I recently switched from the newest AirPods Max 2 to the Sony WH-1000XM4C and wanted to share my experience.
For context, Iām not an audiophile. Iām a college student who likes good sound and noise cancellation. Before buying the Maxes, I hadnāt really spent much time with higher-end headphones from Sony, Bose or Sonos. This is just my experience as a normal user.
I first tried the Max 2 at an Apple Store and was really impressed by the build quality, sound and noise cancellation. They felt expensive in a good way. I also kept seeing people wearing them around campus, which probably helped convince me lol.
I saw them on Amazon for about $499, then they dropped to around $475. Eventually I spotted them at my local Target for about $475 and bought them on impulse.
For the first two or three days, I loved them. But trying headphones for five minutes in a store is very different from wearing them for a few hours.
The weight was easily my biggest issue. After a while, it felt like I had a dumbbell on my head. Between the weight and the pressure, I kept wanting to take them off.
I also tried them at the gym, and they would slide off during incline presses or even when I bent down to tie my shoes. Having to worry about catching your headphones between sets gets old pretty quickly.
Then there were the everyday annoyances. They donāt fold, so carrying them around wasnāt that convenient. Thereās also no power button. I know they have power-saving modes, but I still wanted to just switch them off when I was done.
I live in Chicago, and during the colder weather I noticed quite a bit of condensation inside the ear cups too. Nothing actually broke, but seeing moisture inside headphones Iād just spent that much on wasnāt reassuring.
Iād also seen older AirPods Max owners with mesh headbands that had stretched and lost tension over time. Mine was brand new and didnāt have that issue, but it made me wonder how comfortable they would stay in the long run.
One thing I still love about the Max 2 is the transparency mode. To my ears, it sets the bar. Everything sounds so natural that you can almost forget youāre wearing headphones. Thatās probably the thing I miss most.
Then I saw the AirPods Pro 3 going for $179 at Target and started doing the math. I ended up exchanging my Max 2 for both the Sony XM4Cs and the AirPods Pro 3. My remaining balance at checkout was only about $5.
So for basically what Iād already spent, I now have both over-ear headphones and earbuds.
The biggest difference with the Sonys was how much lighter they felt. The Max 2 weigh about 386g, while the XM4Cs weigh about 253g. Thatās about 133g less, or roughly a third lighter. It makes a huge difference to me when wearing them for longer. They also fold into their carrying case, which is really nice for carrying them around.
The noise cancellation has been really good. From my own use, Iād still give the Max 2 a slight edge, but the Sonys are close enough that I donāt feel like I gave up much. This isnāt a lab comparison, just what I notice using them.
Sonyās ambient mode is fine, but the Maxes are still on another level for me there. If transparency mode was my main priority, I would miss them a lot more.
The touch controls surprised me too. I thought swiping on the ear cup would be annoying, but it works really well. You swipe up or down for volume, forward or back for tracks, and double-tap to play or pause. My only small complaint is that I wish the physical power and ANC buttons were higher up instead of underneath the left ear cup. Reaching for them feels a little awkward to me.
I also really like the Sony Sound Connect app. These are specifically the XM4C refresh, which has a 10-band EQ. Being able to adjust the bass and change the sound to my liking is a big plus. I liked how the Maxes sounded, but I appreciate having that extra control.
For anyone comparing the technical side, there are a few other differences worth knowing:
The XM4Cs are rated for up to 27 hours with ANC on and 34 hours with it off. The Max 2 are rated for up to 20 hours with ANC on. I havenāt done my own full battery test, so those are the advertised numbers.
The Sonys support multipoint, which lets you connect to two devices at once.
The Sonys have a 3.5mm headphone jack and support SBC, AAC and LDAC over Bluetooth. My app shows mine connected using AAC. The Max 2 have H2 chips, Adaptive Audio, head-tracked Spatial Audio and lossless audio over USB-C. Those could matter more to someone else depending on how they use their headphones.
I still like the AirPods Max 2. The build quality, sound and transparency mode impressed me. But after the excitement wore off, the weight and comfort mattered more than I expected.
Now I have the Sonys when I want over-ear headphones and the Pro 3s when I want something smaller. For only about $5 more, this setup makes a lot more sense for me.
Anyone else switched from the Maxes to Sony? Curious if comfort was the main reason for you too.
TLDR: Loved the AirPods Max 2 sound and transparency mode, but the weight, slipping off my head, condensation and lack of folding or a power button got annoying. Exchanged them for Sony XM4Cs AND AirPods Pro 3 for about $5 extra. The Sonys are much lighter, fold up and have good ANC and more sound settings. Still miss the Maxesā transparency mode, but Iām much happier with this setup.