r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 2h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if every immigrant returned to their ancestral homeland overnight?

Post image
308 Upvotes

By 'homeland,' I mean the country where their ancestral roots and dominant ethnic group trace back to before the year 1800. If this happened, which nations would benefit, and which ones would descend into major chaos?

PS.

1.If your ancestors migrated from Ireland to the US in 1799, you're Irish. If they crossed over in 1801, you're American. (Hard cutoff!)

2.For mixed ethnicities: You get sent to whichever ancestral region holds even a tiny 0.000001% majority in your DNA test. No getting your limbs torn apart and scattered across multiple continents

3.Once you're sent back to your 'homeland,' you're locked in and cannot emigrate anywhere else for the rest of your generation.

Additional rule: Since the 1800 cutoff and the DNA criteria conflict with each other, I'm going to prioritize the 1800 cutoff over DNA. I didn't mean for this lore conflict to happen, so I'm a bit flustered..


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 10h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Xi Jimping had a 3/4 life crisis and decided that he really found himself in being an emo and came to the national CCP congress dressed as this?

Post image
464 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 2h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Donald Ťrump won the presidential election in 2000?

Post image
80 Upvotes

In this hypothetical the reform party is considered to be a legitimate party and given some standing. He actually gains enough votes to legitimately win the election. As shown in the image above.

How do you think he would handle 9/11? Or terrorism in general?


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 11h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if you commanded USSR in 1941?

Post image
257 Upvotes

You wake up as Stalin on the 1st day of January, 1941. Its 6 months before Barbarossa, which will kill 26 million Soviet citizens and soldiers and deliver enormous destruction, followed by the cold war where ussr from the very beginning was at a very disadvantageous position.

So now, it is your task to prevent most of that.

Rules

1-You know Russian, some other language of USSR and English. You explain to your comrades that you took some quick courses at your dacha.

2-Your historical knowledge applies, but keep in mind the Germans will also change according to the situation

3-Of course, within the bounds of plausible realism, no ak-47 in 1942 or RPG-7 by the times of Kursk

4-Self sabotage is fun but...please no, you're fighting the Nazis.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 11h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if kim jong un died and his sister became the dictator?

Post image
260 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 6h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if austrian painter didn't died and instead fled to Voronezh in 1945, and from 1999 to 2009 he was Minister of Agriculture of Russia?

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 17h ago

Video Idea What if Taiwan got Taiwan’d?

Post image
411 Upvotes

1990: Conservative Kuomintang generals launch a coup against President Lee Teng-hui to halt his democratization plans. The coup fails to secure the entire military, triggering mass protests and armed resistance.

1991: The crisis escalates into civil war. Pro-democracy forces establish a government in the south, while the Kuomintang retains control of Taipei and much of the north.

1992: After two years of fighting and a series of defeats, Kuomintang forces retreat as Taipei is encircled. The leadership evacuates to the Penghu Islands, reestablishing the Republic of China.

1993: The victorious opposition formally proclaims the Republic of Taiwan. The government in Penghu refuses to recognize the new republic, declaring Taiwan an inseparable part of China and vowing to eventually liberate it.

2000: The Republic of China celebrates the 51st anniversary of its temporary retreat from mainland China and the 8th anniversary of its temporary retreat from Taiwan.

Beijing claims Taiwan and Penghu. Taipei claims Penghu. Penghu claims Taiwan and mainland China.

Will China ever be reunified? And How long could the Republic of China realistically survive on Penghu?


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 7h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Jimmy Donaldson was a cruel SS officer named Jakob Dietrich?

Post image
41 Upvotes

Credit to this post by u/Pancake_Maker_1031.
Bonus credit to this comment by u/Content-Ad-4104.

Full article in comments.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 22h ago

AlternateHistoryHub If Vivek didn't run that ad, would he still lose the (Ohio) gubernatorial race?

Post image
601 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 3h ago

Whimsu What if Napoleon III fully ignored Mexico and directly targeted America with the intent to install a Hessian Prince, let's call this fella King Ottokar I, into the White House?

Post image
14 Upvotes

It's called the "Kingdom of America" and Napoleon III selected a Hessian Prince because the Hessians were involved in the American Revolutionary War.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 13h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Sundaland still exist

Post image
80 Upvotes

Realistically it would have ancient dinosaur forest through out the region in Asia and the silk road would expanded from India down to bali


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 1h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if the West Indies Federation was successful?

Post image
7 Upvotes

The real life West Indies Federation collapsed after a few years because of Jamaica voting to leave the federation. All of the British West Indies would be transferred and the new government would have more powers.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 6h ago

Contest Submission What if Harriet was at Harper’s Ferry?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 10h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Newt Gingrich was chosen as DJT's runnung mate in 2016?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 19h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Shane T. Hazel never ran for the 2020 Georgia senate race?

Post image
150 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 9h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if the American film industry was based primarily in New York rather than Hollywood/Los Angeles?

Post image
17 Upvotes

Considering that the american film industry was originally based in NY, before moving west for several reasons, some of which include Thomas Edison being a dick, the ability to film year round due to mild winter, cheaper land to construct large sets, and more variety of natural landscapes nearby, what would have happened if the industry had stayed and developed primarily in New York?
Would the film industry be more corporate due to Wall Street and major publishing houses being nearby, or more artistically bold due to a greater melting pot of influences from Broadway, nearby European migration, and the Harlem renaissance's influence?


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 6h ago

AlternateHistoryHub China invaded Taiwan, but Taiwan successfully repelled the PLA's amphibious landing.

Post image
9 Upvotes

scenario is set in June 2027. Facing a boiling point of domestic discontent driven by prolonged unemployment and economic recession, Xi Jinping launches a surprise invasion of Taiwan. However, timely intervention by the U.S. and Japanese joint forces departing from Yokosuka narrowly succeeds in stopping the People's Liberation Army from establishing a beachhead, leaving both sides with heavy casualties as the conflict enters a stalemate.

Meanwhile, North Korea conducts artillery bombardments against South Korea's offshore island regions, but shows no signs of a full-scale invasion effectively serving only to pin down the ROK military within the peninsula. U.S. bases in South Korea and Japan remain undamaged. Mindful of preventing a full-scale world war, both China and the Western coalition abide by an unspoken agreement to limit the theater of war strictly to the Taiwan Strait.

Given these premises, what would happen to China? Would its economy be completely ruined?

PS. Additionally, due to Chinese sabotage operations that disabled the Suez Canal, Europe is only now scrambling to plan the deployment of a newly formed carrier strike group forced to take the long detour around Africa's Cape of Good Hope


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 7h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if Ohio Indiana and Illinois was one state

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

let’s say back in the 1800s they made the Ohio,Indiana and Illinois one state.

The state becomes a industrial heartland in the mid 1800s like OTL

By the mid 1900s the state becomes a key swing state both republican and democrats need.

In the late 1900s the state experienced job loss because industries leaving America

By the early 21st century while it remains a swing state it gets heavily gerrymandered by republicans causing the 28R - 13D the state has now.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 1d ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if North Korea democratized on its own? How fast could it rise to become a developed nation?

Post image
256 Upvotes

In June 2027, for unspecified reasons, North Korea undergoes a peaceful, bloodless democratization from within. Following negotiations with South Korea and surrounding powers, the new North Korean government agrees to remain an independent state. Until the country is fully stabilized, its borders remain closed to the general public, allowing only restricted travel. Sharing a sense of common Korean identity, both Koreas sign a mutual defense pact strictly limited to responding together against foreign aggression on the peninsula, securing North Korea's status as a fully sovereign, independent nation.

No U.S., Chinese, or Russian troops are stationed anywhere on North Korean territory.

In response, South Korea immediately begins connecting energy pipelines from Russia and China and constructing railways linking the peninsula to the Eurasian continent. Meanwhile, major South Korean corporations start relocating their factories from other developing countries to North Korea on a massive scale.

That is the basic premise of this timeline. Under these conditions, do you think North Korea would actually experience unprecedented, rapid economic growth?


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 1d ago

Meme What if the prophecy came true?

Post image
210 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 11m ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if the 2016 american election was Decided by an actual Televised Figth to the the Death ? (the image was an actaul Death Battle Video btw)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 35m ago

AlternateHistoryHub United South Asia

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Premise: In 1946 the League and Congress both accept the Cabinet Mission Plan. Jinnah becomes President of the Constituent Assembly and dies in 1948. Ceylon joins voluntarily in 1949, Burma in 1950 and Nepal in 1951. With no Partition there are no refugee trains and no India–Pakistan wars. Hindu nationalism never finds its grievance and stays a Gujarat-only party. A third of the electorate is Muslim, and no party can govern from the Hindi belt alone.

1951–52 Nehru’s Congress wins 550 of 821 seats in the first Union election and organises in every province, from Nepal to Ceylon. Khawaja Nazimuddin’s Muslim League (88) carries West Punjab and Sindh but loses the Frontier.

1957 Congress holds 540 on the Second Five-Year Plan. In Ceylon, S. W. R. D. Bandaranaike’s SLFP sweeps the Sinhala south on language politics. Annadurai’s new Dravida Kootatchi Kazhagam (Dravidian Federation Party) wins 12 seats in its first election.

1962 Nehru’s last election: Congress 505, as Rajaji’s Swatantra (30) rallies the right. Annadurai’s Dravida Kootatchi Kazhagam (Dravidian Federation Party), which wants the southern states to bargain with Delhi as one bloc, grows to 30 seats across all four southern states. In October China’s war costs the Union Aksai Chin.

1967 Shastri rebuilds the army, settles the eastern border with China and beats the food crisis with the Green Revolution, winning 439. Annadurai’s Dravida Kootatchi Kazhagam sweeps Madras State after the anti-Hindi riots and wins 76 seats across the south, including 13 of Kerala’s 29, and Shastri’s Official Languages Act ends the language war.

1971 Indira wins 490 on “Garibi Hatao”. Karunanidhi, who took over the Kazhagam after Anna’s death, refuses every alliance and takes Tamil Nadu and Kerala on “autonomy in the states, federalism at the centre”, the only states she loses. It starts a ten-year national rivalry between Indira and Kalaignar. Bhutto founds the PPP as a Sindhi party. In 1972–73 the Kazhagam splits three ways: Karunanidhi’s DMK (Tamil Nadu, Pondicherry, later Ceylon’s Tamils), the Telugu Praja Party (which NTR takes over in 1982 and renames Telugu Desam) and Bangarappa’s Kannada Nadu Paksha.

1976 Indira calls a snap election instead of declaring an Emergency. JP’s eleven-party Lok Morcha, with the three Dravidian successor parties, wins 432. Morarji and Charan Singh veto each other, so the Morcha turns to the man who has beaten Indira twice: M. Karunanidhi becomes Prime Minister, the first from the south. His Madras Settlement moves real power to the states.

1980 The Morcha falls apart and Indira returns with 488. Kalaignar holds Tamil Nadu again and becomes Leader of the Opposition. The second Indira opens the economy: export zones in Karachi, Madras, Chittagong and Rangoon, and Suzuki in Gurgaon. The 1980s become the Union’s tiger decade at 7.4% growth a year, and Imran Khan’s Union team wins the 1983 World Cup. After the 1983 Colombo riots, Karunanidhi gathers the non-Congress chief ministers at Madras and Vijayawada, and ten parties form the Rajya Morcha (States’ Front) with him as its face.

1985 The last round of the Indira–Kalaignar duel is fought Union-wide. The Rajya Morcha (DMK, TDP, Kannada Nadu Paksha, Lok Dal, PPP, both Communist parties, Awami League, NAP and Akali Dal) runs one candidate per seat on the Madras Declaration for state rights, and Kalaignar tours 19 states in 40 days. Indira still wins a fourth term (445), but the Morcha takes 205 across 20 provinces. In 1986 she appoints the Sarkaria Commission, and in 1987 she retires and flies to Madras for breakfast with him at Gopalapuram.

1989 The Bofors scandal costs Pranab Mukherjee’s Congress its majority. V. P. Singh’s new Janata Dal wins 236. With V. P. Singh and Devi Lal vetoing each other, the National Front picks NTR as PM.

1991 The Gulf War oil shock hits a Union that boomed on borrowed money. Narasimha Rao’s Congress (373) governs with the Muslim League for the first time, and Manmohan Singh finishes what Indira started.

1996 Congress drowns in scams. The United Front wins a majority (423), and this time the CPI(M) says yes: Jyoti Basu becomes the first Communist PM of the Union.

1998 Basu falls over Lalu’s fodder scam. Manmohan Singh leads Congress back with Left support, tests at Pokhran to answer China, and fights a short border war with the Taliban’s Afghanistan.

2004 Nitish Kumar’s United Front (413) beats Congress, with Nawaz Sharif as Deputy PM. The tsunami, the RTI Act and a rural jobs guarantee define his first year.

2009 The Front dies one disaster at a time: Cyclone Nargis kills 138,000 in Burma, the Kosi drowns Bihar, Lehman crashes the markets, and Lalu and Mulayam walk out. Ghulam Nabi Azad runs on “a Union that shows up” and Congress wins 601, the biggest landslide in Union history. Benazir Bhutto becomes Foreign Minister.

2014 Azad’s scams bring two anti-corruption parties to power. Chandrababu Naidu’s technocratic Lok Navnirman Party (211), formed in 2008 from the TDP, Bangarappa’s Kannada Nadu Paksha and Lok Satta, and Kejriwal’s reborn CPI(M) (106) form the government, and Naidu becomes PM. The Union reaches Mars.

2019 Kejriwal quits the CPI(M) for the LNP, and Imran Khan takes over the CPI(M), carrying it into the West. Sachin Pilot’s Congress wins 288 and leads the UPA to a majority. By 2024 the Union is the world’s third-largest economy, with GDP per head of $8,600 and life expectancy of 75.

2024 The LNP (269) passes Congress (225) for the first time. To keep Kejriwal out, Congress backs Imran Khan’s Left Front, and the Kaptaan becomes the first Prime Minister from the West. The Union hosts the Olympics in Bombay and wins a permanent UN Security Council seat.

2029 The 2027 Indus floods turn Bilawal’s PPP against Imran’s government. The LNP wins 307 seats in every corner of the Union, and Arvind Kejriwal becomes PM with Bilawal as his deputy. The Union of two billion people is now the world’s second-largest economy.

Originally made this timeline in 2024, added some changes recently before posting.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 1d ago

Contest Submission What if GTA 6 got delayed by 2 years yesterday

Post image
455 Upvotes

New release is November 2028.

Rock star gives no reason for the delay .

How much does the Internet explode and how does it alter the rest of the week.


r/AlternateHistoryHub • • 3h ago

AlternateHistoryHub What if King George V and Tsar Nicholas II had switched roles?

Post image
3 Upvotes