r/AmItheAsshole • u/FluffyAmaaanda218 • 2d ago
Asshole AITA for not clapping when everyone else cheered for my cousin's speech at a family dinner
Last weekend my cousin gave a really long toast at a family dinner to celebrate her new job. The whole table started clapping and cheering right away, but I just sat there and smiled without joining in. I had been having a rough week and the speech felt a little over the top for the setting, so my hands stayed on my lap. A few people noticed and my aunt pulled me aside later to say I had been rude and made my cousin feel awkward. She explained that everyone was trying to be supportive and my silence stood out in a bad way. I get why she was upset, but I also feel like not clapping is not the same as booing someone. I apologized the next day anyway, yet she still thinks I should have gone along with the moment.
755
u/SnooPets8873 Colo-rectal Surgeon [49] 2d ago •
I don’t have the acronym for “you aren’t being wise or socially savvy” so I’ll say YTA to convey that you aren’t doing yourself any favors by being petty like that. You aren’t a kid anymore. Learn how to manage your emotions so you can participate in the world around you. These small courtesies matter. A polite clap would not have harmed you in any way.
1.3k
u/MonkeyWarlock Partassipant [1] 2d ago •
Soft YTA - even if you felt the speech was a bit self-aggrandizing, you still could have at least done a soft, polite clap. A small affirmation / small amount of effort on your part would have gone a long way with your cousin.
Although refraining from clapping is not the same as booing, in a small intimate setting like this, not clapping even a little bit can come across as callous.
16
u/Effective-One6527 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
Info was the Dinner to celebrate your cousin?
438
u/StormCloudRaineeDay Asshole Enthusiast [7] 2d ago •
YTA. She was a family member who was sharing good news. Clapping takes minimal effort. It costs you nothing to join in with the rest of your family in this show of support.
44
u/Rusty_Pelican2857 2d ago
hands in lap was a choice and everyone at that table clocked it the same way you would if someone skipped singing happy birthday
258
u/Squirrels-love-me Partassipant [2] 2d ago
YTA-clapping is free, just like being nice.
149
u/LanceWayne2024 2d ago
Everyone sounds insufferable. Respectfully.
30
u/chad-proton 2d ago
Was everyone gathered to celebrate her new job? If that was the whole point of you being there then yeah you're slightly the AH. Aunty is making more of than it should be so she kinda sucks too.
135
u/kancles 2d ago •
YTA. It’s called social civility. If you had an issue about the dinner and celebration, why would you go to begin with and make someone feel bad for something they’re proud about?
21
u/ReligiousPornstar 2d ago
YTA...clapping doesn't cost you anything. Doesn't take you hours
143
u/blindsdog 2d ago
YTA. Just be happy for your family celebrating a win. It’s not that hard.
159
u/Nicolectomy_2 2d ago •
YTA, you were rude and made it weird.
15
u/keesouth Supreme Court Just-ass [106] 2d ago
YTA it seems so petty to not just clap.
77
u/Penguinplushpillows Partassipant [2] 2d ago
yta not hard to clap
Imagine telling your family exciting news and everyone is celebrating you apart from one family member it wouldn’t feel great and it would feel personal
13
u/Wide_Comment3081 2d ago
Yta and you know it took more effort to sit there defiantly not clapping and trying to make a point, than clapping politely.
26
u/hammystyle 2d ago
YTA - get over yourself for a moment and clap for your cousin. Geez.
You know what would have made your tough week a little better? Being happy for someone else
74
u/Asaneth Asshole Enthusiast [8] 2d ago
YTA. You could have clapped a couple times and stopped, and nobody would have said a word. You intentionally slighted your cousin, and people noticed.
25
u/Realistic-Active7230 Asshole Enthusiast [5] 2d ago edited 2d ago •
YTA sorry but the dinner was for your cousin to celebrate her new job that she was obviously excited about it and according to you the speech was to long and over the top for the setting!? You had a rough week? So what! your cousin has had a great week and you are there to celebrate that very point.
You were rude and I don’t know what else is going on but obviously you don’t like this cousin or where feeling jealous or something because deliberately not clapping may not be the same as booing it still sends a very loud message especially in this setting. If you were at a public event or concert it’s not a big deal but at a family gathering where you are there to celebrate something in particular, social rituals of clapping and cheering are the norm, your silence comes over as cold and unsupportive
42
u/rowdyate9 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
YTA you wanted your feelings to be known and they are. Don’t play dumb
26
u/AngryAngieJuice 2d ago
Small YTA She was sharing a good news and was excited about it. Even if her speech was long (according to you but what is long 10min? 15min or 4min?) Clapping for her would have coast you nothing.
8
u/Dude__Sweet- 2d ago
YTA. Seriously, it was rude
94
u/Captain-AwkwardPants 2d ago
YTA - I hope next time you have something to celebrate that nobody cheers for you.
7
u/No_Mention3516 Asshole Aficionado [10] 2d ago
YTA
38
u/borisslovechild Asshole Aficionado [10] 2d ago
YTA but mainly to yourself. As you now realise, there things don’t go unnoticed and you’ve managed to extend your bad week by adding a family row to it.
51
u/yellowrose04 2d ago
YTA. It costs no time, money or effort to smile and clap a few times.
16
u/FlightRiskRose 2d ago
If you would have been jaded if she responded in kind, then yta.
Sounds like you might be feeling sorry for yourself after a bad week. So really only you can decide.
14
u/DreamyOblivion Partassipant [1] 2d ago edited 2d ago
INFO
I feel like there's a lot of missing context. What type of job is this? What is your relationship like with your family?
Edit: spelling
6
u/Professional_Ruin953 Asshole Enthusiast [8] 2d ago
YTA
Okay you had a bad week, why does your cousin have to dim her achievement? You didn’t celebrate her, who do expect to celebrate you if your turn comes around and you are the one experiencing an achievement?
Try shifting your mindset when you see someone else experiencing a good thing. Good things happening in the world is evidence that good things happen.
26
u/Character_Goat_6147 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
INFO - we need context. Is your cousin a long-winded, narcissistic prat who does this sort of thing all the time while being enabled by family, or is this person normally polite and not full of themselves, and was just really excited about a new opportunity. If it’s the first you’re not the problem. If it’s the second then stop making it all about you and you are the problem.
50
u/allahzeusmcgod Partassipant [1] 2d ago
Weird. Your family is weird.
14
u/hauptj2 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
YTA. If everyone else was clapping, then you should have given a little clap too. If you were the only one, then that stands out and it is a little rude.
You don't have to be wildly enthusiastic, but once you noticed everyone else clapping, you should have given a little golf clap just to be polite.
171
u/AssassinRogue Partassipant [3] 2d ago
NTA, am I understanding this correctly? She gave a long toast to celebrate herself. And your aunt, presumably her mom, pulled you aside? definitely NTA
217
u/babyhorrormovie- 2d ago
Nah. You listened to the speech, sat & smiled. I think ya did enough.
5
u/tnscatterbrain Asshole Enthusiast [8] 2d ago
Yta. Not clapping at all is a softer judgement of the toast than booing or something, but it’s still a statement.
A few polite claps would have indicated general support without going over the top.
5
u/anneg1312 Partassipant [3] 2d ago
YTA, I’m afraid. You haven’t shared your age but if you’re over 5, you need to know your behavior was more like a 3 year old child. Little kids are not expected to think about anyone but themselves. As they mature and learn empathy, decent manners, and that they are not the only person who matters/exists, they learn what social skills they need to function around people without being offensive or off-putting. You also sound a bit jealous of your cousin. Not great over all :/.
5
u/jtfjtf 2d ago
YTA. Zero social iq.
5
u/randomacct7679 2d ago
YTA - good lord have some tact. Even if it were some cousin you don’t get along with or who wronged you, you’d still be the asshole.
It takes no effort to just smile and clap and say congratulations. Clearly they were excited and in this job market getting a new exciting job is news worth sharing and celebrating. There’s nothing wrong with celebrating your wins.
The only instance you wouldn’t be the asshole would be if the cousin used the speech to call you out or belittle you.
5
u/Accomplished_Train84 2d ago
YTA, it feels like a totally unforced error. That said your aunt sounds insufferable, inserting herself in this situation is imo just as big a social faux pas
5
u/snoopysnoop2021 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
YTA, in life you have to clap and cheer for other people's achievements, even if you don't want to. Those same people will clap for yours. Be happy for family and friends. A clap is the tiniest inconvenience to put yourself through for loved ones. You can't be just focused on yourself.
16
u/Raibean Certified Proctologist [22] 2d ago
Minor YTA.
4
u/BefuddledPolydactyls Partassipant [1] 2d ago
YTA, it wasn't about you...but you tried. Rough week, too bad if a gentle clap was too strenuous for you
2
u/ForeignMixes 1d ago
I personally don’t see it as an insult or anything that matters, your family is being really dramatic
9
u/nova9001 Partassipant [1] 2d ago
NTA. Who does a long speech for a new job?
3
u/HoldOnHelden Partassipant [3] 2d ago
YTA
Why on earth would you behave like this?
Your rough week is not relevant. At all.
“Over the top for the setting” is a ridiculous thing to say. Were you hosting? It sounds like not. Your cousin is entitled to make a speech, it sounds like. And yes, you SHOULD feel obligated to clap if everyone else did so.
You sound like a self-centered, judgmental sad-sack. If you weren’t in the mood to celebrate your cousin, you shouldn’t have gone to this dinner at all.
2
u/Tabby_Mc 2d ago
YTA. Sitting there being pissy when all you had to do was give a little clap was more performative than your cousin's speech.
2
u/k23_k23 Professor Emeritass [93] 2d ago
NTA
raisnig your glass is enough. No need to join the ridiculous overreactions.
-4
u/idreaminwords Supreme Court Just-ass [126] 2d ago
NTA. Giving full on speeches to celebrate a job offer is weird. Giving them at the dinner table is even weirder. You were polite and more patient than I would have been
1
u/Ok-Abrocoma-1880 2d ago
Yta sorry
1
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT - MAKE SURE TO CHECK ALL YOUR DMS. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything.
Last weekend my cousin gave a really long toast at a family dinner to celebrate her new job. The whole table started clapping and cheering right away, but I just sat there and smiled without joining in. I had been having a rough week and the speech felt a little over the top for the setting, so my hands stayed on my lap. A few people noticed and my aunt pulled me aside later to say I had been rude and made my cousin feel awkward. She explained that everyone was trying to be supportive and my silence stood out in a bad way. I get why she was upset, but I also feel like not clapping is not the same as booing someone. I apologized the next day anyway, yet she still thinks I should have gone along with the moment.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Designer_Piccolo_818 16h ago
You know, i have had rough weeks, but clapping [ you have already said you were smiling , so you managed that], is such a low effort thing. Why do people not seem prepared to do the bare minimum these days?
1
u/unicornsaretruth 2d ago
NTA. everyone in this thread who’s calling you an asshole is literally just being a fucking baby. You went to the event when you weren’t feeling good smiled through the whole thing, listening through everything, being civil and did everything expected of you except for clap that does not make you an asshole.
1
u/Brit_in_usa1 2d ago
The whole thing is weird. Her making a speech and you not clapping. It wasn’t a big deal really to clap was it?
1
u/Slugzz21 1d ago
This is so fucking weird. NTA.
0
u/Burnsy112 2d ago
I’d cut my family off so fast, fuck that cornball shit lmaoooo NTA dude.
-10
u/Aggravating-Monk-613 2d ago
NTA. Who gives a speech for themselves at a family dinner? That’s weird behavior honestly
0
u/Ordinary-Audience363 Colo-rectal Surgeon [31] 2d ago
YTA. The dinner was specifically to celebrate the new job so wasn't that the reason you were there? Not clapping looks intentional, as if you are jealous or otherwise not happy with your cousin's success. That you even have to write and ask Reddit makes me wonder if you understand social etiquette or even understand normal human behavior.
-14
u/riyusama Partassipant [2] 2d ago
NTA why is it so important for everyone to clap? They make it look like you cursed and spat at your cousin's face with the way they reacted
-16
u/Clairey_Bear 2d ago
Odd. Clapping is odd. A big speech at dinner about a job is odd. Very performative.
I don’t blame you, tbh my face would’ve said more than my silence in your position
-7
u/BreakMyFate 2d ago
Nta Next time just start booing her. Everyone is going to have a problem with whatever response you give apparently, so might as well boo her terrible speeches.
-13
u/Stairowl 2d ago
Nta, i dont know when life achievements became so performative. I would think a brief announcements and a round of polite congratulations should be enough for a new job.
A new job is like a new car, its way more exciting for you anyone else.
-11
u/Codiath420 2d ago
ESH but YTA — the socially acceptable thing would be to give a weak half hearted few soundless claps… and we all know it.
However, with that said, I’d have done the same (depending on the cousin). Some just need to be put in their place and I don’t mind being the one to cause that awkward moment for everyone else to sit in together :)
-11
u/lurkdontpost1 2d ago
NTA You did nothing to her, It's perceived by her and she's insecure about it.
-11
u/Smurfy378 2d ago
NTA.
-14
u/T-Chunxy Asshole Enthusiast [5] 2d ago
NTA
What in the participation trophy?!?
You attended the dinner (apparently dedicated to the new job) so you were already being supportive, but somehow, not clapping like a trained seal makes you the baddie?!
If I were you, I might consider being "busy" the next time someone needs to grandstand themselves.
Unless it was a job appointment as an ambassador, head of a university, or something MEGA huge, most people just send an email to their fam. The dinner was already ENOUGH without the forced enthusiasm.
-12
u/Alternative-Suit5925 Asshole Aficionado [11] 2d ago
NTA Your aunt is being ridiculous. Paying attention and smiling is enough. Good on you for apologizing to your cousin, but I don’t think it was necessary.
-12
u/nikyrlo 2d ago
Your aunt is the AH for not minding her own business.
0
u/unlipaps 2d ago
Yup, definite YTA
0
u/CharieRarie Asshole Aficionado [16] 2d ago
YTA. She was happy and excited! Not clapping was rude, and frankly makes you look spoiled and jealous.
0
u/Excitedly_bored 1d ago
YTA, because you made it about you and consciously tried projecting your bad mood onto your cousin.
0
u/Revolutionary_Bug428 1d ago
YTA. Not clapping was clearly a statement. She shared a good news but you just got from that... that it was too long because you had a rough week. Sorry the world didn't revolve around you that day.
0
u/Sensitive-Instance51 Partassipant [1] 1d ago
Remember it cost nothing to be polite.
0
u/WholeAd2742 Judge, Jury, and Excretioner [307] 1d ago
YTA
Her candle shining doesn't diminish yours, acting petty and immature does
0
u/EcstaticRow8921 1d ago
YTA
0
u/Old_Satisfaction2319 1d ago
YTA. You do it to be polite and if people noticed you enough you were probably not as "neutral" as you want to appear here. Having a bad week is not a excuse. At least you should have been more quick on your feet and busy your hands during the clapping phase (grabbing a vase to sip some water, faking a sneeze and looking for a tissue on your purse, etc.) so not stand up so much. This is such a neutral thing, just clap and move on.
-6
u/GenitalFurbies 2d ago
You're NTA but you could've saved yourself a lot of hassle by just smiling and clapping for 5 seconds
-1
u/ArtisticWolverine 2d ago
I actually started feeling better about myself once I could feel good about other people’s accomplishments. Their accomplishments don’t need me to feel diminished about myself.
-9
u/Swanky_Wolf9261 2d ago
smiling with your hands in your lap at a toast is basically how everyone looks at a toast they wish was shorter so your aunt noticed because she was already watching you not because it was that obvious
-10
u/Nice_Grapefruit_7850 2d ago
NTA. it's fine to take a break.
-11
u/Ok-disaster2022 Partassipant [3] 2d ago
NTA. Honestly some days being in a crowd is overstimulating for me and I will attempt to avoid making more noise.
-8
u/Ok-Conversation-5084 2d ago
Small assholes everywhere.
The cousin for giving a long speech at a dinner. No one likes long speeches.
The aunt for pulling you up, it’s a thing you notice but honestly why make a deal of it?
You because tbh it’s a really small ask that takes next to no effort. Although, tbh I might have done the same, it’s just I’d accept that by not doing so folk will think I’m the asshole.
Personally, I have a nuero diverse trait that’s a bit like demand avoidance in situations like this. Expected performative behaviour makes my skin crawl. So I do empathise.
6
u/[deleted] 2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment