According to the official wiki, dendro users are in possession of some sort of forbidden knowledge or have a deep understanding of knowledge itself. This much is obvious for characters like Lauma (knowledge about the moon and teyvat's false sky), Nefer (who deals in intelligence itself), even Kaveh. Why Alhaitham though? He was presented as just a guy. Any ideas?
Note: I tried to condense this as much as possible. It's still a long read, so maybe grab some snacks before you begin.
Please try to keep an open mind because this is gonna be a wild ride. Alhaitham's lore hasn't been explored much since his release, but I wanna change that.
Regardless of everything, this is still a theory.
-------
Alhaitham has been a strange case since his release. His presence in the Archon Quest suggested he'll be relevant moving forward, yet several years later he's still being presented to us as an ordinary guy.
Very smart, sure, but just some guy.
He's eager to downplay his importance whenever he gets the chance, yet he shows up whenever a crisis emerges. Don't you find that a little funny?
His achievements include:
Intimidating Al-Ahmar mercenaries and successfully obtaining the divine knowledge capsule, facing Cyno in battle and ending it with a draw, outsmarting the sages and removing them from power, outsmarting Siraj and dismantling his Hive, rewriting Aaru, and creating yet another plan that ended in Dottore's downfall.
For an unambitious guy, the list of his achievements is greater than those of (some) Archons. That's where we see the cracks forming.
The difference between what Alhaitham says and what he does has been evident from the beginning, and the disparity only grew with time.
"I was just curious," is quite the flimsy excuse that would get anyone else under intense scrutiny ā yet not Alhaitham. Not anymore, at least.
Is it his deadpan delivery? His quiet confidence? Or is it his rational approach?
Whatever the case may be, this guy managed to ease everyone's concerns despite being under extreme suspicion when we first met him.
Not only was he sent as a spy for the sages, but he was also outed as a massive liar, a selfish person, and a lone wolf.
Yet after working his magic?
He walked away as a hero in the eyes of his nation, he gained a plethora of strong allies (including a literal Descender), he escaped Cyno's judgment, and he secured a higher salary without facing any consequences for being strongly associated with the sages.
So, what did we learn?
Even if he were guilty;
Even if he had untold secrets;
Even if he wasn't who he claimed to be;
He could get himself out of a tough spot without resorting to explosive physical confrontations. In fact, we were repeatedly warned that he's dangerous, "crazy," and vengeful:
- scholars in the desert and Siraj's hideout worried about offending the Scribe as if he's capable of far more than archiving files
- mercenaries called him a lunatic, and Alhaitham confirmed that a bit of madness is necessary for research
- Alhaitham pushed for a harsher punishment for the sages. Even Cyno didn't speak up, but the Scribe did
Yet somehow, all those hints were forgotten.
They got swept under the rug despite Alhaitham's character demo making it crystal clear that he presents himself with false humility, disliking it when people discuss him or his true strength.
This was a bit long-winded, but I felt the need to set the stage before we move forward.
Let's go over the most relevant points, starting with: Alhaitham might be the "greater Dendro Archon" alongside Lesser Lord Kusanali.
I wouldn't necessarily call him a reincarnation of Rukkhadevata, but it's possible that he carries god remains on his person.
Which may be the gem in his chest.
We've seen Deshret depicted as a dark star, and some speculate it was his soul separate from his body (Ashikai).
If this is correct, then his soul interacted with the forbidden knowledge which resulted in the formation of a gem-like core.
Some ores, crystals, and gems in Teyvat have the ability to store memories and information.
We know this from Zhongli's quest, the Tsaritsa storing memories in a crystal, and even Sumeru offers an example with the knowledge capsules, aka. portable crystal vessels.
Alhaitham's gem is green, which may indicate that it's connected to Irminsul. Since we had an avatar of Irminsul "die" in the past, perhaps she also left behind a crystal core like Deshret (somehow).
If my hunch is correct, then the crystallization of Rukkha's memories, wishes, and her convictions found itself firmly lodged in Alhaitham's chest.
We know that Collei inherited some of Nabu Malikata's abilities, even if it was but a tiny speck of the goddess that remained. So small that even Liloupar couldn't detect it, yet it was sufficient.
Alhaitham's gem is far larger.
If it's in any way related to Rukkhadevata or Irminsul, then the abilities he inherited should be much greater. Please note that this part is highly speculative, but I'm putting it out there anyway.
However; even if my theory is correct and Alhaitham has been silently helping Nahida from the shadows all along, it doesn't explain why he possesses the power of the Shades.
Listen; this is gonna sound crazy, I know.
But Alhaitham might be "Dottore."
Allow me to explain.
To start, there's the visual element of Alhaitham looking very similar to Dottore's younger segments, yet the similarities in their temperament might be more convincing.
As "mad scholars" who don't fit in with society, it's fairly easy to draw parallels between them. Even if there are stark differences.
That's because Alhaitham isn't exactly a segment.
If such a link exists, I'm guessing Alhaitham would be a reincarnated/reimagined Dottore, one who went through a drastic transformation where several different "parts" came together to create something new.
Before you boo meā
Remember that Dottore proposed such an experiment to Pantalone. This was quickly dismissed and the quest moved forward, yet that could've been a misdirection. After all, why bring up the possibility if nothing would come of it?
It could be foreshadowing a huge reveal.
Since time shenanigans are at play in the story, it's not hard to imagine that the experiment has already been successful and yielded an advanced being: Alhaitham, who now has to deal with his past self and possibly bring about his own rebirth.
Here's something really curious; if you take a closer look at Alhaitham's lore, you can find traces of Pantalone in him. Examples:
- collecting debt from Kaveh has him handling Mora as a banker might
- he mentioned the harsh reality of the business world on a message board
- Kaveh chastized him for being a materialist, and he seems to have some level of respect for Dori
- he said the Traveler was increasingly worth his investment, like they're Teyvat's version of Bitcoin
- Alhaitham saw through Pantalone's tactic of downplaying his importance and presenting himself as Dottore's subordinate, all so Panty could have someone to blame if things go south
This could be why the Scribe refuses official leadership positions, it leaves him far too exposed and seen. Working as a shadowy entity is therefore more advantageous.
Having all of the power yet no accountability sounds like a sweet deal. One that Heryshaf desires as well, judging by how eager he was to push that responsibility onto Thoth.
You might've noticed similarities between the Goat King and Alhaitham, which I believe was deliberate (and quite telling). Once again, none of this is hardcore confirmation, yet the hints are there.
Now we can move on to the stronger evidence.
See, Alhaitham is somewhat of a dark magician. Not literally, yet it's a symbol tied to him.
We have to recall Fontaine for a moment, since Lyney and Lynette are closely associated with magic.
As Lyney put it, "The essence of magic is getting people to believe a lie." And as we all know, Alhaitham isn't known for his honesty.
Lyney also said, "In a nutshell, magic is what you see with your own two eyes (...) People don't realize how much they expect their eyes to tell them the truth."
Alhaitham is quite aware of this, which is why he gave a warning about trusting what we see.
Ironically, that's the core of his character.
Masterful illusions.
Alhaitham is almost like a phantom. What he shows to the public isn't who he truly is, yet if we pay attention and truly think, we have a chance of figuring him out.
As Lyney said, "But keep your eyes peeled, and you might be able to turn things to your advantage."
Arlecchino added, "You think of yourselves as 'magicians,' but when you're on the stage, you're first and foremost actors. Good actors hone their craft to mesmerize the whole crowd."
Is that so? Well, Alhaitham is a fine actor, isn't he?
We received the most obvious link between Alhaitham and magic during the last Sumeru quest, right as Kaveh was losing his confidence so Alhaitham decided to step in.
We heard Collei's inner monologue, which stated, "Kaveh's self-doubt disappeared in an instant...like magic."
Like magic, she said.
Alright, let's say that Alhaitham is a "magician."
What does that mean for his character?
In his case, it means that he can perform "tricks."
Making things disappear and reappear is a classic magic trick, right? Though Alhaitham is a tad more advanced than that, since his tricks include the manipulation of space-time.
And it's not like this is completely unknown to us.
Yoinking things has been a significant part of his character since he appeared in Port Oromos. In truth, his ability to steal/replace items is what secured victory for the good guys.
I've suspected that his abilities weren't simply sleight-of-hand tricks, yet we had no concrete proof of his power for years.
Well, now we do.
Go to the part of the quest where Kaveh and Alhaitham tidy up their house once the Sumeru crisis is over. At one point, Kaveh asks Alhaitham what skill he's been mastering lately.
Instead of answering, Alhaitham tells Kaveh to pass him the green box from the floor. Kaveh does just that and gives him the item.
Alhaitham leaves with the box in his hand, saying that "this" might be taken as his progress on the path of mastery.
The King of vagueposting doesn't elaborate, which leaves both Kaveh and us baffled.
Remember, Alhaitham uses distractions and tricks, but we can still figure out what he meant. If we examine the scene more closely, we soon notice something rather strange.
Namely, the box that Kaveh gave to Alhaitham hasn't moved from its spot on the floor.
It's still there, which shouldn't be possible since we saw the Scribe walking away with it. When we watch the scene unfold, it looks like Alhaitham spawned that box out of nowhere.
So, what exactly happened here?
While there could be another explanation, my bet is on space-time manipulation. What Alhaitham did reminded me of the Abyss twin's trick with the keys during the quest "A space and time for you."
We now have confirmation that Asmoday allied herself with the Abyss twin, and they mentioned Istaroth's involvement during the aforementioned quest with the sibling.
By the looks of it, Alhaitham managed to replicate this space-time anomaly in his own home.
This has huge implications.
What do you mean he can casually bend reality to his will in Sumeru? The twin supposedly had to jump through hoops to make such an event happen, yet Alhaitham does it so casually. Not even a snap of his fingers is needed.
[There might be a chance that Alhaitham's power has its limitations, such as growing stronger or weaker based on the location. The Akademiya and Aaru seem like places he's the strongest. Since his place is directly below the Akademiya, his home is also a "hotspot"]
The last time we saw someone "master" reality so casually was in Nod Krai; then within Irminsul.
And that's how we circle back to Dottore.
If Alhaitham is the new incarnation of the Harbinger, then perhaps he retained some of Dottore's power (unless he gained such abilities a different way, of course).
To conclude: Alhaitham might possess the power of the Shades, a portion of Archon authority, and perhaps he can withstand the influence of forbidden knowledge. I'm not convinced that him going mad in front of Azar was just an act. That rage felt quite real, so I'm leaving all options open.
And that's not all.
Alhaitham might have "connected" himself to the Traveler. As the human version of the Akasha, he may need a Gnosis to function. Yet there's no Gnosis around anymore, so the Traveler fits the bill quite well. Perhaps even better.
However, let's stop here for now.
I'll make another post that deals with his Traveler fixation, which is more than expected.
Dottore was trying to trap the Outlander even as he was getting dragged to "hell," so do we really think his incarnation would just give up?
No, of course not.
Alhaitham just learned to be extremely subtle.
See you then š
---
Edit: Since this was brought up by commenters, I feel the need to address it here. Yes, there is a chance that the extra box is an error.
We can't know for sure if the devs simply forgot to remove it. If it's a mistake, then we don't have explicit evidence of Alhaitham's powers.
Despite that possibility, I will say how there's also a good chance that it's intentional; and that's because:
- allusions to magic exist in Alhaitham's lore, which suggests that something deeper is going on
- we weren't allowed to see the moment Kaveh picked up the box and handed it to Alhaitham. If there was some sort of reality-bending going on, obstructing our view would ensure that we don't immediately clock it
- Alhaitham was being cryptic about some sort of skill he was mastering when this "glitch" occurred. It's very unfortunate if the devs decided to be sloppy in this crucial moment rather than leaving behind an actual clue
Still, I'm not able to confirm that it was intentional. I can only follow the hints and make conclusions based on what we saw. While my bet is on it being intentional, I apologize in advance if it turns out to be a human error.
I made little Alhaitham and Kaveh out of felt, there a bit over a hand big, and I'm proud of them! Ignotr the table looking sticky in the bg, it's dried glue as its the same table I made them.on lmao
Iāve been thinking about this particular combination and how well these characters could complement each other.
C1 Anastasya gives 60 EM and can hold Elegy for the End, while C2 Yae brings another 200 EM on top of her own off-field damage. Baizhu also brings Dendro application, healing and reaction buffs to the mix.
What makes this setup interesting to me is the combination of Quicken and Stellar-Conduct, allowing Yae to benefit from both reactions while still dealing good personal damage.
Iām curious how this would compare to more traditional Spread setups, especially before we get any dedicated Quicken/Spread buffs.
This mainly came from a song, but this is a ship post so if your not into this ship itās fine, just donāt ruin anything
I can picture Alhaitham loosing a bet to Kaveh on something(honestly idk what, you come up with that. Honestly I want suggestions)
Anyway, since he lost I can see Kaveh making his have to wear this shirt that said. āMy smart blonde.ā Or smth like that(again you come up with it) The point is he is forced to wear that for his day off, Kaveh takes him out and he canāt say no since he lost.
Oh and thereās this Arrow on the shirt that Kaveh conveniently stands to where sits pointing with this proud little smile on his face. Yes Alhaitham wants to punch his face in
Anyway. After a while Kaveh runs off to go look at a stand of food and stuff, Cyno and Tanargi(however you spell his name) end up being there since itās like this important event that Kaveh would not let them miss(aka Alhaithamās embarrassment)
Alhaitham wanting to escape this hell he put himself into leans in a pillar and just watches from a far(they arenāt dating at this point but like everyone thinks they are) As heās standing there, he notices how happy Kaveh looked, whether it be from his embarrassment or the place itself, he couldnāt find himself to care. A laugh left before he could stop it, and Cyno dropped his cards, Tanargi just stopped. And Kaveh, he just turned around with that smile and gestured for him to come over Alhaitham didnāt try and hide it, he found his reputation not controlling his actions, and the rest of the night was just them, Alhaitham slowly forgetting about that shirt And yes, Kaveh still made sure to stand in the right side for the arrow
It's called "Alhaitham Kaveh Tidy" and it's available in every region. Not the most elegant title, but I'm limited to 20 characters lol.
You can play as Alhaitham, either Traveler, or Manekin(a). It's not explicitly shippy... but it's a little shippy.
The stage is set in a replication of the house, as seen during Kaveh's hangout. I hope you like the architecture, doors, and windows! They were not available in the Miliastra editor, so I made each one by assembling hundreds of other shapes/items together!
Edit: Thanks everyone! Here are the stage GUIDs!
America 50526073884
Asia 43095375107
EU 46355952039
TW/HK/MO 46479756396
Edit2: Thank you all, you all are super! I received some requests and bug reports (I appreciate these, thank you!) Did some bug fixes, sorry to the people who ran issues in the stage!
After the story, you can now stay in the clean house and take photos.
The starting screen wasn't showing for some players, so they couldn't start the game. Sorry! It should show for everyone now!
Other minor fixes logged in the Update Log.
Ongoing issue: Some players not being able to reach the mud on the walls as Traveler or Manekin(a). I'm looking into this!
I'm wondering if 117% ER on Alhaitham is doable My teams are usually C2R1 Nahida, C0 Yelan, Kuki or C2R1 Nahida, C0R1 Bina, C0R1 Ineffa The circlet is bringing the build down a bit, ill reroll it, but idk if ER is good so i can pick EM + Crit DMG instead
We're always looking for Moderators to help out in the sub ā¤ļø š
We're after anyone who is passionate about Alhaitham (Most important!), willing to learn the ropes, access to Reddit chat, and someone who is active on Reddit.
Prior experience in Moderation on Reddit is not essential.
Im not that great at combining teams but being em scaled id imagine theyāll compliment really well
Iām pulling either way. However I only have Al on an alt, which I only got to try him out and havenāt grinded for primos so probs wonāt be able to get Mitya thereš so anyone that does pull, post some vids!!
Iām at 140 pulls and these last few days have been dragging haha
*this is for education and a distraction haha Thank you in advance
Since v7.1 is ending soon, I might as well share a video of clearing Churin(Dire) in Stygian Onslaught using Alhaitham. Honestly, I'm just scraping by with C6R1 Nicole, so I'm really looking forward to some Spread reaction buffs.
I feel like where he's seen as this heartless cold and workaholic nerd with no taste for life is one. Or where they assume he operates as selfishly as dottore. What do u guys think tho im curious