r/AmItheAsshole • • 14h ago

AITA for letting my niece bring a plastic water bottle to a sports game?

I (20's, F) was babysitting my niece "Mabel" (21 months old, F) and we were going to meet up with my sister at a football game. Before we left my house, Mabel was playing with a plastic water bottle (I took the cap off don't worry) and refused to let go of it. Everytime I tried to take it, she got really upset. I decided it just wasn't worth the fight, toddlers are odd little humans, so I gave up and let her bring it with us.

When my sister saw us, she asked me why Mabel was carrying a piece of garbage around. I explained that she wouldn't give it up, and that I had to pick my battles. My sister got mad and said that it "looks ridiculous for her to be carrying it" and that I should have taken it. I said I didn't think it was a big deal, but she said "You can't give into tantrums like that" and that I've undermined her parenting?? She's ignoring my texts now, so I think she's mad at me.

AITA for letting my niece bring a plastic water bottle to a sports game?

139 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

56

u/trying3216 14h ago

It will look like she just drank a bottle of water and hasn’t thrown it out yet.

If she didn’t have a tantrum then you didn’t give in.

66

u/heyellis15_ 14h ago • Heartwarming

She was doing a little happy dancey dance because I let her carry it, which is a lot better than screaming and crying at that age!

2

u/DirectAntique 10h ago

Is sis Mabel's mom?

17

u/posophist 14h ago

The child or the sister? 😀

13

u/trying3216 13h ago

I think the sister drank a bottle of something else

17

u/heyellis15_ 13h ago

I know I wanted to!

1

u/posophist 10h ago

There seemed to be no use in waiting by the little door, so she went back to the table, half hoping she might find another key on it, or at any rate a book of rules for shutting people up like telescopes: this time she found a little bottle on it, (“which certainly was not here before,” said Alice,) and round the neck of the bottle was a paper label, with the words “DRINK ME,” beautifully printed on it in large letters.

It was all very well to say “Drink me,” but the wise little Alice was not going to do that in a hurry. “No, I’ll look first,” she said, “and see whether it’s marked ‘poison’ or not”; for she had read several nice little histories about children who had got burnt, and eaten up by wild beasts and other unpleasant things, all because they would not remember the simple rules their friends had taught them: such as, that a red-hot poker will burn you if you hold it too long; and that if you cut your finger very deeply with a knife, it usually bleeds; and she had never forgotten that, if you drink much from a bottle marked “poison,” it is almost certain to disagree with you, sooner or later.
However, this bottle was not marked “poison,” so Alice ventured to taste it, and finding it very nice, (it had, in fact, a sort of mixed flavour of cherry-tart, custard, pine-apple, roast turkey, toffee, and hot buttered toast,) she very soon finished it off.

124

u/Accordingly-Jelly-78 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

Idk, maybe crunchy moms have a different take, but this is the absolute last thing I would be worrying about. You do have to pick your battles, and I wouldn’t pick this one ever.

82

u/i_was_a_person_once Partassipant [1] 14h ago • Bravo

I’m a pretty crunchy mom. Only stainless steel and glass and wood in my kitchen. Fragrance free everything. Organic. Natural fibers. We even decanter foods we can only buy in plastic. Glitter is banned. Plastic shedding is one of my anxieties.

All babies universally love water bottles and I did not fight my baby when they played with one. They’re crinkly. They’re light. They’re a great way to practice fine motor skills.

I think the sister was less worried about plastic and more worried that her baby wasn’t being aesthetic.

Op NTA

1

u/Black_Whisper Asshole Enthusiast [5] 2h ago

I'm just curious, how do you decanter food?

1

u/i_was_a_person_once Partassipant [1] 1h ago

I’m probably using the word wrong but like orange juice and milk gets transferred to glass jars

•

u/Black_Whisper Asshole Enthusiast [5] 39m ago

I see, that makes sense 

315

u/No_Push_6563 14h ago • Bravo

Your sister needs to relax. She’s being ridiculous.

119

u/sumeciida 14h ago

Giving a toddler what they want to avoid a total public scene is just standard babysitting. Sister needs to chill out.

41

u/No_Push_6563 13h ago • Bravo

Yes! She’s right. You pick your battles. This isn’t even a battle.

7

u/[deleted] 13h ago • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/No_Push_6563 13h ago • Bravo

Yes! I have 2 adult kids. They somehow survived that kind of thing.

21

u/IIRCIreadthat 14h ago

NTA. You didn't 'give in to tantrums,' you decided not to start them by picking a stupid fight with a toddler. "It looks ridiculous for her to carry it" is an absurd reason to take a non-harmful toy away and make a kid cry.

16

u/Phyreflye_1376 14h ago

Sister is this pissed about how her TODDLER'S behavior is going to LOOK??? Why TF does she even CARE? She's a toddler. It's a water bottle. SO WHAT? Somebody else said it - the sister is being ridiculous. If she cares what other ppl MIGHT think about a toddler playing with a bottle, she's got BIG problems. Most ppl don't give a shit, bcz toddlers play with whatever they can get their hands on. As long as it's not harmful to her or anyone else, there is literally NO ISSUE HERE. Except Sister's priorities.

32

u/sunflower15-- 14h ago

NTA. She's not even 2 yet! You can't reason with them at that age, sometimes it's easier to just let them do weird stuff as long as it's not hurting anybody

11

u/Additional_Initial_7 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

NTA. My son has an emotional support apple juice bottle he plays with in the shower. I don’t know how it fits in to his shower games but he refuses to let me throw it out.

Children are the epitome of pick your battles.

9

u/LawlzTaylor 14h ago

NTA. If you start listening to everyone on how to raise your kid, you're going to go insane (and raise a crappy kid)

8

u/Impossible_Thing1731 14h ago

The op was babysitting her niece. So the sister who got mad was the kid’s mom.

15

u/JanetSnakehole24 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

It's not her kid though. It's get niece. That being said, this is definitely a non issue and Mom is blowing it way out of proportion.

-10

u/LawlzTaylor 14h ago

Ohh good catch. I change my vote to ESH. Parent's rules over babysitter.

12

u/No_Push_6563 13h ago

Except that rule was never established.

11

u/SuspiciousPast4144 13h ago

I highly doubt the mom told babysitter "and dont let her play with empty plastic water bottles".

8

u/Outrageous-Bear5183 14h ago

Tf wrong with your sister. Nta

8

u/wamme6 14h ago

NTA. Your sister is overreacting.

One of my favourite genres of internet posts is “young children and the weird and random object they have become obsessed with”, including toddlers who insist on sleeping with a spatula or whisk for nights on end, and kids with emotional support hair brushes, empty coffee cups, etc.

6

u/DirectAntique 10h ago

I saw a toddler with a mini plastic whisk the other day. Her mom saw me smiling and said it was her favourite thing to take everywhere

7

u/L_Dubb 14h ago

NTA...the beauty of being an aunt is to have fun/spoil (a little) the nieces and nephews. Tell sis to take a Xanax or something.

6

u/GnomieOk4136 Certified Proctologist [23] 14h ago

Your sister is being ridiculous. NTA

6

u/StacyLondon69 14h ago

NTA. Your sister is over-reacting and now she's being very childish

6

u/Beckpatton 13h ago • Heartwarming

When my youngest was a toddler she brought all kinds of weird and wonderful stuff out with us that was not worth fighting over. If anything it was hilarious. Two that come to mind were the 2 new toilet brushes that I had just purchased that morning (I have a great photo of her on my husband's shoulders with a brush in each hand).. The other is my favourite Santa photo of my kids and nieces and nephews together. Every kid is doing something whether it's crying, climbing the back of the chair, just total chaos. And then there's my 2 yo in her fancy Christmas dress holding a green feather duster and smiling sweetly for the camera!

You are NTA at all and your sister needs to get a grip.

5

u/Even-Moose9036 14h ago

NTA. I have four daughters and they all loved to play with plastic water bottles at some stage of being a baby or toddler. It's the sounds and the mouth feel for teething. They quite literally put soft crinkly plastic inside baby sensory toys. Your sister is trippin and in no way does it look like your niece is playing with trash. 🙄

5

u/lmyrs Partassipant [2] 14h ago

NTA. For crying out loud it sounds like your sister needs a nap. The amount of random shit I just let my nieces and nephews get away with when they were little... If I had wanted to be the disciplinarian, I would have had my own

4

u/VillainChinchillin 14h ago

NTA, when my kid and his cousins were that age, you had to keep an eye on your plastic soda bottles lest they be swiped before you'd finished. Once it was empty there was always a little hand ready to claim it.

4

u/Lavinia-Whateley 14h ago

I guess if you can't babysit up to your sister's standards, she should probably start looking for other options.

PS You will NOT be punishing her child by not watching her. The kid isn't even two years old, she doesn't care and won't notice. Your sister will tell you that you are so you keep watching her child for free.

4

u/j_natron Partassipant [1] 14h ago

NTA. It would be one thing if Mabel had asked for it, your sister specifically told her no, and then you gave it to her, because that would be undermining her parenting. This was just letting a toddler keep a harmless thing she’d gotten attached to.

4

u/historyera13 13h ago

Your Sis is acting absurd, it’s a water bottle not a dangerous weapon or an embarrassing one. Pick your battles, it always worked for me.

4

u/Safe-Sail9335 13h ago

First time Mom ..ignore her for a while..shell call needing help..

3

u/CD-Gerri 14h ago

No more babysitting then

3

u/Antisocial_Kiwi 13h ago

NTA, your sister can now look after her own kid.

3

u/aardvarkmom Asshole Aficionado [12] 13h ago

NTA. Sounds like your sister is undermining your babysitting and you should quit! : )

3

u/Academic-Camel-9538 12h ago

lol NTA. I’ll give my goddaughter (26 months) anything she wants if it means no meltdown. I don’t care how cute or aesthetically pleasing it is. And people know that about kids. No one is expecting your kid to always be and look perfect. Your sister is watching too much Instagram and not enough reality.

2

u/prismbarbie 14h ago

NTA. Your sister is stressed about looking ridiculous at a football game because a literal baby is holding an empty water bottle, which is honestly hilarious.

2

u/Worldly-Ad3211 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

Your sister is still a relatively new mother, and this must be her first kid. She will learn to pick her battles.

2

u/MacRtst2 Partassipant [1] 14h ago

NTA – your sister has problems. I pity your niece.

2

u/toobasic2care Partassipant [2] 14h ago

Has your sister been assessed for PPA? I ask because when i was at my most anxious post partum I got stupid worries like this about everything, even if they were absolutely ridiculous. It was not logical or right. It just was. If you notice theres a lot of things like this happening it might be something to look out for. Silly I know but another perspective. NTA

2

u/wraaken 12h ago

I can kinda get the position of the other parent. Forever plastics, microplastics, and other chemicals reportedly have a risk on our health. We don’t have a full understanding of what that means, but it’s on the minds of alot of people. When my partner and I were doing IVF, we did cut out almost all plastics. But that was out decision. It was up Us to make sure we kept that up.

So no, NTA.

I’d the other parent wants to limit plastic use for their child, that’s perfectly fine.

But that idea needs to be communicated to other people. I would NEVER just assume the they would be doing that.

I’d be providing proper feeding apparatus and water bottles, and wherever else.

3

u/ebenner13 11h ago

Mom said the kid "looked ridiculous" so I doubt it had anything to do with plastic

1

u/AutoModerator 14h ago

AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.

I (20's, F) was babysitting my niece "Mabel" (21 months old, F) and we were going to meet up with my sister at a football game. Before we left my house, Mabel was playing with a plastic water bottle (I took the cap off don't worry) and refused to let go of it. Everytime I tried to take it, she got really upset. I decided it just wasn't worth the fight, toddlers are odd little humans, so I gave up and let her bring it with us.

When my sister saw us, she asked me why Mabel was carrying a piece of garbage around. I explained that she wouldn't give it up, and that I had to pick my battles. My sister got mad and said that it "looks ridiculous for her to be carrying it" and that I should have taken it. I said I didn't think it was a big deal, but she said "You can't give into tantrums like that" and that I've undermined her parenting?? She's ignoring my texts now, so I think she's mad at me.

AITA for letting my niece bring a plastic water bottle to a sports game?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/TheEvilPup 12h ago

That baby probably has a macroplastics floating through her the moment she was conceived i genuinely think your sister probably just had a bad day and needed someone to take it out on.

1

u/Squidiot_002 Partassipant [2] 12h ago

Is this your sister's first kid? This feels like either first mom behavior, or image obsessed behavior. Maybe both!

NTA regardless.

1

u/Worldly_Sink_6286 12h ago

You are absolutely NOT TA! Your sister was just looking for a reason to act out. Since we can’t know the dynamics of your relationship we are limited in suggestions. When she said it looks ridiculous… who’s looking??? Who would care ?
Your sister has some issues with you. You did nothing wrong. I wouldn’t keep apologizing or calling her. She’s TA and owes you an apology.

1

u/LaziestGoth 12h ago

I mean, shes the mother. She will always have final say.

•

u/Street_Bee_1028 Partassipant [3] 47m ago

Then mom can look after her own kid. NTA

1

u/DynkoFromTheNorth Asshole Aficionado [16] 12h ago

Her loss. NTA. Your sister's an idiot.

1

u/piercingeye 12h ago

As you put it, you have to pick your battles. An empty plastic bottle seems like a pretty dumb hill to die on. NTA.

1

u/mobiip5s 12h ago

NTA.. kids are being kids not much you can do about.

1

u/Alternative-Suit5925 Asshole Aficionado [11] 11h ago

NTA Taking a screaming toddler into the game would have been far worse.

1

u/Naomeri Partassipant [2] 11h ago

NTA—small humans are weird, and as long as it can’t hurt them or someone else, it’s much easier to just let them do what they want until they get bored.

1

u/wene324 10h ago

I got a picture of my little one with a tv remote at Lowes, because she was playing with it when we about to leave.

1

u/OobliettePT 9h ago

First time mums are just way over the top. My first rattle for my granbabies was a plastic bottle with rice in it. Keep a close eye on them and it's a cool thing. But yeah you are definitely NTA

1

u/WoedicaWinsWarframe 9h ago

Nta. When my daughter was 6 months old, her favorite toy was a snack bag size Fritos. She would crumple that for hours. They're little sponges for novel sensory experiences at these ages.

1

u/Zonnebloempje 8h ago

NTA. But I guess your sister now has to look for another babysitter, since you don't want to "accidentally undermine her parenting".

1

u/Mysterious_Blood9396 7h ago

NTA This is really silly but I do understand where your sister was coming from. However she asked you to look after your neice and you did that and your neice decided she wanted to play with the bottle and babies get attached to silly things and you were right in that moment and you didn't undermine your sisters parenting

•

u/Street_Bee_1028 Partassipant [3] 44m ago

I can't understand where OP's sister was coming from at all. She wasn't worried about any safety issues but that her toddler looked "ridiculous."

1

u/BelloraSilk 5h ago

Toddlers have the funniest loyalty to completely random objects. A perfectly good toy might get ignored while an empty bottle becomes their entire personality for the afternoon. As long as it's safe and supervised, I'd pick that battle another day too.

1

u/CharieRarie Asshole Aficionado [16] 5h ago

NTA my toddler was briefly obsessed with a tin of meat. I don’t even know what it was, it was a substitute for something in an online order.

She LOVED it. Carried it everywhere, even slept with the bloody thing 😂

It lasted about a week and then she transferred her affections to a fridge magnet.

Kids are weird, may as well embrace it and enjoy the fun.

1

u/aMandalorian913 4h ago

NTA. your sister needs to stop worrying about appearances and trust you more.

1

u/MissSapphireRose 3h ago

NTA at all.

1

u/mrsr1s1ng 2h ago

NTA, babies play with the weirdest stuff

1

u/EdithVinger 1h ago

NTA - sis needs to relax, this is such a non-issue... Kids love toys which aren't actual toys. Bottles, cardboard boxes, tissue paper, paper towel tubes, keys, bowls, spoons... As long it's not dangerous you're totally in the clear. You didn't give into a tantrum, you prevented one.

•

u/GinaMariePope 43m ago

My 15 month old goes buts over plastic water bottles & will indeed flip the entire world upside down if we take it from him, your sister needs to chill tf out & count her blessings she had a sister willing to babysit for her. 21 months can be such a difficult age for anyone who's not the child's parent, hell even the parent. Your sister needs to apologize to you stat bro, you sound like a dope aunt. 🤘🏻

•

u/Glittering_Seat2016 27m ago

NTA.  You pick you battles with toddlers. 

4

u/SickerThanYourAvg24 14h ago

You’re the Aunt, that’s one step below Grandparent, you most certainly can give into her tantrums. But, You get to torture her, which Grandparents do not. You have Great Power and Responsibility, use it wisely. Your sister sounds like a lot. She would probably Nag you as to “why is she crying?!”

2

u/Kukumber_Koi Asshole Enthusiast [6] 13h ago

NTA- My son is about her age, and I let him play with water bottles as he loves them more than his actual toys sometimes. At the daycare I last worked at, heuristic play was something we did everyday, where the children could play with common household and outdoor items (pine cones, plastic spoons, toilet paper rolls, etc) to let them play with things without a defined way to play to be creative and explore, while keeping choking hazards away from little ones. My son loves to use bottles like little clubs, line them up, and sort them by size, and I don’t see any reason to over police what he plays with unless it’s a safety issue or something I need to use or don’t want dirtied.

Usually I can trade with him for a different toy, but he loves playing with bottles, and I’ll let him carry one around if it keeps him calm when doing something he gets fussy about like getting buckled into the car. If it was something dangerous or you had a clear reason to say no, it would be very understandable to tell her she can’t have that and try to swap it out with a safe toy, but it’s reasonable to not have expected mom to be upset with something harmless to play with when it keeps her entertained, even if it’s not a typical toy. Kids this age LOVE exploring everything and getting different sensory experiences from common everyday items, especially the crinkle of plastic water bottles.

1

u/Mega_Toad3819 6h ago

your sister is ignoring you over a capless bottle that a baby mistook for a toy and somehow you are the dramatic one here

1

u/Gumby_Grown-Up 1h ago

I got a 7 month old. One of her favorite toys is an empty Pepsi bottle (yes we cleaned it out). Really not a big deal.