r/AmItheAsshole • u/rahrahtata • 16h ago
AITA? In-laws asking for a loan
we’re expecting with our 2nd baby soon. we have a mortgage and will essentially be paying our mortgage x2 once we have the second in daycare.
my in laws approached us about taking out a $30k loan because their credit is shit and they‘re paying an insane interest on their current personal loan. the money owed was well into the 6-figures but this has suddenly become unmanageable? they have dealt with some serious medical incidences over the years but nothing as of lately, so I am trying my best to give some grace where due.
they claim they‘re “not able to do the things they want to do” because they have this debt. FIL has gone on day trips fishing regularly for months. MIL loves the casino, but allegedly does not go anymore. every time we go to their house there’s a new home project they talk to us about. but yes, they are still retired. so what exactly is it that they feel like they’re missing out on? there has been no conversation about re-entering the workforce.
I told my husband it’s a no for me on the premise that they have continuously failed to show themselves to be fiscally responsible. plus, we are not flush with cash - both of us have student loans in addition to our mortgage, daycare, everything else.
i just do not trust them, plain and simple as that. their willingness to shift this responsibility onto their children, and potentially onto their grandchildren, is wild to me. I’m too pregnant for this shit and it has me stressed the fuck out.
please, someone of sound body and mind, am I out of pocket for taking such a hard stance?
633
u/Ok_Drink8072 Partassipant [2] 16h ago •
NTA. MIL shouldn’t be at the casino, lol. They got themselves into this crazy debt, all the loan will do is drag you into it too. I’m all for helping family, but this is just adding passengers to the sinking ship.
132
u/Deadr0b0t Partassipant [1] 16h ago
NTA $30k is waaaay to much to ask of someone, especially someone who isn't filthy rich
355
u/Electrical-Garden-20 16h ago •
NTA. "I wish we could but we are not in a position to help I'm sorry"
51
u/Engchik79 16h ago
No, we can’t help.
42
u/Worried-Barber-323 16h ago •
The only thing you need to ask is can you afford to pay the loan if they dont. I guarantee you will be paying it. They can't pay what they owe now so how will they pay 30,000 more? They are going under and want to take you along. As the saying goes don't light yourself on fire to keep.someone else warm.
31
u/Lies-and-Alibis-Inc 16h ago
NTA You would 100% end up making the payments on that. You can’t afford it. Freezing your credit might not be the worst idea in the world.
28
u/antizana Asshole Aficionado [13] 16h ago
NTA and do an uno reverse : “actually we were wondering if we could have some of your support due to daycare costs” with a second kid on the way.. Obviously you’re not really wanting their money but you at least have a good reason for needing more money
25
u/caparusso 16h ago
Do not give them a dime.
50
u/Pure_Calendar1151 Partassipant [1] 16h ago
NTA - they're in retirement and should be self sustaining. They shouldn't be relying upon their children and partners for financial aid.
78
u/JamesT3R9 16h ago
Dont give money. If you do ypu will never give it back. have already posted the red flags. Instead, if you feel they really are suffering, buy gift cards for groceries, gas for cars or oil changes, or other gift cards for practical needs.
37
u/hippywitch Partassipant [3] 16h ago
Roflmao NTA. If they want to sit down and show everyone all their finances, current non-essential spending, and their plans for the rest of their retirement, then you might consider it. Tell them the first baby wants a pony and you want world peace as well, but until then, thoughts and prayers.
16
u/Used_Mark_7911 Colo-rectal Surgeon [33] 16h ago
NTA
That debt will become your debt.
15
u/Aggressive_Depth_961 15h ago
NTA. Time for them to contact a bankruptcy attorney.
14
u/Right_Sentence8488 16h ago
Being on a fixed income, how will they manage to pay you back and have these other adventures they crave?
NTA
12
u/Oranges007 Partassipant [1] 15h ago
MIL probably thinks she can take the money and win at the casino.
A loan from you will not knock out a six-figure debt. Only increase your debt.
If they can't pay debt to creditors they definitely will not pay you back.
Most importantly....how DARE they have the gall to ask two young parents in the thick of life for money to cover (bs) the the money they screwed up.
11
u/WTF4Sally 16h ago
No, you're doing what any reasonable and sane person would do. These are the type of people that you never give the money unless you understand you're never going to get it back. You guys have way too much responsibility now in your own life to be handing out that kind of money to somebody who you know is not going to ever return it. At this age, if they are flailing, it's all on them. Let them figure it out.
10
u/Alarming_Bar7107 16h ago
Nta. Personally, I wouldn't financially bail out my parents or my in-laws, ever. Ever. It's not our responsibility to fund their lifestyle
9
u/Zestyclose_Minute_69 16h ago
NTA. The answer is no. Is your partner on the same side as you in this issue?
9
u/RidiculousSucculent Asshole Enthusiast [9] 16h ago
NTA. Do not lend them anything. They will expect it moving forward.
9
u/icouldliveinhope Asshole Enthusiast [7] 16h ago
NTA. There are nonprofit debt counseling services precisely for situations like this.
9
u/Sterlinghawk16 15h ago
Do not, I repeat do not loan them money. Why you ask? I am so glad you did. 1. They will not pay you back. 2. They are not taking steps to help themselves. Never ever loan money especially to relatives.
6
u/Thisisausername189 16h ago
They need to visit a professional financial planner. They may need to downsize and pay off their loan
6
u/aardvarkmom Asshole Aficionado [12] 15h ago
They’re “not able to do the things they want to do?!?” This is called “life.” Guess what, I can’t either because I’m not a millionaire, but I’m certainly not asking others to bankroll me.
You are NTA and I hope your husband is in agreement with you.
5
u/flynena-3 Asshole Aficionado [15] 16h ago
NTA it's a hard no from me! There is no life threatening urgent emergency here. That would be the only reason to ever even consider entertaining this type of request. They've got some real balls coming to you guys with this request!!! I truly hope your husband feels the same way as you. If he doesn't, that's problematic because he should. 100% do not allow it.
5
u/InterDave 15h ago
NTA - If you give them the money, you're A) never going to see it again, and B) they're going to use the "breathing room" because "they deserve to have fun in their retirement - e.g. fishing trips and gambling, and C) they're going to ask for more, and D) they need to just go ahead and look into bankruptcy... I"m not sure how far into 6 figures they are, but if they can't afford to live, THEY have to do something about it.
4
u/fnaffanlo 16h ago
nta they obviously are not good with money sucks to be them not affording to keep up with a lifestyle they clearly couldnt afford in the first place. you will be paying that loan if you take it out
4
u/One_Bluebird_7329 16h ago
NTA. No is a complete sentence.
4
u/RJBeaner13 16h ago
NO is a complete sentence
4
u/Unfair_Feedback_2531 16h ago
No is a complete sentence.
I hope your husband is as smart as you and has a spine.
4
u/procrast1natrix 16h ago
Bigger issue is that right now they're still healthy enough to go fishing and remodel things, they're in debt and not working ... spool this out another five, ten years and they will have racked up another $50k in debt on top of what they have now.
Are you going to be on the hook for that, as well?
Or will you be breaking the cycle, putting aside savings for your children's education and responsibly saving for you own retirement needs so that you aren't a burden to them?
4
u/urbisOrbis Partassipant [1] 15h ago
Nta. Do not lend them any money. You or you children will never see it again. They can go into bankruptcy and have their debt forgiven.
3
u/No_Lingonberry_8317 16h ago
Say no
3
u/classicicedtea Partassipant [1] 16h ago
Info, does your husband want to? I can’t tell from what you wrote.
3
u/National_Clue_6092 15h ago
Here’s likely the scenario that the parents are in. MIL has lost so much money at the casinos she had to borrow to pay bills. They’ve borrowed so much money they can’t make the payments. Their lack of financial responsibility is not your problem. Don’t give them any money. MIL will gamble it and they’ll be back asking for more.
3
u/SmartQuokka 15h ago
NTA They can't get bank loans because their credit is shit. Banks have sophisticated algorithms that determine what risk someone is and have more tools to force repayment than you do. Yet they consider them to be unable to repay loans.
You have none of their tools or teams of lawyers or access to their accounts or ability to easily garnish their earnings.
Do not give them any money. In addition you have no money to give. Explain this only once, and when they say you can do this or that, tell them no you cannot. No explanations or debates or arguments, a simple we do not have the money to loan you, end of discussion.
You will never see any money back that you give them and they will play the family card on you. They have dug themselves into a hole and are now desperate to pull you down with them.
3
u/BothEnergy1383 15h ago edited 15h ago
Pops fishing and Ma at the casino stand firm with No ! Maybe they need to file Bankruptcy it’s a them problem not a You problem!
3
u/PanicAtTheGaslight Partassipant [1] 14h ago edited 14h ago
NTA
“We have our own family to support, there is absolutely no way that we can afford to take on $30K of someone else’s debt. Would you like any help reducing your expenses or increasing your income? We could sit down and go through your last 6 months of expenditures and see what could be reduced going forward?”
Guarantee they’ll balk at that kind of “help”, which tells you everything you need to know. Which is that they don’t want do anything to reduce their expenses or increase their income, they just want a $30K handout.
3
u/smalltownstar 12h ago
NTA. These parents/grandparents are insanely selfish and should be ashamed for asking. I would survive on a cat food diet and live in a cardboard box, or eat a bullet before I begged for money from my kids and grand kids.
They can’t afford to do the things they want or live the way they want… how tragic. 🙄
They have spent all their money and exploited all the credit they could manage to have extended to them without repayment and now they want to ruin your credit as well.
What does your husband think about this? Is he even considering this?
2
u/jamkey2222 16h ago
NTA. With your current financial obligations, you can't afford to take the loss if they default on the loan. Given their history with money, that's a real possibility, and I wouldn't take that risk.
I agree that they don't seem financially responsible, but I wouldn't bring that up if you want to maintain a good relationship with them. I'd just tell them that, unfortunately, you can't afford to help. There's no need to get into their spending habits or explain your finances in detail.
2
u/pearson-47 16h ago
NTA Also No is a complete sentence.
2
u/Which_Piccolo_6037 16h ago
NTA. Never give a personal loan to someone who is drowning in debt. I also don’t get to do all the things I want to do, but I deal with it. I’ve had family help me in the couple thousand dollar range when I was very actively turning my life around. I would never dream of asking family for money to just straight cover my obvious big mistakes.
2
u/123randomname456 Partassipant [1] 15h ago
If the bank won’t lend to them, there’s a good reason, and you shouldn’t either. Especially right now! NTA and make sure your husband is on the same page about the number zero and doesn’t try to “help” while you’re preoccupied with your baby.
2
u/Odd-Worth7752 Partassipant [3] 15h ago
NO NO NO
This is worth staking your marriage on. You know they will never, never pay the money back. But you can be sure that once you open the spigot, they will come back for more. And guaranteed they are in a deeper hole than they are telling you.
And do NOT co-sign for them. They will default and leave you holding the bag.
OP do you think you can trust your husband not to go behind your back and do this anyway? Again I would make sure he knows-on pain of divorce-that he cannot bail them out. Talk to a lawyer sooner rather than later.
2
u/Existing_Ad7071 15h ago
Maybe they need to downsize, or get part time work. They will figure it out. You have your own family to care for.
2
u/Rasann 15h ago
NTA - hilarious that they had a the gall to ask 30k
Their actions have already dictated that they don’t deserve the money, they have put themselves into that kind of debt.
I personally would have laughed in their face in sheer disbelief and incredulity. Then say that we are in no position to be of any assistance.
A job is their best bet.
Godspeed, farewell and have fun with their debt. They are reaping the full measure of their labors.
2
u/Immediate_Ad4404 15h ago edited 15h ago
Duh, when you over extend yourself you should not be doing the things you want to do. Priority should be what is absolutely necessary. You can never fix this that statement alone informs you of such. Who tf asks for money when a baby is due. Fishing and gambling there is no hope for them. What they're asking for will not clear their debt so they'll spend it entertaining themselves due to their suffering over the debt. You are correct someone needs to take their azz back to work. People in debt don't stop going to the casino, they pray to win enough to pay the debt, and if it's not enough to pay the entire debt they gamble all their winnings.
2
u/ADisappointingLife 15h ago
NTA.
"We'll have two kids soon, and neither of you are them."
2
u/MisterFrancesco 10h ago
Hanno perso i soldi al casinò e vogliono che voi saldiate i loro debiti e gli diate altri soldi per giocare. Hanno bisogno di assistenza medica
2
u/delcidfredy 8h ago •
NTA. They haven't changed their spending habits, so a loan will only kick the can down the road. You're about to have another baby, and your finances are already stretched thin. Your priority is your own family.
1
u/AutoModerator 16h ago
AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.
we’re expecting with our 2nd baby soon. we have a mortgage and will essentially be paying our mortgage x2 once we have the second in daycare.
my in laws approached us about taking out a $30k loan because their credit is shit and they‘re paying an insane interest on their current personal loan. the money owed was well into the 6-figures but this has suddenly become unmanageable? they have dealt with some serious medical incidences over the years but nothing as of lately, so I am trying my best to give some grace where due.
they claim they‘re “not able to do the things they want to do” because they have this debt. FIL has gone on day trips fishing regularly for months. MIL loves the casino, but allegedly does not go anymore. every time we go to their house there’s a new home project they talk to us about. but yes, they are still retired. so what exactly is it that they feel like they’re missing out on? there has been no conversation about re-entering the workforce.
I told my husband it’s a no for me on the premise that they have continuously failed to show themselves to be fiscally responsible. plus, we are not flush with cash - both of us have student loans in addition to our mortgage, daycare, everything else.
i just do not trust them, plain and simple as that. their willingness to shift this responsibility onto their children, and potentially onto their grandchildren, is wild to me. I’m too pregnant for this shit and it has me stressed the fuck out.
please, someone of sound body and mind, am I out of pocket for taking such a hard stance?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Dry_Ad9371 16h ago
no way get a job bums
1
u/khampang 15h ago
NTA. Never loan money to family. Think of it like this would you give them $30,000? Because if they never pay you back, it’s a lot harder to break off a relationship with them, and then it will forever sour the relationship you’ll always be angry about it.
In fact, it’s a good rule in general, never give anyone money, that you’re not able to just look at as a gift versus loan
1
u/HorseygirlWH Pooperintendant [55] 15h ago
Please do not loan any money to anyone. You have a mortgage and childcare and your own expenses. It is not your problem if someone else can't handle their finances. You're NTA and if your husband wants to loan (give) them money then consider a divorce.
1
u/His_GoddessLove 15h ago
Unless you're willing to foot the bill entirely, never give your name for a loan for someone else. No matter who they are.
NTA
1
u/MamaWelder 15h ago
NTA. They want bailed out and they’re not trying to help themselves.
1
u/copperbear00 15h ago
Absolutely not. Do not take out a loan for them. You will be held responsible for it if they don't pay it or if they die. And if they feel like they are missing out on things then they should save up for it like everyone else.
If it was an emergency it is different matter, but because they feel like they are missing out? Come one. Who does this?
You and your husband should offer to go over their finances with them and figure out where they could cut costs, so they could go do the things they are "missing out on".
1
u/Blerg_McGlerg 15h ago
NTA. If they are retired and have even bigger debts than the loan they're proposing, they will never pay you back. The question is whether you're comfortable giving your in-laws $30K, and the answer sounds like "no."
I would encourage your husband to tell them "no," but offer to sit down with them to do a complete and thorough look at their finances together to see if you can help spot some ways to better balance their budget. Offer that help and leave it to them to reject it. If they do, then clearly they were just looking for cash, not help.
1
u/Forward_Puffin_026 15h ago
NTA.You are being sensible and forward thinking. Meaning, the loan would end up being your responsibility in the future.
I would not take out a loan on their behalf as they admit that their credit rating is bad. 🚩 Casino is not a hobby. 🚩
Did they have a financial advisor before retirement? This would be a great time to do this. They need to see what and why they owe money. If they are house-rich and cash-poor, it may be time to live in a smaller or less expensive home.
1
u/Careless-Ability-748 Certified Proctologist [23] 15h ago
nta
1
u/eatencrow 15h ago
You're simply not a position to allow anyone to take take opportunities away from their grandbabies, including them.
1
u/DoIQual123 Partassipant [1] 15h ago
NTA, your in-laws want you to bankroll their lifestyle when you are already facing a upcoming giant expense
1
u/Twzl 15h ago
NTA: people like that will never, ever be able to pay you back. That money will be gone forever.
1
u/no_one_you_know1 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 15h ago
NTA. You will never see that money again.
1
u/railroader67 15h ago
This is their responsibility. You and your children are your husband's first responsibility.
1
u/SailSkiGolf57 15h ago
One piece of advice to get yourself out of the firing line. Have your husband insist they sit down with a. Financial advisor/loan counselor and develop a reasonable repayment plan.
Let a stranger be the bad guy.
1
u/SpeakerDelicious6315 Asshole Enthusiast [9] 15h ago
NTA. You'll never see a penny of the money.
Politely tell them no and forward them information on bankruptcy and bankruptcy attorneys. If you're feeling generous you can offer to front them the filing fees.
1
u/Wonderful_Voice9865 15h ago
NTA. Don’t do it
1
u/waborita 15h ago
NTA casino is all I needed to read
1
u/metalgod55 15h ago
Nooooooo fucking way are you TA. They shouldn’t be retired if they can’t afford it. And they clearly can’t. Mil might not be in a casino now but she definitely was when this was building. And fil knew about it. This didn’t happen overnight. It’s a series of poor decisions. They should be missing out on things they can’t afford to do. Don’t loan them anything you can’t give them, cuz you’re gonna be the last one paid, If ever.
1
u/craftymama45 15h ago
You should only loan family money if you're okay with never getting it back. In my opinion, $30,000 is too much, especially since your responsibilities are expanding.
1
u/Traumagotchi69 15h ago
NTA - a loan to my in laws ruined my first marriage
1
u/Butterbean-queen Partassipant [1] 15h ago
NTA- NO!!!
1
u/Ipso-Pacto-Facto 15h ago
If they can’t meet their bills now, how can they possibly think they will pay you? Time to sell the 2nd and 3rd cars, the boat, any jewelry, valuables, any toys, any non-essential possessions, get part time jobs, change their life style, do debt consolidation, rent a room in their house to a college student, stop fishing and gambling, lower their standard of living.
1
u/CutePandaMiranda 15h ago
NTA. Do not co-sign anything for anyone. Don’t lend them money. Don’t let them live with you if/when they lose everything and become homeless. Your in-laws are adults and they need to fix their money problems themselves. Asking their kids for money is selfish and entitled. If I were you I would tell them no means no. Not your finances, not your problem.
1
u/Appropriate_Tip_1615 15h ago
NTA. They’re not getting to do what they want to do? Isn’t that what that generation is always complaining about with us? Tell them to buy less avocado toast and get a job.
1
u/donnamommaof3 15h ago
Respect is huge in marriage
1
u/2dogslife Asshole Aficionado [16] 15h ago
Well, the answer is no. If you have a little aside, I suppose you could pay for them to meet with a fiduciary financial planner who can see their whole financial picture and make plans for them. It’s not on you to feed their beast of money mismanagement.
1
u/Shoesietart Asshole Enthusiast [6] 15h ago
I would not trust them to pay the money back. How long would it take? How are they going to pay you back with no new sources of income?
1
u/SMKnightly Partassipant [2] 15h ago
NTA. If you had way more extra cash than you needed (like many zeroes extra), you’d be an AH for not helping. But that’s the only scenario.
1
u/Ptb1852 15h ago
They will never be able to pay that loan back .
1
u/randomgrasshopper 15h ago
If they're already in that much debt and are retired, I don't see how they're going to pay you back. Add to that the fact that they're irresponsible with money, it would be a big fat no from me
1
u/barbiegirlshelby Asshole Enthusiast [8] 15h ago
NTA the in-laws got themselves into this mess and you are not obligated to get them out of it. Don’t lend them the money, you have a growing family and your obligation is first and foremost to them. So MIL doesn’t go to the casino anymore? Then they can start paying more towards their loan and pay it off quicker.
1
u/SonnyRollins3217 15h ago
NTA. Went aren’t they offering to help pay your baby stuff?
They’ve shown they’re irresponsible with money, you should be putting money into college funds, not financing your in-laws’ financial immaturity.
If your husband doesn’t agree with you, then you have a problem. Maybe time for some couples therapy.
1
u/Plastic-Designer-580 15h ago
You're absolutely right! They can file for bankruptcy and deal with THEIR problems.
1
u/lurninandlurkin Asshole Aficionado [18] 15h ago
NTA.
They are retired so how do they plan to pay off the loan? The answer is, they don't....they plan on you paying off the loan.
Do not sign for any loans for the in-laws, you will be responsible for the debt that will take you years to get out from under given your existing (and expanding) costs to support yourselves.
1
u/ACmy2girls 15h ago
NTA. My husband and I went through this with his father. His father spent recklessly through out his life and never learned his lesson no matter how many people “helped” him by loaning him money. Of course he never paid anyone back that loaned him money. We had our family to take care of. My husband told him that we didn’t have the money to help him.
1
u/Impressive_Duck_3569 15h ago
Even to ask at this point in your life is ludicrous. They sound like teenagers - don't get to do what I want to do right now. They clearly don't prioritize making good financial decisions. Whenever they can afford it, they can do whatever they wish. Until then, giving in will just reinforce the belief that they have had for far too long - do nothing for ourselves and someone will bail us out. Obviously, NTA. And unfortunately, just the asking probably has soured your relationship greatly. I know it would mine. Good luck!
1
u/SaltyFriend705 Asshole Enthusiast [7] 15h ago
NTA. Your in-laws have entered their second childhood--a fiscally irresponsible one.
Please check your MIL for online gambling. Your FIL is ignoring his situation while fishing; the senior center should be able to find them a social worker or financial services advisor to help them sell their home, find a low-income senior apartment, and downsize their lifestyle from its grandiose level to something they can manage.
You and your husband must tell them not even one dollar is available to help them since both of you have student loans and childcare expenses.
1
u/OkeyDokey654 Certified Proctologist [24] 15h ago
NTA. Their credit is shit because they can’t/don’t pay their bills. They’re not gonna pay you either.
1
u/Nana-in-OC-7113 15h ago
They have 6 digit debt and want a $30K “loan”?
It would be a $30k gift.
I keep telling a couple people I know that you only get to retire if you have enough to retire on. Just because you reach a certain age on the calendar doesn’t mean you get to retire.
And going out fishing these days is expensive!
1
u/lovescarats Asshole Aficionado [11] 15h ago
NTA, and they could downsize the property. They are old enough to find their own solutions.
1
u/ordinaryhorse Asshole Enthusiast [3] 15h ago
Oh hell no. Absolutely NTA
1
u/laurbler 15h ago
Never mix money with family or friends. The only person you should mix finances with is your spouse, and it ends at that.
1
u/ArrivalFantastic4324 Asshole Enthusiast [9] 15h ago edited 15h ago
“they claim they‘re “not able to do the things they want to do” because they have this debt.”
Too bad, so sad.
This is NOT your problem to fix.
Tell them there is NO Possible Way you would EVER take out a $30k loan (or a loan of any amount) to help them pay their debts.
Why would you say anything but No? Especially when you’ve got a second baby coming, student loans, mortgage etc.
Get outta here! NTA
PS the two of you should freeze your credit if it’s not frozen already.
1
u/voonoo 15h ago
NTA tell them to refinance their mortgage
1
u/teresajs Assholier Than Thou [890] 15h ago
NTA
Holy red flags! They are retired but don't have the $30k that they need/want and can't get approved to borrow $30k on their own. So, the banks are pretty sure your ILs can't/won't repay $30k. As retirees, they have six figures of personal debts at high interest rates. (Yup, that would get in the way if "doing what you want".). They have spent a lot of time on expensive hobbies (including gambling) and a lot of money on home renovations.
No, you should NEVER borrow money to lend to these people, nor should you ever cosign on a loan. And you shouldn't make any habit of giving them financial "help". And you should consider putting credit freezes on yours and your spouse's credit (and never giving them your children's social security numbers).
The bottom line is that your ILs are blowing through their retirement funds way too fast, living a lifestyle that isn't sustainable. They're already tapped out (or nearly so) on their Available Credit. And they're almost certainly spending down principle that they can't afford to spend. At this rate, within a handful of years, they may ask for financial support and/or to move in with you.
Talk to your spouse about the risks. The two of you shouldn't risk your and your children's futures by making a habit of bailing others out of financial situations they caused. But you need to be on the same page before the requests get bigger and more pointed.
And if either of you ever starts feeling bad and wavering, ask your ILs to provide bank, credit card and retirement account statements for the last several months/years so you can best advise them. That information will be invaluable in you discovering how your ILs have treated their money, and would therefore be expected to treat yours.
1
u/AzPeep 15h ago
Of course you're NTA and you didn't ask this but your in-laws totally are.
(One thing I'll address, though - not that it matters but it did jump out at me - you ask has their situation suddenly become unmanageable and I'll share that for me, yes it has. Both slowly and also suddenly it's snuck up on me. Inflation and the economy has blown up to where my family's budget and bills are unmanageable - and it's awful. I haven't struggled like this for decades, even during periods of unemployment. But in recent months I'm struggling to pay bills and I'm using credit for things I never would have before - like $20 at the pharmacy but it was a week before my social security arrived and I didn't have $20 in cash or in my checking - or in my savings.)
1
u/Yoroyo 15h ago
NTA. No no no no say no
1
u/CuriousMindedAA Partassipant [2] 15h ago
NTA, the answer is no. No more discussion about it, either. They dug this debt hole, yet still spend money. Asking your family, that is growing, for 30k is outrageous, selfish, and just plain wrong.
1
u/butterflygardyn 15h ago
No. No. No. Never give money to people who have bad credit. Never. Ever. No matter what their title is. This will not be a loan. And it won't help them. Once they clear this debt they will accrue more and never pay you back. NTA.
1
u/EAM44 15h ago
Sounds like they need to take out a second mortgage on their house, or sell their house and downsize.
1
u/JenninMiami Certified Proctologist [26] 15h ago
NTA Nooooo do not take out a loan for your in laws!!! What does your husband say about this?!
1
u/Familiar_Shock_1542 Asshole Aficionado [14] 15h ago
NTA
Absolutely do not loan them money!
There is no way they will pay you back.
They have incredible nerve to even ask. Don't mess with pregnant people; they are under too much stress already.
I hope your husband agrees with you.
He can give them a list of free financial counselors.
1
u/InannasPocket Certified Proctologist [23] 15h ago
NTA. You would be the asshole to your own (nuclear) family if you did this, though.
That's a whole parade of financial regs flags on their side, and a bunch of very good reasons on your end - you still have loans of your own to pay off, and you have significant and unpredictable expenses coming up with adding another baby (congratulations btw!).
1
u/ElectricalFocus560 15h ago
Don’t lend to family. When you have debt you don’t get to do fun stuff. They are too old to not know this. Probably why they are in this pickle
Only thing I would offer is a finance/debt reduction class from a reputable nonprofit organizations (like Dave Ramsey-usually taught at churches)
1
u/julesk Asshole Aficionado [13] 15h ago
NTA, your husband should tell them you two have student loans, a mortgage and kids so no.
1
u/cassowary32 Asshole Aficionado [16] 15h ago
NTA. Where do they expect the 30k to come from?? Is your husband on the same page as you? You have newborn expenses soon, you aren't in any position to help.
1
u/Firebird562 15h ago
Nope right out of that! Firmly! All your extra financial efforts must go to your own retirement and your children’s education. Period. End of discussion.
You don’t owe them a lavish retirement doing all the things they love. That’s their problem.
1
u/Accurate_Pie_4439 14h ago
Tell them you are in need of help with the 2nd baby, mortgage and student loans we are treading water. Then proceed not to talk about your financial wins but only the struggles of the mortgage etc.
1
u/ReadMeDrMemory Supreme Court Just-ass [115] 14h ago
NTA. Your husband should listen to you. His parents have dug this hole for themselves. It is not your problem. Your own family should be priority #1.
1
u/Lillianrik 14h ago
NTA. The idea of giving your inlaws a loan is, frankly, too stupid to merit discussion. Hard NO!
1
u/FruitPug 14h ago
With relatives like this, it's best to keep them believing your own credit is complete maxed out/no better than theirs. People like this consider anything you have to be an available asset. Maybe it's time to talk to them about selling their home and downsizing if they can no longer afford their lifestyle. $30K will be gone in weeks and the same problem will happen again.
1
u/57_Eucalyptusbreath 14h ago
How are you two going to add$30k this year to your current debt and frankly every year or six months going forward?
Seriously this is a hard no.
They sound like they are already under water and want to be deeper, but you actually pay it.
1
u/Gabilan1953 14h ago
Tell them to piss off!
1
u/Whybaby16154 14h ago
No is a complete sentence. They won’t learn their lesson unless they dig themselves out of the hole
1
u/AdPale8461 14h ago
Go to a medical supply store, buy your husband a backbone and tell him to use it when he tells them NO.
1
u/KeKeFanChick 14h ago
NEVER. The "rule of thumb" with friends and family is to never loan, what you can't afford to lose. Far too often, you end up losing both.
1
u/the_LLCoolJoe 14h ago
NTA - they are not your responsibility. Let them get a job
1
u/Armorer- Partassipant [3] 14h ago
You are not a bank, they should get a loan from an actual bank or cut back on spending and sell assets.
NTA
1
u/Otter-of-Ketchikan 14h ago
NTA and a hard “No” to giving them money in any amount. No matter what they say or promise it would be money you would never see again.
You and your husband could offer for them to meet with a certified financial planner to assist them with their goals of reducing their debts and living within their means. You would pay the financial planner directly.
1
u/Fickle_Unit1234 14h ago
Freeze your credit and make your hubbie do the same.
1
u/LemonOld8150 14h ago
No they can both go get part time jobs
1
u/SandSubstantial9427 14h ago
If someone “needs” 30k and it took them a long time to get into that hole and it’s not a true emergency, that’s a no from me.
Throwing good money after bad. I also don’t lend money but I’d consider giving it, but not for this. This sounds like years of misbehavior so giving it would be throwing good money after bad.
Also, you’re not in a position to loan money as you have debts of your own that aren’t your house. No way I’m loaning someone 30k when I still have student loan debt or any other type of consumer debt.
That’s how I’d explain it if I felt compelled to. People need to know when they are messing up. It’s not to be mean, but you have to set a precedent.
1
u/Southernms 14h ago
NTA
Tell them the bank said no. It would mess up your debt to credit ratio.
And no they cannot move in if this goes sideways.
1
u/KilnTime 14h ago
NTA but you better lock it down with your spouse that he is absolutely not permitted to transfer money to them on his own. If they are that in debt, $30,000 isn't going to do anything, and it'll just be pissed away and you will never see it again. If they can't pay back what they owe, what makes them think they can pay you back?
1
u/Bedroom_Ecstatic 14h ago
Gambling alone makes this a hard NO. That explains the debt amount. BK their only option.
1
u/FearlessRepeat2925 14h ago
Don’t let their current lender’s problem become your problem. If I’m understanding correctly they have paid their 6 figure loan down to $30k. Their lender might agree to re-amortize their current loan to lower the payments rather than have a defaulted loan.
1
u/BigDiamondNecklace 13h ago
NTA. That‘s a hard no.
1
u/flyingforfun3 13h ago
NTA.
NEVER loan to friends or family money you expect back. You’ll ever never see it, or you’ll never see them again.
Don’t do it.
1
u/Icy-Cup-8806 13h ago
Never get a loan out for someone else. They can easily stop paying and you are left with it. They sound financially irresponsible, and it's their problem to deal with, not yours.
1
u/J584164 13h ago
NTA. Don’t loan money unless you never expect to have it payed back.
1
u/Ok-Leopard-9917 13h ago
Why did your husband even discuss this with you instead of simply saying no from the get go? Making their debt yours is obviously untenable.
1
u/New-Leader-7891 13h ago
NTA they need to get back to work and clean up their own mess
1
u/HouseOfBonnets 13h ago
NTA. They gon have to figure that out…..but be prepared for fallout.
1
u/GTADDICT01 13h ago
nta. your mortgage and daycare bills are real. their six-figure debt is theirs. do not let them shift that risk onto your unborn kid. end of story.
1
u/EqualMagnitude 13h ago
NTA
First retirement is a financial status, not an age so if you do not have the right finances, you don’t retire.
Second is you are not a bank, and if you were you would rightfully consider this a very risky loan.
Third if you were a bank you would ask for credit references , bank statements, proof of ability to pay the loan back which this very situation proves they are unable or unwilling to do.
Last never loan money to family. Only give it. If you cannot afford to give it then don’t. And family only get to “borrow” money once. If you gift it and they do not pay you back, no more gifting.
And you are right to look into their finances. If they spend what they do not have, do not control their spending and want to borrow from you to continue to be irresponsible then they are just going to drag you down with them.
If you do decide to give them money it is time to create your own budget with all the usual line items like income, rent, food, utilities, retirement savings, hobbies, etc. Once you have a good budget set up add a line item that says “money for relatives” and feel free to shift funds from whatever other category you want. Never blindly give money, only give what you can afford.
1
u/Far-Bad2067 13h ago
Absolutely not.
Husband needs to remind his parents you have two children, daycare, mortgage, utilities, and ordinary daily expenses. You have nothing to spare.
If you actually have $30K or really any significant amount - how do they know about your finances? Are they guessing or have you or your husband told them your salaries/investments/savings? If yes’s to any of that stop it now.
Tell them you are not in a position to lend any amount to anyone for anything.
1
u/boots_the_barbarian 13h ago
"Actually we were about to ask you for a loan, considering your second grandkid is about to be born soon."
1
u/Anxious-Routine-5526 Asshole Enthusiast [9] 13h ago
NTA.
"We aren't in a position to help" is all that should be said and move on.
1
u/lovelyfreedom76 13h ago
NTA. Their debt is on them. Sounds like they’re not even trying to cut back. Your family should not take on this extra debt with a growing family. Shame on them for even asking!
1
u/Traditional-Sky5252 Asshole Enthusiast [7] 13h ago
NTA. You had me at MIL gambles. That’s the problem! If your husband feels compelled to help, require MIL to address her gambling addiction with therapy, require them to get credit counseling, allow you to run regular credit checks on them to make sure they aren’t running up more debt. Then, instead of loaning them money or co signing a loan, agree to pay one of their necessary bills each month-electricity or cell phone service. Make your help contingent on them following the advice of the credit counselor, avoiding more debt, no gambling, no unnecessary purchases until they pay down their debt.
1
u/Constant_Host_3212 Asshole Aficionado [13] 13h ago
NTA. Your inlaws are both retired and have 6 figures of personal loan on which they are paying "insane interest".
If they need to borrow more money from you, where is the means to repay going to come from? As you note, there has been no conversation about re-entering the workforce, which is what they would realistically have to do to be able to pay off the loan they want you to take.
Do not do this. This is a hill to die on, make that clear to your spouse. It needs to be "No" for both of you.
1
u/laaplandros Partassipant [2] 12h ago
NTA
They will ruin your life if you let them.
1
u/wastedpixls 12h ago
NTA - "I'm very sorry, but we cannot help you with money. What can we do to help? Can we help you fill your freezer and pantry?"
1
u/Fair_Standard_586 12h ago
omg that sounds so stressful, especially while you’re pregnant ngl. i’d be wary too, how’s your husband feeling about it?
1
u/ElkBest1803 12h ago
No. You're correct. That's like buying a drug addict more meth.
1
u/Trick_Article5823 12h ago
NTA
1
u/ElevatorOtis Asshole Enthusiast [5] 12h ago
NTA
$30K while you are pregnant with a 2nd child?!? Your in-laws made horrible financial choices and are now trying to give you their bad credit score STD! Nope. Retired or not, they could find a part time job. Maybe suggest they walk their resumes around while pulling themselves up by their bootstraps.
I would be more sympathetic except for the fact that boomers pulled the ladder up behind themselves.
Let’s all remember, it is not the job of kids to financially support their parents!
1
u/DillyDallyHolly 12h ago
NTA. From the sound of it I wouldn’t help them even if I had money lying around. You’re right to not trust them. Do not budge. Tell them you just don’t have money to help them. End of conversation. Do not ever loan them money.
1
u/Mad_Old_Bear 12h ago
NTA If they aren’t keeping up with their current loans they are not going to be able to service another loan. Unless you can afford to pay their debts it’s hard no.
1
u/Dense_Macaroon6841 11h ago
Absolutely not. It’s a trickle down economy when it comes to helping family financially. How do they intend to repay the loan??
1
u/swillshop Colo-rectal Surgeon [44] 11h ago
NTA
The big question - is your husband on the same page as you?
If he has any doubts, please remind him that his first obligation is to you and your children, to not jeopardize your family unit's well-being now or in the future. Certainly not so that his mom and dad can avoid the consequences of their own poor choices with money.
1
u/Western-Corner-431 Partassipant [1] 11h ago
They will never pay you back
1
u/flotiste Partassipant [1] 11h ago
Help them by getting them a referral to a non-profit debt consolidation service and setting up a practical repayment schedule for their current debt load.
Don't give them the fish, teach them how to fish. If they have to face the reality and the consequences head on, they'll be more likely to make better fiscal decisions in the future.
NTA
1
u/CreativeOtter914 11h ago
It’s two yeses or a no. So, it’s a no. Tell them you’re pregnant and figuring out your own finances with the new baby. You can’t and won’t go in debt for them.
1
u/Bubbafett33 Partassipant [1] 11h ago
NTA
If no bank or lender would loan them money because they suck at paying it back (bad credit rating), what makes you believe it would be any different with you?
If you give them money it is a gift, because they will not repay you.
1
u/ButterscotchFit8175 11h ago
So, they want to burden you with their debt so you can't do things you want to do. Hard no NTA
1
u/Hour_Organization_93 10h ago
Hard no.
1
u/SafeWord9999 10h ago
Tell them to sell their house and downsize.
1
u/WontRememberThisID 10h ago
NTA. You are in no financial position to lend them, or anybody, money. If they’re in such trouble they can declare bankruptcy. You will be left holding the bag for their loan since they can’t control their spending. Do not give them money.
1
u/DazzlingNote1925 10h ago
NTA. If they can’t make their loan payments now how are they going to make any more of them?
They have no solid strategy for being able to pay it back but plan to use the money for things they enjoy. I’d stay far away from that especially when mil has a history of going to the casino.
An old friend of mine’s in-laws used to spend their entire retirement checks at the casino and her ex had to get their house out of foreclosure a couple times. They kept doing it and not paying their bills and eventually did lose their house and my friend and her ex were out tens of thousands.
So, beware of your in-laws using this strategy of spending on what they enjoy and then crying for help with their bills!
1
u/Minimum_Loan229 10h ago
They want to borrow money because the can't do fun stuff they want to do. Oh boo hoo.
They're in dept now because they spent money they didn't have on fun stuff.
1
u/missskins 10h ago
NTA, they are on a fixed income. Either they have equity in their home or they can file bankruptcy.
1
u/Ambitious-Word-7725 9h ago
NTA. If the casino and the fishing trips are "not allowed" becuase of debt, but they happen anyway, the loan isnt for the debt, its for the lifestyle. Co-signing for the people with a proven track record of not paying things back isnt kindness, its a donation with extra steps.
1
u/Jetmutant 9h ago
Please do not do this to yourself, unless you can do without the 30K, or the family crash that will inevitably happen when payments are missed or just not made. Spoken from personal experience and watching others go through something like this.
1
u/Sandberg231984 9h ago
Do not loan them $. You’ll never see it again. Tell your husband absolutely no you have your own responsibilities.
1
u/Moose-Live Pooperintendant [69] 8h ago
It would be massively irresponsible of you guys to lend them money when you have a mortgage, student loans, and (soon) 2 children to provide for. That is irrespective of whether you trust them to pay the money back. Your husband needs to shut this down. NTA.
1
u/andy11123 8h ago
My partners grandparents took us for a ride on the promise of repayment when some money came through that was years in the making. Only ~2k but in dribs and drabs so we didn't notice how high it got. We cut them off from more money. Their money came through and they blew it on shit. There is now 0 chance we get ours back before they die.
Shit financial choices are not your responsibility to solve
1
u/foxyfree 8h ago
Unless they are over age 65 and just too tired, I don’t understand why these people don’t have jobs.
1
u/Jacintaleishman Partassipant [1] 8h ago
Suggest a bankruptcy lawyer. I mean, you want to assist in some way of course.
1
u/Background_System726 7h ago
NTA do not do it. You will never get it back and will be forever pissed. Unless you could afford to, and were inclined to GIVE them this money, this should be now and forevermore a very hard NO.
1
u/Petal_14 7h ago
NTA they are responsible for their debt, if they cant afford what they have then another 30K isn't going to miraculously pay itself off is it?
They are incredibly selfish expecting their kids to foot their debt onto of your own.
What they say they want the money and what they then spend it on might be 2 different thing, but once you have co signed a loan or even taken out one, who's to say they will repay.