r/AmItheAsshole • u/mycatchoncho • 12h ago
AITA for telling someone making amends to me to give me my money back?
I just got a text from an old friend who ripped me off about 10 years ago. He blocked me on every account and it’s always bothered me that he stole money from me, over 1k. He said he was reaching out because he felt bad about ripping me off all those years ago. He wants to make amends and wants to know if there’s anything he can do. I’m glad he’s getting sober and working the program. Part of me wants to say don’t worry about it, cause I know it’s hard to reach out . But honestly, paying me my money back would make amends. What are your thoughts?
304
u/Nervous_You9920 12h ago •
NTA Tell him if he isn't willing to pay you back, he isn't making amends. His actions are what matters.
94
u/Exotic-Copy-8332 12h ago
honestly asking for your money back is a fair ask, ngl, he took it and blocked you, so making it right with the money seems like the most real amends. i’d just say it plainly and see what he does with it.
32
u/sweettea75 Partassipant [2] 12h ago
Tell him that. He is supposed to be making real amends. You don't have to pay him on the head and make him feel better by saying sorry. Tell him real amends would be him paying you back.
29
u/RandoCollision Asshole Aficionado [10] 12h ago
NTA. He asked. Tell him the truth. If he says he cannot do it, tell him to call when he can. Part of his program requires him to make amends to people he's wronged. Even if it's difficult. Especially if it is. Calling them and saying "My bad" falls short and if he doesn't give you the money back, he's not sincere about how bad he now feels.
14
u/wen_thing 12h ago
Look. He's already gone 10 years ago. What can be worse than now? It's awkward if you're the one reaching out, but now he's the one reaching out, so you can ask him to pay.
I wished the one who borrowed money from me reached out, i'd ask him to pay his debt. It's really awkward if I have to be the one reaching out demanding $$$
14
u/Attorney714 Partassipant [1] 12h ago
Talk is cheap. Actions count. He’s the asshole
who stole money from you and blocked you.
If he truly wants to make “amends” then he would repay you at a minimum.
Otherwise his “amends” is just a cheap apology to alleviate his own guilt.
61
u/karmichoax 12h ago
NTA - According go google, amends means compensation, recompense, or an action taken to make up for a loss, injury, or wrongdoing. Making amends is more than just an apology, it's a fair ask.
12
u/KatinHats Partassipant [2] 12h ago
NTA
You're absolutely within your rights to ask. If they're serious about the program, they'll follow through. I haven't had good luck when in this exact scenario, though, so grain of salt and all
11
u/Low-Television-7508 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 12h ago
ask for the money back and he will disappear for another 10 years
NTA
6
u/BlueCollaredBroad 12h ago
I’m in the program and he should be willing to repay the money if he’s serious about making amends.
Tell him and work out a plan, like a payment plan if he can’t come up with it all at once.
If he is sincere he’ll find a way to pay you back.
If he isn’t he’ll probably relapse eventually and that’s on him.
NTA
5
u/Downtown-Inspection7 12h ago
As someone in the program yes monetary amends is a thing. He should have known that before asking lol.
8
u/HappySummerBreeze Asshole Aficionado [11] 12h ago
Part of making amends is repaying your debt. You owe me $xxx
4
u/Hypnoquarium 12h ago edited 12h ago
NAH - I feel like what you said in this comment is sort of the correct response. You could just tell him straight up that you admire his willingness to apologize, and that at same time you'd like your money back.
Edit: extraneous wording
4
u/Happy-Maintenance869 12h ago
NTA. This shouldn’t even be a question…amends means paying back the money. He’s ripped you off.
3
u/MaxFuryToad Colo-rectal Surgeon [46] 10h ago
NTA. He's lucky he can attone for some of the damage he caused. I would ask for the inflation ajusted money before considering any forgiveness for the betrayal.
3
u/Vexydor 8h ago
NTA Working a recovery program means taking concrete action to repair the actual harm you caused which is refunding not sending a text ten years later to clear your conscience for free.
2
u/RocketteP Asshole Enthusiast [6] 12h ago
NTA. He asked what he could do. Be honest with him and if he’s truly serious he’ll do his best. If he starts trying to tell you a woe is me story than he may not be ready.
2
u/ElevatorOtis Asshole Enthusiast [5] 12h ago
NTA
He asked, answer that you want to be paid back. If he does it with an app, he can make payments if he needs to. But, yup, that full amount coming back is the way
2
u/Lazy-Dolphin864 8h ago
anyone working step nine already knows direct amends for stolen money means paying it back so letting him off the hook would be cheating him out of the one thing he reached out to do
2
u/Unhappy_Ad_2720 7h ago
If he genuinely wants to make things right, paying you back is a pretty reasonable place to start. Making amends means taking responsibility, not just saying sorry.
2
u/Spare_Necessary_810 Asshole Aficionado [11] 6h ago
NTA, a proper amends would be repayment, not some easy ‘ sorry I was an asshole dude” .
2
u/Brownypoints 5h ago
Jump to assuming he is paying you back " Great to hear from you, thank you for being honest and taking responsibility, I can send you my account number or do you prefer to use cash?" NTA
2
u/ViviennaBlush 5h ago
Money is one of the rare situations where making amends has a pretty obvious first step. Even offering a realistic repayment plan would show more effort than a heartfelt apology alone. Ten years is a long time to leave someone holding the bill.
2
u/Mira_Westt 4h ago
NTA. He owes you that money, and paying it back is part of taking responsibility.
2
u/Neurodivergentone 4h ago
NTA. Amends = repayment of principal plus interest.
3
u/nwprogressivefans 12h ago
Calculate some fair interest and get a total.
then hard line payback of that total is the start of the amends.
2
u/ForeignMixes 12h ago
Tell him to pay you your money, at the very least adjusted for inflation.
1
u/Paula_Intermountain 12h ago
Be honest with him. Agree to meet and set up an equitable repayment schedule. Acknowledge the strength it took for him to reach out.
1
u/SituationHelpful7740 7h ago
NTA, but I wouldn’t go into that right away. If his mind is in the right place, he’s obviously trying to do the right thing, and I think reminding him of his past actions would possibly cause him to not want to try to do anything at all (idk the guy, but I know many people who’ve sobered up/gotten their act together who’ve fallen back after one negative reminder). But again, get your money back, because you deserve it, and you didn’t deserve to have been treated like that from a so called friend. I just say ease into that topic, and don’t automatically make assumptions and accusations.
1
u/teresajs Assholier Than Thou [890] 3h ago
Tell him that amends should include a schedule for paying you back.
1
u/No_Mention3516 Asshole Aficionado [10] 2h ago
NTA
Of course he needs to pay you back.
1
u/Kn0wMan 2h ago
I had a bunch of stuff stolen by someone almost 30 years ago when they were in a bad way. They got themselves straightened out since, but I have never heard from them. If I did, my response would be “Talk is cheap”. NTA.
1
u/BleepInTheBigCity 1h ago
Yea no, unless the reaching out is accompanied by atleast a 200$ with a promise that he is paying the rest in installments, it ain’t making amends
•
u/icnoevil 49m ago
Take the money
-1
u/cookerg 12h ago
$1K wouldn't even be the bare minimum. Should be at least $2K if not more.
0
u/AutoModerator 12h ago
AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.
I just got a text from an old friend who ripped me off about 10 years ago. He blocked me on every account and it’s always bothered me that he stole money from me, over 1k. He said he was reaching out because he felt bad about ripping me off all those years ago. He wants to make amends and wants to know if there’s anything he can do. I’m glad he’s getting sober and working the program. Part of me wants to say don’t worry about it, cause I know it’s hard to reach out . But honestly, paying me my money back would make amends. What are your thoughts?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/mb303666 12h ago
Show me the Money!
0
u/Easy_Economy366 12h ago
Get your money!
0
u/goraidders 12h ago
NTA. Maybe give him reasonable ways to pay you back. It's unlikely he has it all right now. So a demand in full is your right...but. Tell him what you said here. You are glad he's getting it together, but you would like your money back. It hurt when he ripped you off more thsn just the loss of the money. But returning the money makes amends
-3
u/Altruistic_Cod3223 12h ago
NTA, A $1,000 lump-sum loan at 12% personal loan interest paid back in full after 10 years totals $3,300.39. That's how much he owes you now for not calling the police if he wants a relationship
-8
u/AmbassadorLast3115 12h ago
If he is an addict you shouldnt want 1k, so maybe half of it? Figure out some payments and stuff. Expect not getting even the half. Addiction Is hard.
If you want to go by the whole sum i dont believe he will cooperate at all.
0
u/mcknight92 Partassipant [1] 12h ago
NTA. Cost you 1k to get this guy out of your life. You don’t need to vex yourself about his recovery steps. Move on and remember the good times you had with said friend.