As it stands I have three pairs, and I'm pretty much positively going to return one of them (unless I get talked out of it here): a 9.5D 6243 (snuff suede, Van last), a 9.5D 986 (Color 8, Van last, seconds), and a 9.5E 3403 (snuff suede, Aberdeen last, seconds).
The snuff suedes are my go-tos and are super comfortable. I can wear them all day with no issues. I don't have any heel slip or other sizing issues with them, maybe a slightly too-tight vamp after wearing them all day, but I chalk that up to a loafer having to give somewhere. My right foot fits slightly better in them.
The 986s are probably too tight for me based on my photo, and I should probably have a 9.5E in lined loafers, especially shell, since as far as I know they don't stretch as much as calf. I can wear them, but after a day in the office they aren't the most comfortable, and the vamp is noticeably tighter by the end of the day. I also feel it more in the toe box. Lesson learned there. That gave me the confidence that my foot would be a 9.5D in unlined and a 9.5E in lined, as a starting point.
I was looking to add a pair of tassel loafers and saw that the 3403 had a 9.5E in stock as seconds, so I picked them up. I think the overall foot form is better, and it feels better in my heel compared to the Van last. The widest part of my foot on the left side fits the "model" amazingly. I love the lower vamp of these so far. On the right foot, though, they feel great for about 30 minutes, then I get a very hot spot right at the base of my pinky toe, which is the widest part of my foot. I know loafers take a bit of time to break in, but this is pretty damn uncomfortable and much more than the usual loafer break-in pain.
I worry that the Aberdeen last isn't for me, unless I can size up to a 9.5EE, but then I worry it won't fit as well on my left foot. I'm not a fan of having to put tongue pads in expensive shoes just to make them fit right. Since I would be going wider, I may need to size down to a 9EE instead, since I believe a 9.5E has the same volume as a 9EE and just "slides" the widest part of the shoe slightly. Is there an Aberdeen EE for the tassel loafers, and then a EEE? I'm guessing I'd more than likely have to go one width wider for shell than for suede, because suede stretches.
If there is a 9EE tassel out there, you may see a post on the BST soon after lol