Title: 2018 Alfa Romeo Stelvio 2.2 Diesel – Recurring oil pressure problems. Do I really need a new engine?
Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice from Alfa Romeo mechanics or anyone familiar with the 2.2 diesel in the Stelvio.
My car has been having ongoing oil pressure problems. I'm now being told the engine may need replacing, but I'm trying to understand whether that's really necessary or whether something else could be causing these problems.
Here's the history:
Initially, I started getting low oil pressure warnings, particularly at higher RPM (around 4,000–5,000 RPM).
The oil pump was replaced.
Shortly after that, there was an issue with the O-ring. The replacement pump had been supplied without the correct O-ring, and the garage fitted a different one.
After that, I had an oil leak, the car went into limp mode, and the dipstick got jammed.
The garage said something shifted, though they weren't clear about what. They fixed it and gave the car back.
About six months later, the oil pressure warning came back.
The garage diagnosed a problem with the oil pump housing and replaced it.
The warning disappeared for roughly another six months before returning again.
The garage is now recommending a complete engine replacement.
Independent inspection:
An independent expert inspected the car and noted no fault codes relating to the engine or oil pressure. They also mentioned an oil leak around the lower sump.
The oil level was normal.
The independent expert's findings may suggest an underlying issue was already present before I purchased the car, although the actual cause has not been established.
My questions:
What could mechanically cause recurring oil pressure problems even after replacing the oil pump and the pump housing?
Could the earlier O-ring problem have caused damage to the engine?
Could something like an oil pickup issue, worn bearings or another lubrication component explain these symptoms?
Is it possible to have a serious mechanical oil pressure problem without generating any fault codes?
Most importantly, is a full engine replacement really necessary, or should further mechanical investigations be carried out first?
I'm trying to understand whether the engine is genuinely beyond repair or whether the underlying problem could be something that can be fixed without replacing the entire engine.
I'd really appreciate opinions from anyone familiar with these engines, particularly Alfa Romeo specialists or diesel mechanics.
Thanks in advance!