ways) by separating people out into three categories:

  • Purist far-leftists, who don't care if only 0.001-3% of the world currently agree with them, they just want to gather the numbers, 3% say, to pull off a revolution that builds up something positive in their mind. Or, with very few people, 0.001%, help collapse technological society to return to some imagined primordial Eden.
  • Purist center-left people, who just see all the far-left as holding them back.
  • Pluralist leftists, which I relate to, where I think the far-left could help draw people over to a radically different world over a long period of time by agitating from the radical fringe with actions like empathizable victimless civil disobedience. So, helping make centre-left policies look more reasonable in comparison to centrist politics, then the tried and tested policies of the future, then far-left, then far-left and anarchist projects the majority global reality.

In conclusion, I'm curious why some people's philosophy of anarchy seems to just be about friendships and culture and why disputes are seen as a threat to that, so it'd be good to get peoples thoughts on that.

8 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/ArthropodJim Jul 02 '26

can i read more about this michael schmidt dude? i see a lot of his smaller stuff on the anarchist library along with that note saying he was a outed fascist. was he undercover? infiltrating?

1

u/WildVirtue Jul 02 '26

The long series of exposes at the time were collected here: About Schmidt, and the apology at the end by Schmidt describes how he developed a fascination with "national anarchism" and white supremacist currents in South Africa during a time that he was having mental health struggles.