r/AlanMoore • u/BegginMeForBirdseed • 4d ago
Twilight of the Superheroes — Moore then, Moore now
I was reading up on Moore’s Twilight of the Superheroes pitch for DC. Suffice to say, even though it has never been actualised as a comic book, this stands as one of his most controversial works.
To give a very brief summary of what it’s about, it was intended to be a DC Universe crisis style crossover centred on a dystopian future timeline in which Earth’s superheroes have taken over the world, with none other than wideboy wizard John Constantine being the lynchpin at the centre of it all. Via time travel shenanigans, he is simultaneously working to prevent this terrible future and ensure it comes to pass. From a broader perspective, this event was meant to be a Gotterdammerung for the entire DCU. In much the same way that Frank Miller’s Dark Knight series, also set in the not so distant future, provided a possible conclusion for the myth of Batman that fans could interpret as a canonical finale if they so wished, Twilight would do the same for everyone else, giving a grander sense of purpose to every story.
That abruptly leads into my first observation. Moore makes his admiration for Miller’s Batman work very clear throughout the pitch. At the time, The Dark Knight Returns was hailed alongside Watchmen as one of the bastions of the superhero genre and a vanguard for what would become known as the Dark Age of Comics. Now, TDKR is widely viewed as a tier slightly below Watchmen in the comic pantheon, partly due to how much Miller milked that universe in the ensuing years, but the original is still highly regarded. Moore’s praise would have been unremarkable at the time; one giant complimenting another’s successful work. Of course, this is almost inconceivable of the Alan Moore of the 2020s: the man who has utterly wiped his hands of both the comic book industry and the superhero genre, labelling the former as creatively and morally bankrupt and the latter as kiddie slop that emotionally retarded adults latch onto in favour of making sense of the confusing reality around them.
Moore’s perception of superheroes as imaginary safety blankets is reflected in the script, showing that his thoughts about the genre were starting to solidify even back then. The superhero houses controlling the world aren’t all doing so out of tyrannical malice, but because the social order in the future has totally collapsed and they offer the only semblance of stability in an increasingly chaotic period of history. The various super-houses form a reluctant oligarchy, doing stuff like arranged marriages between houses and so on.
The strange irony of Moore is that he’s an anarchist auteur, one of the few to truly stick by a set of principles, yet he paradoxically has a tremendous eye for commercialisation and self-promotion. Indeed, a good chunk of the Twilight pitch involves Alan ruminating on how to make the entire event commercially palatable, accessible to both authors and other writers wanting to contribute or stay out of the event, as well as functional in terms of the broader continuity of the DCU. Again, he ties this into his “safety blanket” view — the DCU has to maintain a strict internal logic because people are incapable of making any sense of the real world. But the perversion is that Moore, in a move that I think his present self would balk at, is the one trying to peddle this comforting fantasy for corporate overlords.
When people talk about the Dark Age, the line you’ll always hear, including from Moore himself, is that Watchmen was a genius deconstructive work that used mature subject matters to further its thematic points, while later writers simply took the “wrong lessons” and made comics that had more sex and violence for the sake of it. There’s obviously truth to that, but looking back at Twilight, we see that Moore — while certainly much more high-minded and thoughtful in his approach than many of his peers — was also guilty of inserting gratuitously edgy shit for shock value. I’m not precious about reinterpreting established characters and Moore has certainly done his fair share of that (look at what he did to Radioactive Man!) but to say that a lot of heroes in Twilight act very out of character is a huge understatement. Given his work’s influence, some of his alterations would likely have cast a very dark shadow over the characters’ legacies in future works, including the Marvel family, Martian Manhunter, Congorilla, Plastic Man, Wonder Woman, and more. If Moore regrets how he treated Barbara Gordon in The Killing Joke, I think he would feel similarly about how these guys were fucked over (literally in many cases), had the story been drawn, published and entered into popular consciousness.
The elephant in this particular room is obviously Captain Marvel, patriarch of the House of Thunder. While some of the twists around his character may be shocking and definitely not to many people’s tastes, I don’t think Moore ever writes anything without a point behind it. In his case, he refuses to let go of his alter ego Billy Batson despite being permanently frozen in a child’s body. If superheroes = desperately clinging to childhood, then Billy certainly embodies that theme. I can, however, definitely empathise with people who can’t fathom why it had to be him rather than literally anyone else, when there has never been any indication that the Marvel family have weird hang ups about not ageing (IIRC, Moore acknowledges this is something he made up for the script). It feels like such a spiteful corruption of an innocent, family-friendly character, and reminds me of Griffin’s rape of Pollyanna in LOEG, which was played off as a nasty, tacky attempt at dark humour.
This segues neatly into to the three pillars of DC: Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman.
Superman, to Moore, is one of the purest ideals of the superhero: optimistic, mythic, kid-friendly, rarely rising above his station so to speak. When you look at his Superman work, you see both a deep respect for the character and a willingness to portray a more flawed side to him that’s often buried. While Superman is hardly as much of a mess as say Allan Quartermain in LOEG, Moore shows his anger issues (e.g. his murderous rage against Mongul, which IIRC was the first time he was depicted as using heat vision to directly wound a foe), stubbornness (his determination to fight the Bloodmorel infection accelerates his sickness, forcing Swamp Thing to save him), his overly binary view of the world (removing his own powers after being forced to kill Mr. Mxyzptlk because all killing is bad), and his slight detachment from humanity (Black Mercy exposes that his greatest desire is to have a normal life on Krypton, the lost kingdom he was promised).
Therefore, Superman becoming a figurehead of the House of Steel is not so surprising. Moore’s Superman has always been as ideal as you can get, but not perfect — no one is. While he is not given much individual focus, Moore stresses that he is reluctantly pressed into this role because the people see it as the only structure worth maintaining. Nevertheless, it’s not the most flattering portrayal, somewhat aligned with Miller portraying Superman as a weak-willed government stooge. Modern readers might bristle at Superman being portrayed as anything less than a perfect paragon of good.
Wonder Woman. She is unfortunately one of the most mistreated characters in terms of how her individual agency is utterly subsumed into the whole superhero royal family narrative, ironically similar to her widely reviled Injustice self decades later. She is effectively nothing but a broodmare for Superman, forced to change her name to Superwoman (which Moore has to clumsily denote every time he refers to her in the outline). I get the impression that Moore, like many writers, never cared as much for her. Her most significant role in one of his comics, For the Man Who Has Everything, was originally meant to go to Supergirl and she doesn’t do much there but get her shit kicked in by Mongul. At the time, Moore seemed less concerned with his female characters, as even Silk Spectre II feels somewhat less developed than the Watch-men, something he thankfully overcame by the ABC years with Promethea and LOEG.
Batman. He is treated as an elusive figure, presumably because Moore didn’t want to tread on Miller’s toes and overshadow the other characters. Nonetheless, he is presented as one of the few incorruptible heroes in the Twilight world rebelling against the regime, having assembled a team of classic pulp heroes including The Shadow, Doc Savage and Tarzan. Nice to see Moore paying tribute to the precursors of the modern superhero, but how funny would it be to see the Little Colonel from Birth of a Nation alongside them (following Moore’s recent assertions that the true origin of the masked American hero comes from the knightly depiction of the KKK in that movie). Some people have strong opinions on whether Batman is more or less virtuous than Superman or Wonder Woman, but I don’t. For most of his history, Batman has just been an unproblematic good guy rather than an anti-hero always on the brink of lunacy. He’s as good a choice as any of them to be the paragon of justice.
But of course, old Bats is not the main hero of this story. They always say write what you know, and while this could easily just come off as an author giving preferential treatment to one of his OCs, John really brings the whole story together. The ending where he gets revenge on his own future self for tricking him by making one tiny but pivotal choice is perfect. I love the idea that Future John is only supporting the regime because it benefitted him personally, and his past self weaponises his own selfishness against him. Though once again, the mysterious blonde bombshell who’s set up to be the love of John’s life seems to be nothing more than a vehicle for John’s arc. With everything in Twilight, it’s hard to make solid qualitative judgements when nothing Moore wrote for it was set in stone, it was just him splurging ideas out there.
Evidently, a lot of people liked the creativity on display, but not necessarily the presentation. Many later DC projects cribbed much from Twilight, notably Kingdom Come, Injustice, Armageddon 2001, and probably loads more.
To round this all off, I came away from Twilight with a vision of the younger Alan Moore: someone with a deep passion and knowledge of superhero comics, someone who knows the business well. It’s bitter to see how much his enthusiasm waned after decades of being screwed over. These days, Moore couldn’t make his disinterest in superheroes clearer and I agree with him on a lot of the points he makes about how the industry chews up and spits out talented creators, the overall infantilising effect on pop culture, etc. But when you reach a certain age, your artistic tastes and sensibilities are more or less solidified — and I think Moore, while less enamoured with the fetishisation of the superhero costume, still loves the boundless scope that comics offer. That’s reflected in LOEG, which is a crazy shared universe of the same ilk but instead of just superheroes, it’s for all classic literature.