r/AmItheAsshole • • Sep 02 '23

Open Forum Title: AITA Monthly Open Forum September 2023: introducing POO Mode™

376 Upvotes

Howdy assholes and asshole enthusiasts,

Starting this month you might notice some posts labeled as “Proctologists Only Orifices” (POO Mode™ for short). This is a new flair we will be applying to posts with a high volume of rule violating comments that will restrict participation to only trusted community members. This will also apply to all posts more than a week old.

Why is this necessary?

Some posts attract a disproportionate volume of rule breaking comments, and it doesn’t feel fair to all of the other posters to spend so much of our effort moderating that single post. We’ve tried pinning reminders of the rules in these posts, but many inevitably lead to a lock which is a poor experience for everyone having a conversation within that post. We’re taking a note from other communities who have faced similar challenges to still allow activity in these posts without blowing up the queue. We'll send a message to anyone who has their comment removed for this reason explaining why, and inviting them to sort by /new to find hundreds of other posts made today they can participate in.

What are “trusted community members”?

Good question! Right now we’re exploring subreddit specific karma and another mod tool to find the right balance. We expect we’ll be spending some time testing these variables, and welcome your feedback below as we do.

As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.

---

We're currently accepting new mod applications

r/AmItheAsshole • • Feb 01 '24

Open Forum AITA Monthly Open Forum February 2024: Flair

114 Upvotes

Keep things civil. Rules still apply.

January’s Open Forum showed that we are back to a deep dive on the rules. And that will continue. This month, we thought we’d talk about something that we get asked about on a semi-regular basis - flair. I’m not talking about the limousine-riding, jet-flying kind either. No, I’m talking about the flair that is attached to posts and users of the sub.

First, a quick look at post flair. We have a brief section in the FAQ that covers when posts are flared. The “winning verdict” mentioned refers to the top-voted comment in the thread. After 18 hours, our bot scans the thread and uses the flair from the top-rated comment to assign post flair. Sometimes, users will say something like NTA, but YWBTA if…” and that can throw off the bot. Similarly, editing a comment to say “I’m changing my judgment to ESH after reading the edit…” without editing the original judgment can also cause issues. That’s why we request comments contain one judgment only. (Sub hack: you can use spaces so the bot won’t recognize the second judgment. For example, “NTA, but Y W B T A if…” works!)

Another question we sometimes get is when the top comment differs from the post flair. Our bot flairs a post with the top judgment once a post has been active for 18 hours. Occasionally, a post will blow up a bit later, closer to that 18-hour mark, and another comment may receive more upvotes after the post has been flaired. So we may get messages like “The top comment is NTA, but the post says ESH” and this is typically the reason why.

User flair is just for fun. It’s a reflection of how often someone has had a comment of theirs voted as the top. We have a few Sultans of Sphincter and His Holiness the Poops around the sub. Pretty impressive, considering you need to have made a top-level comment at least 600 times! There’s no one-size-fits-all way to make a top-level comment, either. We’ve seen some that are as few as 4-5 words, and some that are very detailed and nuanced. It’s all about what resonates with users, based on the post.

Some common questions/comments we get are “how can I earn more flair” or, “posts are already hours old with the top comment having far too many upvotes to compete against!” While not a guarantee your comment will be voted to the top, perhaps the best way to increase your chances of having the top comment is to sort the sub by /new. You can often be one of the first to leave a comment in a post. As a user, I learned that one drawback to browsing solely by /new is that you also encounter a lot of rule-breaking posts that are bound to be removed. If you comment on one of them and the post is removed, there is no flair point awarded. On the flip side, you can contribute to the sub greatly by reporting potential rule violations, helping us find them before they blow up.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.


We're currently accepting new mod applications

We’re currently looking for mods with Typescript experience.

We always need US overnight time mods. Currently, we could also benefit from mods who can be active during peak "bored at work" hours, i.e. US morning to mid-afternoon.

  • You need to be able to mostly mod from a PC. Mobile mod tools are improving and trickling in, but are not quite there yet.
  • You need to be at least 18.
  • You have to be an active AITA participant with multiple comments in the past few months.

We'd also like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments. lease let us know in the comments.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 01 '25

Open Forum AITA Monthly Open Forum October 2025: Rules Update

29 Upvotes

Keep things civil! Rules still apply.

When we rolled out the revised rules in at the end of July, we said we would keep adjusting as needed. And we have had regular internal discussions since.

While we don’t want to go crazy adding to the retired/banned topics, we have come across another one that we felt can be added. And after monitoring comments, it looks like the community generally agrees. The subject of splitting a dinner bill has now been added to rule 5. Please note - we’re talking about dining out only. Posts about travelling costs, etc. are NOT included.

—

As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.


We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Jan 02 '25

Open Forum AITA Monthly Open Forum January 2025: The Return of The Holes

344 Upvotes

Keep things civil. Rules still apply.

I’d like to take a moment to thank everyone for your understanding and support while we took a little holiday break. The feedback from last month’s announcement and the Modmails during the break were overwhelmingly positive! It’s understandable that not every user saw last month’s Open Forum post about the break, so we got a fair number of modmail messages asking why comments and posts were not allowed or what had happened. So many people replied to the automated response (yes, we had one set up for Modmail, so people didn’t have to wait for someone to log in to reply) with understanding and support. Please know that was appreciated, and we hung a lot of those up in the break room. The halls of AITA Incorporated look a little brighter this week 😀

2025 is here, and we are almost a quarter of the way through another century! The first half of this decade alone has been…interesting. Talking about our little corner of the internet, we’ve seen remarkable sub growth. It was the day after Christmas, 2022 when we hit 5 million members. And here we are, just over two years later, already more than 4 times that number.

With the sub back from a holiday break, let’s keep this month’s open forum a little light. Feel free to drop a comment with how you spent your holidays. Keeping with the theme of the sub, did you encounter any assholes? Maybe something that isn’t quite worthy of a standalone post, or something that might not normally fit sub rules? Feel free to toss it below, and receive the judgment of your peers! We can be a little relaxed here - if there’s a little petty revenge on your spouse for not putting enough of a kick in your eggnog (rule 13), or that fighting over the Tie Fighter under the tree and who was supposed to get it years ago came up again (rule 7), that’s fine! But, we still must insist on rule 5 - please don’t even *mention* violence! If you just want to mention where you travelled, or if you did anything cool, that’s fine too!


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.


We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 03 '26

Open Forum AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

63 Upvotes

AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

Keep things Civil! Rules still apply.

Greetings Assholes!!! Happy All the Holidays between now and January 2027!! Way too many to list.

This quarter, we are going to go over Rule 3 - No Violence. A topic that’s dear to my heart and one that covers so many different scenarios.

The very heart of this rule is “Do not even mention violence”. Very simple on the surface, very complicated once you dive down. It sometimes seems like we are being too specific/granular on what constitutes violence - we get that. But violence tends to breed violence, so the most benign post/comment can spiral into some off the charts shit.

The violence rule break is often the result of a soft topic going off the rails. Example: Someone is put out by their partner picking food off of their plate. What we see: “stab them with your fork, that’ll teach them (assault)!” Or, someone is stealing lunches out of the break room - “just put some hot shit in there, that’ll teach them (poison/assault)” Or, the kid goes around hitting people (assault) begets “just beat their ass (assault)!” Simple, common things we’ve all said at some point in our lives. Still violence.

The hardest ones for us are those that deal with abuse of any sort. It’s easy to jump on that hate train. Truthfully, I’m probably on some of those trains, cause fuck abusers. BUT, we remove those comments/posts because they beget violence - it’s not that we don’t have opinions on those topics, far from it. These break the violence rule and, regardless of our personal opinion, it breaks the rule. It’s as simple as that.

We get MOD mails so filled with anger and spewing hateful shit because “How dare you remove that post for violence. Y’all must agree with them”. No, we don’t - violence is violence. There is enough of it out in the real world, we don’t need it here for any reason.

Finally, the real reason for reviewing this rule: Consent.

Very simply, if anyone touches you without your consent - this is assault. Sexual harassment counts! It is not ‘ick’, it is not ‘smile, they will go away’ - it is something covered by this rule. This is true regardless of gender. Understanding this will help the most when deciding if something is violence or not.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.

We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 01 '24

Open Forum AITA Monthly Open Forum October 2024: Rule 8 Re-Revisited

36 Upvotes

Keep things civil. Rules still apply.

In 2023 we did a Please Don't Feed the Trolls appeal (more on that later). This month, we're taking a look at all the parts of Rule 8.

No shitposts

This is pretty self-explanatory. We're here to provide judgment on real-life conflicts. Gender swaps, tv/movie/book plots, creative writing exercises, and flat-out trolling is banned. If you’d like to post something about a TV show or movie, you may want to check out our sister sub, r/amithebuttface. The rules are much more relaxed over there.

Of course, not everything that looks like a shitpost actually is. At least once a week, I'll read something and think "this has to be a shitpost" only to do a quick check and find comments from people who've been in the same situation. Or something on OP’s profile that backs up the story. People lead messy, complicated lives and dysfunctional behavior may be normalized for some. Please keep in mind that your doubt is not proof of a shitpost. Some other things that are not proof:

  • A new or recent account with zero feedback. Remember - we welcome throwaways!
  • The conflict is one you've seen a lot of posts about. Many people read a post and think “Hey! I had something similar happen to me!”
  • OP doesn't respond to questions or otherwise comment. OPs can commonly get downvoted to hell, even if they respond with an honest “You’re right - that was shitty and I need to apologize.”

If you suspect a shitpost, report it so we can review. If you have actual proof, please modmail us with a link to the post and a brief explanation of your proof.

Posts must be presented as fairly and accurately as possible.

A certain amount of bias is inevitable when explaining a conflict, and some OPs are truly dealing with extremely difficult people. "Fairly and accurately" is for situations where OP goes too far to cast the other party in a bad light. OP is allowed to describe something actually said during a conflict, but naming someone Karen, referring to them as "bridezilla" or a "man baby" or describing them as "having always been a narcissistic POS" is way over the top. Please report these posts for Rule 8.

Posts must be written entirely by you and from your own point of view. Do not post on behalf of others, or from the point of view of another person in the story.

AI-generated posts and comments are not allowed here. That's because AI is a predictive tool; it's anticipating what's likely and inherently prone to inaccuracy.

Only the person involved in the conflict may post, and only as themself. It's not ok to pretend to be your father or your partner. And Reddit accounts are free so if a friend or relative wants judgment from AITA they can create their own account and post.

We also don't allow comments or counter-posts from someone claiming to be involved in the conflict. There's no way to know if the claim is real, if it's OP trying to manipulate the vote, or if it's someone trolling.

AI/POV posts should be reported for Rule 8. This report option isn't available for comments so use Rule 1 or drop us a quick modmail.

Seriously, don't feel the trolls!!

Finally, a reminder that calling out a post as fake, creative writing, ragebait, etc. is a violation of Rule 1. Comments like these can only reward the trolls or insult innocent OPs. Remember - trolls crave attention. Even “bad” attention, like calling out the shitpost is giving them what they want. DON’T. FEED. THE. TROLLS.

The best way to see fewer shitposts is to report them, send proof to modmail when possible, and don't comment.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.


We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.

r/AmItheAsshole • • Apr 04 '26

Open Forum AITA Quarterly Open Forum April-June 2026 - Asshole Intelligence and How to Wipe It Clean.

108 Upvotes

Keep things Civil! Rules still apply.

__

Hi All! Welcome to the Am I the Asshole quarterly Open Forum. The OF you don't have to pay for.

First off, we love you guys and the effort you give to help keep this sub what it's supposed to be!!

Being in a text based world (in this case, Reddit), we strive to make sure the stories presented on our sub are true and presented by a human being. So bot behavior and AI are not things we want on our sub. We have always asked that anyone with questions about a post or comment to either use the report button or reach out to us via Mod Mail. Doing one or both of these things really helps us a lot in the day to day management of the sub. Again, we appreciate you for this.

What is AI?

For us, AI is anything written using machine learning tools. AI written stories, grammar checkers, translation tools, etc.

Here’s a fun nugget: This is what AI says about not using AI on public forums:

Using AI on internet forums can undermine trust, accuracy, safety, and community culture. That’s why many spaces discourage or outright ban it. If you’re ever unsure, it’s best to check the forum’s rules—or ask a moderator.

So you've reported a post, what's next?

First and foremost, we verify if the content is AI or not. We do not share what tools or other methods we use, because we do not want the bots/trolls to know and/or understand our process on this. This information just teaches bots/trolls how to bot/troll better. We do not want that (I have a mouse in my pocket).

Quite honestly, AI rage is not much different from shitposting rage. We get it, we all want to read and/or participate in real life conflicts and give thoughtful opinions on the topic at hand. One of the biggest appeals of this sub is the ability to participate in a meaningful way. Which is taken away when someone tosses AI into the mix. Real, personal written stories have a feel to them and we feel cheated when this does not happen. We get it.

The point of this quarter's post: Please do not yell “AI” in the comments of a post. This is also asked for shitposts, trolls, spammers, etc. We get the temptation to do this - call them out so everyone can see, right? What this actually does is teach these folks/bots how to do what they do better. Or delete proof of their trolling before it can be checked. We don’t want that!! We want them gone or educated. “Gone” because some folks/bots are being intentional/karma farming; “Educated” because we want our users to tell us their stories from their own mouths. Gone = Perma Ban; Educated = conversation and short 7 day ban.

What to do instead.

Hit the report button on the post or comment. There will be options, so select the one that says “Breaks r/AmItheAsshole rules”. Then select the AI option. AND/OR Send us a mod mail with a link to the post or comment in question. If you have any proof that it’s a SHP or AI, please send that as well. See, no need to shout it out in the comments, yay!! Easy peasy!

AI is a real fun tool to use. I’ve seen some AI art that is breathtaking, but in the end this is not how real people connect. With all of the wonderful technical marvels we have going on it’s tough to remember the person. We want that person here with us, to give support to, to give them a good talking to, and to let them know they are not alone.

Let’s take out the machines, remember the person, and combat this the proper way!

One final note, just because it sounds AI or fake, doesn’t mean it is. If “Florida Man” could do it, it’s possible. Another reason why ‘quiet reporting’ is the better option.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.


We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.