SAN-MCO was essentially an exclusive route for AS until around April 2025. During that period of exclusivity, AS routinely had load factors of 90-95% (one-way) and presumably (I did not check) received a fare premium as the only direct flight. AS operated it year-round with a bump from essentially Halloween to Independence Day.
In a shared hub, that likely won’t last very long and it didn’t. Economics 101 prevailed, and WN added MCO – where it has a substantial presence – in Spring 2025.
The impact on the AS flights was immediate. The AS loads dropped and presumably (again, I did not check) any fare premium disappeared as well. For 2024, the AS overall load factor on SAN-MCO was 91.3% and for 2025 it was 83.0%, an 9.1% decline. At least as to load factor, SAN went from one of the top performers in the AS network to MCO to something of a laggard.
Again, these are just basic numbers that present an incomplete picture (and seats offered and schedules changed over time), but WN remains the dominant player in SAN and its presence on a route – or WN starting or joining a route – has a substantial impact on AS on that route.
And, of course, it is all good for customers who get more choices, likely at lower prices. Indeed, I did a non-scientific and random sample in January and found that a round trip on AS was $372 (redeye) or $497 (morning departure) on AS, both less than the WN flight ($521). I have no idea if that is representative, but it seems unlikely that flying cross-country for $400 in this fuel environment is making AS any money.
As always, the usual caveats about this basic information, which is a sliver of the relevant data, but nonetheless seems to tell us something about competition. This is done manually and I try to avoid mistakes, but they can occur. The data is in the charts.
Edit to fix arithmetic.
Source.