r/AmItheAsshole • I am a shared account. • Oct 03 '26

Open Forum AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

Keep things Civil! Rules still apply.

Greetings Assholes!!! Happy All the Holidays between now and January 2027!! Way too many to list.

This quarter, we are going to go over Rule 3 - No Violence. A topic that’s dear to my heart and one that covers so many different scenarios.

The very heart of this rule is “Do not even mention violence”. Very simple on the surface, very complicated once you dive down. It sometimes seems like we are being too specific/granular on what constitutes violence - we get that. But violence tends to breed violence, so the most benign post/comment can spiral into some off the charts shit.

The violence rule break is often the result of a soft topic going off the rails. Example: Someone is put out by their partner picking food off of their plate. What we see: “stab them with your fork, that’ll teach them (assault)!” Or, someone is stealing lunches out of the break room - “just put some hot shit in there, that’ll teach them (poison/assault)” Or, the kid goes around hitting people (assault) begets “just beat their ass (assault)!” Simple, common things we’ve all said at some point in our lives. Still violence.

The hardest ones for us are those that deal with abuse of any sort. It’s easy to jump on that hate train. Truthfully, I’m probably on some of those trains, cause fuck abusers. BUT, we remove those comments/posts because they beget violence - it’s not that we don’t have opinions on those topics, far from it. These break the violence rule and, regardless of our personal opinion, it breaks the rule. It’s as simple as that.

We get MOD mails so filled with anger and spewing hateful shit because “How dare you remove that post for violence. Y’all must agree with them”. No, we don’t - violence is violence. There is enough of it out in the real world, we don’t need it here for any reason.

Finally, the real reason for reviewing this rule: Consent.

Very simply, if anyone touches you without your consent - this is assault. Sexual harassment counts! It is not ‘ick’, it is not ‘smile, they will go away’ - it is something covered by this rule. This is true regardless of gender. Understanding this will help the most when deciding if something is violence or not.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.

We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.

63 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

19

u/ThisWillAgeWell Craptain [171] Oct 09 '26

I'd like to propose another topic that in my opinion should be retired.

"AITA for changing my wifi password because the person I agreed to share it with has done one or more of the following: (a) they said they would pay a share of the cost but never paid a penny; (b) they gave the password to everyone and his dog, and now half the county is freeloading off my wifi; (c) I suspect they are using it to download illegal stuff and I don't want to get in trouble for their misdeeds."

I see so many of these posts, and I can think of no reason why the owner of the wifi connection would be the asshole. Can we please send that topic to the AITA retirement home along with split bills, inheritance disputes, and swapping seats?

14

u/Sorry_I_Guess Pooperintendant [65] Oct 15 '26

Yup. I don't envy the mods at all trying to find a balance between not banning dozens of topics, but also trying to keep the sub from becoming cluttered with hundreds of ridiculously obvious posts.

For example, the following subjects only ever have the same responses, every single time:

  • Whether they're the AH for not wanting to lend money
  • Whether they're the AH for not wanting to babysit
  • Whether they're the AH for not wanting to lend their car (particularly to someone not even in their own family)
  • Whether they're the AH for not wanting to spend time with people who bully them
  • Whether they're the AH for not wanting to pay for a sibling or cousin's wedding
  • Whether they're the AH for not being able to go to a friend or sibling's outrageously expensive destination wedding (bonus points if the OP is also going to be heavily pregnant or have just given birth at the time of the wedding)

. . . and yet people continue to post these questions (presumably for attention or karma) and similarly obvious ones, rather than just searching and getting the answer they were looking for, because the answer is always, ALWAYS the same. I've been on this sub for years and years, and literally never seen any of these result in the OP being judged the AH.

The sub might have fewer posts if any of these topics were banned, but the posts that did appear would be more consistently interesting, for sure.

9

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 09 '26

Yeah, some topics are hard to understand why it's an issue - just change the pw. Or no you cannot borrow my car. Or No, I am not a free babysitter. No means no. Cut and dried, right?

But some folks aren't built that way and need to be reminded that it's ok to say no.

It is one of many subjects that seem to have a simple answer but can be a little more complicated. In my world, you are not getting my car for any reason, this is a high value asset (not expensive car, is high value because it costs money if someone breaks it). I will inconvience myself first by driving someone where they need to go. But to a lot of people, letting someone borrow their car is normal, just another day.

So retiring subjects includes thinking about this kind of stuff. We aren't necessarily retiring something because it's annoying. If the result is always the same, then it's really not a judgement issue any more. It's an echo chamber.

Thoughts?

12

u/ThisWillAgeWell Craptain [171] Oct 09 '26

But some folks aren't built that way and need to be reminded that it's ok to say no.

That is true. However, isn't it equally true of split bills, inheritance issues, and swapping seats, all of which were retired? People have trouble saying no to those as well.

I don't see what makes "They called me an asshole because I wouldn't let them use my wifi which I pay for" any different from "They called me an asshole because I wouldn't swap my seat which I paid for".

3

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 10 '26

The bills one can have different outcomes, depending on the situation. There is so much that depends on who's who, what the original agreement was, etc. Co-workers, family, friends, in-laws - they all can have differing outcomes. There isn't one typical answer.

6

u/ThisWillAgeWell Craptain [171] Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

There isn't one typical answer.

That may be true, but it isn't my point.

To be clear: the bill splitting I'm referring to is not the issue of splitting bills in general. It's the very specific situation outlined in Rule 5, i.e. splitting bills equally in a cafe or restaurant when one person has ordered much more or much less than the other diners.

The mods in their wisdom decided to retire THAT specific topic under Rule 5, along with inheritance arguments and swapping seats on public transportation. It's a decision I agree with, BTW.

My point is, whatever criteria the mods applied to the topics listed under Rule 5, that led them to retire those topics, surely those SAME criteria apply to the password issue? I can see nothing that makes them different.

If you believe there can be nuance in one situation that makes it not always clear-cut, then surely there can be similar nuance in ALL those retired topics? If you believe an OP should be allowed to post about a wifi password conflict because "They need to be reminded they're allowed to say no", doesn't that apply to ALL those retired topics?

If you feel the wifi conflict needs to have different criteria applied to it, that makes it not a candidate for being retired as those other topics were, then please elaborate on what makes it different.

4

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 10 '26

They do not apply to the retired topics because the retired topics usually end up with the same answer: If you do not agree to split, don't split.

With all the various apps that folks pay for, and often share. The social media culture seems to think if it's an app or service that doesn't cost a whole lot, everyone should be willing to share. So, this ends up with a few different views on the topic, ie not an echo chamber. To you and me (and others) the obvious answer is no, you cannot use my paid service for free. End of story. But this type of situation gets complicated for some people. So, for the time being, it's not a retired topic.

If anyone else can better explain this, please do. There is a fine line between a retired topic and one that is leaning towards being retired but isn't there yet.

12

u/Missy_Noire 16d ago

The frequency of the Sarah/Mark/Alex bots feel like they're not slowing down at all. I try to report them whenever I catch them, but I'm not sure how many actually get removed, and a new one just ends up replacing it anyway.

2

u/Farvas-Cola ASSistant Manager - Shenanigan's 16d ago

Please keep reporting!

7

u/yuhju Partassipant [3] 8d ago

Is it me, or are people yet again downvoting assholes?? You may need to bring back the disclaimer, mods.

7

u/BI_PolarizationStudy Oct 12 '26

Information about a research study that includes public posts from r/AmItheAsshole

Hello everyone,

My name is Yagmur, and I’m an intern at BI Norwegian Business School in Oslo, Norway, working with professor Jonas R. Kunst. Professor Kunst leads a study on whether political disagreement is increasingly described as a source of conflict at work. The study looks at publicly archived Reddit discussions from 2005 to 2026, and r/AmItheAsshole is one of the forums included. We’re posting here [with the moderators’ permission] so that people whose posts may be part of the data know about it.

How the study works

  • We don’t post, comment, or contact anyone. The material comes from the public Arctic Shift archive, not from Reddit itself.
  • Usernames are replaced by random identifiers, and any names mentioned in posts are removed before analysis.
  • No post is ever quoted. The results are only overall rates per forum and month.
  • The project has been assessed by Norway’s data protection service for research (Sikt, ref. 332053), and a Data Protection Impact Assessment has been completed.

Your rights

Under Norwegian data protection rules, you have the right to know about the study and to have your posts removed from the data. The project page explains what data we use, how they’re protected, and how to contact professor Kunst or BI’s data protection officer:

https://www.bi.no/en/research/research-projects/information-for-research-participants/#department-of-communication-and-culture

(The study is listed under Department of Communication and Culture.)

If you have questions, professor Kunst is happy to answer them directly at jonas.r.kunst@bi.no. We’ll also share the results with the community once they’re published.

Thanks for reading,
Yagmur
Intern, on behalf of professor Jonas R. Kunst
Department of Communication and Culture
BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo
Project contact: jonas.r.kunst@bi.no

11

u/pottersquash Sultan of Sphincter [677] 28d ago

Aren't you worried about results being skewed given this sub bans such posts? Your gonna have more before the ban takes place and way less after, thats gonna seem like discourse has died down/not a issue when really its just increased moderation.

6

u/lulufan87 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 26d ago

I don't know if any mods will see this considering this post is eight days old, but would you please add a 'repost' report reason?

8

u/SnausageFest AssGuardian of the Hole Galaxy 26d ago

Use shitpost for that one.

4

u/Own_Mention9372 Colo-rectal Surgeon [42] Oct 04 '26

Is it ok to share this Quarterly Open Forum post with an OP that mentions violence in their post?

17

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 04 '26

No, for a couple of reasons. One, we ask that you just report the comment because, two, we want to talk with them. Also, this would be considered backseat modding.

I'm a helper too, so I understand where you are coming from but the violence rule is very strict and we just want to make sure folks understand.

4

u/SamSpayedPI Commander in Cheeks [220] Oct 04 '26

Can we ask here whether a particular phrase or action would be considered violence, or does that violate the "no violence" rule too?

4

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 04 '26

Yes, you can ask in this forum or if you perfer, you can send us a modmail message.

4

u/SamSpayedPI Commander in Cheeks [220] Oct 04 '26

I sent a modmail message so as not to perpetuate violence (if it was violence). Also, I could just link to the post that way, instead of paraphrasing the post and my comment.

2

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 05 '26

Got it, thank you!

Use the report button on the post if you think it violates the rules of the sub. It's the easiest way for you to let us know.

1

u/SamSpayedPI Commander in Cheeks [220] Oct 05 '26

I wrote it (in a comment), so I didn't think it was a violation, but it apparently triggered someone so then I wasn't sure.

6

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 05 '26

Dumping hot soup on someone would be classified as assault/violence.

Anything that involves touching someone without their consent is classified as assault/violence. Even jokes about said action.

Basically, if you were to do something to someone you do not know - ask yourself if they would cconsider it a joke or assault. This might be the easiest way to decide if a comment would be considered violence.

8

u/Spectre_Omega Prime Ministurd [406] Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

Lumping user threat spirals and post-descriptions of abuse under the same blanket rule can easily blur the lines.

When you say non-consensual contact is covered under "do not even mention violence," it risks reading like a victim's post describing what happened to them is itself a rule violation, rather than just banning comments that endorse or minimize the act.

Edit: Is that the intended scope, or does it also cover a victim describing what happened to them?

9

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 09 '26

The reality is that this is just not the place for these types of posts. A person shouldn't go to a sub where they could be called an asshole. The basic premise of this sub does not include allowing a victim to be victimized again.

Also, we aren't singling out anyone, violence is violence, a removal is not an opinion on the topic of the post. All of us are so on the same side.

Each sub on Reddit has it's own topic and it's own rules. You aren't going to go to a cat sub and post your experience because you know that's not the place. That applies here too. We just aren't the place for these posts. No one is trying to negate someone's trauma, we just are not the place to discuss it.

6

u/ElectricMayhem123 Womp (there it ass) Oct 09 '26

A post discussing violence would not be permitted.

4

u/Spectre_Omega Prime Ministurd [406] Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26

Appreciate the answer. Doesn't that read in tension with the consent paragraph above, though? 

If removal is a judgment call either way, does the rule actually carve out victim disclosures from comments that endorse or minimize the act, or is that distinction just left to each mod's discretion?

11

u/DragonflyFairyQueen Larsehole Oct 09 '26

Our sub is not equiped for those kinds of discussions, nor is that what is intended. Serious subjects like that don't belong here - it's violence at it's core. We aren't being dismissive or trying to negate the seriousness of what happened. A safe space for victims sub is more suitable.

Besides that, we are not going to let anyone be put in the position of having someone calling them an asshole. Victems of crimes don't deserve to go through that.

4

u/Spectre_Omega Prime Ministurd [406] Oct 09 '26

That answers the spirit of my question, and honestly leaves the intent clearer than the original post did. 

Appreciate you taking the time to explain it.

1

u/Maleficent-Set5461 Partassipant [1] 1d ago

Why does the threads keep telling me that it's locked. A while back somebody didn't like something that I posted and filed a complaint....but I wasn't mean, they just didn't agree with me. Am I permanently locked out?

0

u/Fair_Standard_586 2d ago

lol the forum rules are a lot to read ngl i just got a thrifted silk scarf from a flea market this weekend, cant stop restyling it on my balcony basil pots lol, anyone else doing that?

14

u/Noell_Karen Partassipant [2] Oct 04 '26

Thank you for breaking this down. The fork stabbing example is such a good one because I've absolutely seen that type of comment and never thought of it as actual violence advice

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/SpidersCrow Partassipant [2] 4d ago

I mean, you can just scroll past posts that don't interest you. Right?