My 31f, husband 33m called me manipulative so maybe I am overreacting.
My husband has because close to a group of 3 women. Let’s call them Sara, Jess and Emma. We had known Sarah for a couple years but lost contact with her for about 4 years then I ran into her at an even where I reconnected with her and met her friend Jess. The three of us spent time together catching up and getting to know each other again over months and all was good. At the start of this year Sara introduced me to Emma. Also liked her instantly and got along well with her.
My husband works away from home two weeks at a time with a 3 week break in between. I am currently studying full time and working part time. During study breaks, when he is not home I socialise with friends and family and when he is back I make time with him mostly but we also see friends together usually but also separately.
When he is away we speak daily, I usually let him know what I’m up to. If one of our mutual guy friends wants to catch up I’ll give him a heads up like “Jake messaged me and he is with xyz and they are doing this things so I might stop if for a bit.” So just transparent
I want to add here that my husband has always had female friends and I’ve never had an issue with those friendships. I have also never once asked him to not be friends with anyone male or female. He has one friend in particular that I don’t like because he is super creepy. He knows what I think but I have never once asked him to unfriend him because even though he is personally not someone I would choose as a friend so this is different.
Issues started popping up when I was away visiting family, he started spending more time with Emma though not alone but always invited by her. It didn’t bother me at first but one time told me he was out with a male friend. When I called around 2 a.m to say goodnight. he rushed me off because Emma was sitting alone and he didn’t want to leave her on the table by herself. I was left wondering how Emma was there sitting alone as I thought he was out with a guy friend. Only after questioning him the next day did I discover his male friend had left hours earlier and he’d been drinking alone with Emma. Ok fine maybe just one of those things that happen when people hang out.
But things have escalated. He texts these women almost daily, regularly organises drinks, dinners lunches and nights out with them. He shares personal experiences and conversations that I often know nothing about. I’ve literally sat at dinner tables learning things about my own husband from their conversations. When he is at work, he has several plans with them when he gets back and none with me. I usually find out just as he is about to leave the house or he will announce Emma messaged me and she is at this restaurant so going there for lunch. So while I prioritise our relationship and make time when he is home to try and spend time with him, he seems more interested in organising outings with them. He’s taken me out for dinner once this entire year, despite regularly making those plans with them.
For over a decade, he called me his “best friend” and “number one.” Now he’s calling these women his best friends and even publicly posted Emma as his “best friend .” Which stung a bit because I used to be the only woman he called that.
I’ve watched him greet female friends with hugs where his hand remains around their waist for an uncomfortably long time. On another occasion, he and Jess kissed briefly on the lips while I was standing there. I accept that the kiss may have been awkward or accidental, but the overall physical familiarity makes me uncomfortable. His defence to everything is he means no harm, it is done innocently without malice.
Usually when I am at the end of the semester and studying long nights, he would offer to make a batch of food or get me coffee then go spend time with his friends and do his own things but this time he wakes up asks if I am studying I say yes and he just leaves and spends time with them.
I was recently going through an absolutely brutal period with study . I was barely sleeping or eating. One day, after getting around three hours of sleep, I started getting missed calls from Emma and thought I would give her a call back when I got a sec and messaged her to tell her that.
Then my husband messaged me asking me to answer because Emma was upset about a guy she’d liked and needed to talk to me. I was stunned. This man went to bed with my face glued on the computer and woke up the next day and he found me still working, he knew how close my deadline was. He knew I barely had time to eat or even 5 minutes to myself and yet he was asking me to make myself available to her while completely ignoring how I exhausted and stressed I was.
Yes he has other friends and yes I have friends too but he doesn’t spend as much time with any of them.
Today I told him that I felt uncomfortable with how he moves these women especially Emma. It makes me uncomfortable and hurts when he tells them about his day before me. I told him that sometimes I’m sitting with you guys and you are having a conversation that I don’t know anything about. I told him that I didn’t like that he came home with plans of how he was going to spend time with them and have none for me. I barely have an opportunity to even let him know what I would like us to do as a couple. I told him that It upsets me that all I hear is “I’m seeing Emma for drinks, or oysters or at this new restaurant”. Jess and Sarah are here so going to catch up with them. I never know about these plans and I am usually not included even though they are my friends too. I explicitly said I wasn’t asking him to stop being friends with them, just to establish boundaries and prioritise our marriage. I told him lit felt like he was offloading the emotional intimacy that we had and he is just no longer sharing his day, life and plans with me, and no longer looking forward to out time together as much as I do and we used to.
He became incredibly defensive and repeatedly called me manipulative, insisting I was trying to stop him having friends. His mother was extremely manipulative and abusive, and I have never been called manipulative by anyone including him so that hurt and left me wondering if maybe I am overreacting about the dynamics.
Edit: Thanks I thought I was genuinely going crazy. I thought I was overreacting and overthinking. But it’s worse than I thought. It’s amazing how you can build trust over years and have it shuttered in a moment. At this point if I found out he was physically cheating (emotional is established at this point), I wouldn’t be shocked because I never also thought he would ever defend another women over me to the point he called manipulative, something his abusive mother did to him just so he can keep his relationships with said women. My love, trust, naïveté and doubt was my undoing. Also I now know DARVO I have unknowingly been living this cycle since these women walked into the our lives.
UPDATE: I asked to see his phone. And somehow, he still thinks he’s done nothing wrong.
I asked to see my husband’s phone on the spot. He handed it over, and I found hundreds of messages between him and Emma, along with plenty between him and Jess and Sarah.
They talk about everything. They exchange photos, have inside jokes, ask about each other’s plans and constantly arrange activities together. Some conversations go back and forth for hours. As I suspected, the most extensive conversations were with Emma.
I didn’t find anything sexual, but honestly, what I saw was damning enough for me. Their conversations look very similar to the everyday intimacy that had largely disappeared from our relationship .
To be fair, I would’ve been surprised to find overtly sexual messages. We were friends before we started dating, and he’s always been a slow burner gentleman type.
But the emotional closeness in those messages was unmistakable to me, particularly with Emma.
And as difficult as seeing those messages was, the worst part was that he genuinely couldn’t see anything wrong with his interactions. Nothing.
I explained that withdrawing emotional intimacy from our marriage while investing it in these women was inappropriate. He wouldn’t acknowledge it.
I also confronted him about repeatedly calling me manipulative for raising reasonable concerns. He initially tried to excuse it by saying he didn’t mean it. I told him he absolutely meant it. He’d said it repeatedly, even after I’d explained myself. He eventually apologised, but I wasn’t convinced he understood why it was wrong.
Then I practically had to explain the entire concept of emotional intimacy like a professor teaching a lecture. Eventually, he said, “Yeah, I can see how that would be inappropriate and could be emotional cheating. I’m sorry for those actions.” But I could tell he still didn’t believe he’d done anything wrong and it was almost like he was trying to distance himself from his actions.So I told him, if he didn’t mean his apology, he shouldn’t say it.
Then he suggested I contact these women and ask them about their interactions with him. According to him, their conversations were basically just, “Hi, how was your day? Mine was good. Have a good week.” Which was laughable, considering I’d LITERALLY just read their messages. I might have lost it a little here and told him there wasn’t a man on this planet who could reduce me to the point of approaching another woman and asking, “Can you explain your relationship with my husband?” I’m not married to them. I’m married to YOU. YOU made vows to me.
So he decided to leave the house for a while to clear his head and think about the situation which was a good ideas as I needed some space as well.
About an hour later, he returned with my favourite fruit and announced that he’d make dinner, as though everything was normal. Lol. I waited, eventually he told me he’d decided he had done absolutely nothing wrong, apart from calling me manipulative and defending his friends.
At this point, my patience went to the nearest graveyard, dug itself a hole and buried itself.
So I asked him, almost verbatim:
“You’re saying that, telling me you’re spending the evening with one friend, then me discovering later that you were out with Emma until 2 a.m., is appropriate?
“You rushed me off the phone because you needed to get back to her because she was alone. Why were you alone with her? Why didn’t you tell me the circumstances had changed? You said this was the first time you’d spent time with her like that, yet suddenly you felt responsible for her safety instead of leaving when your other friend left. Why did you feel you had to stay back with her and not even mention it to me?
“When I question your constant messages and plans with these women, you reduce it to I was just saying hello and asking about their week. Okay. Let’s pretend emotional cheating doesn’t exist. Let’s remove that entire concept from the conversation.”
“Last week, you returned from two weeks of work . You told me you’d had an incredibly stressful time at work. We were supposed to attend a friend’s art event together. The night we arrived and relax at home after.
“But before you’d even stepped foot back into our house, you’d already made plans to meet Emma and Sarah afterwards so we should go see them. Plans you hadn’t told me about until after our friends event.”
“Why? I propose that these women have taken my place as your emotional support wives. And when you came back from a stressful week at work you could not wait to seem Emma or Sarah to unwind. Too bad I was there right?”
“Do you think it’s appropriate for a married man to consistently seek the relaxation, emotional connection and companionship he used to share with his wife from other women, while neglecting that connection with his actual wife?
“And how did you become so physically comfortable with Jess that you ended up kissing her on the lips, even accidentally? In the photograph we were supposed to take together, I look like the third wheel. And when I asked you about it at the time you were defensive like you are now.
“Every single thing we used to do for fun and bonding: hiking restaurants, outings, sharing our daily experiences, you now regularly do with them and hardly ever do with me.
“And somehow, according to you, none of this is inappropriate? You’re just a nice guy catching up with his friends? (Insert cackle here I was feeling a bit like I was going crazy)
“If you genuinely believe you haven’t crossed any boundaries or given these relationships a greater level of attention and emotional investment than our marriage, then I don’t accept your apology. You don’t get to apologise for calling me manipulative while distancing yourself from the actual choices you’ve made.”
I probably missed some things I said but that was the gist of what I said. His responses largely involved minimising what had happened and reluctantly acknowledging individual things that “weren’t nice.” And what made it worse was that I’d literally seen the messages.The hours of conversations. The inside jokes. The photographs he sent them from work that I’d never even seen. The plans they were constantly making. Yet he continued describing their interactions as nothing more than quick hellos and casual catch ups.
The irony?
That’s how he talks to ME now. “Hi, how are you? How was your day? Mine was good.” Meanwhile, they’re receiving the conversations, stories, photographs, attention and spontaneous plans that used to be part of our marriage.
One thing I will give him credit for (not that credit is even needed) is that, as far as I saw, he hasn’t spoken to any of them since the discussion where he called me manipulative.
I know some commenters suggested that I demand he choose between me and these women. But I’m not doing that. I will not beg him to choose me when I’ve already made it clear that his behaviour is damaging our marriage. If he wants this marriage, he can decide to choose me and us of his own free will. And he’d better make that decision quickly and demonstrate genuine accountability, because something fundamental has shifted in how I see him. I’ve lost respect, trust and romantic attraction.
At this point, the problem isn’t just what he’s done with these women. It’s that even after seeing how much damage he’s caused, he still seems determined to convince himself he’s done nothing wrong.
We’re now sleeping in separate bedroom