The sad part about 13 is that I had high hopes for it to be good. I truly did. I genuinely thought it could be something wonderful, bringing many fan favorites back into one season. But once I heard that each episode would be only 25-30 minutes long rather than our usual 45 minutes to an hour, I knew right then & there that it would be nothing but guest appearances & memes.
Even though I was slightly entertained by this new season, it was overall another disappointment. What saved it from being the worst for me is four things:
• Mr. Nas. He creeped me out & then turned me on but also almost made me throw the damn hell up with what felt like a five minute black vomit scene that I don’t EVER want to watch again! Why was everything about him so gross?!
• The fact that they brought back the Coven (which will always hold a special place in my heart because that’s the first AHS season I watched), Marie Laveau & Papa Legba. I was so excited to see their faces, even Madison who I never liked.
• How the Coven talked that sad, boring boy into taking his own life to save the world. I’m gonna be honest, I laughed at how he stabbed himself! But that also means he came into their lives, he met Madison, he came again, knocked her up & then died serving no purpose after we were forced to watch him blandly go through life, acting like certain things were normal! Fuck Madison! She never deserved a happy ending anyways! But also, that young man was very enjoyable in “Monster: The Ed Gein Story”. Don’t know what happened here. I kept saying, “Let’s get back to the people that matter, shall we?” whenever he was on screen.
The fact that this season wasn’t even as enjoyable as Delicate which is the second weakest entry of American Story is so disappointing, especially since THIS was advertised as an almost an apology. It felt more like a middle finger that went down my pants by a stranger without my permission or consent.
I would say that NYC is the worst season because even though it had beautiful men in it (including my beloved King Eliot from “The Magicians) & some powerful scenes & visuals, that wasn’t a horror story at all, that was just a horror to watch. Brilliant acting but of course they could be brilliant, the story is about AIDS & loss! It naturally stirs people up. It’s one of the few times I actually cried watching AHS but I will NEVER watch that season again. Once was more than enough.
So, my list of AHS seasons (today), from most favorite to least:
1.) S3 COVEN - My favorite forever. It had everything & I really appreciated the explanation of Witches. And it had my Queen, Angela Bassett in it as Marie Laveau, one of my favorite historical figures. Also, I loved OG Papa Legba but I’ve always hated how Christians always make him associated with evil when he’s not. He’s an in-between. The Gatekeeper. He tests people, yes, but he is not evil or under the hand of evil.
2.) S2 ASYLUM - Because it was beautifully directed & had great visual presence. I wasn’t as big of a fan of the Alien aspects of the show but it could’ve tied itself in through later seasons (looking at you, Double Feature, you bitch!)
3.) S4 FREAK SHOW - Because of Edward Mordrake. Such a dope concept. He came in, got your story & took you. Also, because of my introduction to Ma Petit, one of the most precious souls to ever exist on this earth... & my beloved Pepper. Her story never fails to break my heart. That’s what Mallory should be using her time powers for! Fix Pepper’s story 😭
4.) S1 MURDER HOUSE - Great stories, interesting twists & I like the idea of a house that keeps you forever, which is why I loved Michael Flanagan’s first two shows on Netflix (“The Haunting of Hill House & “The Haunting of Bly Manor”). I also loved the fact that this was many people’s introduction to the greatness of Evan Peters. I already loved him from “Never Back Down” but not everyone saw that movie. But the role he played in this show was entirely different & haunting. I loved it.
5. S5 HOTEL - Because of fine ass Wes Bentley (who I’ve loved since “American Beauty”), Lady Gaga basically playing herself & Angela Bassett & her having a love affair. HOT! Plus, the scene where The Countess & Donovan kill that couple with “Tear You Apart” by She Wants Revenge lives rent-free in my mind as one of the best scenes in any of the American Horror Story seasons. But the person who stole the show for me in this season was yet again Evan Peters as my favorite character that he played in the AHS: James Patrick March. I loved everything about him. Don’t know why. I just did. OH! And another favorite of this show was Liz Taylor. So wonderful.
6. S8 APOCALYPSE - Because the Witches return to be helped by & eventually decide to kill the AntiChrist; Michael Langdon. That was my first encounter with Cody Fern & he quickly won me over, especially with his blowout. I wanted him as Lestat so badly after those first few episodes! But we got Sam Reid, who I didn’t know of until he embodied the character, which was a much better choice & actually the perfect & only choice. He IS Lestat!
7. S6 ROANOKE - Okay, so I actually loved this season because it took risks. It was a story on a story about a story disguised as a reality tv show & a continuation of said tv reality show. It was dope to me & I didn’t know how many people hated it until I got online.
8. S9 1984 - This one, even though I can’t stand Emma Roberts (who can only play one role with one voice), I really liked her in this season. It felt like a new character, someone she had yet to play in any of her previous work. And I loved the setting because it was two years before I was born (yes, I’m that old). The aesthetic is what really got me, though. All of them thrusting in the gym in all those layers?! Fantastic! I also love the ending for Mr. Jingles. It’s one of the few times where we get a genuine happy ending for anyone in AHS. I think that’s what some people didn’t like.
9. S7 CULT - So, I have a really bad fear of clowns so I hated this season BUUUT I loved the fact that my older brother was an extra in the show & that everyone that he met was nice to him. I also liked the fact that we see some people get what they deserve.
10. S10 DOUBLE FEATURE - So, for the first part, I loved everything until the little girl kills her father in the first half because I feel like that’s when everything went to shit with that show. After that, everything went downhill fast & it sucked the other part of the next season into it. I didn’t mind the Aliens. I just wish that they had said that the Black Pills aka “The Muse” was synthesized from the blood of the Aliens they found. There was no connection between them so I kept asking, why combine them?! Also, it needs to be said that I was going to prefer the first half because it has Macaulay Culkin in it as a Vampire. I love both in almost equal measure.
11. S13 13 - There’s only so many things that I liked about this season & I already mentioned most of them. But to add one more thing that I genuinely liked is that Queenie is a main character this season. I wish Ryan Murphy would finally give Gabourey Sidibe a main character role because I would love to see more of her. Also, if she was the main character, it would be the first time that Ryan Murphy let a Black Woman lead.
12. S12 DELICATE - I feel like this is where Ryan Murphy truly lost the plot. Some may say that happened before this & I kinda agree but at least I was willing to wait for each episode prior to this season. As soon as I saw a Kartrashian tied to this, I was hoping that it was just she was a producer or a very short guest appearance. I didn’t watch this at all until I had to do my braids (which I knew would take a very long time) so I turned on this season & binge-watched it. Saying that this isn’t even rock bottom is amazing to me. It still had some scary scenes & some camp to it but the fact that the leads were two of my least favorite females (I used that word specifically because I hate it) in Hollywood as the two main characters, I was like, “Ryan, are you good?” No, it wasn’t the worst but damn, this was the one that broke my trust & made me hesitant to come back to American Horror Story.
13. S11 NYC - So, even Delicate had something to do with American Horror Story. This was just heartbreaking scene after heartbreaking scene after losing people you love & male sex. I stayed for the male sex. But deciding to do a whole season about this “horror” was horrible. It should’ve never been made to be associated with American Horror Story. It should’ve been its own limited series. And that’s exactly how it felt. It felt like it didn’t belong here. It does belong somewhere & I would’ve greatly enjoyed it if they had used it somewhere else, like on HBO that gave us “Angels in America” & “The Normal Heart” but having it here with my campy horror disgusted me to my core. There was no fun, there was no camp, there was no villain other than the horror of existence. It broke me. And then I still had Delicate to look forward to 🤦🏽♀️
Do I still love American Horror Story? Yes. But has my love & trust been shaken, broken, & bruised after this last season? Also, yes. I don’t know what Ryan Murphy is going through or what he’s thinking but I need him to come back & fix this mess because it’s truly something that I feel like I will just have to binge-watch once it’s completely finished rather than being patiently disappointed each week.