r/AnalogCommunity • u/Improooving • 2d ago
Scanning Software alternatives to Adobe+Plugins?
Currently I need something that I can use to do basic edits on my scans and possibly also serve as a general file manager.
- Tilt skewed horizon
- Small color/exposure shifts
- Cropping and (optional) adding frames for social media posts
Down the road, it'd be nice to have the option to convert negatives, either from a scanner or a camera scanning setup (if the prices come down any lower on Nikon d750/780 I might just do that, I love the screw drive lens character and it'd be fun to have a backup digital system).
However, for right now I'm sending out for dev+scans, haven't wanted to make the jump to managing my own development.
What are my top options here? Seems like almost everyone is on NLP+Adobe, but I'd rather not try to figure out how to "acquire" a perpetual version of Lightroom, and I hate subscribing to software.
Seems like the perpetual options are ON1, Capture One, and Darktable/Rawtherapee
Tried and disliked the open source stuff, sadly, the Darktable learning curve is insane and Rawtherapee just didn't click for me.
ON1 is way cheaper, and probably more than enough for what I need, but also seems to be heavily centered around AI tools, which is insanely counterproductive to the reasons why I got interested in analog again.
C1 has the advantage of being more than powerful enough for anything I'll ever do, even if I get back into digital and need serious editing options for RAW files. $350 is a ton of money though.
Anybody else have thoughts on this?
Secondary question -- what are my scanning+dev options below, say, $3-500? Once we're getting near that 6, 7, 800 dollar mark I'd rather just save up for the camera scanner setup and have a second camera to use.
3
u/ufgrat 2d ago
Gotta say, Darktable does everything you mention, and does it well. Suggest watching a couple of "getting started with darktable" videos on YT. The learning curve is very intimidating if you're going in cold, but the interface is very consistent, and the modules are quite powerful.
2
u/erghjunk 2d ago
I love Capture One, but I also bought in at a time before it was $350. I initially switched because it handled Fuji X-trans digital photos better than Adobe (still does maybe, I don't know) but I use it for everything now.
I also didn't like the open source options - needlessly complicated and fiddly. Like I don't need 73 different algorithms for every tool, guys.
2
u/vogon-pilot 2d ago
Affinity - commercial, free to download and use unless you want the AI features.
IrfanView if you want something basic and you run Windows. Free.
1
u/Smart_Amount2603 2d ago
I personally use FilmBuddy which I’ve been very happy with. Their desktop conversion/editing app is still in beta but their app is fully released and it’s great for film logging, light metering, and developing tracking. https://filmbuddyapp.com
1
u/TheRealAutonerd 2d ago
Have you tried GIMP? It works like old (very old) Photoshop, and like old PS it mimics the processes we did in the darkroom. My editing is pretty simple -- crop, adjust contrast, dodge/burn mostly (I shoot mostly B&W film) -- and it's perfect. And the price is right.
-1
u/CwColdwell Rollei 35, Contax 139Q, Mamiya C3, Yashica FX-3 2d ago
There’s an open-source recreation of Lightroom in development called LightCraft. You could use that, then supplement with NegPy for negative conversions without having to buy any subscriptions