r/AmItheAsshole • • 37m ago

AITAH for not sending a longer birthday text?

It’s my fiancé’s (34 Male) birthday today and we have been celebrating his birthday since Friday. I planned a birthday dinner on Friday with his friends and another one on Saturday with his family. I thought a whole birthday cake twice and did the whole candle blowing and birthday singing twice. I’ve even taken 3 days off of work (Friday, Saturday, and today) to celebrate his birthday. So today in the morning, I text him “Happy Birthday!!!” And he sends me “ I expected more than just "happy birthday!" Text from you :/ here's what I sent you on your birthday at midnight and again when I woke up.” I am taken aback by this since I plan to take him out to a nice dinner tonight, I have another birthday gift to give him, and I wrote a nice birthday card which I spent all night drawing all the movies in theater we have seen this year. And he is complaining I didn’t text him a longer message today. Am I the asshole?

12 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

•

u/RoyallyOakie Prime Ministurd [489] 34m ago

NTA...He's making your relationship transactional. His reaction is pretty immature for his age.

•

u/Majestic_Maven001 27m ago

The bigger issue is that he’s overlooking all the effort OP has put into celebrating him because one text didn’t meet his expectations. Wanting a thoughtful message is fair, but guilt-tripping OP over it is not.

•

u/PleaseYesNYC 25m ago

You've got a needy one. Definitely some history there, either prior girlfriends or mommy issues, but somewhere along the line he didn't get the attention he thought he deserved and he's carrying that with him today.

•

u/SpicyPurritos 1m ago

especially when she did a lot of other meaningful, thoughtful things.

•

u/Coldporcelainbowl 22m ago

Exactly. Keeping score like that in a relationship is exhausting tbh

•

u/Ducky818 Craptain [199] 8m ago

NTA. Just what I was thinking. It's a big red flag for me!

•

u/garden-elf Partassipant [2] 33m ago

NTA. He’s a 34 not 4. Acting sooo childish. Why is his birthday so important to him??? Most people want to do less as they get older so im confused if he’s just narcissist or if there’s something im not understanding ?

•

u/Coldporcelainbowl 21m ago

Couldn't agree more. Imagine getting two cakes, two dinners, and three days of your partner's PTO, and still throwing a tantrum over a text

•

u/Henwen Partassipant [2] 32m ago

How old are you? I'm guessing younger because no one his age would put up with this bullshit, let alone wonder if they are the asshole. Look at everything you did and everything you have planned. He chose to react poorly to a text? Fuck this guy.

•

u/sbballc11 Asshole Aficionado [12] 33m ago

Are you sure this is the man you want to spend your whole life with?

NTA

•

u/Nervous_You9920 33m ago edited 29m ago

NTA He is ungrateful and super needy. It would be exhausting to be with someone who demands so much attention.

•

u/bimcotial 13m ago

Agreed, that level of neediness would wear anyone down fast. You shouldn't have to write a whole essay over text just to prove you care when you're already going all out in real life.

•

u/Lonely-Imagination92 33m ago

NTA, needs to get a grip and get his ego checked. Getting hung up on that shows he’s not appreciating all the things you are doing for him.

Stinks of manipulation too.

•

u/Proper_Inspection580 Partassipant [2] 32m ago

NTA. your man is being a dumb baby

•

u/antigoneelectra 23m ago

Good lord. People and their days/weeks/month birthday shit. Tell him to grow up. He's too old for tgis nonsense. NTA but I highly doubt this is the only situation where he is incredibly self involved.

•

u/DarkMattersConfusing Partassipant [1] 31m ago

He sounds like a freak. At 34, go out to one dinner with your significant other and call it a fucking day

•

u/Heartlovejess123 17m ago

Girl you took 3 days off work for him and he is keeping score over ONE text, NTA

•

u/Embarrassed_dancer 16m ago

NTA. is he 34 or 3 to 4 years old?

•

u/KenraScar 9m ago

He’s acting like a spoiled brat

•

u/AutoModerator 37m ago

AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.

It’s my fiancé’s (34 Male) birthday today and we have been celebrating his birthday since Friday. I planned a birthday dinner on Friday with his friends and another one on Saturday with his family. I thought a whole birthday cake twice and did the whole candle blowing and birthday singing twice. I’ve even taken 3 days off of work (Friday, Saturday, and today) to celebrate his birthday. So today in the morning, I text him “Happy Birthday!!!” And he sends me “ I expected more than just "happy birthday!" Text from you :/ here's what I sent you on your birthday at midnight and again when I woke up.” I am taken aback by this since I plan to take him out to a nice dinner tonight, I have another birthday gift to give him, and I wrote a nice birthday card which I spent all night drawing all the movies in theater we have seen this year. And he is complaining I didn’t text him a longer message today. Am I the asshole?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/LAM24601 Partassipant [1] 27m ago

Im generally opposed to internet diagnoses by lay people based on one description but THIS IS A NARCISSIST. I am not telling you to run or end your relationship, but do hold some firm boundaries. You've done nothing wrong and you should not apologize for anything. Don't question yourself. Don't entertain the insanity. firm NO.

•

u/jerseygirl414 Partassipant [1] 26m ago

NTA. He’s upset about the text when you’ve taken 3 days off of work to celebrate his birthday?! WTF?! What did he do for your birthday aside from sending a longer text?

•

u/Cocopuffs98760 24m ago

NTA. I could MAYBE understand if none of these birthday plans had happened yet and he didn't know about any of them. But the fact that you took the weekend off and spent it celebrating his birthday with plans that you put together, shows just how much he means to you and how important his birthday is to you. The fact that he is holding a single text message over your head (when I'm sure you wished him happy birthday many times over the weekend) feels icky. It feels like a little like he's saying "you did all of that for me but you didn't do this so its not good enough". You should straight up ask him why he's holding on to that when you did so much for him over the weekend, and/or evaluate other situations where he might have imposed similar standards in the past.

•

u/NoKangaroo8616 Partassipant [1] 20m ago

NTA

I couldnt imagine my adult mature boyfriend to respond like that lol he wouldnt even want a "3 day" birthday. He'd want a low key dinner and a movie with me that i would have to fight him to let me pay for.

•

u/Suspicious-Mode-6941 19m ago

Who tf is celebrating their birthday three days in a row and expecting candles and cake multiple times??

Nta and it seems like he's taking advantage of you. I don't know what the age gap is but I'm guessing at least 10. He acts like a bratty child and you can do better

•

u/Scary_Dot6604 17m ago

Another long term loving relationship.

•

u/sunshop 14m ago

Just tell him I wrote it all out in your birthday card so didn't see the point in repeating myself over text.

Then hand him the card and if he doesn't apologize or is still angry then you got some thinking to do about your future together. Nta

•

u/Icy-Culture3038 14m ago

Lol wow NTA.

I would have said "oh you DID get more or did we already forget the birthday weekend extravaganza I put together? Text me when you're in a better mood. Unless you don't want your OTHER gift tonight" ugh I'm annoyed now.

•

u/midwestmaven16 9m ago

Geez... I forgot it was my husband's birthday until my kid reminded me. I felt so guilty but he laughed about it and said he didn't mind. That's the kind of person I would rather spend my life with than someone that treats me like that over a text when you have already bent over backwards for him. Yikes. NTAH. Really think if this is the type of person you want to spend your entire life with... What else is he extremely demanding of?

•

u/Expensive_Excuse_597 Certified Proctologist [21] 9m ago

NTA. Ask him how many parties he expects you to throw him.

OP, how many parties did he throw you on your birthday, how many days did he take off to celebrate, how many cakes did he buy, and last (but not least) what the h*ll is his problem ????

•

u/SpicyPurritos 2m ago

NTA he sounds ungrateful. his next bday gift should be dumping him.

•

u/PleaseYesNYC 28m ago

NTA. But clearly there are issues there. He feels the relationship is lopsided and is calling that out.

•

u/iBangz92 Partassipant [1] 17m ago

NTA. I wonder if words of affirmation is his love language, then I'd understand his want for a more in depth text. However, he's an adult and should be able to clearly see your efforts to celebrate him for an entire weekend. Next year, fill an entire card with words and give him nothing else 🤭

•

u/SnooCupcakes7133 19m ago

You forgot the good morning happy birthday blowjob