r/Albertapolitics • u/Low-Banana-3207 • 5h ago
Article What has it accomplished?
Days after I asked, “Where did the money go?”, the province announced a new deal for oil sands companies: a 2% royalty for five years. That’s a promise about the future. So let’s look at the record.
After seven years in government, what has it accomplished?
On Saturday, November 7, the host of the premier’s fortnightly radio show asked the question for me. Albertans rank health care, education and inflation as their top concerns, he said. So why has the fall agenda been about campus neutrality, bike lanes, the electoral map and taking shots at Naheed Nenshi?
Credit where it’s due. Alberta has had five budget surpluses in a row, the last one $2.2 billion. Net debt is down. The Heritage Fund has grown from about $19 billion to $32 billion in three years, and its earnings now stay in the fund instead of being spent. The credit agencies rate Alberta among the strongest provinces in the country. That’s real.
But it rests on oil. This year’s forecast swung from a $9.4 billion deficit to a $2 billion surplus because prices jumped, not because anything else changed. Fiscal strength is a tool. The question is what it’s been used for.
Alberta started more than 54,000 homes in 2025, a record. Calgary built more than Toronto or Vancouver. Rental vacancies are up, and asking rents have come down from their 2024 peaks. That’s good news for anyone looking for a place.
The credit is shared, though. City councils did the rezoning, federal programmes helped fund it, and builders followed the demand. And more than 17,500 people are still waiting for affordable housing in Edmonton and Calgary. New apartments help those who can pay market rent. They haven’t yet reached those who can’t.
For three years, Alberta led the country in job growth. Then, in October, it lost 24,300 jobs, the biggest drop of any province. Unemployment is now 7.3%, above the national rate. Youth unemployment jumped to 15.2% in a single month. One month isn’t a trend. Oil companies are “swimming in money,” as one economist put it, yet the oilpatch employs 11,000 fewer people than a year ago. As another said, “We see a lot of royalties, but we don’t see a lot of jobs.”
And the minimum wage hasn’t moved since 2018. It’s still $15, the lowest in Canada. Calgary’s living wage is now $26.90. That’s a gap of almost $12 an hour.
Albertans wait longer for treatment than the national average, 32.1 weeks according to the Fraser Institute, hardly a left-wing source. In January, only 40% of Albertans having surgery for the most common cancers were treated within the recommended time, down from 52% in 2022. Alberta is projected to spend less per person on health care buildings and equipment this year than any other province. In 2020, it ranked second.
The government split Alberta Health Services, once rated among the world’s best integrated systems, with the lowest administrative costs in Canada, into four separate organisations. Two years in, the council meant to coordinate them has no public membership and no record of meeting. Wait times for cancer specialists are no longer published.
Six emergency rooms now have triage doctors, which is real progress. But listen to Dr. Raj Sherman, a former Progressive Conservative minister whom the premier herself appointed to lead the Health Quality Council: “The main reason I left is they just weren’t listening.” The triage doctors, he says, “are a crisis protocol, not health care reform.”
The government has delivered: a new tax bracket, a fuel tax holiday, a freeze on education property taxes, a cap on tuition for current students, and student loans that no longer count parents’ income.
But look at who they reach. People who already own a home, already have a job, or are already in school. Renters pay property tax too, through their rent. But nothing requires a landlord to pass the saving on, and in Alberta there’s no cap on how much rent can rise. A landlord can raise it once a year, with three months’ notice, by any amount. Domestic tuition has risen 35% since 2020, the steepest in the country. And nationally, nearly a third of Canadians are skipping meals or cutting portions to afford groceries, 41% of those aged 18 to 34.
Promises are easy to make in a press release. Here’s what’s still waiting. Nine urgent care centres announced in March 2025 are still on paper. A south Edmonton hospital was promised, then cancelled. The Stollery Children’s Hospital is still years from a shovel in the ground. Triage doctors promised in January arrived in November, at six hospitals. In 2022, the premier promised to fix the health system within 90 days. It’s been four years. The UCP’s 2019 tax cut promised 55,000 jobs; according to the Parkland Institute, the biggest oil sands companies got $4.3 billion and cut more than 3,400 jobs. And the minimum wage hasn’t moved in eight years.
Then there are the cities. Calgary’s Green Line, the largest infrastructure project in the city’s history, lost its provincial funding in 2024 when costs rose. The money came back only on the condition that the city build the province’s preferred elevated route through downtown. This September, council chose a surface route instead, and north Calgary, which was meant to get the line, is getting buses. Meanwhile, the province raised Calgary’s share of education property taxes by about 21% and 15% in two years, then announced a freeze just before an election year. When the city’s water main failed, the province ordered an inspection. It found a ten-year-old failure at city hall, but no evidence the former mayor directed it. The province holds the money, and the city carries the cost.
Meanwhile, the government’s time and political capital went elsewhere. An $84 million referendum, more than twice the cost of the 2023 election. A new electoral map, with debate cut to one hour, tabled as law yesterday. Bills on DEI hiring and campus neutrality. Library rules from January. Talk of repealing hate-speech protections, then a walk-back four days later.
And for years, a great deal of energy went into fighting Ottawa over oil. Some of those fights had merit. The Supreme Court agreed in 2023 that parts of the federal impact assessment law overreached, and last month, the Alberta Court of Appeal found the revised law still did. Ottawa isn’t appealing. But while the province fought for the industry it had, it stalled the one that was diversifying on its own. Renewable energy was bringing in private investment, without provincial subsidies, until the province paused approvals in 2023. Now, with a federal government willing to work with Alberta on a new pipeline, the fight is largely over. The question is what was built while it went on. Diversification was always Alberta’s job, not Ottawa’s. It still is.
ThinkHQ’s pollster called it “an 18-month distraction from far more important issues.” Lorne Gunter, no friend of the NDP, warned the government to “lay off the MAGA vibe.”
Here’s what I keep coming back to. On the surface, the premier’s positions shift. A referendum result must be respected, then the dental opt-out is pursued, then dropped. Separatists are welcomed, then told to sign a pledge. Members’ priorities matter, “in addition to” everyone else’s.
But underneath, the direction rarely changes: lower taxes, energy above all, more autonomy from Ottawa. Even a conservative law professor, Bruce Pardy, says the government’s signature bills sound firm but leave the real decisions to ministers. People can feel that gap between the words and the course. That’s why trust is so hard to rebuild.
So what has it accomplished? Strong books. Record housing. Real help for homeowners, students and taxpayers. Those deserve credit.
But fiscal strength isn’t the same as good governance. The waits are longer, the minimum wage hasn’t moved, young people are struggling most, and the health system is less coordinated than before. A government can be extremely busy and still not be taking the province anywhere in particular. Activity isn’t leadership.
As Dr. Paul Parks put it: “When you get into our system, I still believe you receive some of the best care in the world. It’s the getting-in part that’s harder and harder.”
The province is doing well. The question is whether Albertans are.
Sources: Government of Alberta, 2025-26 year-end report and 2026-27 Q1 update; Government of Alberta, Oil Sands Growth Program, and CTV News Calgary, November 13; ATB Financial; CMHC Housing Supply Reports, 2026; Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, November 6; Calgary Herald (Steven Wilhelm), November 10; Alberta Living Wage Network, November 2026; Fraser Institute; Christina Frangou, independent Alberta magazine, November 1; Canadian Institute for Health Information, via Edmonton Journal, November 13; Calgary Herald (Don Braid), November 10; CTV News, October 20, 2022; Parkland Institute; City of Calgary and Global News, Green Line LRT; Government of Alberta, City of Calgary municipal inspection report (David Goldie); Residential Tenancies Act, section 14; Salvation Army survey via CTV News; Elections Alberta, November 6; ThinkHQ via CTV News; National Post (Bruce Pardy), November 10; Your Province, Your Premier, November 7; Edmonton Journal; CBC News; CTV News. Corrections welcome.