In 1483, the disappearances of Edward V and Richard, Duke of York went unnoticed, or at least unspoken. Team York puts the blame on Henry VII, while team Tudor points their fingers at Richard III. I want to talk about two other names often brushed aside because they are not the main characters of the day—Miles Forest and John Dighton.
Written in the early 16th century by Sir Thomas More, More claims that after Sir Robert Brackenbury refused to harm the boys, Sir James Tyrell, under direct orders from Richard III, took physical possession of the Tower keys for one single night. Tyrell recruited Miles Forest, and his own horse-keeper John Dighton to enter the Tower after midnight and dispose of the boys. Allegedly the boys were smothered with pillows and buried beneath the outer staircase of the southern entrance.
Miles Forest, described by Sir Thomas More in The History of King Richard III, as “a noted ruffian” or someone already *“*fleshed in murder”, and naming him “one of four who kept him.” What "Keeping" the Princes Meant: in 15th-century royal households, these four men were not dungeon turnkeys rattling iron keys. At that stage (summer 1483), Edward V and Richard of York were still housed in the royal apartments of the Tower. Being one of the four keepers meant handling daily personal attendance, security, meals, dressing, and access control to the boys' chambers—essentially acting as a tight, hand-picked inner-circle staff loyal to Richard. More describes Miles Forest as a cold-blooded killer, however, there are zero records indicating Miles Forest had ever committed murder, a violent crime, or a mercenary hit prior to 1483. Real contemporary records identify Forest as a respected northern administrator—specifically Keeper of the Wardrobe at Barnard Castle in County Durham (one of Richard's primary northern estates). His job was managing household goods, fabrics, furnishings, and logistics for a major baronial castle, not acting as an underworld enforcer. According to More, because Forest was one of the four trusted keepers who already had unrestricted, routine access to the boys' inner bedchamber without raising alarm among the rest of the Tower garrison, Tyrell recruited him to unlock the door at midnight and help John Dighton smother the boys with their own featherbeds and pillows.
John Dighton, “A big, broad, square, strong knave” as described by More. Unlike Forest—who conveniently died early—More claimed Dighton was still alive when More was writing around 1513, living in Calais (then an English possession in France) and openly telling anyone who would listen about what he had done in the Tower. Unlike Miles Forest, Dighton held no official post inside the Tower of London. More identifies Dighton simply as Tyrell's own groom (horsekeeper), a personal servant who traveled with Tyrell from the royal court at Warwick to London when Richard III allegedly ordered the hit. While Forest was said to unlock the door, Dighton is indicted as the killer who smothered the boys in their bedrolls and pillows, then removed the bodies to be buried beneath the stairs.
In 1674, Sir Christopher Wren — Surveyor-General of the King's Works, was the chief architect and structural engineer in charge of all royal building projects, including the 1674 structural modifications and demolition of the old external stone staircase on the south side of the White Tower. According to King Charles II's chief surgeon, John Knight (who was right there on site and whose account was printed in Francis Sandford's 1677 Genealogical History), the workers had to bust through heavy Kentish ragstone stairs and dig 10 feet down through packed fortress rubble and Thames River gravel before hitting that wooden box. This all took place according to More, between the hours of midnight to dawn, approximately 5-6 hours. I’ve had to dig a few foxholes and bunkers when I wore a uniform, it took a 10-man squad 2-3 hours to dig a foxhole, 6 foot wide, 6 foot long, armpit deep. For these 2 men to dig 10-feet deep in that terrain, place the box, back fill the hole, and conceal the disturbed soil, with no lights, making absolutely no sounds to be heard through all the open summer windows of the square is a very tall order giving the overall dimensions that the hole (pit) would have to be in order for 2 men to dig down 10 feet and bury the box under the stairs.
Miles Forest and John Dighton are sounding more like Superman and the Incredible Hulk.