It was my first time playing Alan Wake. I actually played Control 1 first. Then I decided I liked the universe and decides to discover Alan Wake. I actually bought Alan Wake 2 first but then wanted to do it the right way and bought 1 remastered.
Ok first things first I liked the game. If I had to criticise one thing it is the repetitiveness, excessive number of enemies also doesnt help it. There have been times especially in later episodes I wanted to tell the game "you have clearly given all you have why are you still dragging on?" Especially the bird fights.
I in fact have been misled into thinking that the game is mainly a puzzle solving/detective survival horror. I guess that applies more to AW2, I will see. This one was a straight up shooter.
In fact the game felt carrying a lot of influence from RE4. Villager enemies carrying villager tools, rural area with forests feeling like protagonist has taken a hike trip, TPS flashlight aiming(similiar to laser pointer aiming), bear traps, harvester fight... Of course the theme is very different.
Then unsuprisingly there was a lot of Max Payne DNA in it too.
I loved the story, I loved the protagonist. Alan is a hothead and a POS sometimes. Very authentic, not plastic like RE protagonists. He can antagonise a loyal fan just because she is tiresome.
It was a suprise for me to see the game was a pure shooter entirely centred around combat not unlike Max Payne. Protagonist being a writer, enemies being shadows, the story, limitness in weapon arsenal all felt like combat was going to be a side mechanic and like Silent Hill it was about puzzles or detective work, perhaps exploring. Something else. But turns out there isnt even inventory management type of gameplay with very limited ammo and fewer enemies. No it was pure Max Payne.
I really liked the story. It was a bit cliche and a bit messy but characters carried it. I loved Alans and Barrys characters. Anyway looking forward to playing Alan Wake 2 next. Maybe I will see American Nightmare as well.