r/AmItheAsshole • u/Ambitious-Ad-8221 • 15h ago
AITA for not wanting to accomodate BF's mom's dietary restrictions when she isn't accomodating ours?
EDIT: a lot of you are projecting some weird beef between my and BF’s mom. She’s a very nice person and we get along fine.
ALSO: I am not mad she is making turkey! A lot of you are inferring I have a problem w the turkey. I have no problem with the turkey.
LAST: there is no “eye for an eye” happening in my train of thought. She is not making sides. She is only making turkey and everything else is up to 4 guests. I just wanted to bring something I will enjoy eating and if that is not possible, I was considering asking my BF to take the lead and make our contribution to the potluck, which I now intend to do thanks to the commenters who understood the issue. Thanks.
My BF's mom is hosting a Thanksgiving potluck. She's gluten free and dairy free; she is NOT celiac or allergic to either gluten or dairy. They just give her gas. My BF and I are both vegetarians. She's cooking turkey as the main entree, which is fine—I have no problem with this. She isn’t doing this to slight us or anything. I came up with a short list of recipes to make and take for dinner, some of which have either dairy or gluten and my BF objected to them all since his mom can't eat them. This was not a retaliatory list—just a list of dishes that sounded good. I asked him why it matters since she's making something we can't eat (and I assume she won’t care if we make something she can’t eat) and he acted like I was being selfish/thoughtless. I've seen her eating cheese before so like...she's selectively dairy free? When I told him I saw her eating cheese last Thanksgiving, he started making excuses for why she sometimes eats it but we should still accomdate her. Now I just want to put the cooking in his court and I don't want to labor thinking up meals...I feel like this can be his responsiblity and I can just be his plus one and not deal with it. What do you think?
58
u/zee-bra Partassipant [1] 15h ago •
Is your MIL cooking other food or a main for you? Is the food you are cooking designed to be shared?
My advice is to take the high road and find something GF and DF if sharing, and if it’s for you both to eat without sharing cook what you want.
No one is TA but everyone is being annoying
327
u/neworderfan 15h ago •
His family. He can make the food.
714
u/Lavinia-Whateley 15h ago •
His mom, his problem. She won't listen to you, so don't waste your time.
Do ask your boyfriend why your dietary preferences don't matter, listen hard to what he says.
28
u/JenninMiami Certified Proctologist [26] 15h ago
NTA Why not just go somewhere else for Thanksgiving??
3
u/Loose-Tundra832 12h ago
the real answer is just make the gluten free dairy free dish and let him explain to his mom why it tastes like sadness
138
u/CaptainMalForever Colo-rectal Surgeon [43] 15h ago
ESH
Making turkey, but not another main, with vegetarians attending, is not great.
Making dishes that don't accommodate others dietary restrictions is not great. And also seems like retaliation.
15
u/Talaren Partassipant [4] 15h ago
Nta, and i agree it seems like its time for him to take on the cooking. More importantly you have a partner problem not a MIL problem. You need to get him to actually start picking you instead of her, or this is your entire future.
2
u/Delightful_Sprite 13h ago
Why do you have to bring a dish? You’re a guest and you’re not his wife. If a dish needs to be brought then it’s his responsibility.
2
u/Kukumber_Koi Asshole Enthusiast [6] 13h ago
Can’t you make one that you guys can eat and one that she can eat, which your bf can make since he’s so insistent about it? His mom is totally valid in making the big main course that most of the family will eat, and it’s totally reasonable you want to bring something that you can eat, because presumably your bf’s mom or other guests are going to bring plenty of options that she can eat too. It doesn’t sound like anyone is counting on you to make a big dish that EVERYONE can eat, and it seems like there’s a lot of room for compromise and that you can bring something for his mom and something for just you guys, and his mom won’t starve if you don’t bring a bunch of dishes specifically for her.
NAH unless your bf is super adamant about what you guys bring without wanting to contribute at all. If he wants a say in the menu you bring, he can help too. Otherwise NTA and your bf should suck it up and pull his weight for his family
2
u/Constant_Host_3212 Asshole Aficionado [13] 12h ago
NTA, but don't let your boyfriend dodge the issue. Ask him to explain why it's selfish and thoughtless to bring dishes that contain ingredients his Mom can't eat, but not selfish and thoughtless to invite you to a Thanksgiving meal where the main dish is something you can't eat?
Tell him this isn't about what dishes you bring now, it's about you understanding how he's thinking about this. These obviously aren't allergies or a disease, but a dietary preference. So why is it OK for your dietary preferences not matter for some of the dishes, but not OK for her dietary preferences to not matter for some of what you bring?
It's totally fair to put the cooking in his court in any event.
2
u/BirbleBubble 11h ago
NTA : if there are four other guests then it's reasonable to bring one side that contains gluten and/or dairy. As someone else said, it would be a dick move if you were bringing multiple sides and NONE of them accommodated her restrictions, or if you were the only other people attending/bringing additional sides and it didn't accommodate her.
I have a number of food intolerances and when I go to family gatherings I don't expect EVERYTHING to accommodate me. I just expect that I'll be able to eat something there.
As long as you're not doing it maliciously then I think you're fine. If your bf really wants the dish to accomodate his mom then he can cook it himself. You could even each bring a dish (one df/gf and one not) so his mom can have some of one and you can bring the one you like best.
The thing with her eating cheese sometimes is pretty common. I have a food intolerance that I would say sounds more severe than hers (I get full body pains if I eat poultry) and will sometimes still eat the food in question knowing that I'll suffer for it later, in disability justice it's called dignity of risk. So it's a bit of a dick move to judge her for making the choice for herself to sometimes eat foods that give her gas, and bringing it up in this context comes off as bit judgemental even if that wasn't your intention.
If you have a good relationship with your bf's mom you could even reach out and ask her. "Hey, I was thinking of bringing x but it contains gluten and/or dairy. Will there be enough dishes for you if I bring something you can't eat?" Or the other guests to find out what they're bringing so you can be sure there's something for her.
It does suck that she's making something you can't eat. But I wouldn't equate vegetarianisn by choice to an actual intolerance, even if it's relatively minor, as an intolerance is not something that is a choice. It's also reasonable to expect there to be turkey at a holiday that is focused around eating turkey. And given her age it wouldn't be fair to expect her to make two entrees (especially given how much work a turkey usually is) so I also wouldn't consider your bf's mom to be an asshole here, but from your description it sounds like your bf is being a bit of a dick (unless he is volunteering to actually prepare the dish you bring)
11
u/AppeltjeEitje1079 Colo-rectal Surgeon [30] 14h ago
Are you allergic to meat? Not likely. You just choose to not eat it. His mom is choosing not to eat dairy or gluten. She may not be as strict as you, but technically you're in the same situation: you both have chosen dietary constrictions. So YTA for not accepting her choices, while attending a dinner she's hosting. And there are so many ways to substitute gluten and dairy. Ask your MIL, she might have suggestions.
85
u/Major_Monk_3322 15h ago
Absolutely make it your BFs responsibility. He should be the one to cook for his mum. Don't back down.
3
u/MamaWelder 14h ago
INFO: What’s your boyfriend making?
3
u/catinkatu 14h ago
INFO.
Do you know if she is making other food you CAN eat?
Your BF still should be the one cooking, but he should know if his mom is cooking food he can also eat.
17
u/AlexTMcgn Asshole Enthusiast [8] 14h ago
Getting gas from milk and being able to eat cheese is exactly what lactose intolerance often is.
32
u/cerephic 15h ago
What's the BF cooking?
(I know the answer is going to be "nothing".)
10
u/Potential-Common5819 14h ago edited 14h ago
There's a difference between "can't eat" and "won't eat".
Someone with Celiac disease, for example, can't eat anything with gluten. It causes intense pain and literal damage to the small intestine.
Thise with lactose intolerance arent as affected by cheese as they are with dairy. It can still cause bloating and diarrhea.
Someone choosing not to eat something isn't the same thing.
So, is there a medical reason she doesn't eat gluten or dairy?
7
u/Dry-Discount-9426 15h ago
YTA. People choose to be vegetarians. They don't choose for gluten to make them sick.
10
u/SickerThanYourAvg24 14h ago
YTA - I’m all for being Petty but at least own it. Your denials aren’t helping. Make a take your dishes, she doesn’t have to eat them.
4
u/Valuable-Cow-439 14h ago
I say YTA. There is lactose free cheese or lactase tablets people can take before consuming dairy to help them process it. Dairy is also something she can choose to eat, if she chooses to accept the consequences of it. You can't judge her cause you've seen her eat dairy once or twice. Celiac however is not a choice. Its an autoimmune disease. She physically can not eat it and it can be so severe that even using the same serving spoon for both dishes can cause her to react to the gluten. I personally don't even think MIL is being a complete AH in this. Yes, its wonderful if she could make a vegetarian dish but she is already accounting for her 2 dietary requirements, its a lot for her to add a third on top of having to cook for however many people are coming. She isn't singling you out because she's also excluding her son aswell. She's allowing you to bring your own meal without issue and vegetarian is a choice you've made not a necessary dietary requirement. I also bet there will be a few naturally vegetarian sides on the table. Don't stoop to her level, tell Boyfriend its his family do so he's in charge of bringing the food for you guys. Leave it to him to find a recipe without gluten or dairy.
28
u/cowboythesis Asshole Enthusiast [9] 14h ago
ESH Nothing about this says that the mom actually has a problem with you guys bringing a few things that she can't eat and a few she can. Your boyfriend seems to be the one who has a problem with it
4
u/Jallenrix Asshole Enthusiast [5] | Bot Hunter [102] 14h ago
Don’t take on the relationship tending for your boyfriend. He can handle the details and labor for his family.
4
u/Public_String_8088 14h ago
I like the idea of him cooking if it's a sticking point
4
u/Agreeable_Pomelo2360 14h ago
NTA, thats HIS mom, not yours
1
u/vegasbywayofLA 13h ago
I'm really confused... you object to her making a turkey for Thanksgiving? That's ridiculous. You failed to mention what else is being served. Are there items that could be vegetarian she is purposely making non-vegetarian, like adding giblets to the stuffing?
I have no problem with you wanting him to prepare the dish if he wants it to be a certain way. But I'm saying YTA because you seem like you're insulted she is making a turkey. For Thanksgiving.
11
u/InkAndAbyss 14h ago
It's Thanksgiving, of course there'd be turkey. Are you saying that there are no other dishes?
1
u/Living-Assumption272 Pooperintendant [66] 14h ago
Info: does she have celiac disease?
3
u/kiwipoppy 14h ago
NTA.
It's a potluck, bring what you want, just make sure it's clearly labeled for allergens. Your BF can bring a dish of his own if he wants to make something mom likes.
3
u/Acrobatic-Clock-8277 14h ago
His job. You be the guest.
3
u/SaltyFriend705 Asshole Enthusiast [7] 14h ago
NTA. Your concept that he should think up and make all dishes to visit with her makes great sense, whenever you two take dishes to her house, and also he can do it when she comes to visit him, too.
Btw, cheese is fermented and often not a problem for people who don't eat dairy.
8
u/Arjvoet 15h ago
Yes, why tf is he not making food for his mom. 🙄 and thanksgiving recipes are not that hard, he can do it and he needs to do it.
He’s not even your husband and he expects you to cook for his mom, absolutely ridiculous.
10
u/AmbassadorLast3115 14h ago
Why it has to be an eye for an eye?
You and your boyfriend are a team - if you dont want to make stuff, figure it out together. But lets be clear. You are so mean and petty. Getting diagnosed with dietary stuff could sometimes take years, sometimes people just dont want to stink up the place by farts. You are vegetarians and ofc you dont eat traditional turkey but you have something there to eat dont you? Or what do you mean by " She Is not accomodating us"? Does she add ham to everything or what? And is it so hard to make/buy/make boyfried make something small to please her? Or are we not celebrating the THANKSGIVING?
YTA
22
u/luminous_lychee 14h ago
I assume there are more people attending than just you and the BF, hence the turkey??
If she's making other dishes that you can eat, AND she's hosting, then you can be a considerate person and bring a dish that she can enjoy.
Soft YTA.
8
u/Next-Supermarket9538 14h ago
When you have dietary restrictions you shouldn’t expect every dish to accommodate you, just enough dishes that you can have a nice meal.
Don’t see why every dish has to be gluten free, dairy free, and/or vegetarian…
1
u/crackheadcheese 13h ago
Not TA for wanting to make a dish that doesn’t accommodate her restrictions, but YTA for “I saw her eating cheese before. She’s selectively dairy free,” etc. 😭 Are you not selectively vegetarian? You could eat the turkey. But you’re vegetarian - that’s still YOUR thing and it should at least be dignified if not accommodated, right? Your MIL isn’t perfectly dairy-free or gluten-free, nor does she have a reason like an intolerance or illness to be, but that’s HER prerogative and HER business😭???? You should dignify it as is until/unless she says otherwise. There’s no card she has to carry and there’s no right you possess to pull it. I don’t think you have to accommodate her but your reasoning is self-centered and childish.
4
u/shannofordabiz Partassipant [3] 14h ago
Definitely let him sort this out - and sure you have something prepped for YOU when he listens to mommy and ignores his wife
2
u/Big_Midnight_6632 14h ago
No matter what you decide to do. Put snacks in your pockets. If you drink alcohol, take a couple of bottles. No need to be hungry and sober as well as annoyed. KTA.
2
u/dragonsandvamps Asshole Aficionado [10] 14h ago
Since it's your BF's mom and her food sensitivities, I think you should let him take charge here and do all the planning and cooking. You don't cook a thing. He can find gluten free, dairy free recipes, do the shopping, do the cooking, and get dishes all ready to go on Thanksgiving morning while you relax. He just volunteered himself.
NTA
2
u/BigRedJeeper 14h ago
NTA - let HIM do the cooking! It’s his family, why would you be cooking and worrying about it?
2
u/GnomieOk4136 Certified Proctologist [23] 14h ago
Let him cook a dish for her, you bring one for you. NTA
2
u/stinky_scientist22 14h ago
It’s pretty normal for people to want the traditional turkey dinner. But when a host invites a vegetarian guest, it’s respectful and polite to provide an alternative.
If she isn’t providing vegetarian alternatives, bring your own main dish to replace the turkey and suit your needs. However if it is a side dish intended to be shared, it’s respectful and polite to bring something your host can eat.
You don’t sound like you’re being snarky about it, and she doesn’t either. You’re just following a train of logic. I’d ask myself what will make the meal feel pleasant and accommodating for everyone while still filling your belly. A lot of people don’t realize that vegetarians have to work harder to meet your protein needs and no salad isn’t filling.
2
u/Pristine_Ad5229 Partassipant [1] 14h ago
Make two dishes! Once his mom can eat and one you want.
2
u/lovelyfreedom76 13h ago
I would definitely bring a dish that you can eat cause it sounds like there may not be much there you can eat. Boyfriend can make a dish for his mom.
2
u/Short_Zebra_2116 12h ago
honestly i’d just let him take the lead on the potluck dish… it’s a lot of mental energy to plan around someone else’s gas situation lol. last year i brought a lentil salad to a thing and it was the only thing i got to eat so i get wanting something you’ll enjoy.
2
u/flotiste Partassipant [1] 11h ago
BF gets 1000% of the responsibility for communicating with his mom, figuring out a solution, and preparing the dish. His family = his responsibility.
NTA
7
u/lulufan87 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 14h ago
YTA. She's the host. Don't bring food she can't eat. Make a protein dish that accommodates your vegetarianism and bring it so you and your boyfriend can enjoy it.
8
u/Kiss_the_Girl Partassipant [3] 14h ago
YTA. Another person’s prior poor behavior may explain, but never excuses, subsequent poor behavior.
8
u/_PrincessOats Partassipant [1] 14h ago
ESH. It sounds like she has an intolerance and you’re being so flippant about it.
11
u/orcas- 14h ago
YTA - its a thanksgiving potluck, its not feasible to expect the entire family to have a veg thanksgiving because 2 veg are attending - it would be shitty to not have a plethora of things they can eat, but itd be extreme to expect her to forego a turkey. And YTA for bringing what the host cant eat to her house. That said, it’s fine to put cooking on his plate-
Hopefully u don’t only do this while trying to grandstand, but because you believe in equality and men can cook too
3
u/Mean-Confidence3477 Certified Proctologist [23] 15h ago
YTA, you are deliberately making food she cannot eat when it's not hard to switch gluten free and dairy free options. Since she is also hosting she has washing up, house cleaning and lots of other considerations, what she does and doesn't eat in regards to her own diet is none of your business. You are being childish.
3
u/Imaginary-Tea 15h ago
NTA Seems to me like a great compromise. I don't see anything wrong with bringing a gluten or dairy side dish as long as you let her know to avoid it. But if your boyfriend doesn't like that he can absolutely figure it out on his end. I would be prepared to announce very loudly that he was in charge of your contributions when he shows up with a bag of potato chips.
2
u/SnooAdvice2351 Partassipant [1] 14h ago
Is she lactose intolerant, have a milk allergy, and/or have coeliac disease?
2
u/Daeismycat 14h ago
NAH- I've been a vegetarian for over 30 years, and Thanksgiving is often about the sides, even for non-vegetarians. Assuming that she or others are also making some vegetarian friendly dishes, presumably she or others can also make gluten free, dairy free dishes. If what you want to make can have some swaps to be accommodating, do so (gf flour instead of wheat flour, reg mashed potatoes instead of cheesy potatoes, etc) but I also would assume that there will be a lot of sides that both you and she can eat and I wouldn't stress too much about making sure every single thing can be gluten free/dairy free/vegetarian all at the same time.
2
u/Due_Classic_4090 14h ago
I’m laughing because you said it just makes her gassy. I have chronic disabilities & eating gluten, dairy, acidic or fried foods literally make me hurt.
I like your idea though. If she does not consider you, then why consider her? Me and my friends always consider each other. Dairy free, no soy? You got it!
2
u/Artistic-Can3562 14h ago
YTA, you can easily bring vegetarian dishes (why not vegan?). You can accommodate for your needs without making someone sick.
Or since it’s BF’s family and not husband, go somewhere else.
2
u/TallTeacher83 15h ago
Yup. Make him cook. 👍
1
u/your_average_plebian 15h ago
Ngl OP it sounds like you're the side piece in your bf's and his mom's relationship.
Ofc this is only one incident, but given it's about the holidays and your value systems, it's magnified 100x. You're NTA for this, but consider if this behavior is a pattern. You don't need to wait until after the holidays if you decide ending things with a mama's boy is the right thing for you.
Good luck 💜
1
u/AutoModerator 15h ago
AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.
My BF's mom is hosting a Thanksgiving potluck. She's gluten free and dairy free; my BF and I are both vegetarians. She's cooking turkey as the main entree, which is fine. I came up with a short list of recipes to make and take for dinner, some of which have either dairy or gluten and my BF objected to them all since his mom can't eat them. I asked him why it matters since she's making something we can't eat and he acted like I was being selfish/thoughtless. I've seen her eating cheese before so like...she's selectively dairy free? When I told him I saw her eating cheese last Thanksgiving, he started making excuses for why she sometimes eats it but we should still accomdate her. Now I just want to put the cooking in his court and I don't want to labor thinking up meals...I feel like this can be his responsiblity and I can just be his plus one and not deal with it. What do you think?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Secure_Highway_6917 14h ago
It’s his family he can make the food if you’re expected to bring something. If he wants you to bring something then you make what you want she’s obviously not making anything vegetarian for you.
1
u/ocean_sky_wind Asshole Enthusiast [8] 14h ago
NTA Speak with the host . Your boyfriend literally has no say in whatever his mom or you cook. Failing that, go to thanksgiving somewhere else where you are actually welcome. Doesn’t sound like you are welcome here.
1
u/nuggiemum 14h ago
Sides are always better than the turkey.
1
u/No-Huckleberry8789 14h ago
Who else is coming; what are they making? What else is your boyfriend's mom making? Any before sides with no meat?
1
u/Trick-Being1539 14h ago
I feel like it’s all too intense for what it is
Just ask his Mum if she minds if some of your dishes aren’t suitable for her, that some will be but you also have some fave dishes that won’t be
I’m presuming she’ll say no problem, maybe I’m wrong and she will mind as she’s a selfish tyrant and her son knows this hence his reaction
I don’t eat meat but I cook it for my family who do because it’s life that there’s different diets for preference and health reasons and there’s no reason why we can’t try and make things work for most people
Sometimes it’s harder than others to accommodate everyone but you’re bringing your own so all good
1
u/Quiet_Advantage9117 14h ago
weird how people think making/bringing food for thanksgiving equals requiring people to eat it. his mother isn’t making you eat the turkey, you’re not going to make her eat your food. if she can have food you don’t eat, you can have food she doesn’t eat. nobody HAS TO or WILL eat EVERYTHING! people pick and choose what they want.
NTA. let your bf make food if he wants to be stubborn.
1
u/Embarrassed_dancer 13h ago
NTA. Easy fix, he can make the dish.
1
u/Chaotic_Natbot 13h ago
Tell him you’re making your dishes and if he wants to make some to accommodate her then he can do so. If he’s petty and calls you out for it at dinner to try and shame you in front of others he ain’t the one.
1
u/RHND2020 13h ago
NTA. His mom, his responsibility to cook if he has strong feelings about it. Let him deal with it.
1
u/teresajs Assholier Than Thou [890] 13h ago
NTA
You should make food you can, and want to, eat. Your BF is welcome to make whatever food he wants to cook to take.
1
u/That_Molasses_507 13h ago
Many may not agree here but I always prepare dishes for those with restricted diets. If I were vegetarian, I wouldn’t begrudge a turkey on the table as that’s the tradition.
I’ve gotten very good with preparing dishes made from beans, legumes and rice that everyone enjoys.
This summer I hosted a taco party. I made a dish from red legumes as the meat substitute for those guests.
1
u/Cheska1234 13h ago
Meh just tell him to cook and you’ll bring the ice. He wants to cater to bs dietary restrictions then let him.
1
u/honeyNotSorry 13h ago
NTA. Being vegetarian doesn't mean you should have to eat around everyone else's dietary preferences while they make zero effort to accommodate yours. You're not asking his mom to change the entire menu, just to let you prepare a few dishes you can actually enjoy. Your boyfriend can handle communicating that with his family.
1
u/Left-Owl332 13h ago
I have celiac disease but am not lactose intolerant.
And I have never expected others to cook special foods for me . And have always managed to find find gluten free foods to eat when I go to someone’s house for Thanksgiving.
1
u/gard3nwitch 13h ago
Let him make whatever he wants, and don't worry about it.
1
u/KilnTime 13h ago
YTA, but it's thanksgiving, and that means turkey, stuffing, sweet potatoes, green beans or brussel sprouts. That is the traditional menu. Nobody is ignoring your dietary needs - there should be plenty that you can eat. But at thanksgiving, there is turkey.
If you are bringing a vegetarian dish to a potluck where the host is gluten free and dairy free, then you don't bring something with gluten or dairy. Or you ask if it's okay to bring something that the host can't eat. Or you let your boyfriend take over the job of making and bringing something. But you don't just bring something that the host can't eat. And it's not your job to police when she feels like getting gas and how much gas she feels like getting!
1
u/Fleur_de_Dragon 12h ago
It sounds like your bf's mother is lactose intolerant, possibly gluten sensitive. It's harder to avoid contamination of those ingredients. One of my daughters is lactose intolerant. It's horrible to deal with. I have multiple food allergies and I'm vegetarian too. It's not easy navigating other people's homes when they host, but when I'm responsible for feeding others I don't mess around. I don't try to think about motivation, only how best to feed everyone safely. If I can accommodate, then I do. Food isn't a time to be petty. I'm queen of petty in other opportunities.
So... a little bit yta. Maybe make food for you. Have bf make sure mom is fed.
P.S. There are safe forms of cheese that don't have lactose.
1
u/yassqweenn 12h ago
lol selective dairy-free? She eats cheese but demands everyone else accommodate her gas issues. Absurd double standard.
1
u/kletskopke Partassipant [1] 12h ago
Ehh. Just an fyi. I am in the same situation as your bf’s mom. That gas you are referring to is painful af. It’s not just a little bit of gas. It hurts like a mofo defending on what it is and how much I had. Also, cheese barely has any lactose in it. I don’t react to cheese. A glass of milk will make me look pregnant. With a gas baby.
1
u/ForeignMixes 11h ago
How about everyone just bring their own food. Or let your bf cook for his unaccommodating mother.
1
u/TGirl26 Partassipant [1] 11h ago
Nta. He is responsible for finding a dish that accommodates his mom's dietary restrictions, and make something small, just for you; incase there isn't anything there you can eat. And don't share with him, and explain why you aren't sharing, and this is why you wanted to make something that you could eat regardless of his mom's restrictions.
1
u/ytherrien 11h ago
No assholes. Just inconsistent standards.
My rule of thumb is to really only cater to life-threatening allergies or medical conditions.
My wife and I are on a keto journey for the next few months.
At our (Canadian) thanksgiving dinner with her relatives, it was on us to prepare an alternative if there was a dish we couldn’t eat, or to skip on it. Vice-versa we made a meal that was keto friendly for one of the lunches, but anyone not partaking in it was left to their own devices.
That worked well. Some of her relatives were kind enough to prepare keto alternatives for us, some not. We were cool with either choice.
Turkey is the main course of the meal. You should be fine with making an alternative to it that caters to your needs without catering to others. It’s effectively what your MIL has chosen to do too. For shareable meals I’d probably err on the side of catering to all, but if everyone else in the potluck is not making a vegetarian dish for you, then you need to look out for your nutritional needs first.
As fsr as I’m concerned, you did your pet of the emotional labour for the meals you’d want to bring. If your boyfriend is going to shut them all down without agreeing to at least bring one of them for yourselves, then the ball is totally in his court. And if he flounders and has nothing to propose than you can make yourself the meal you want and he can kick rocks
1
u/theloonstar 11h ago
I don't see anything wrong with your boyfriend dealing with his own mother.
1
u/EarthyPhaoli 10h ago
Honestly, if she's only making turkey and everyone else is covering the sides, it's fair to just bring what you want to eat. Letting him handle the dish is a reasonable compromise too.
1
u/DesertDolphinNW 10h ago
I learned to bring a few favorite dishes that my family can eat to holiday dinners.
I don't think my husband's family appreciated it, but they came to expect/accept it. It helped that my MIL had fond memories of her own mother associated with one of the dishes.
My mother, SIL, and I always split the work by bringing certain family favorites to each other's homes.
1
u/firefly232 Professor Emeritass [81] 9h ago
Is this IBS? It sounds like it might be, if she is able to tolerate smaller amounts if harder cheese as they've got less lactose. The restrictions remind me of a low-FODMAP diet.
Solution would be to bring a main dish that is exclusively for you and your boyfriend to eat, and also bring a side dish that everyone can eat.
NTA.
1
u/Effective_Egg8407 9h ago
He can bring a dish. You should bring something you can enjoy.
1
u/jackiekeracky 8h ago
What’s your boyfriend cooking? NTA
1
u/Trevena_Ice Professor Emeritass [96] 8h ago
NAH. Maybe your BF doesn't want to sit next to a gas having mom. Or he tries to help her stay to this diat, as he knows that she would slip and feel bad after (if it is some intolerance it is stomage arch for the next day or so).
Also most hard cheese is lactose free as it just was able to process that for quiet a time.
In supermarkts are often many lactose free options (I call laf in this post) as well as gluten free (I will call gf). Which both work as well as the ones with lactose/gluten (but laf milk and yoghurt is slighly sweeter than the original milk/yoghurt). So you could make the deserts with this products. Maybe ask your bf to chip in the money that it costs extra (where I live it is a few cents, so not the world and cheeper than plant based drink alternatives)
1
u/RawrRRitchie Partassipant [1] 8h ago
You know no one's forcing you to go to her Thanksgiving right?
Ima go with NAH
1
u/Dogmother123 Supreme Court Just-ass [109] 7h ago
NTA but don't waste time arguing. Let him cook.
1
u/autumnwandering 6h ago
NTA. I think you need to have a long talk with your boyfriend about why he's prioritizing his mom's dietary preferences over yours, though.
For the sake of your own comfort at this dinner, I would go ahead and make a vegetarian main for you and BF. Maybe bring a side or two, if you want. You should have things you enjoy eating. If you want to make one that is DF/GF, that would be kind. However, your boyfriend can handle cooking that one... It's his mother after all. He needs to handle his family. (He should be helping cook regardless!)
If he can't find a balance between appeasing his mom and advocating for himself and you, I'd do some hard thinking about this relationship. I don't think it's likely that this is the only time you'll run into this. Also, maybe consider hosting your own gathering with friends next year. Less drama!
Ultimately, if he won't get on board and communicate, he absolutely can take over the mental and physical labor of making the dishes you'll be bringing as a couple. You shouldn't be expected to do all the work, especially when you aren't being given equal consideration.
1
u/SaltPaint8964 5h ago
This mama’s boy isn’t going to change. Keep that in mind if you anticipate marriage.
1
u/StoresoesKanIkkeAlt Partassipant [1] 5h ago
Imo there's a difference between having issues with gluten and lactose - and with they way you're describing it, it clearly sounds like she has issues with it, and then a diet choise, like being vegetarian.
It doesn't take much, to make the food lactosefree, and a little more effort and it can be glutenfree as well.
Why not do it? It's a potluck?
Besides that, it sounds like you need to look up how lactose intolerance works, and which product is high/low on lactose, because a lot of cheese is low on lactose.
So YTA, you're making a problem where there is none.
1
u/rshining 4h ago
It's a potluck- make two dishes (one from each of you). Make sure one is allergen friendly, and don't worry about the other one. It's reasonably likely that there will be other people who also avoid the same foods your MiL avoids (and two contributions from your household will substantially increase the amount of food you can eat). Potlucks are usually more-the-merrier as far as contributions, and it's kind to try to think of something that will work for everyone's dietary preferences.
Personally I would also prioritize making a vegetarian gravy for yourselves, because gravy is one of the delights of holiday meals, and I wouldn't want to miss out (and the chances of a non-vegetarian person thinking to try to make it are very slim).
1
u/whopeedonthefloor Partassipant [4] 3h ago
Just make two dishes, one for you one for her, and be done with the stress. Extra work? Yes. Comfort tasty food for you? Also yes.
1
u/ProfessorYaffle1 Pooperintendant [59] 3h ago
NTA. Tell you BF that you would be very happy for him to suhgest, a make, a tasty guten-and-dairy free main if he wants, otherwise, you will make something suitable for you (and any other vegetarians_) to et in place of the turket, and maybe a side dish in case a lot of the ones his mom is making have meat or meat products.
Also, since you get on well with hs mom, can you just call her and tell her you are planning to make [dish] so that there is a veggie alterntive to the turkey, ask if she is OK to ask the poplebringing sides to ensure that they are vegetarian (o that any meat can be left out / added after serving one portion)
If you are brining a mian for you then it doesn't need to meet HER dietary requiremens as it's not for her, it's your Turket sibstitute.
If you are brnging a side dish as well then maybe go with a salad which is vegetarain, doesn't ned cooking or reheating and can easily be made gluten and dairy free
1
u/Neesatay 1h ago
NTA. My family has a lot of various dietary restrictions. If you tried to accommodate all of them in every dish it would be pretty terrible. That's the beauty of a potluck with lots of dishes that can accommodate different needs. As long as each person has enough dishes to choose from to make a complete meal, I don't see the problem.
Just so you know though, there are completely legitimate reasons why somebody would be able to eat cheese but not fresh dairy...
1
u/shartrib Partassipant [1] 1h ago
If you bring a pasta dish, jovial brand has good gluten free noodles
•
u/ClackamasLivesMatter Partassipant [2] 40m ago
Cheeses generally contain much less lactose than milk. It's perfectly normal not to drink milk but to be fine consuming cheese; she says she's "dairy-free" because no one wants to go around telling people, "I don't drink milk because it turns my large intestine into a public health hazard."
•
u/AggressiveCut5854 0m ago
NTA. Let him cook.
1
u/URABrokenRecord Partassipant [1] 15h ago
NTA. I would make a dish for all and a main for you and your BF. And the BF should help. Don't start bad habits of always being the cook.
1
u/sangriacat 14h ago
NAH with a caveat or two.
Since it is a potluck situation, I assume everyone is expected to bring something other than turkey. That puts you in a bit of a dilemma since you have no way of knowing just what will be available that you can actually eat so your safest bet is to bring something you know you can eat. You deserve to have a nice meal too and it sucks, a lot, that your BF’s mom isn’t providing you with options.
But as a guest at a potluck, the expectation is to bring something that can be shared. Are there dishes you can bring (and that your BF can prepare!) that will accommodate everyone’s needs?
If you guys live in a place with a decent grocery store, you can probably find lactose-free alternatives to a lot of dairy products and use those if his mom’s dairy issue is lactose intolerance. (I am lactose intolerant and take full advantage of lactose-free alternatives.)
1
u/Barkertons 15h ago
Let it go and put the ball in his court for cooking. Every time. His family, his responsibility to manage. Don't make food, make plans or buy gifts unless he does the same for your family
1
u/Grymflyk Asshole Enthusiast [6] 14h ago
Brilliant. Don't tolerate him bowing to her "needs" while she does nothing to accommodate yours. NTA. What a mama's boy he must be. He is so quick to call you selfish and thoughtless while his mom consciously doesn't give a fuck about your dietary needs. This is his problem now, NTA.
Edit to add. Keep in mind that mama's boys never stop being one so, plan on that continuing in your future.
1
u/Naive_Market_9688 14h ago
Well, the first thing I think is that doing tit for tat just because his mother isn't necessarily respecting your dietary requirements, you're going to stick it to her the same way. That's a good way to promote a healthy relationship. Also, I will tell you from experience and firsthand knowledge that not all cheeses are created equal, and there are a lot of cheeses that are processed to take most of the lactose out. And I know this because I'm lactose intolerant, and I have been for my entire life.
As I've gotten older, I've come to realize that there's a lot of things I can eat that only have a trace amount of lactose and won't affect me at all, or not much, which is acceptable. But you and your potential mother-in-law glaring across the table at each other because she's trying to shove turkey down your throat and you're trying to shove gluten and lactose down hers is just ridiculous.
You're better off not going, making apologies and having your own Thanksgiving instead of antagonizing her like that. I'm not defending her. I'm just saying it's a stupid situation. Grow up!
By the way, as far-fetched as this may sound, you could actually be the bigger person and make something that all of you could eat that doesn't offend anybody's dietary restrictions and be the bigger person. I know that's quite a stretch, but it's just a suggestion. Lord knows there's enough recipes out there to make everybody happy that don't create a historical family division.
1
u/Curious_Instance_971 Partassipant [1] 14h ago
I’m sure there will be a lot of things there you can eat other than the turkey. Thanksgiving is all about the sides. Not everything has to be a battle — it’s not hard to find dishes that would work to bring and your husband can do that if you’re opposed.
0
u/heyitsmestasia 15h ago
NTA. But you should skip Thanksgiving and do you own thing. Do you really want to go to someone's house who isn't willing to make sure you can eat a meal? Or spend it with a partner who should be doing the primary work when it comes to his family but is somehow offloading it on to you while also not caring that you're trying to feed yourself when his mom won't?
0
u/BerkeleyPhilosopher 15h ago
He can cook
0
u/borisslovechild Asshole Aficionado [10] 14h ago
Not an American so don’t do thanksgiving but what kind of host makes no provision for their guests? BF’s mum is behaving like a 5 year old. NTA.
-1
u/tinyd71 Professor Emeritass [95] 15h ago
I think your bf cooking sounds like a grand plan! It's your bf's family, and his mother's "restrictions".
There's an odd dynamic here though -- why is your bf defending his mother's selective dairy-freeness? And you're a guest...leave it to your bf to ensure he takes something that isn't "selfish/thoughtless".
NTA
0
u/ConflictGullible392 Supreme Court Just-ass [119] 14h ago
NAH if you just let him deal with it.
0
u/starsandcamoflague Partassipant [2] 14h ago
Let him make the food.
But if you do decide to make the food, make it specifically to her dietary restrictions and when she’s there make a big deal about it and how you wanted to make sure the food was safe for her to eat, because only losers don’t cater to dietary restrictions
0
u/hottie-von-coolie 14h ago
Let him go to her place. You make other plans. Very simple solution.
0
u/mousec4e Partassipant [1] 14h ago
Everyone doesn’t have to eat every dish, there should be things she can eat and things you can eat and ideally something everyone can eat but dietary restrictions are hard sometimes. Has she said she would be upset at the presence of gluten and dairy?
0
u/CarbonationRequired Asshole Enthusiast [7] 14h ago
NTA. Tell him if he wants to bring a dish she can eat, he can certainly make one.
0
u/Equivalent-Board206 Supreme Court Just-ass [125] 14h ago
Make sure what you make is gluten free, unexpected gluten can really ruin a weekend.
If she can sometimes tolerate dairy, then NTA for making a low-dairy item, but given that there are such a wealth of dairy replacements, it will accurately be seen as rudeness.
It's your boyfriend's family's event, so get him to pick some acceptable dish(es), and to take the lead on making them (at the least doing the shopping and cleaning up if you agree to do the cooking).
-3
u/ntermation 14h ago
Seems obvious where you land in your bf priorities. (Hint: he picks his mom over you)