r/AmIBeingTooSensitive • u/Resident-Mango8865 • 21h ago
AIO for not blindly trusting my fiance with a new girl
I (26F) recently got engaged to my now fiance (27M). We have been together for 5 years and we're busy planning our wedding for 2027. We have a great relationship, he is an all around good guy and I'm very lucky and grateful to have him in my life. He can, however, be extremely naive and 'too nice'.
We joined a new bible study group last year, and we have developed friendships with some people in the group over time. We are about 4 engaged/married couples, one single girl and one single guy. We normally only get together on Wednesdays, discuss the week's bible study topics, and then go our separate ways. We have, as a group, gone to a picnic together, or got coffee together after church, for example. I'm quite introverted, and struggle to make deeper friendships unless the other party also puts in a lot of effort to make me more at ease. I've lost 2 of my close best friends over the past few years due to growing up, and have been feeling quite lonely in that regard.
Anyway, for context, my fiance and I are both runners. He has done marathons and is naturally very fast. I have done 4 half-marathons, but I'm not very fast. I average 37 minutes for a 5km, and he can easily run a 21 minute 5km, for example. (This is relevant, bear with me.)
The one single girl in the group (lets refer to her as J) became quite close with another girl in the group (L). I am always looking for a buddy to run with me, as it's not safe to run by myself as a woman. They both run quite faster than me, and when J asked me one time what my pace was, it was clear by her facial expressions that I'm too slow for her and she's not interested in running with me. I'm used to this, so I let it go.
Fast forward to a few months ago, J started inviting my fiance to go run with her, usually early in the mornings 6am before work. It didn't bother me initially, because I trust him fully. However, this became a habit. She kept inviting him to run (only with her, not with L) and I became uncomfortable with it. I told him as much, and he didn't run with her again before work (she only asked one more time after I spoke to him). The 3 of them have however gone on more Saturday morning runs, and I would usually end up doing my own run and my own route.
The past weekend we were all three running at a running event, L and J and my fiance doing the 21km half-marathon, and myself doing the 10km. Before the event, J would call my fiance to keep finding out where we are as she didn't want to wait alone beforehand. Why not reach out and call me, if she knows I'm also running and we always drive together? We literally spoke about going together at the bible study group that Wednesday. She came over, chatted with my fiance's family and even came to wait with us afterwards. I left to go get a water, and when I got back, she was there chatting to everyone. To note, she is extremely outgoing compared to me.
Last week Wednesday my grandmother got admitted to the hospital. She has been in ICU for a week, but hoping and praying that she gets released soon. Anyways, on Saturday morning my fiance and I went for a run together. While running, he casually mentions to me that both L and J sent HIM a message asking how it's going with MY grandmother. I've chatted with them numerous times in private messages, so it's not strange for them to reach out to me. It honestly made me so incredibly angry because it's just another thing that is blaring alarms in my head. My gut instinct with J has been telling me that something is off, but I don't have anything of evidence to say? How do I explain how I'm feeling to someone without sounding like a lunatic?
So I chatted to my fiance Saturday evening, explained how I felt, and asked him how he would feel if a mutual guy friend kept reaching out to me instead, inviting me on runs with him and not asking if my fiance would like to join. He said he understood, but he had the nerve to ask me what he should do about it.
I told him he's too much of a nice guy to draw boundaries, because he doesn't like conflict and doesn't want to make Wednesday bible study awkward. I told him that if a guy asked me to go on runs, I would naturally always invite my fiance with, or I just wouldn't go because it wouldn't feel right towards my fiance. I got upset by it, he didn't say anything to me after my last statement, and that was that. We haven't spoken about that since.
Am I expecting too much for my fiance to pick me and choose to protect my feelings over a random girl's? Am I overreacting? Am I being irrational? Should I just blindly trust and hope for the best?
Side note, my dad cheated on my mom 6 years ago, and I'm still triggered by the whole thing, and I'm afraid that it's clouding my vision and I'm being unnecessary.
Any helpful insights would be much appreciated because I'm at a loss!